Alright, now it's time to get into the meat and potatoes. I'll wait for tour players to make their posts before I finalize the VR, but the balance patch has been sitting long enough that I feel comfortable putting it to print. The full reasonings are posted below, but if you just want the list in plaintext, I'll include it here as well.
Balance Patch
Nerfs:
:armaldo: Armaldo: -Toxic
:weavile: Felice: Frost Breath now 55 BP.
Ground coverage removed from many mons, full list below.
Aerodactyl, Aurorus, Cardantis, Carracosta, Combysa, Hemlophosaur, Meganium-Sonic, Moscourge, Pesbasil, Skeledirge-Ancient, Stratusaur, Swampert-Ancient, and Tyrantrum: -Earthquake
Aerodactyl, Aurorus, Bellibolt-Twisted, Cardantis, Carracosta, Hemlophosaur, Meganium-Sonic, Rhyperior-Generator, Tyrantrum, and Ungabunguss: -Earth Power
Combysa, Pesbasil, Rhyperior-Generator, Swampert-Ancient, and Tyrantrum: -High Horsepower
Reworks:
:aerodactyl: Aerodactyl: -5 Atk, +Brave Bird
:cradily: Cradily: +5 HP, +25 Def, -30 SpD, +Nasty Plot
:gourgeist: Gourgeist-Ancient (all forms): +Calm Mind
:gourgeist: Gourgeist-Ancient: -5 Atk, +5 SpA, +5 SpD, -5 Spe, +Grassy Surge (replaces Stamina)
:gourgeist: Gourgeist-Ancient-Large: -10 Atk, +10 SpA, +10 SpD, -10 Spe, +Stamina (replaces Grassy Surge)
:gourgeist: Gourgeist-Ancient-Super: -15 Atk, +15 SpA, +15 SpD, -15 Spe
:lapras: Lapras-Abyss: +10 Atk, +25 Def, -30 SpA, -5 SpD, +Crunch, Dragon Tail
Buffs:
:bellibolt: Bellibolt-Twisted: +Corrosion (replaces Static), +Acid Armor, Body Press, Sludge Bomb, Surf, Twisted Heart
:floatzel: Brawlutra: +15 Atk, +10 Def
:lurantis: Cardantis: +Levitate, +Trick Room
:runerigus: Carriguana: +5 Def
:walking-wake: Chimeragon: +20 HP
:conkeldurr: Conkeldurr-Conch: +Aura Sphere, Calm Mind
:excadrill: Goldoco: +Meteor Mash, Recover
:sceptile: Hemlophosaur: Hemlock Hit now 95 BP, +Swords Dance
:slaking: Letherium: +5 Def, -10 SpA, +5 SpD
:nidoking: Moscourge: -20 Atk, +20 SpD, +Pain Split, Parting Shot
:roaring-moon: Nochummer: +Swords Dance
:aggron: Pesbasil: +10 Spe, +Wild Charge
:rhydon: Rhydon-Generator: +Aqua Tail, Bolt Strike, Dynamic Punch, Zap Cannon
:rhyperior: Rhyperior-Generator: -10 SpA, +10 SpD, +Aqua Tail, Bolt Strike, Dynamic Punch, Zap Cannon
:kleavor: Servachne: +15 Atk, +Scale Shot
:sigilyph: Sigilyph-Ancient: -10 Atk, +10 SpA
:skeledirge: Skeledirge-Ancient: -20 Atk, +10 SpA, +10 SpD
:swampert: Swampert-Ancient: -20 Atk, +5 Def, +10 SpA, +5 SpD, +Dry Skin (replaces Torrent), +Morning Sun
:dracovish: Swishivish: +Double-Edge, Thunder Fang
:tauros-paldea-combat: Tauros-Ancestor: +10 Atk, -10 SpA
:scolipede: Venopleura: +5 Atk, +5 Spe
Nerfs
Not too many nerfs this time. The meta feels like it's in a pretty good place right now on the higher end, so this patch mostly focuses on buffing lower-tier mons to help them fit the established power level. However, there are still a few mons that could use a little detuning.
