ze infamous doublepostenbludden.... nahhh... zis is not possible
diamond is unwallable
National Dex, for all its flaws, is a metagame I am extremely passionate about. It really has managed to capture my attention in a way that no other tier on smogon has, and despite how annoying it can get, the raw breadth of options available and their relatively balanced nature is extremely attractive for me as a tournament player and builder. I think what draws me to nd is obviously just the extreme level of creativity possible, and how when everything insane from the past few years is compounded with the broken old stuff of old, you wind up with an extremely balanced metagame. The top dogs (no pun intended) of zamazenta and gholdengo are fundamentally not that bad to deal with, and for most well built teams should not create much of an issue outside of what they do on the tin. Z Gholdengo is a potent defensive piece and breaker, but 99% of most teams will not find themselves ever being swept by it in a million years. Zamazenta, being the fastest mon in the tier with some of the best coverage you could possibly ask for, is so easy to answer defensively that most teams wind up covering it without much thought, while zama can still remains potent if unattended in game. You can go down the VR and find much of a similar dichotomy- the good offensive guys can either get walled solidly or out offensed, and the good defensive guys are kept in check by the layering of offensive pieces while everything still remains viable and balanced. but there is one mon that I believe fundamentally breaks this framework, one who truly pushes the limits of what I would consider allowable. no points for guessing.
I will stray from my usual trend of word salad creation to keep things as clear (again no pun intended) as I can make them- Diancie does not have switchins and remains so potent versus offensive teams that it breaks what should be permissible. In the ENTIRE ndou tier, there are three pokemon who can switch in to Mega Diancie. Gliscor, Assault Vest Alomolola, and Assault Vest Melmetal. that is it. I'm going to interject here and just say that melm is pretty awful as a diancie check due to the fact that it has zero ways to recover hp on its own, so I am going to not talk about it for the remainder of this post. If you think AV melm is just gods gift to natdex then i cant really stop you but it has so many issues (not just as a diancie check) that its not really worth discussing IMO. Moving back into the light of viability, alo and glisc are the two possible residents who can switch into diancie. But even still there are issues here, and not ones that can be easily ignored. Assault Vest Alo is probably the biggest set of teambuilding training wheels in ND, with it being spammed on ladder and seen with unfortunate frequency in tournament play. AV Alo seems promising at first as a one-slot diancie and gholdengo check, able to come in on either, sponge a hit easily, and flip out to leave. However, this set has extremely exploitable issues for every archetype, namely being how easy it is to exploit and chip down with hazards and its total impotence when facing the second best offensive threat in the tier, Ogerpon Wellspring. DianSpring is the match made in heaven offensively. Every dragon type or flying type or pecharunt or ferrothorn that would otherwise wall a Swords Dance Wellspring are completely fodderized by Diancie, and Assault Vest Alo and Gliscor are threatened heavily by Power Whip, Spikes, and Knock Off in Alo's case, (which all if clicked prevent it from being able to check diancie) and just a plain old Ivy Cudgel in the case of Gliscor. This toxic yuri marriage absolutely ravages most teams, and can only truly be stopped by either a Zamazenta managing to spook off either of them or a scarfed urshifu scaring them off the hunt. The only other offensive presence capable of beating diancie is volcarona with a free boost, which is... less than ideal to get up versus the two grim reapers of fire types. and even then, with proper building, that is not a hard matchup, since volc is fairly easy to cover for in 2026 with moltres, heatran, and dragonite in the tier.
Now, okay, diancie has no switchins. neither does calm mind tapu lele or close combat Ceruledge. What's your point?
Diancie, even for teams that move at a pace that don't worry about those crazy fatbreakers, still get obliterated by diancie, ESPECIALLY if diancie gets reasonably lucky. Despite giving diancie fewer entries, diancie is still perfectly happy to square up on other offensive pieces or faster defensive ones and blow their shit off smooth, like gholdengo and landorus. This is due to the fact that it sits at a calm 350 speed, making it faster than the likes of lele, charizard, garchomp, iron treads, and kartana (lol), meaning that everything without a scarf can get outspeed and 1-2tapped Faster pieces often can't even meaningfully hit diancie like tornadus and cinderace, and can even grief their own team's ability to check diancie by giving it opportunity to flip the coin of diamond storm, making checks like gliscor, landorus, and zamazenta unable to kill diancie after the boost.
oh god.
Diamond storm.
Diamond storm introduces a coinflip for diancie to cheat out the game even in the event that your opponent comes prepared. with even just one boost, offensive checks can become unable to kill even through a -def nature, and can lead to some nightmare inducing calcs especially if it manages to win the coinflip twice.
252+ Atk Technician Scizor-Mega Bullet Punch vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie: 192-228 (79.6 - 94.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 Atk Zamazenta Heavy Slam (120 BP) vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie: 196-232 (81.3 - 96.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 Atk Garchomp Earthquake vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie: 128-152 (53.1 - 63%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 Atk Great Tusk Headlong Rush vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie: 156-186 (64.7 - 77.1%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 Atk Wellspring Mask Ogerpon-Wellspring Power Whip vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie: 174-206 (72.1 - 85.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252+ Atk Choice Band Rillaboom Grassy Glide vs. +2 0 HP / 0- Def Diancie in Grassy Terrain: 150-176 (62.2 - 73%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
This makes already the most potent offensive presence in the tier, whose only weakness its its frailty versus select threats, able to tank those hits and slam back for an instakill. Obviously, if I was alluding to a diancie ban over only a 47% chance to cheese some kills I'd be rightfully laughed out of the thread, but compiled onto diancie's already self-insert tier swathe of strengths, it adds a horrifying level of rng into something already so extremely consistent. In a cruel twist of fate, perhaps to find novelty in lowering itself to the level of mortals, diancie takes a seemingly weighted coinflip and turns it on its head, making it extraordinarily capable of robbing the life out of opponents.
So what's the actual point here? Am I really advocating for a Diancie suspect? The answer is... kind of? The tier is in a fine enough state as is, and undoubtedly diancie does keep some cancerous threats like volcarona, garchomp, and tornadus in check, but the python-like stranglehold it has on the builder on its own is comedic. I think there's also just a very interesting habit of low level or ladder players just not using/accounting for diancie, and I think that would probably result in a DNB from your average natdexxer. But as one of like. seven people who build this tier consistently for tours, I think its absolutely worth trying to get more minds on this than just slop "sack everything and lose" cat. anyway pl has been fun i think these have been the most engaging games i've ever played despite my own mistakes and I should have some cool stuff these next 2 weeks ok lmk what u guys think especially other tour players ok bye :D