• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Unpopular opinions

Samtendo09 said:
If anything, Smogon has managed poorly on handling the SV singles metagame by being too rigid on their approach instead of acknowledging that Gen 9 is particularly bad about the single battle power creep.
I quit Singles in large part because of how Gen 9 was handled. The community's stubborn refusal to even entertain Tera Preview and the timing of the Tera Blast suspect lining up with the launch of Champions show how much of a clown fiesta the whole thing has become.
 
I know several people including myself that have moved to VGC and enjoyed it and essentially nobody moving to Singles. The monthly number counts for CG official tiers are lower on average than the first month of recorded usage stats in 2014.

This is not just "the gen went on for too long!" because anyone that paid attention to The Threads would know I was bitching about how SV OU had less games tham SWSH OU on a month to month basis ~on average (there were a few select outliers, general trend is correct).

SV OU did not start this way, its first months had insane activity, clearly there was an appetite, but VGC was simply the better game. It was not money that solidified this either, but grassroots marketing as well.

Going from an immense jump over SWSH OU to lower than SWSH's lows in less time shows an overall rejection. People did try modern gen singles, and they broadly didn't like it and left.

Even if numbers remained the same as SWSH OU overall in its later years, that'd still be a 50% decline from SM OU in its final months btw.

If Modern Singles (ie. not tiers with a massive legacy, which appeal is being classic) is going to be relevant in a decade the game and community will have to change, but as said community gets older on average that's not likely to happen.

It is what it is.
 
As dumb as it is that open team sheet/Tera preview wasn't integrated into cartridge (Tera preview is literally as easy as having the icon show next to the Pokemon icon) VGC was definitely at it's best in gen 9 because Terastalization mitigates a lot of issues VGC had to begin with. Games are too predictable with unpunishable openings? Tera into a Ghost type, dodge the Fake Out, and throw your opponent for a loop. Your opponent won the matchup at team preview and now you're staring at an Urshifu-W that you can't one shot? Tera into a Grass type and Tera Blast it. A braindead legendary like Calyrex-S is spamming their broken signature and trying to win? Tera into a Normal type and take 0 damage from it's attack.

It didn't matter that teamsheets were open because, while they do know your Tera type they don't know when they're use it, and types are so dynamic that they shift the game on their own while having applications offensively AND defensively, the latter VGC definitely needed more options for. The fact that they decided to balance it by having knowledge of what Tera the Pokemon are beforehand via open team sheet is even better, as it allows for the opponent to play around it and your opponent can now assess whether they want to do things like use Fake Out on a Pokemon that has Tera Ghost, instead of that being the overwhelmingly optimal play and just being blasted by a 1/18 chance that was completely out of his knowledge.

Unfortunately, none of this matters now nor can improvements be made because Pokemon wants to actively destroy the ability to play Singles and has decided to reward VGC players with the most buns format where the main balance projections is just to add in Pokemon that don't fix the fundamental issues VGC has without Tera. Tera was shown at launch, and I refuse to acknowledge Champions as anything but a bad game filled with false advertisement until the year+ it takes (if lucky) to implement everything they showed in the trailers.
 
ant4456 said:
I know several people including myself that have moved to VGC and enjoyed it and essentially nobody moving to Singles. The monthly number counts for CG official tiers are lower on average than the first month of recorded usage stats in 2014.

This is not just "the gen went on for too long!" because anyone that paid attention to The Threads would know I was bitching about how SV OU had less games tham SWSH OU on a month to month basis ~on average (there were a few select outliers, general trend is correct).

SV OU did not start this way, its first months had insane activity, clearly there was an appetite, but VGC was simply the better game. It was not money that solidified this either, but grassroots marketing as well.

Going from an immense jump over SWSH OU to lower than SWSH's lows in less time shows an overall rejection. People did try modern gen singles, and they broadly didn't like it and left.

Even if numbers remained the same as SWSH OU overall in its later years, that'd still be a 50% decline from SM OU in its final months btw.

