• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Metagame National Dex Metagame Discussion

Jokler said:
Man why are we allowing this? These bits can make your laddering experience absolutely miserable.
This is just a normal 149 turn game, the stall team is able to win games even though it loses more often than not. 149 turns is not a rediculous length for a game and we already have a limit for Endless battle clause at 1000 turns, if the game reaches that point the user with leppa berry will automatically lose.


Natdex at one point quickbanned leppa berry due to a similar bot grabbing a lot of games, which got us a lot of flack from tiering policy and we had to quickly revert it. This type of thing has been litigated on and is officially allowed.
 
Jokler said:
I saw one of the most godless things I have in a long time.

There is this stall bot on the ladder that has block rest recycle leppa Blissey and Pyukumuku. It just stalls you and waits for you to get annoyed and ff.

This is actually just evil. It has no actual strategy. It has been programmed to let the timer run down to 60 seconds every 3 turns. You will still win even if you get trapped because as soon as you faint to struggle, the team is unable to win a normal match. It's just there to waste time and fish for forfeits.

Man why are we allowing this? These bits can make your laddering experience absolutely miserable.

View attachment 862511

See this account was made barely 70 days back and it already has 4000 battles -
View attachment 862512

Most of these are loses but it has racked up so many wins as well solely on ffes I would wager.

https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen9nationaldex-2680050321-d6kq594u8rpv8fxnsyjyml9is1k365tpw

Check this replay and pay attention to timer showing up when his Blissey was pp stalling. Bliss PP stalled me for straight 100+ turns and it took a real time of over 30 mins. It itself announced that it's a bot at the end of the match.

I seriously think there needs to be a policy against what you could do with bots. This one is solely there to annoy people.
i completely agree and i’m my opinion bot battlers should genuinely be banned from ps. thankfully this thing only lurks around low ladder but then that would mean newer players may have to deal with, because newer players always start from the bottom of the ladder, that’s how laddering works.

This is just another level of scum and whoever is behind that bot deserves to step on a floor of lego bricks. Truly a chud.
 
IMO bots should be banned but right now they are not nearly good enough to be an issue. Every stall bot I’ve fought I’ve beaten because of how exploitable they are. The farthest up a stall bot has been on the ladder I’ve seen was 1685 and I won pretty easily, even if it was 130ish turn game. While from my experience the farthest non stall bot I’ve seen was one running balance which made it to 1752. I’d imagine bots are a greater and more common problem for mid and lower ladder, which is so bots should still be addressed. Smogon should work on fixing the problem before these bots can peak #1 on ladder and it should be done sooner rather than later.

However despite saying all of this Nat Dex has no control over any of this and it is up to Senior Staff and Coders. I agree that banning Leppa was stupid and if you want it banned cause you don’t wanna take the time for a 150 turn game then maybe you shouldn’t be playing Competitive Pokémon. And why would you ban it cause low and mid ladder can’t beat or don’t wanna play stall, when now big tours like NDPL are effected because of it.
 
moltres-pokemon.gif

Hello there, everyone! After playing qute the time in the NDOU Metagame and playing on ladder, I just wanna shoutout to a Pokemon with this post and it’s set that I think a lot of people sleep on. I have been using many Pókemon with different movesets, but I think an underrated set, and one that I used quite a lot, would be the following: Specially Defensive Moltres. So, without further ado, here's the explanation:

:sv/moltres:
Moltres @ Heavy-Duty Boots
Ability: Flame Body
Shiny: Yes
Tera Type: Fire
EVs: 248 HP / 248 SpD / 12 Spe
Calm Nature
- Flamethrower / Mystical Fire
- Brave Bird / Hurricane / Toxic
- U-turn / Defog
- Roost​

So here's the thing, what bring this set to the table for teams? Well, for starters, this set is incredibly useful to wall strong attackers. Due to its good Defensive Combo in Flying and Fire, Moltres can surprisingly wall a good chunk of Pókemons in the NDOU metagame. For example the list of Pokemon it can deal as a specially defensive wall 1v1 are quite a lot there: you have Charizard-Mega-Y, Kyurem, Volcarona, Gholdengo, Tapu Lele (If no STAB Specs Psyshock), Venusaur-Mega (and Venusaur under the sun) and occasionally even Terapagos. Hell it could also naturally wall physical attackers as well like Scizor-Mega, Great Tusk and Rillaboom, meaning that even outside of Glowking and AV Alomomola, Moltres could be a really great alternative special wall for Balanced Offence/Balance or even Stall teams. So how could Moltres threaten these guys? How could Moltres deal with special attacking threats for a team?

Gholdego speaks for itself, you just shoot STAB Flamethrower to KO it or wear it down very low. For Charizard-Mega-Y, Weather Ball is only STAB when the sun is up, so after 5 turns of sun, Yard will be just a sitting duck. In the meanwhile you can just use Toxic and passively wear it down by walling it. Volcarona is the same as Yard, but you can use STAB Brave Bird or Hurricane to throw a wrench at its plans. As a special tank, Moltres can also sponge hits form choiced-locked wallbreakers such as Tapu Lele, given it resists STAB Moonblast, Focus Balst and still can eat up Psychic if a drop doesn't happen. Venusaur unde sun doesn't need really much explanation, but as the same as Volcarona, you can take hits from Venusaur Mega and get rid of it with STAB Brave Bird/Hurricane. Just like with Yard, you can sponge attacks from Terapagos and badly poison it with Toxic and passively damage it until death. If you have STAB Mystical Fire, it makes that much easier to sponge Terapagos. Scizor-Mega and Rillaboom well... I don't think I have to say more than be careful of Knock Off and Hazards for Moltres, do I? And as for Great Tusk, as long as it doesnt have Rock or Electric coverage for Moltres, I think you'll be fine.

