• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Rejected Impact of Tera Blast ban in OU on lower tiers

Status
Not open for further replies.
If the argument for freezing rises is stablezing lower tiers, then BLs should be allowed to rise. A tier will not be destablized because a BL cannot be retested since it rose to a higher tier.

"it sucks that x tier no longer has the chance to maybe someday unban this BL" is just an argument against usage based tiering. It's not really about ensuring stable end of the gen tiering.
 
BLs rising can still have an effect on lower tiers, even putting aside retests, such as something in PUBL rising to RU, and these rises can still have a destabilizing effect on those in-between tiers because viability ≠ usage, especially as the Generation goes on. Cherry-picking where the frozen rises policy gets implemented to appease the urge to see Garchomp’s return to OU would be a mistake.
 
I don't think anybody is asking for something in PUBL to jump through NU all the way to RU - if it sees play in NU, wouldn't it rising to RU cause the exact problem that freezing rises sought to avoid? Going from a banlist to the tier immediately above, and no further, sounds like a perfectly fine occurrence and exactly what other people are talking about
 
missangelic said:
I know people feel bad for BLs, but please don’t single them out as deserving rises just because they aren’t usable in a lower tier. Taking away a lower tier’s ability to retest something like SS PU is doing with Guzzlord is not immaterial when that Pokemon would have otherwise been NU. This would get even more arbitrary when considering Pokemon can be in a BL of a lower tier, not used / barely used in the tier directly above, and then used much more in a tier more than one directly above (Brute Bonnet with more usage in NU than PU or ZU combined, Ninetales-Alola in UU versus PU, Cresselia in RU and OU).
Guzzlord got enough usage to be RU, allowing it to be tested into PU is a crazy loophole that should be removed
 
Django said:
Guzzlord got enough usage to be RU, allowing it to be tested into PU is a crazy loophole that should be removed
It didn’t even get enough usage in that tier… it didn’t hit 4.52% in RU during the frozen period: 2.727% in July 2022, 1.466% in October 2022. It only reached 5.807% NU by the October 2022 shifts. Regardless, taking retests off the table and being selectively rewarding to the most proximal BLs that have good vibes is a bad move for policy.
 
missangelic said:
Cherry-picking where the frozen rises policy gets implemented to appease the urge to see Garchomp’s return to OU would be a mistake.
missangelic said:
Regardless, taking retests off the table and being selectively rewarding to the most proximal BLs that have good vibes is a bad move for policy.

I think these posts are very unfair and a bit disparaging. Nobody is saying we want good vibes tiering. Some people just want the tiers to be accurately reflective of what the usage says, and if this can be done without impeding on the aforementioned policy goal of stabilizing the tiers for the end of the generation (i.e. the reason there is a freeze in the first place), that seems to be a perfectly fine stance to take.
 
If BLs being tested down is so vital, maybe it would be good to offer examples of sucessful unbans during a freeze or as a post gen? the only one i could point to in recent times is SS ND UU Hydreigon when rises were frozen, only to be later banned in post-gen. In my understanding of the topic, there are far more bans in these two phases than unbans by an extreme margin and the unbans that are floated around in recent times have been rarely getting enough support to be unbanned. I like it when tiers are stable, thus supporting the freezing of rises. BLs don't have any ACTIVE impact on tiers below it and the amount of metagames that would want to willingly unban a BL that is also a contender to rise to a higher tier is so negligibly low that tweaking the system to be more accurate is better than the incredibly slim chance hypothetical that a BL is actually balanced.
 
Runo said:
If BLs being tested down is so vital, maybe it would be good to offer examples of sucessful unbans during a freeze or as a post gen? the only one i could point to in recent times is SS ND UU Hydreigon when rises were frozen, only to be later banned in post-gen. In my understanding of the topic, there are far more bans in these two phases than unbans by an extreme margin and the unbans that are floated around in recent times have been rarely getting enough support to be unbanned. I like it when tiers are stable, thus supporting the freezing of rises. BLs don't have any ACTIVE impact on tiers below it and the amount of metagames that would want to willingly unban a BL that is also a contender to rise to a higher tier is so negligibly low that tweaking the system to be more accurate is better than the incredibly slim chance hypothetical that a BL is actually balanced.
SS PU is currently undergoing an unban test for about 8 months now I believe, with Araquanid, Guzzlord, Raichu-A and Virizion being tested. While its technically still ongoing, there are talks about doing a vote sometime soon. Of these 4 drops, really only araquanid has any chance of staying banned, with the other 3 being generally agreed upon to be fine and in some cases, mediocre.
Rising BL's up takes away opportunities like this, and in SS PU's case, it does make the tier better (most people that have played the new meta agree its gotten better). I don't see why we need to do this rising BL's stuff, all its doing is actively taking away options from lower tiers for very marginal benefit.
 