:armaldo: Armaldo
-Toxic
While it's certainly abusable on the defensive end, the biggest draw of Armaldo is moreso how freely it makes progress. Outside of Tornadus (who still gets smoked by Stone Edge variants), EQ+Knock+Toxic is basically an impossible combo to switch into well in this meta, and the few mons that don't mind it just get pivoted on for free (not to even mention the threat of Rocks or Spin). Armaldo just brings too much to the table right now, and the tool that I've decided to cut is Toxic. The flavor for this move isn't really there anyway, and without it, mons like Icaruff, Alticombat, and Gourgeist become significantly better switchins.
:weavile: Felice
Frost Breath nerfed to 55 BP.
Felice's power level is pretty acceptable right now outside of Frost Breath. Vacuum Wave is nice for revenge killing but rarely manages to sweep, and Chi Shift is weak enough that Drednaw can usually still recover from a failed prediction. This makes a Special Attack nerf less appetizing, but thankfully there's another option - just nerfing Frost Breath itself. The only other mons that learn the move (Lapras and Tornadus) never run it anyway (and have stronger Ice coverage regardless), so the only mon actually affected by this will be Felice. This nerf flips important rolls against many top meta defensive pieces like Carracosta, Ungabunguss, and non-AV Kabutops variants, hopefully giving the meta a bit more room to breathe against the ice cat.
Now, there is one other nerf, but rather than nerfing a single mon, the goal of this change is to shift the entire meta. It has been a constant complaint from players that Ground coverage is far too strong in the current meta. Everything gets it, and so many of the top defensive options are weak to Ground, making Ground coverage the most obvious choice for anything that's able to run it. This has made defensive pieces like Venopleura, Skeledirge, and Dracomizer basically impossible to run, since most if not all of their good matchups are flipped the moment their target clicks EQ. To fix that, allow me to introduce...
THE GREAT GROUND COVERAGE PURGE!!!
:aerodactyl::aurorus::lurantis::carracosta::slither-wing::sceptile::meganium::nidoking::aggron::skeledirge::raging-bolt::swampert::tyrantrum:
Aerodactyl, Aurorus, Cardantis, Carracosta, Combysa, Hemlophosaur, Meganium-Sonic, Moscourge, Pesbasil, Skeledirge-Ancient, Stratusaur, Swampert-Ancient, and Tyrantrum
-Earthquake
:aerodactyl::aurorus::bellibolt::lurantis::carracosta::sceptile::meganium::rhyperior::tyrantrum::brute-bonnet:
Aerodactyl, Aurorus, Bellibolt-Twisted, Cardantis, Carracosta, Hemlophosaur, Meganium-Sonic, Rhyperior-Generator, Tyrantrum, and Ungabunguss
-Earth Power
:slither-wing::aggron::rhyperior::swampert::tyrantrum:
Combysa, Pesbasil, Rhyperior-Generator, Swampert-Ancient, and Tyrantrum
-High Horsepower
The main focus here was to remove Ground moves from mons who have other ways of getting around Kabutops and Drednaw, as those two are strong enough as-is and don't need the buff. In addition to that, a lot of these are just cosmetic, since the nature of fossil slates and ancient forms mean many mons that were previously Rock/Ground type retained Ground coverage as a result, without actually having the flavor for it. However, quite a few mons on the list, particularly names like Aerodactyl, Bellibolt, Cardantis, Hemlophosaur, Meganium, Pesbasil, Rhyperior, and Tyrantrum, all ran Ground moves commonly, so losing those moves will flip their matchups into many currently-rare defensive pieces. You might ask, "Some of those mons aren't all that good right now even with the Ground coverage, so won't losing it kill them?" However, I've already planned for that, and those mons will be receiving compensatory buffs in the following sections.
Reworks
Before I get to the buffs, there are a couple changes that aren't straight up gains. Their reasonings will be explained below.