Outsde of that discussion, I want to discuss what traits Moltres has overall and in comparison of its rivals. Outside of offensive moves like STAB Flamethrower and Brave Bird or Hurricane, Moltres has the possibility of recovering via Roost (unlike Ting-Lu) instead of pivoting out like Glowking and AV Alomomola. Speaking of pivoting, Moltres has access to U-Turn, which can't be stopped, to project a prediction or just pivoting out of unfavorable moments. While to much common, it could use Defog as a way to get rid of hazards and I see the vision since Moltres is something Gholdeng really doesn't wanna switch into unless it has Power Gem which is just very rare and not very much ideal outside of the purpose of surprising Moltres (or Volcarona). One last thing about the offensive moves, I have seen poeple using STAB Mystical Fire on Moltres and it makes sence, since you weaken Specia Attackers with the moves. As consequence makes it easier to Moltres to just screw and sponge special attackers. At last you have Toxic, which you can set on any Pßokemon who arent Gliscor, Poison and Steel types, especially for Pókemon that can be troublesome for your team for example Alomomola, Garchomp and Raging Bolt.

But we are not done yet, we have some other stuff that Moltres can do for the team. With its ability, Flame Body, you can with a 33% possibility to burn physical attackers due to making contact with Moltres, which makes it very scary for the physical attackers like Kingambit and Scizor-Mega and even other physcial pivots like Corvkinght, Rillaboom and Alomomola. Moltres can also serves as an Earthquake a.k.a Ground immunity when you need on for your team, though you wanna be careful of Rock coverage. The EVs shared here are for outspeeding Kingambit to at least being a problem for it.

So here you go. Whilke there are better options for special walls, I think people should see the utility Specially Defensive Moltres brings to the table for teams. So here's a reminder if yu struggle for a pick for a special wall, here you have Moltres. So here you go: reamaber to have a great day and time!
 
Last edited:
Comett7778 said:
if you want it banned cause you don’t wanna take the time for a 150 turn game then maybe you shouldn’t be playing Competitive Pokémon.

Oculars said:
This is just a normal 149 turn game, the stall team is able to win games even though it loses more often than not. 149 turns is not a rediculous length for a game and we already have a limit for Endless battle clause at 1000 turns, if the game reaches that point the user with leppa berry will automatically lose.


You guys have completely missed my point. I specifically called out the intentional ff fishing with pp stalling sets combined with timer stall tactics. If you see the replay you would realise the team is meant for this because the team is not built to win a match.

I don't mind stall but I think a bot that is actively deployed to cause disruption and waste time should not be allowed, aside from whatever technicalities or policies you quote.

Beating it is also besides the point. As I said in the original post, it's almost impossible to lose even if you get trapped.

The thing I have a problem is a bot will never get bored. Why are we letting actively time wasting bots roam around on even low ladder? What exactly is the upside?

This just actively worsens your experience and is not providing anything positive.

If not bots or even stall bots, a line needs to be drawn to prevent these disruptive bots from laddering.
 
I fail to see the issue with allowing a bot that gives you free elo if you have a half decent team and can play the game decently, so long as you are fine wasting 20 minutes of your life. If you're that bored open up another game and devote your time and energy to that one and farm the bot in the background. Additionally it does seem like I got the point of your message. You don't wanna spend 150 turns playing this bot on ladder, as you view it as a waste of time. To which I say okay then maybe mons isn't the game for you. I get it, I lost vs a stall team a couple nights ago on ladder cause I was getting impatient. I didn't make the super safe optimal play that would cost me another 5 minutes of my life, got crit, and lost. My original point still stands however. This bot is not an issue, while other that intend on winning and improving are rapidly becoming one.


Vlarcheops said:

Hello there, everyone! After playing qute the time in the NDOU Metagame and playing on ladder, I just wanna shoutout to a Pokemon with this post and it’s set that I think a lot of people sleep on. I have been using many Pókemon with different movesets, but I think an underrated set, and one that I used quite a lot, would be the following: Specially Defensive Moltres. So, without further ado, here's the explanation:

:sv/moltres:
Moltres @ Heavy-Duty Boots
Ability: Flame Body
Shiny: Yes
Tera Type: Fire
EVs: 248 HP / 248 SpD / 12 Spe
Calm Nature
- Flamethrower / Mystical Fire
- Brave Bird / Hurricane / Toxic
- U-turn / Defog
- Roost​

So here's the thing, what bring this set to the table for teams? Well, for starters, this set is incredibly useful to wall strong attackers. For example the list of Pokemon it can deal as a specially defensive wall 1v1 are quite a lot there: you have Charizard-Mega-Y, Kyurem, Volcarona, Gholdengo, Tapu Lele (If no STAB Specs Psyshock), Venusaur-Mega (and Venusaur under the sun) and occasionally even Terapagos. Hell it could also naturally wall physical attackers as well like Scizor-Mega, Great Tusk and Rillaboom, meaning that even outside of Glowking and AV Alomomola, Moltres could be a really great alternative special wall for Balanced Offence/Balance or even Stall teams. So how could Moltres threaten these guys? How could Moltres deal with special attacking threats for a team?

Gholdego speaks for itself, you just shoot STAB Flamethrower to KO it or wear it down very low. For Charizard-Mega-Y, Weather Ball is only STAB when the sun is up, so after 5 turns of sun, Yard will be just a sitting duck. In the meanwhile you can just use Toxic and passively wear it down by walling it. Volcarona is the same as Yard, but you can use STAB Brave Bird or Hurricane to throw a wrench at its plans. As a special tank, Moltres can also sponge hits form choiced-locked wallbreakers such as Tapu Lele, given it resists STAB Moonblast, Focus Balst and still can eat up Psychic if a drop doesn't happen. Venusaur unde sun doesn't need really much explanation, but as the same as Volcarona, you can take hits from Venusaur Mega and get rid of it with STAB Brave Bird/Hurricane. Just like with Yard, you can sponge attacks from Terapagos and badly poison it with Toxic and passively damage it until death. If you have STAB Mystical Fire, it makes that much easier to sponge Terapagos. Scizor-Mega and Rillaboom well... I don't think I have to say more than be careful of Knock Off and Hazards for Moltres, do I? And as for Great Tusk, as long as it doesnt have Rock or Electric coverage for Moltres, I think you'll be fine.