Heatranator said:
SS PU is currently undergoing an unban test for about 8 months now I believe, with Araquanid, Guzzlord, Raichu-A and Virizion being tested. While its technically still ongoing, there are talks about doing a vote sometime soon. Of these 4 drops, really only araquanid has any chance of staying banned, with the other 3 being generally agreed upon to be fine and in some cases, mediocre.
Rising BL's up takes away opportunities like this, and in SS PU's case, it does make the tier better (most people that have played the new meta agree its gotten better). I don't see why we need to do this rising BL's stuff, all its doing is actively taking away options from lower tiers for very marginal benefit.

I think the question was more, of those 4, were any of them actually going to rise end of gen for SS, otherwise there is no missed opportunity there. I don't actually know the answer to that, but there's a big difference between not being able to test any BLs, and not being able to test BLs that would have risen end of gen if not for the freeze, which is the more specific issue at question here. However, this entire subject of re-testing BLs seems completely separate from what the intended goal of the freeze was in the first place. It doesn't mean it's not discussable, but what should be more important here is looking at the intended goal of the policy that was put into place (stabilizing tiers end of gen).
 
Heatranator said:
SS PU

i specifically ignored SS PU because it is ongoing (thus not yet sucessful)

but on the point, this would realistically only impact Guzzlord no? The only mon that is a serious part of the NU metagame. The other 3/4 potential unbans in that thread are frankly still free to test down under this proposal and are irrelevant. Not going sit here and say Guzzlord is NU by usage in SS because I don't know usage stats by heart, but of course if Guzzlord too didn't qualify for NU at the end of the gen then it's also irrelevant to the discussion at hand.
 
I looked at the usage stats, and it seems like Guzzlord (5.8% usage in the last month in NU) was the only one that would have risen when tiers completely froze (as in the gen ended). So yes, this proposal would impact just Guzzlord.

But even though it is just one mon, I don't think rising said BL's to their higher tiers is worthwhile. The SS PU discussion about unbans only actually started getting tested years after SS ended as a gen, there is no way we can predict what BL's will get tested post gen. There have also been small discussions about unbanning stuff from SS NUBL, and I saw a few people arguing Torn should get unbanned. Its currently B rank in RU and if rises were not frozen, would have enough usage to rise to the tier (5.2% in last month). Now maybe torn precedes to fall flat in SS RU in the next few months and its useless as an arguement, but the point still stands that we cannot predict how these pokemon will turn out in the tiers above AND how people will perceive them in the tiers below.
The benefit of making the tiers look more accurate is cool and all, but lets be so fr here, tiers do not reflect what they are actually with the multitude of mons that are stuck in tiers either because they rose due to low ladder numbers/a few select people spamming games OR said pokemon got stuck in the tier due to being a noob trap and such. Trying to deal with BL's rn is putting the cart before the horse, if tiers do accurately represent what they are aside from BL's being in the higher tier when they should be, sure, that would be more justifible. But again, that should be addressed first.
 
There's no horse to put the cart in front of. Most if not all "fixes" for tiering have been shot down or ignored entirely. Also let's be so for real, any major fix isn't going in SV, it will be in WiWa, which is over a year out at the earliest. You really expect supporters of this proposal to wait that long AND wait for the herculean task of overhauling tiering first??? It's kicking the can down the road in such a nonsensical way for an issue that only an extremely small amount of metagames on smogon are effected by.
 
Runo said:
There's no horse to put the cart in front of. Most if not all "fixes" for tiering have been shot down or ignored entirely. Also let's be so for real, any major fix isn't going in SV, it will be in WiWa, which is over a year out at the earliest. You really expect supporters of this proposal to wait that long AND wait for the herculean task of overhauling tiering first??? It's kicking the can down the road in such a nonsensical way for an issue that only an extremely small amount of metagames on smogon are effected by.
Maybe we should stop immediately shooting them down and ignoring them entirely so we can actually have a discussion here.

Editting to make this not a 1 liner, but we really need to stop just kicking ideas aside for one reason or another. The point of this is to come together and discuss problems that we as a community have, and how to fix them. Just because an idea is "flawed" doesnt mean its useless. But I feel theres 2 mentalities that make discussing the issues we have with tiering horrendous.
1) The previously mentioned "Flawed = Kick it aside and ignore"
2) The idea that we can "do better" than an idea someone provided, which in turn leads to it being kicked aside.

There will always be flaws, VR based, Usage based, freezes, no freezes. But theres very clearly a problem with how we do things now, and the fact that we just ignore any and all ideas for small and sometimes meaningless reasons makes it incredibly difficult to actually address these issues. Even if an idea is flawed, we can iron some of these flaws out by discussing how they can be altered.
 
Last edited:
Going to close and lock this as it feels the discussion has run it's course. Following discussions with tiering team and tier leaders we will be doing the following:

- Leaving rises of all sorts (including BLs) frozen, and not making other changes to fundamental tiering of Gen9. There is neither the ladder activity or the appetite amongst the community to make changes this large at this time.
- More work will be done to ensure as much council activity as possible is kept up for the rest of the generation (expect more news in this thread) soon. This should help push tiers to the best place they can be by the end of the generation
- While we still don't know what Gen10 will look like and how it will affect tiering, we will commit to open a discussion about Gen10 tiering and learning from Gen9 in the near future. TBC exactly what this looks like

Feel free to reach out to me if you have any questions or concerns.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top