:aerodactyl: Aerodactyl
-5 Atk (105 to 100)
+Brave Bird
Aerodactyl is losing EQ and a bit of Attack, but in return, it is finally gaining the one tool it has been missing for so long - reliable STAB. Brave Bird completely changes how Aerodactyl is played. No longer will you be forced to rely on weak Dual Wingbeat or awkward Poltergeist on defensive sets - Brave Bird is strong, consistent, and its downside is easily mitigated with Roost, making it the obvious choice for mono-attacking sets. Meanwhile, Band sets get
significantly stronger with this, as while losing EQ does suck into Venopleura and Bellibolt, Brave Bird deals with Carracosta in its place, makes Ungabunguss a borderline non-issue, and provides a nuke button even into itemless opponents. This is a pretty polarizing change for sure, so we'll be keeping a close eye on Aerodactyl going forward in case it needs additional balancing.
:cradily: Cradily
76/88/93/108/103/47 --> 81/88/118/108/73/47
+Nasty Plot
Cradily has been a historically very troubled mon, either being far too strong or basically unusable. In its current state, it just does not have a clear niche, being outclassed as a defensive piece by every other bulky Water, and being outclassed as a Sticky Web setter by Servachne. This rework has a twofold goal. Firstly, Cradily is a very poor SpDef Water. It loses badly to Kabutops, can't wall Felice, and has longevity issues despite having access to Poison Heal because of how horrendously weak it is to U-Turn spam. This stat reshuffle makes Cradily more clearly a physically-defensive mon, allowing it to easily tank physical hits and not be punished nearly as hard by U-Turns from mons like Archeops, Armaldo, and Yizolt. Arguably even more important for it is the addition of Nasty Plot, allowing Cradily to punish opponents for letting it hit the field in a way it just couldn't before. This also lets Cradily straight up 1v1 Drednaw and Gourgeist, mons it previously hated seeing that now make easy setup fodder. Kabutops will remain a permanent thorn in Cradily's side, but hopefully these new tools will help it carve out a niche for itself in spite of that.
:gourgeist: Gourgeist-Ancient (all forms)
+Calm Mind
Abilities swapped between Average and Large, Average now gets Grassy Surge and Large now gets Stamina.
Small: 65/100/82/67/65/115 --> 65/100/82/67/65/115 (unchanged)
Average: 75/89/92/78/65/95 --> 75/84/92/83/70/90
Large: 85/78/102/89/65/75 --> 85/68/102/99/75/65
Super: 95/67/112/100/65/55 --> 95/52/112/115/80/40
Every Gourgeist form had subpar usage in PMPL, and while I personally feel both Small and Large are plenty viable as-is, it is clear something needs to be done for at least the other two forms. Since Small is already very strong, this rework is focused on changes that can boost the other forms without affecting it at all. The most difficult part of this to plan out was the stat reworks - working within the existing Gourgeist stat formula complicates things heavily. In the end, the decision was to make Attack and Speed decrease more dramatically as size increases, and have Special Attack and Special Defense increase more in exchange. Additionally, Average and Large are getting an ability swap. The logic here is that Large was already borderline-meta and really did not need a substantial buff, so swapping GSurge over to Average ends up with the GSurge Gourg having basically the same stats as before, just with slightly higher Attack and Speed in exchange for less bulk. While mild as far as changes go, this will hopefully make GTerrain offense builds more appealing to players, as Gourgeist now provides more of a threat on its own with Swords Dance + Grassy Glide. Meanwhile, the addition of Calm Mind in tandem with the stat tweaks now make the other two Gourgeist forms FAR stronger. Large finally has something to do with Stamina, as its higher bulk and SpAtk compared to Average make it a very potent crit-me-not sweeper with Calm Mind. Meanwhile, Super has had the largest stat changes of all, further cementing its niche as a Trick Room abuser and potential OTR mon. Calm Mind also allows it to run bulkier sets outside of Trick Room, diversifying its options and allowing it to compete with other bulky setup mons like Aurorus and Woolefant.