Outsde of that discussion, I want to discuss what traits Moltres has overall and in comparison of its rivals. Outside of offensive moves like STAB Flamethrower and Brave Bird or Hurricane, Moltres has the possibility of recovering via Roost (unlike Ting-Lu) instead of pivoting out like Glowking and AV Alomomola. Speaking of pivoting, Moltres has access to U-Turn, which can't be stopped, to project a prediction or just pivoting out of unfavorable moments. While to much common, it could use Defog as a way to get rid of hazards and I see the vision since Moltres is something Gholdeng really doesn't wanna switch into unless it has Power Gem which is just very rare and not very much ideal outside of the purpose of surprising Moltres (or Volcarona). One last thing about the offensive moves, I have seen poeple using STAB Mystical Fire on Moltres and it makes sence, since you weaken Specia Attackers with the moves. As consequence makes it easier to Moltres to just screw and sponge special attackers. At last you have Toxic, which you can set on any Pßokemon who arent Gliscor, Poison and Steel types, especially for Pókemon that can be troublesome for your team for example Alomomola, Garchomp and Raging Bolt.

But we are not done yet, we have some other stuff that Moltres can do for the team. With its ability, Flame Body, you can with a 33% possibility to burn physical attackers due to making contact with Moltres, which makes it very scary for the physical attackers like Kingambit and Scizor-Mega and even other physcial pivots like Corvkinght, Rillaboom and Alomomola. Moltres can also serves as an Earthquake a.k.a Ground immunity when you need on for your team, though you wanna be careful of Rock coverage. The EVs shared here are for outspeeding Kingambit to at least being a problem for it.

So here you go. Whilke there are better options for special walls, I think people should see the utility Specially Defensive Moltres brings to the table for teams. So here's a reminder if yu struggle for a pick for a special wall, here you have Moltres. So here you go: reamaber to have a great day and time!
I 1000% agree. It's such an anti bs mon which I have no clue why is seeing less usage. It tanks hits so well and matches up amazingly into the current meta. Tho imo running defog on moltres leads to a loss vs most hazard stacks cause the moment that molt gets knocked it's over. I would honestly add whirlwind over defog as a niche utility move that helps vs set up mons.
 
Last edited:
Comett7778 said:
I fail to see the issue with allowing a bot that gives you free elo if you have a half decent team and can play the game decently, so long as you are fine wasting 20 minutes of your life. If you're that bored open up another game and devote your time and energy to that one and farm the bot in the background. Additionally it does seem like I got the point of your message. You don't wanna spend 150 turns playing this bot on ladder, as you view it as a waste of time. To which I say okay then maybe mons isn't the game for you. I get it, I lost vs a stall team a couple nights ago on ladder cause I was getting impatient. I didn't make the super safe optimal play that would cost me another 5 minutes of my life, got crit, and lost. My original point still stands however. This bot is not an issue, while other that intend on winning and improving are rapidly becoming one.

This is a really good post that allows me to make a point in which I ask why do you play mons? I would wager most of you would say to get some sort of enjoyment out of it, no?

See, this is not a job. We don't have to train AIs to take our place here as well. Leave that to the workplace :psycry:.

I don't think playing bots intentionally made to be a nuisance is fun, but maybe that's just me.

I do realise that this user is most likely a troll because they double down on the losing vs bots and mons not being for me points again but I will reiterate once again for those who missed the original point that it is nearly impossible to lose vs that bot unless you forfeit.

Also my point isn't that playing bots is a time waste. My problem is that a bot is intentionally made to waste your time and nothing else.

I implore everyone to just to look at the replay if nothing else because then you will understand why I am calling it made to be an intentional time waste. Notice the sets, the timer stalling till 60 every three turns.

I
 
Personally I believe that bots in general should be addressed as a blanket issue, and banned wholesale.
Flooding ladder with bots benefits nobody, and it's only a matter of time until they end up either good enough or numerous enough that the whole ladder is flooded.
This is a competitive game where people play versus people, and every other major competitive game that has had a bot problem has taken action against said bots, thus, so should showdown/smogon.
 
SHOSPLE COLUPIS said:
Personally I believe that bots in general should be addressed as a blanket issue, and banned wholesale.
Flooding ladder with bots benefits nobody, and it's only a matter of time until they end up either good enough or numerous enough that the whole ladder is flooded.
This is a competitive game where people play versus people, and every other major competitive game that has had a bot problem has taken action against said bots, thus, so should showdown/smogon.
I think bots should only be a good thing when playing on unofficial formats that don't have a ladder or invitational battles. Those are the only things that would make bots beneficial since it doesn't hurt any laddering system and can test players' abilities against certain archetypes. The only thing I don't like about bots is how they take up space on the ladder since they're not a real person and it's just automation.
 
warview_vet said:
I think bots should only be a good thing when playing on unofficial formats that don't have a ladder or invitational battles. Those are the only things that would make bots beneficial since it doesn't hurt any laddering system and can test players' abilities against certain archetypes. The only thing I don't like about bots is how they take up space on the ladder since they're not a real person and it's just automation.
Another person, who really made an account, just to reply to a person. Big Bruh ️
 
Decently sized post about bots (my own takes + responding to others)

As long as bots don't begin to breach official competition and tiering policy, I personally see no issue with them on ladder. This isn't a new issue for PS, with the idea being brought into the mainstream thanks to Leppa Berry Slowbro, and has been addressed before. As mentioned before by Oculars, limitations have been put in place (such as the format wide 1K turn cap) and is officially allowed on ladder. Ladder really isn't the pinnacle of competition, or skill for that matter, and isn't taken very serious when it comes to policy decision. The game this site mimics is quite literally an RPG where you fight bots programmed into the game until you finish the story. Bots in general, let alone on the PS ladder, follow a series of predetermined checks and steps that takes minimal effort to learn on the fly and be used in your adventage, and have a very difficult time dealing with probability (crits, ability procs, move procs, etc.) compared to the average human. I myself have not coded a bot to play ladder for me, but know how code works and exploit AI behavior in the mainline pokemon games.

Jokler said:
View attachment 862512

Most of these are loses but it has racked up so many wins as well solely on ffes I would wager.

This particular bot has a 42% (rounded up) winrate with an even worse 31.8 GXE, a very obvious display of the flaws and predictable behavior making it not hard at all to beat. If a chunk of those wins are from opponents from forfeiting, as suggested above, that means there's EVEN LESS times this bot genuinely bested its opponents with its strategy.