If Modern Singles (ie. not tiers with a massive legacy, which appeal is being classic) is going to be relevant in a decade the game and community will have to change, but as said community gets older on average that's not likely to happen.

It is what it is.
If we're airing our grievances about Smogon and its tiering now I just want to talk about how fucking cool it is that when you click on the Champions subforum the first thing you are shown is the literal fanfiction 6v6 metagame that Champions is not designed around because it does not exist with the real formats being basically treated as side things. Awesome! This will do wonders for maintaining relevance!
 
i think smogon has to pivot out of the "gamefreak and tpc are stupid and we are objectively better" mindset tbh. not that those two dont make stupid decisions all the time but i think a lot of decisions have been made w the idea that smogon would remain the premier competitive pokemon experience forever and that tpc could never make anything that would change that.

...which doesnt work anymore because they do have a product and a format w more growing acceptance and smogon is no longer the premier competitive pokemon experience, thet have to share the spotlight with vgc. so you gotta get out of ass and start ramping up on improving the site and how tiers react to community requests (and also stop acting like complex bans are the devil i promise you its fine)
 
Competitive singles is cooked for no other reason than the people making the actual games decided it is. As someone who hated it when Showdown/Internet homogenization monopolized Smogon as the only way to play competitive singles I hate it even more that now is that Pokemon wants VGC to be the only way people play Pokemon. That behavior genuinely disgusts me and I would rather have these mechanics be in the dustbin of history (like they honestly should've been after RSE) than see Champions actually succeed in its mission in lasting multiple generations.
 
Yung Dramps said:
If we're airing our grievances about Smogon and its tiering now I just want to talk about how fucking cool it is that when you click on the Champions subforum the first thing you are shown is the literal fanfiction 6v6 metagame that Champions is not designed around because it does not exist with the real formats being basically treated as side things. Awesome! This will do wonders for maintaining relevance!
You're complaining that something under the clearly marked Smogon Metagames heading is in fact a Smogon metagame? Sure, maybe BSS and VGC are no longer the best names for the Cartridge Metagames subheadings but I really don't understand this as an issue.
 
Ironmage said:
You're complaining that something under the clearly marked Smogon Metagames heading is in fact a Smogon metagame? Sure, maybe BSS and VGC are no longer the best names for the Cartridge Metagames subheadings but I really don't understand this as an issue.
The main grievance a few people have is that Smogon did in fact have the chance to *use* Champions to their advantage to attract new players by giving them what Champions cannot.....

...and chose to not do so anyway.

I don't think anyone wants smogon/showdown to die or disappear, rather sees this as such a wasted opportunity where due to possibly outdated mentality combined with attempting way too hard to play soccer with a rugby ball they are missing every possible chance to drag in new players.
It does not matter how ipotetically "better balanced" the smogon formats are compared to VGC if there's noone left to play them.
 
The decision to turn Pokemon Tower into the Kanto Radio Tower was the objectively correct choice for Lavender Town's future. Pokemon Tower was littered with crime - festering with evil Rocket Gang members looking to make a quick buck, cultist looking to indoctrinate the public youth in their twisted satanic rituals, and evil ghosts looking to attack innocent bystanders rather than the REAL villains (the aforementioned Team Rocket situated one floor above). Furthermore - the tower itself made the town a tourist death-trap. Why would little Timmy's parents bring him to Lavender Town to have an uncomfortable talk about what happens to Pokemon when they die, maybe get spooked by creepy ghost, or get mugged by a Team Rocket member when instead they could be shopping it up at Celadon City, go for a leisurely cruise in Vermillion City, or compete in a blood pumping Safari game in Fushia City? The simple answer is they wouldn't & Lavender Town's economy suffered as a result.

The Lavender Town Radio tower was a great way to rebuild its dying tourism industry, modernizing it with the hip new subculture the youth was fully embracing. Even beyond tourism, the Radio Tower sustainable a commercial anchor for Lavender Town, attracting regional sponsorship while generating new employment opportunities for its residents. It made Lavender a centerpiece in Kanto's growing communication infrastructure, rather than a forgotten relic that it would have become otherwise.