:lapras: Lapras-Abyss
130/90/85/100/95/35 --> 130/100/110/70/90/35
+Crunch, Dragon Tail
Lapras has been borderline unviable for almost as long as it's existed, but it clung on to a shred of viability as a bulkier alternative to Kabutops for a long time, keeping it out of the buff sights until Drednaw finally put that niche to bed. Water/Dark is just such a horrible typing for a fatmon - its resistances are valuable, but its weaknesses are far too plentiful to make Lapras work without serious support. To remedy this, its stats are being reshuffled, making Lapras so physically bulky that even super-effective coverage just bounces off, letting Lapras serve as a proper physical tank even with the U-Turn spam this meta is so known for, and without dying as badly to uninvested hits from mons like Armaldo and Ungabunguss. Dragon Tail, in tandem with the Attack buff, also gives Lapras a more clear niche and use case over Kabutops and Drednaw, as it is now the clear choice for hazardstack, packing Knock Off and Dragon Tail together with great additional chip from Rough Skin to make progress in a way Kabutops and Drednaw just can't quite match.
Buffs
Finally, the buffs. There are quite a few mons in the current meta that are just not worth running, so they've all been given a facelift.
:bellibolt: Bellibolt-Twisted
+Corrosion (replaces Static)
+Acid Armor, Body Press, Sludge Bomb, Surf, Twisted Heart
Twisted Heart: 90 BP Special Dark. 10 PP. Guaranteed to crit if the target is Poisoned.
It's kind of unbelievable how bad Bellibolt is. Part of it is that its relevant matchups have been themselves shitmons for quite a while now, part of it is that this mon cannot touch Carracosta, with even Earth Power doing pitiful damage, and part of it is that the entire meta eats it for breakfast. This combination of factors justifies an absolutely drastic buff, so I'll be going the extra mile with this one. First off is the addition of Corrosion, which completely changes how Bellibolt is played. Carracosta can no longer safely switch in, removing a hard counter that you really didn't need in the first place. Additionally, we have the completely new move, Twisted Heart, which synergizes very well with Corrosion and finally gives Bellibolt a STAB option that actually packs a punch. These also serve to give Bellibolt new synergy with Moscourge and Hemlophosaur, adding new depth to the Toxic-spam builds that have been bad for so long. Finally, the other new movepool additions make sure Bellibolt has tools for every occasion, with Acid Armor + Body Press to bully Ungabunguss, and Surf to keep Letherium from switching in freely.
:floatzel: Brawlutra
+15 Atk (110 to 125), +10 Def (60 to 70)
This mon is completely outclassed by existing Ground options, and many of those other Ground options are also getting buffed, so Brawlutra is receiving major stat boosts to help it fill a more specific niche as an offensive-leaning Ground tank, something it now does better than both Armaldo and Letherium thanks to its unique access to both Headlong Rush and pivoting.
:lurantis: Cardantis
+Levitate
+Trick Room
Losing EQ is a massive nerf to Cardantis, so in exchange it is getting a massive buff. Levitate fills the hole left by Magic Bounce's removal and adds a whole new dimension to Cardantis's defensive profile, making it significantly better on fat thanks to providing a rare Ground immunity, and now serving as a much better answer to mons like Armaldo, Brawlutra, and Letherium. Levitate also now gives Cardantis a viable defensive ability besides Misty Surge, enabling it to run tools it had previously avoided like Toxic and Will-O-Wisp (better start packing Wisp-immune physmons, people). Trick Room isn't meant so much as a buff to Cardantis itself, but moreso to Trick Room as a playstyle (and more specifically Enamorus-Genbu), providing a Ground-immune Trick Room setter to make up for the shared Ground weakness of many of the best abusers like Enamorus, Goldoco, and Bastiodon.
:runerigus: Carriguana
+5 Def (110 to 115)
Carriguana isn't that far off from being good as-is, and Armaldo's nerf combined with the buffs many other fat tools are getting will hopefully help spotlight that, but as a bit of encouragement for players to run it, Carriguana's bulk is being increased, further cementing it as the most indomitable defensive Ground.
:walking-wake: Chimeragon
+20 HP (61 to 81)
This mon was a flop on release, and time hasn't done it any good. Buffing its offensive profile is a dangerous game considering the power of QD as a setup tool, so instead its HP is receiving a major boost to make setting up significantly easier. Maybe bulky Chimeragon is real now?