FirstlyMe said:
i completely agree and i’m my opinion bot battlers should genuinely be banned from ps.

This is just another level of scum and whoever is behind that bot deserves to step on a floor of lego bricks. Truly a chud.

Refer to points above on why I disagree with this. Also idk if you should be taking ladder this seriously man I don't think you need to call them scum :sob:

Jokler said:
You guys have completely missed my point. I specifically called out the intentional ff fishing with pp stalling sets combined with timer stall tactics. If you see the replay you would realise the team is meant for this because the team is not built to win a match.

I don't mind stall but I think a bot that is actively deployed to cause disruption and waste time should not be allowed, aside from whatever technicalities or policies you quote.

Beating it is also besides the point. As I said in the original post, it's almost impossible to lose even if you get trapped.

The thing I have a problem is a bot will never get bored. Why are we letting actively time wasting bots roam around on even low ladder? What exactly is the upside?

This just actively worsens your experience and is not providing anything positive.

If not bots or even stall bots, a line needs to be drawn to prevent these disruptive bots from laddering.

Multiple points to be talked about here. Firstly, fishing for forfeits, PP stalling, and timer stalling are not strategy unique to bots. Human players can and have done this. Yes, the bot doesn't get tired or bored, but this is not something a human is incapable of. Also, your original post didn't do a great job at making your point clear if bots themselves was not your isn't your issue.

Secondly, being annoying or "disrupting" games isn't a bannable offense. People run Pokemon or use strategies others don't like all of the time, but if the bulk of your argument is "it wastes time and is annoying to fight", there's not much weight to be held. Humans are capable of doing the same thing this bot does, and would probably do a better job at netting wins and making games last longer. Ladder in itself can be described as a low stakes way to play the game, so if something is "wasting your time", you're not going to be losing anything major within the game.

Lastly, as mentioned earlier by Comett, whether or not bots should be allowed on ladder is ultimately not a decision NatDex can make. Tier Leaders and Council do not police the NatDex ladder, and a ban on bots would have to be a sitewide decision made by Senior Staff.

I personally believe that the larger reason on why people take issue to this is that people have an issue with stall. It can be jarring to see a robot play a controversial strategy knowing its a program performing actions automatically rather than a human pressing buttons and making decisions manually. But there's a lot more nuance about this topic than I think people initially realize. It's pretty much a universal truth that the average competitive player hates playing against stall due to average length of a stall game and because it forces players to play a strategy that's drastically different they would play against another archetype such as hyper offense or balance. However, I think a lot of people fail to that is a legitimate playstyle people can use and that some people do find fun in playing a much slower game rather than just using it to annoy others. I won't deny that people definitely use stall because it provokes a reaction out of people, but it's important to step out of their echo chambers and understand other perspectives outside of their own. Anything a bot can do with stall, a human can do it even better.

That being said if I have to fight rocky helmet mola again I might put a hole in my monitor
 
Last edited:
While we don't control the ladder we are able to pass concerns onto PS! Upper Staff which I did this morning and they're going to look into it. I'll preface this by saying I'm only speaking for myself... I'm pretty anti-bot in general, but really anti this. There is a massive difference between a human purposefuly wasting your time (loading stall is not included in this) and a bot. It also doesn't really matter that this only impacts low ladder and that makes it worse in some ways.

The ladder is the easiest way for interested folks to give ND a shot. Even if the ladder itself isn't that serious there are degrees of meaningless games. An inexperienced player having fun with their ingame team is a standard low ladder experience in any tier. The majority of players are going to breeze past this portion of the ladder and get to an elo where they won't be matched up with these bots (assuming you don't run into one on the way up). In contrast, a newer player will likely be matched into this bot, potentially multiple times, and just go: "fuck this tier, why am I wasting my time with this nonsense" and try something else.

Even the most fervent pro-bot folks likely would as well if they actually had to deal with it. While there may be some fun in learning how to outwit the bot, there are very few if any folks out there that wake up and look forward to spending a couple of hours beating a bot using leppa berry stall. Furthermore, if this bot had started slightly earlier and was impacting NDLT there would be significant and justified calls for immediate action and that impacts 40-50 out of a couple thousand ND players. Dealing with this is a no brainer imo and some of the reasoning above for not doing something is genuinely baffling. PS! US is aware and hopefully they'll do something, but we've done what we can so far.

To change the topic...

1) Are there any sets or techs y'all have enjoyed in NDP/FL so far?
2) Is there anything you think will pop off as the tour progresses?
 
Comett7778 said:
I fail to see the issue with allowing a bot that gives you free elo if you have a half decent team and can play the game decently, so long as you are fine wasting 20 minutes of your life. If you're that bored open up another game and devote your time and energy to that one and farm the bot in the background. Additionally it does seem like I got the point of your message. You don't wanna spend 150 turns playing this bot on ladder, as you view it as a waste of time. To which I say okay then maybe mons isn't the game for you. I get it, I lost vs a stall team a couple nights ago on ladder cause I was getting impatient. I didn't make the super safe optimal play that would cost me another 5 minutes of my life, got crit, and lost. My original point still stands however. This bot is not an issue, while other that intend on winning and improving are rapidly becoming one.
It's almost like people play this game to have fun. If it were a human then sure, unemployed behavior but it's fair game. Have you considered that maybe not everyone wants to deal with a literal bot specifically designed to waste your time?

Also anyone who's talking about win rate etc is missing the point. No one cares if they are free elo. It's about humans wanting to play against another human.
 
Moisture99 said:
It's almost like people play this game to have fun. If it were a human then sure, unemployed behavior but it's fair game. Have you considered that maybe not everyone wants to deal with a literal bot specifically designed to waste your time?

Also anyone who's talking about win rate etc is missing the point. No one cares if they are free elo. It's about humans wanting to play against another human.
Okay so there are 3 scenarios here:

1. You care about the competitive aspect and don’t care about the time and just want free elo, in which case you’re fine with it.

2. You’re playing for fun, which I get why someone would wanna face it, so you don’t care about forfeiting and moving on, so the bot is fine just a minor nuisance.

3. You care about both, in which case since the bot has been proven to be easy to beat, you auto pilot the bot game and open a new game that is more enjoyable and focus on the new game. This is what I would do, I personally also want an actually stimulating game against an actual real person and want the free elo. In which case all this leads to yet again bot being just a little annoying.