The fact is - Lavender Town had a choice - either to get in or get left behind. They made the correct choice to modernize and came back stronger than ever.
 
Worldie said:
The main grievance a few people have is that Smogon did in fact have the chance to *use* Champions to their advantage to attract new players by giving them what Champions cannot.....

...and chose to not do so anyway.

I don't think anyone wants smogon/showdown to die or disappear, rather sees this as such a wasted opportunity where due to possibly outdated mentality combined with attempting way too hard to play soccer with a rugby ball they are missing every possible chance to drag in new players.
It does not matter how ipotetically "better balanced" the smogon formats are compared to VGC if there's noone left to play them.
I'm not a competitive player at all, but it was inevitable in retrospect. GF were always going to have a certain framework of rules (Japanese players and developers tend to have a higher tolerance for luck and grinding than Western[ized] ones), and design new mons, items and environments with these in mind. Singles councils could do all they want to try to make the game fit their definitions of "fair" and "skill-based", but power creep always meant Smogon would eventually get overwhelmed by having too many things to ban or at least view with suspicion according to their own standards. No matter how hard you try to systematize viability with statistics, deviations and stuff, it still relies on a dozen humans not completely without subjective beliefs and playing experiences evaluating a tier.

You can maybe understand what's overpowered or underpowered with usage and win rates, or what's too centralizing with correlation stats, and you can try to minimize the luck factor for "uncompetitive" strategies with math, but "unhealthy" is pretty subjective at the end of the day, and one would wonder if eliminating "unhealthiness" is worth the effort anymore. And even with luck, like, why not code Showdown to always have a fixed damage or at least prevent too many crits or high/low rolls in a certain number of turns? Wouldn't speed ties also be uncompetitive by the same logic?
 
Last edited:
Worldie said:
The main grievance a few people have is that Smogon did in fact have the chance to *use* Champions to their advantage to attract new players by giving them what Champions cannot.....

...and chose to not do so anyway.

I don't think anyone wants smogon/showdown to die or disappear, rather sees this as such a wasted opportunity where due to possibly outdated mentality combined with attempting way too hard to play soccer with a rugby ball they are missing every possible chance to drag in new players.
It does not matter how ipotetically "better balanced" the smogon formats are compared to VGC if there's noone left to play them.
LARPing that Champions is a spinoff and waiting for "Gen 10 OU" is Smogon's Losing The Next Generation Moment

which that kind of thing is often the beginning of a major long-term decline without drastic action

and given how things currently operate I don't see that happening
 
I think there's still merit in being the home of 6v6. The games really are a hostile environment for it.

With that said... it doesn't matter much when the game itself is buns.

If we're being blunt, this game has always been impossible to balance, but that doesn't mean GF needed to make it wack. Ubers got so big, there's an Ubers UU tier now. That's just bonkers.

I don't know how Smogon itself should adapt. Would open team sheets help? Maybe, but at the same time, Champions itself doesn't do it. Even though it should, VGC is an ots format.

What I do know is that the forums are fading fast. This thread used to have posts every single day. I get the feeling that the franchise is starting to suffer the issues from its incompetence and gradually losing online presence as older fans get sick of having to spice up the game every game with increasingly fewer tools and higher prices.
Orange Islands is turning into Mirage Island as we speak.

I don't know what needs to be changed. But something has to. Smogon reclaiming some of its relevance is probably the first step.
 
I'd say right now, part of the problem as to why our forums are a lot less active than they used to be is because the franchise has been, in a broad sense, much slower in pushing out new content. There was a two-year gap between SV's DLC and Legends: Z-A, and there's another 2 year gap between that and Winds/Waves.

The series formerly pushing out mainline games every single year may have hurt the quality of the games, and I don't disagree with the decision to slow things down a little, but it also meant we always had a lot to talk about. Now there are long gaps of time where there's almost nothing to talk about, since nothing big and new is keeping the momentum going for us fans talking about the franchise. This year and 2024 are both pretty dead years for the most part. Z-A was the latest mainline entry, but it's old news at this point and far past its prime. Pokopia is cute and all but isn't the type of thing that would spur discussion the same way mainline games do.