:conkeldurr: Conkeldurr-Conch
+Aura Sphere, Calm Mind
This mon was initially going to get a much bigger buff, but PMPL proved that physical sets aren't actually bad at all in the current meta. Because of that, the focus here is just providing a boost to special sets to help differentiate them from Nymphamane and fulfill the mon's initial design of having both viable physical and special sets.
:excadrill: Goldoco
+Meteor Mash, Recover
As new defensive Steels have been added, the cracks in Goldoco's armor have only become more and more pronounced. The biggest issue by far is Goldoco's lack of longevity compared to Drednaw, making it a poor answer to mons like Icaruff and Bastiodon due to how easily it gets chipped down. Recover resolves this issue completely, giving Goldoco a fighting chance in longer matches. To add to this, Meteor Mash is added to provide a much better STAB option than Iron Head, making it easier for Goldoco to slot utility tools over coverage while still being able to threaten neutral targets like Icaruff and Armaldo.
:sceptile: Hemlophosaur
Hemlock Hit buffed to 95 BP.
+Swords Dance
Hemlophosaur is probably the mon hurt the worst by the Ground coverage purge, as it was a weak option already and heavily relied on Earthquake to make progress into Kabutops and Drednaw, among others. To account for this, it is receiving an astronomical buff to its damage output, making Hemlock Hit strong enough to muscle past neutral targets like the Waters, and freeing SD to give it back the breaking ability lost with EQ and then some.
:slaking: Letherium
101/120/86/88/105/50 --> 101/120/91/78/110/50
Letherium is already very close to being good, but it finds itself hard to justify on teams due to its lack of bulk compared to Armaldo and lack of recovery compared to Carriguana and Woolefant. Additional bulk will let Letherium tank hits better, and hopefully combine with the Armaldo nerf to give the sloth more of a niche.
:nidoking: Moscourge
-20 Atk (76 to 56), +20 SpD (86 to 106)
+Pain Split, Parting Shot
Despite the major stat boosts it received after last year's PMPL, Moscourge has still failed to make a splash in the meta. While other buffs in this patch (namely Bellibolt and Hemlophosaur) will likely give Moscourge a nice boost, it's still weak enough to require its own buff. Additional special bulk gives Moscourge more ability to 1v1 special attackers like Nymphamane and Meganium, as well as giving more setup opportunities to NP sets. Pain Split serves the same purpose, while Parting Shot gives a massive boost to Moscourge's currently borderline-useless Choiced sets, or to bulky Corrosion sets if you're sick in the head.
:roaring-moon: Nochummer
+Swords Dance
This mon has been kind of a do-nothing since its release. Band sets have seen limited success, but the biggest issue for the mon is that it wants to be able to switch attacks but just doesn't have the offensive pressure to drop Band. Seeing as the meta has very limited options for setup-based physical breakers, adding SD was the clear fix here.
:aggron: Pesbasil
+10 Spe (86 to 96)
+Wild Charge
Pesbasil really appreciated having Earthquake so it could spinblock Kabutops effectively, and losing that makes it much shakier. To account for this, it is receiving enough Speed to now naturally outspeed Kabutops, and Wild Charge so you still have a way of blowing that mon up.
:rhyperior::rhydon: Rhyperior-Generator & Rhydon-Generator
(Rhyperior) -10 SpA (55 to 45), +10 SpD (80 to 90)
+Aqua Tail, Bolt Strike, Dynamic Punch, Zap Cannon
Rhyperior is just really, really bad in the current meta. Its STAB options are horrible, its abilities barely do anything for it, and it loses to just about everything in the meta. The first, most obvious fix is a stat buff. Additional SpDef makes AV sets more worth running and makes Rhyperior a cleaner answer to Meganium, Stratusaur, and Thundurus, among others. The second mix is a movepool facelift. Bolt Strike finally gives Rhyperior a strong STAB, and pairs with Dragon Rush to make No Guard sets actually pretty threatening. Dynamic Punch and Zap Cannon continue on that train of thought, giving extra utility to No Guard sets, while Aqua Tail serves as coverage for the ever-present Armaldo (along with other Grounds). You may be wondering why I'm even bothering to mention Rhydon here, but its stats are actually extremely serviceable for an Eviolite abuser, and the main thing holding it back is a lack of utility, which these new movepool additions remedy, so it's very possible we could see Rhydon ranked on the next VR.