Granted I’m saying all this but I’m not against this type of bot being banned cause it can’t hurt to ban it. I just think the bots designed to win over waste time are the bigger issue, and that this bot isn’t the biggest problem we have. If this bot was able to consistently win, as well as waste time I would be a lot more concerned about it hanging around in low ladder. Sure right now it’s annoying, but there are bigger fish to fry when it comes to bots on showdown. Just feels like this energy should be directed at a different type of bot, or bots on the whole being banned.

bumboclaat said:
While we don't control the ladder we are able to pass concerns onto PS! Upper Staff which I did this morning and they're going to look into it. I'll preface this by saying I'm only speaking for myself... I'm pretty anti-bot in general, but really anti this. There is a massive difference between a human purposefuly wasting your time (loading stall is not included in this) and a bot. It also doesn't really matter that this only impacts low ladder and that makes it worse in some ways.

The ladder is the easiest way for interested folks to give ND a shot. Even if the ladder itself isn't that serious there are degrees of meaningless games. An inexperienced player having fun with their ingame team is a standard low ladder experience in any tier. The majority of players are going to breeze past this portion of the ladder and get to an elo where they won't be matched up with these bots (assuming you don't run into one on the way up). In contrast, a newer player will likely be matched into this bot, potentially multiple times, and just go: "fuck this tier, why am I wasting my time with this nonsense" and try something else.

Even the most fervent pro-bot folks likely would as well if they actually had to deal with it. While there may be some fun in learning how to outwit the bot, there are very few if any folks out there that wake up and look forward to spending a couple of hours beating a bot using leppa berry stall. Furthermore, if this bot had started slightly earlier and was impacting NDLT there would be significant and justified calls for immediate action and that impacts 40-50 out of a couple thousand ND players. Dealing with this is a no brainer imo and some of the reasoning above for not doing something is genuinely baffling. PS! US is aware and hopefully they'll do something, but we've done what we can so far.

To change the topic...

1) Are there any sets or techs y'all have enjoyed in NDP/FL so far?
2) Is there anything you think will pop off as the tour progresses?
I’m personally expecting cress usage to bell curve this tour. I’ve been having a lot of fun with it personally. Especially scarf sets on HO given how you can usually trick the scarf onto something expecting you to be a sweeper. It helps vs stall, you can trick the bliss or clod, wear the other one down with your Ghold, lunar dance to regain all the pp your ghold lost and then sweep. It’s very satisfying to do. Also it’s hella funny to run it with chesto idef zama to get the 2 time status removal.
 
bumboclaat said:
There is a massive difference between a human purposefuly wasting your time (loading stall is not included in this) and a bot

This is exactly what I meant. Glad to hear that they are looking into it. At the end of the day they it will be a better experience for everyone involved.

To share some sets I have personally really enjoyed to steer away from bots conversation -

Salamence (M) @ Dragonium Z
Ability: Moxie
Tera Type: Dragon
EVs: 252 Atk / 4 Def / 252 Spe
Jolly Nature
- Dragon Dance
- Outrage
- Earthquake
- Temper Flare

This basically is the exact same Dnite Z set. The differences are the speed tier and the ability. Multiscale is really good but Moxie is not bad either. Moxie prevents Intimidate pivoting and you can just blow Z, get kill and have +1. 80 vs 100 speed is also really nice. Not saying Dnite is bad but that Mence has some really good qualities too.

Iron Leaves @ Electrium Z
Ability: Quark Drive
EVs: 252 Atk / 4 Def / 252 Spe
Jolly Nature
- Swords Dance
- Psyblade
- Close Combat
- Wild Charge

This is meant to be used in Electric Terrain and gets Atk boost. This is a nuclear breaker that is unwallable. For instance Max Phys Def Mega Sciz drops to +2 Z move. Ghold and Corvi drop to raw Z in terrain. You need to SD only in few MUs. Vs offense, it's speed tier is decent with decent special bulk and resists so it can throw off attacks and gets kills. It's kind of similar in power to if a Kyurem Black were to use Z Fusion Bolt in Electric Terrain.
 
Jokler said:
This is exactly what I meant. Glad to hear that they are looking into it. At the end of the day they it will be a better experience for everyone involved.

To share some sets I have personally really enjoyed to steer away from bots conversation -

Salamence (M) @ Dragonium Z
Ability: Moxie
Tera Type: Dragon
EVs: 252 Atk / 4 Def / 252 Spe
Jolly Nature
- Dragon Dance
- Outrage
- Earthquake
- Temper Flare

This basically is the exact same Dnite Z set. The differences are the speed tier and the ability. Multiscale is really good but Moxie is not bad either. Moxie prevents Intimidate pivoting and you can just blow Z, get kill and have +1. 80 vs 100 speed is also really nice. Not saying Dnite is bad but that Mence has some really good qualities too.

Iron Leaves @ Electrium Z
Ability: Quark Drive
EVs: 252 Atk / 4 Def / 252 Spe
Jolly Nature
- Swords Dance
- Psyblade
- Close Combat
- Wild Charge

This is meant to be used in Electric Terrain and gets Atk boost. This is a nuclear breaker that is unwallable. For instance Max Phys Def Mega Sciz drops to +2 Z move. Ghold and Corvi drop to raw Z in terrain. You need to SD only in few MUs. Vs offense, it's speed tier is decent with decent special bulk and resists so it can throw off attacks and gets kills. It's kind of similar in power to if a Kyurem Black were to use Z Fusion Bolt in Electric Terrain.
may i see a few teams built around these sets, i think they’re interesting enough to try

if you know anything about me you’d know that when using unconventional mons i always pair them with mola but i feel like these 2 mons with their sets don’t rlly need it.
 

role compression.png

zapdos glowking treads: words from sloppenheimer

This core exemplifies maybe the biggest issue most people tend to have with building good teams in natdex: role compression. Building in natdex is not easy, and thats mainly because you have to cover so much. diancie, waterpon, kingambit, lele, garchomp, zamazenta, and so many more can feel extremely difficult to cover in a reasonable amount of slots. so many people turn to role-compressing slots that can cover a lot in one slot, with the premier core being this: zapdos, glowking, and iron treads. zamazenta is arguably also a part of this trio, but the role of fast fighting can be replaced with other viable options. This core makes teambuilding really easy, as you have arguable outs into a lot of the offensive threats of the metagame. pair this core with a fast fighting type and a couple of fatbreakers, and you're really quite set into a lot of stuff! at least, that's what i thought when i started using this core after the rmoon ban. As the literal first person to use this core post-moon ban (when I think it really became more usable) I obviously get the appeal. it makes building really easy, and you can very much feel set into a lot. but the issues I discovered later into my career are things that people who have replicated this core are not understanding, and its issues make it arguably unviable (?) in today's landscape.