This generation as a whole has been, and will be thus far, the longest in history bar none, and we're at the tail end of the generation where pretty much everything about Gen 9 has been done-and-dusted and "settled". Even the main anime is taking it easy now with Liko and her friends in the show now just doing whatever and them tying things in episodes to various spin-offs or past mainline games. Meanwhile we're also in a uniquely awkward phase where we know Gen 10 exists now, but it's so far off that it's nowhere near time for it to be in its proper marketing phase, which leaves very little to talk about and speculate about because we know so little and we will continue to know very little about Winds and Waves for a much longer period of time.

In general it's not just us, Pokemon as a whole is kind of in an awkward limbo state right now due to the unusual fact that we basically have little to no new content for the series right now and the next big thing for the series is still so far off. I don't think I've been seeing any discussion on anything Pokémon-related anywhere gain momentum as of late because this year is so quiet for the series.

The franchise slowing down is something I approve of, but Gen 9 being much, much longer than usual, even surpassing Gen 4 and Gen 3 in length, has led to an extra period of down time where the momentum of the series in the general public consciousness (not just here online, even though it's in a slow point everywhere you look online) has hit a point of stagnation and now there's nothing for pretty much anyone to really talk about or be excited about right now, and that'll continue to be the case until well into 2027 when WiWa's proper marketing cycle begins in earnest.

Pretty much every aspect of the franchise in Gen 9 has reached a sort of quiet point where things are still ongoing, but are much more lowkey than before because things have more or less settled and there's nothing really big to restart the momentum atm.
 
the forum being slower isn't some trend of disgruntled older fans quitting I agree, it's literally just that the pace of content for the series is slightly more normal now for the first time in decades

how many times have we had a level scaling and open world good or bad convo about sv? people have made peace with their thoughts on gen 9 and are waiting for gen 10

personally ive been playing the shit out of pokemon rejuvenation to get my yearly fix of pokemon, and it might be my favorite game ever now, but im not gonna talk about that on a forum for general pokemon stuff since chances are not a single other person active in these threads has played it to completion

without constant new game releases there isn't really a monoculture and that's okay
 
ant4456 said:
without constant new game releases there isn't really a monoculture and that's okay
I disagree with this, there isn't a monoculture around Pokemon as a whole but that's been because Pokemon was smart and diversified itself to multiple genres and mediums almost since inception. In-terms of competitive Pokemon, there used to be many forums, sites, and apps with their own custom dedicated formats, until a bit after the release of Showdown and it's integration with Smogon wiping most of the others off the map, cutting it to Smogon and the official VGC format. Smogon did not handle this monopoly well, and it's clear the amateur roots that designed this website could not handle being the only way to play competitive singles. Now by the release of Champions, it is of my opinion that Pokemon saw this opportunity to finally cut it's final competitor in the throat, and now we went from having two ways to play competitive Pokemon to just one.

I don't think there's anything that can be done, but the only lesson to be learned from this is that losing options sucks and the best thing one can probably do is embrace the death and move on to greener pastures instead of trying to hold on desperately to something that has moved beyond you, the latter of which is what I believe Smogon has been doing.
 
Volt-Ikazuchi said:
What I do know is that the forums are fading fast. This thread used to have posts every single day. I get the feeling that the franchise is starting to suffer the issues from its incompetence and gradually losing online presence as older fans get sick of having to spice up the game every game with increasingly fewer tools and higher prices.
Orange Islands is turning into Mirage Island as we speak.
I feel like this particular issue is less to do with Smogon or its forums or even Pokémon itself and more with Discord being considered the default option for dedicated online discussion now.
 
I think Gen 1's Pokémon roster was TERRIBLE!
And I'm not just talking about really uninspired designs like Pidgey or Dewgong neither, those are already talked about enough, I'm talking about really random designs with no inspiration or concept behind them! A pig monkey that's always angry, a wierd frog dinosaur plant creature, a wierd lizard with a big tongue, a poliwog that punches you, see what i mean? A lot of these designs are either really random unrelated concept thrown together or just straight up don't have a concept at all!
 