:kleavor: Servachne
+15 Atk (111 to 126)
+Scale Shot
Even after finally gaining a Rain setter, Servachne has been less than impressive, basically only seeing use as a Webs setter (which it's not particularly good at either). A massive boost to its Attack should help highlight Servachne's offensive profile even outside of Webs, and Scale Shot gives it viability outside of Rain as well, as Loaded Dice SD sets should now be a very real option.
:sigilyph: Sigilyph-Ancient
-10 Atk (58 to 48), +10 SpA (103 to 113)
This mon is very close to being good already, being able to capitalize on the extremely high Kabutops usage in the current meta, but its power has been a letdown every time builders experiment with it. Additional Special Attack will hopefully give Sigilyph the boost it needs to be worth running more often.
:skeledirge: Skeledirge-Ancient
104/85/75/100/100/66 --> 104/65/75/110/110/66
This mon has been horrible for a very long time now, so we're reverting its previous nerf and giving it a bit extra Special Defense as well, hopefully making it more usable as an Unaware mon.
:swampert: Swampert-Ancient
90/91/102/99/88/65 --> 90/71/107/109/93/65
+Dry Skin (replaces Torrent)
+Morning Sun
Swampert just doesn't have the longevity to compete with Kabutops and Meganium as a bulky pivot, so it's receiving a major facelift in all departments. First up is a big stat increase, drawing from its Attack to buff up its bulk and Special Attack. This does unfortunately take mixed sets off the table, but something had to go in order to better optimize its statspread. Next up are the seemingly anti-synergetic additions of Dry Skin and Morning Sun. The logic here is that Gooey sets need to be usable, as Gooey was the entire concept behind the mon, and removing it would also remove the mon's identity. However, to be frank, Swampert is a horrible Gooey abuser, having very few relevant physical resistances, zero longevity, and being completely outclassed in that niche by Woolefant. While one of those issues can be fixed by Morning Sun, the other two are unworkable, so an additional niche is being opened up with Dry Skin. Dry Skin is much better than Gooey on specially defensive Swampert sets, enabling it to block pivoting from Kabutops and Swishivish (and Brawlutra if you're feeling suicidal). It also gives Swampert an interesting Rain niche, making it now likely preferable to Kabutops as a bulky special attacker thanks to its Water immunity, additional healing, and access to STAB Thunder. These together are very very strong and would likely define the mon, which is why its healing is being limited to Morning Sun, so that non-Rain sets (and therefore Gooey sets) still have a leg up on Rain sets.
:dracovish: Swishivish
+Double-Edge, Thunder Fang
The addition of Drednaw completely killed this mon (and it was already on a downtrend before that), so we're adding back Double-Edge to make bulky Waters sans Drednaw less effective switchins to Choice sets, and adding Thunder Fang so it can get additional damage into Drednaw with good prediction.
:tauros-paldea-combat: Tauros-Ancestor
+10 Atk (60 to 70), -10 SpA (60 to 50)
This mon has been dead ever since its nerf, and the modern meta is significantly more hostile to it than it was back when it was nerfed originally, so we're reverting the nerf and then some, hopefully boosting Tauros' damage output enough to make it worth considering as a breaker.
:scolipede: Venopleura
+5 Atk (100 to 105), +5 Spe (111 to 116)
While the Ground coverage purge and other buffs will likely give Venopleura many more meta-relevant good matchups, the mon still feels pretty undertuned for the meta's standards, so its Speed is being increased to give it the jump on Gourgeist-Ancient-Small, Yizolt, and Felice, and to stop it from speed tying Icaruff, and its Attack is being buffed a bit to make up for its relatively weak STABs.
This is obviously a massive amount of changes, and will likely flip the meta on its head. However, things were starting to centralize in a way that left a lot of mons by the wayside, so hopefully these buffs will breathe new life into the meta (and maybe push Armaldo/Kabutops below 60% usage lol). Thank you to everyone who played Paleomons in PMPL and gave feedback, and I hope you'll play Paleomons again in the future!