I'll be very blunt to say that I do not like this structure anymore. It has a real tendency to get railed by a lot of the things it's attempting to soft check and is so blatantly easy to overwhelm if it has to play versus more than one of its supposed soft checks that I do not think you can make a team like this that doesn't get blatantly pounded by some common team style. gholdengo, diancie, and trailblaze ogerpon behind screens are all miserable matchups, and if you spend ANOTHER slot on trying to cover stuff defensively you now have a team that is exceptionally inept at getting anything done offensively. I won't post replays as to not shame anyone but I think that if you are using this core to soft check common metagame threats: don't. that's not to say this core cannot win games, it absolutely can, but it is just so easy to run face first into issues that it is just not worth it in 99.9% of contexts. You are creating a really great environment for your two fun slots, but two pokemon cannot destroy every team, and most fat breakers are exceptionally easy to out-offense. similarly, stall just slaughters this style of team, with pokemon like mega sableye just obliterating anything zama + slowking can get done, and nothing aside from the fatbreaker being able to even really touch opposing slots it gets one sided extremely quickly. this sort of weakness rant is also in the absolute best case: you actually have two slots that can touch fat. but after 7 billion servings of word salad, I want to actually get my point across to people using this core in tours or even to test their own cool fatbreakers (cough gardevoir cough).


DO NOT USE THIS CORE AND THEN SLAP ON HANDLESS OFFENSE FARMERS.
i know this is egocentric (when am i not) but perhaps this is the feeling a father has for their child learning to ride a bike, or a teacher seeing their student make slight fumbles. i do not like this core, i've made that extremely clear already. but if you choose to use it, as is your total right and you can absolutely make teams better than what I have with this core (it isn't hard, i suck) please do not load up something that cant touch fat. please do not look at this core and think yeah man i need a cinderace. i need a defensive sciz. i need a dnite. please use the actual strength of this core, its ability to enable a big button clicker, and pick a big button clicker. garde i think actually a good route on this (not what I made though LOL), but please do not handicap yourself and make the core worse than it already is. there is maybe a viable route where you slot ONE more defensive fella to cover some of the more egregious mus like idk a sd glisc or an offensive hrott or maybe a hydrapple or something but its kinda tough because it still needs to be able to do shit offensively. I still do use this core from time to time when working on a new idea, since it lets me clock very quickly whether or not a particular breaker can function on this style of team, not whether this core can work with something in particular. this core is an amazing litmus test for testing potentially broken fkers, but please do not try and make it into something it cannot be. also, please do not use defog zap. that shit is so butt. let ur role compression bot iron treads just do his job. zapdos that cannot touch ferro or ghold or opposing treads is just an extremely sad little chungus. I think this core maybe has a route with an offensive zap though, which is a set I really like and can be experimented with (i have a really bad memory but i think ezra made a specs zap team with this that might be a sample rn? that fixes a lot of this core's issues but many still remain IMO but no shade its a better route to go down i think)

this isn't a post to try and get people to follow my thoughts on the metagame to a T. i just want to make sure that people don't fall into the same traps I did when i was first making this core happen, and to make extremely extremely public the issues with it. perhaps this is my way of atoning for griefing my ndcl teammates with this core like 8 different times. my bad. but consider this a psa on building around slowking zapdos treads and what you need to address in order to make it semi-functional. anyways I'm having fun in ndpl expect some more cool stuff and a big ahh writeup post at the end (also the hydrapple stall got used yippie :D) ok bai
​
 
ze infamous doublepostenbludden.... nahhh... zis is not possible

mega dorancie.png


diamond is unwallable

National Dex, for all its flaws, is a metagame I am extremely passionate about. It really has managed to capture my attention in a way that no other tier on smogon has, and despite how annoying it can get, the raw breadth of options available and their relatively balanced nature is extremely attractive for me as a tournament player and builder. I think what draws me to nd is obviously just the extreme level of creativity possible, and how when everything insane from the past few years is compounded with the broken old stuff of old, you wind up with an extremely balanced metagame. The top dogs (no pun intended) of zamazenta and gholdengo are fundamentally not that bad to deal with, and for most well built teams should not create much of an issue outside of what they do on the tin. Z Gholdengo is a potent defensive piece and breaker, but 99% of most teams will not find themselves ever being swept by it in a million years. Zamazenta, being the fastest mon in the tier with some of the best coverage you could possibly ask for, is so easy to answer defensively that most teams wind up covering it without much thought, while zama can still remains potent if unattended in game. You can go down the VR and find much of a similar dichotomy- the good offensive guys can either get walled solidly or out offensed, and the good defensive guys are kept in check by the layering of offensive pieces while everything still remains viable and balanced. but there is one mon that I believe fundamentally breaks this framework, one who truly pushes the limits of what I would consider allowable. no points for guessing.