Karxrida said:
+2 252+ Atk Life Orb Huge Power Mawile-Mega Play Rough vs. 248 HP / 252+ Def Corviknight: 251-296 (62.9 - 74.1%) -- guaranteed 2HKO

No it shouldn't.
What puts a Mega over is how often they got a stupid ability. Especially when the base mon has low BST.

If they don't have one, they fizzle out very quickly.

Mega Mawile with Intimidate/Sheer Force could've been a regular evo.
 
As I said before in these threads, I find Mega Evolution to be a neat concept but the execution could be done better, namely the distribution. Even with popularity as a main reason, it tend to be at expense of long-term benefits if the low BST Pokémon like Chimecho and the aforementioned Mawile don’t have a full three stage evolutionary line to begin with.

I feel that the Mega Evolution distribution, with it’s one-per-team and other limitations in mind, should be done with just the following so it’s easier to balance (and rebalance) between them:
  • Pokémon that are the third stage of their respective evolutionary line (i.e. fully evolved starter, fully evolved Pseudo, Beedrill, Victreebel, Ampharos, etc.)
  • Legendary Pokémon (Mewtwo, Rayquaza, Heatran) and Mythical Pokémon (Diancie, Darkrai, Zeraora, Magearna) alongside Eternal Floette.
  • Pokémon with an already complex design without fundamentally changing it’s design concept (Lucario, Gyarados, Dragalge, etc.), though that is more of a case-by-case basis than a hard rule. I know a regular evo to the immensively popular Lucario would not sit well as it’ll end up undermining that popularity.
  • Pokémon that would benefit way too much from Eviolite, which include very bulky Pokémon with no holes on it’s defenses and / or no double weaknesses like Toxapex and Dondozo, or is Gliscor. That means the likes of Slowbro (and Slowking), Skarmory and Golisopod can keep their Mega Evolution even if it is not a result of the three above rules.
  • Tatsugiri, due to being single-stage like it’s counterpart Dondozo and it would feel cursed if it receive a regular evo.
I don’t want to include BST as a hard rule as having 500 or higher didn’t stopped Ursaring and Duraludon receiving a regular evolution even long after Mega Evolution became a thing, making cross-gen evolutions more “free-for-all” by comparison but has the advantage of being able to have more than one per team and access to a held item.
 
Karxrida said:
+2 252+ Atk Life Orb Huge Power Mawile-Mega Play Rough vs. 248 HP / 252+ Def Corviknight: 251-296 (62.9 - 74.1%) -- guaranteed 2HKO

No it shouldn't.

A Mawile evolution wouldn't have Huge Power, and the issue with Mawile and Sableye is that their Megas have the same stat total as stuff like RHYDON.

Mawile and Sableye should had gone the way Lickitung and Porygon went, as those have similar stat totals. Hell, Munchlax has that stat total as well (as it is Snorlax with 25 less on each base stat).

I'd place the cutoff point for mega vs evo at around 460 BST. Absol getting Megas rather than evos strikes me as right, but Banette or Chimecho should be evolving (and, please, don't do messes like Dusknoir, even if Mega Banette is also sucky). Beedrill or other early game bugs get a pass, and I really don't vibe with the concept of Obstagoon if you ask me.

But yeah, Rhyperior, Electivire, Magmortar, Porygon-Z, Ursaluna, Kingambit and specially Archaludon throughly strike me as things that shouldn't be. Other than FULLY EVOLVED STARTER RANGE Duraludon, the rest of those were always in the Alakazam/Gengar/Poliwrath/Nidoking range of stats (or a bit beyond for Pory2), and a Mega could had worked wonderfully.

Compare Raichu X with Electivire knowing Raichu and Electabuzz are incredibly similar 'mons:

1788018158647.png


And hell, Mega Houndoom is a bit lackluster, but I'd say it is more solid than Magmortar.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top