I will stray from my usual trend of word salad creation to keep things as clear (again no pun intended) as I can make them- Diancie does not have switchins and remains so potent versus offensive teams that it breaks what should be permissible. In the ENTIRE ndou tier, there are three pokemon who can switch in to Mega Diancie. Gliscor, Assault Vest Alomolola, and Assault Vest Melmetal. that is it. I'm going to interject here and just say that melm is pretty awful as a diancie check due to the fact that it has zero ways to recover hp on its own, so I am going to not talk about it for the remainder of this post. If you think AV melm is just gods gift to natdex then i cant really stop you but it has so many issues (not just as a diancie check) that its not really worth discussing IMO. Moving back into the light of viability, alo and glisc are the two possible residents who can switch into diancie. But even still there are issues here, and not ones that can be easily ignored. Assault Vest Alo is probably the biggest set of teambuilding training wheels in ND, with it being spammed on ladder and seen with unfortunate frequency in tournament play. AV Alo seems promising at first as a one-slot diancie and gholdengo check, able to come in on either, sponge a hit easily, and flip out to leave. However, this set has extremely exploitable issues for every archetype, namely being how easy it is to exploit and chip down with hazards and its total impotence when facing the second best offensive threat in the tier, Ogerpon Wellspring. DianSpring is the match made in heaven offensively. Every dragon type or flying type or pecharunt or ferrothorn that would otherwise wall a Swords Dance Wellspring are completely fodderized by Diancie, and Assault Vest Alo and Gliscor are threatened heavily by Power Whip, Spikes, and Knock Off in Alo's case, (which all if clicked prevent it from being able to check diancie) and just a plain old Ivy Cudgel in the case of Gliscor. This toxic yuri marriage absolutely ravages most teams, and can only truly be stopped by either a Zamazenta managing to spook off either of them or a scarfed urshifu scaring them off the hunt. The only other offensive presence capable of beating diancie is volcarona with a free boost, which is... less than ideal to get up versus the two grim reapers of fire types. and even then, with proper building, that is not a hard matchup, since volc is fairly easy to cover for in 2026 with moltres, heatran, and dragonite in the tier.

Now, okay, diancie has no switchins. neither does calm mind tapu lele or close combat Ceruledge. What's your point?
Diancie, even for teams that move at a pace that don't worry about those crazy fatbreakers, still get obliterated by diancie, ESPECIALLY if diancie gets reasonably lucky. Despite giving diancie fewer entries, diancie is still perfectly happy to square up on other offensive pieces or faster defensive ones and blow their shit off smooth, like gholdengo and landorus. This is due to the fact that it sits at a calm 350 speed, making it faster than the likes of lele, charizard, garchomp, iron treads, and kartana (lol), meaning that everything without a scarf can get outspeed and 1-2tapped Faster pieces often can't even meaningfully hit diancie like tornadus and cinderace, and can even grief their own team's ability to check diancie by giving it opportunity to flip the coin of diamond storm, making checks like gliscor, landorus, and zamazenta unable to kill diancie after the boost.

oh god.

Diamond storm.

NIGHTMARENIGHTMARENIGHTMARE.png


Diamond storm introduces a coinflip for diancie to cheat out the game even in the event that your opponent comes prepared. with even just one boost, offensive checks can become unable to kill even through a -def nature, and can lead to some nightmare inducing calcs especially if it manages to win the coinflip twice.
252+ Atk Technician Scizor-Mega Bullet Punch vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie: 192-228 (79.6 - 94.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 Atk Zamazenta Heavy Slam (120 BP) vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie: 196-232 (81.3 - 96.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 Atk Garchomp Earthquake vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie: 128-152 (53.1 - 63%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 Atk Great Tusk Headlong Rush vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie: 156-186 (64.7 - 77.1%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 Atk Wellspring Mask Ogerpon-Wellspring Power Whip vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie: 174-206 (72.1 - 85.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252+ Atk Choice Band Rillaboom Grassy Glide vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie in Grassy Terrain: 150-176 (62.2 - 73%) -- guaranteed 2HKO

This makes already the most potent offensive presence in the tier, whose only weakness its its frailty versus select threats, able to tank those hits and slam back for an instakill. Obviously, if I was alluding to a diancie ban over only a 47% chance to cheese some kills I'd be rightfully laughed out of the thread, but compiled onto diancie's already self-insert tier swathe of strengths, it adds a horrifying level of rng into something already so extremely consistent. In a cruel twist of fate, perhaps to find novelty in lowering itself to the level of mortals, diancie takes a seemingly weighted coinflip and turns it on its head, making it extraordinarily capable of robbing the life out of opponents.

So what's the actual point here? Am I really advocating for a Diancie suspect? The answer is... kind of? The tier is in a fine enough state as is, and undoubtedly diancie does keep some cancerous threats like volcarona, garchomp, and tornadus in check, but the python-like stranglehold it has on the builder on its own is comedic. I think there's also just a very interesting habit of low level or ladder players just not using/accounting for diancie, and I think that would probably result in a DNB from your average natdexxer. But as one of like. seven people who build this tier consistently for tours, I think its absolutely worth trying to get more minds on this than just slop "sack everything and lose" cat. anyway pl has been fun i think these have been the most engaging games i've ever played despite my own mistakes and I should have some cool stuff these next 2 weeks ok lmk what u guys think especially other tour players ok bye :D
​
 
slopcat said:
ze infamous doublepostenbludden.... nahhh... zis is not possible

View attachment 867445

diamond is unwallable

National Dex, for all its flaws, is a metagame I am extremely passionate about. It really has managed to capture my attention in a way that no other tier on smogon has, and despite how annoying it can get, the raw breadth of options available and their relatively balanced nature is extremely attractive for me as a tournament player and builder. I think what draws me to nd is obviously just the extreme level of creativity possible, and how when everything insane from the past few years is compounded with the broken old stuff of old, you wind up with an extremely balanced metagame. The top dogs (no pun intended) of zamazenta and gholdengo are fundamentally not that bad to deal with, and for most well built teams should not create much of an issue outside of what they do on the tin. Z Gholdengo is a potent defensive piece and breaker, but 99% of most teams will not find themselves ever being swept by it in a million years. Zamazenta, being the fastest mon in the tier with some of the best coverage you could possibly ask for, is so easy to answer defensively that most teams wind up covering it without much thought, while zama can still remains potent if unattended in game. You can go down the VR and find much of a similar dichotomy- the good offensive guys can either get walled solidly or out offensed, and the good defensive guys are kept in check by the layering of offensive pieces while everything still remains viable and balanced. but there is one mon that I believe fundamentally breaks this framework, one who truly pushes the limits of what I would consider allowable. no points for guessing.

I will stray from my usual trend of word salad creation to keep things as clear (again no pun intended) as I can make them- Diancie does not have switchins and remains so potent versus offensive teams that it breaks what should be permissible. In the ENTIRE ndou tier, there are three pokemon who can switch in to Mega Diancie. Gliscor, Assault Vest Alomolola, and Assault Vest Melmetal. that is it. I'm going to interject here and just say that melm is pretty awful as a diancie check due to the fact that it has zero ways to recover hp on its own, so I am going to not talk about it for the remainder of this post. If you think AV melm is just gods gift to natdex then i cant really stop you but it has so many issues (not just as a diancie check) that its not really worth discussing IMO. Moving back into the light of viability, alo and glisc are the two possible residents who can switch into diancie. But even still there are issues here, and not ones that can be easily ignored. Assault Vest Alo is probably the biggest set of teambuilding training wheels in ND, with it being spammed on ladder and seen with unfortunate frequency in tournament play. AV Alo seems promising at first as a one-slot diancie and gholdengo check, able to come in on either, sponge a hit easily, and flip out to leave. However, this set has extremely exploitable issues for every archetype, namely being how easy it is to exploit and chip down with hazards and its total impotence when facing the second best offensive threat in the tier, Ogerpon Wellspring. DianSpring is the match made in heaven offensively. Every dragon type or flying type or pecharunt or ferrothorn that would otherwise wall a Swords Dance Wellspring are completely fodderized by Diancie, and Assault Vest Alo and Gliscor are threatened heavily by Power Whip, Spikes, and Knock Off in Alo's case, (which all if clicked prevent it from being able to check diancie) and just a plain old Ivy Cudgel in the case of Gliscor. This toxic yuri marriage absolutely ravages most teams, and can only truly be stopped by either a Zamazenta managing to spook off either of them or a scarfed urshifu scaring them off the hunt. The only other offensive presence capable of beating diancie is volcarona with a free boost, which is... less than ideal to get up versus the two grim reapers of fire types. and even then, with proper building, that is not a hard matchup, since volc is fairly easy to cover for in 2026 with moltres, heatran, and dragonite in the tier.

Now, okay, diancie has no switchins. neither does calm mind tapu lele or close combat Ceruledge. What's your point?
Diancie, even for teams that move at a pace that don't worry about those crazy fatbreakers, still get obliterated by diancie, ESPECIALLY if diancie gets reasonably lucky. Despite giving diancie fewer entries, diancie is still perfectly happy to square up on other offensive pieces or faster defensive ones and blow their shit off smooth, like gholdengo and landorus. This is due to the fact that it sits at a calm 350 speed, making it faster than the likes of lele, charizard, garchomp, iron treads, and kartana (lol), meaning that everything without a scarf can get outspeed and 1-2tapped Faster pieces often can't even meaningfully hit diancie like tornadus and cinderace, and can even grief their own team's ability to check diancie by giving it opportunity to flip the coin of diamond storm, making checks like gliscor, landorus, and zamazenta unable to kill diancie after the boost.

oh god.

Diamond storm.

View attachment 867456

Diamond storm introduces a coinflip for diancie to cheat out the game even in the event that your opponent comes prepared. with even just one boost, offensive checks can become unable to kill even through a -def nature, and can lead to some nightmare inducing calcs especially if it manages to win the coinflip twice.
252+ Atk Technician Scizor-Mega Bullet Punch vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie: 192-228 (79.6 - 94.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 Atk Zamazenta Heavy Slam (120 BP) vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie: 196-232 (81.3 - 96.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 Atk Garchomp Earthquake vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie: 128-152 (53.1 - 63%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 Atk Great Tusk Headlong Rush vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie: 156-186 (64.7 - 77.1%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 Atk Wellspring Mask Ogerpon-Wellspring Power Whip vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie: 174-206 (72.1 - 85.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252+ Atk Choice Band Rillaboom Grassy Glide vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie in Grassy Terrain: 150-176 (62.2 - 73%) -- guaranteed 2HKO

This makes already the most potent offensive presence in the tier, whose only weakness its its frailty versus select threats, able to tank those hits and slam back for an instakill. Obviously, if I was alluding to a diancie ban over only a 47% chance to cheese some kills I'd be rightfully laughed out of the thread, but compiled onto diancie's already self-insert tier swathe of strengths, it adds a horrifying level of rng into something already so extremely consistent. In a cruel twist of fate, perhaps to find novelty in lowering itself to the level of mortals, diancie takes a seemingly weighted coinflip and turns it on its head, making it extraordinarily capable of robbing the life out of opponents.

So what's the actual point here? Am I really advocating for a Diancie suspect? The answer is... kind of? The tier is in a fine enough state as is, and undoubtedly diancie does keep some cancerous threats like volcarona, garchomp, and tornadus in check, but the python-like stranglehold it has on the builder on its own is comedic. I think there's also just a very interesting habit of low level or ladder players just not using/accounting for diancie, and I think that would probably result in a DNB from your average natdexxer. But as one of like. seven people who build this tier consistently for tours, I think its absolutely worth trying to get more minds on this than just slop "sack everything and lose" cat. anyway pl has been fun i think these have been the most engaging games i've ever played despite my own mistakes and I should have some cool stuff these next 2 weeks ok lmk what u guys think especially other tour players ok bye :D
​
What If You Simply Just Loaded Diancie… Yourself?

Problem Solved.
 
Illouri said:
Decently sized post about bots (my own takes + responding to others)
hi im switching up on this bots are stinky

not going to go super deep into this since i dont want to make mods mad since its clear this is not a natdex focused topics, however, for the sake of my own pr, i'd like to just make some updates (?) to my thoughts

i made this post without knowing just how many bots were on all ladders, let alone nd. i also didn't really have any discussion with anyone before making the post either, so i couldnt really be challenged on my thoughts or ideas. i kinda just made an opinion, did some brief research, and called it a night (it was like 4 am when i upped that). the increase of bot appearances swarming ladder and the fact that they have become difficult to fight (via timer stalling) has made me believe they are a hinderance for the tier rather than something to be ignored

again, this is bigger than nd so there isnt much to do here, just wanted to correct myself. to switch topics so another big discussion doesnt begin, i think galarian wheezing is pretty cool, does some cool stuff with neutral gas that should be explored more. shutting down stuff like regen and good as gold is neat
gweez.png
 
Back
Top