• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

[WIP] Introducing OU Scanalizer - AI/ML teambuilding tool for SV OU

Status
Not open for further replies.
ANinjaDude said:
I don't think that it's particularly random to be against the thing that is bankrupting the world, poisoning our water and air, and corroding our minds, sense of self, creativity, and agency.

Good thing that mankind was already in that position before AI became a popular thing. My point was that saying AI is bad without judging the results of its usage is just giving credit to techno-facists that want to replace everyone with robots. What needs to be said over and over is how the "casual" users of AI lack the ability to determine if what they made is good or not. Most of the time, they are incompetent in that aspect and it's important to clown on them since they are the primary reason of why AI is such a big issue for our society right now.
 
I don't think the overuse of AI in external fields is particularly relevant to this discussion.

However, there is a skill to realizing that your product, AI or not, does not perform to a level to be taken seriously, let alone see much use. What you've effectively done here is make a mockery of teambuilding tools by publishing this slop that will only hurt newer users who are unfamiliar with teambuilding and trust it. You're replacing the honest work of fucking around and finding out with an inaccurate tool that will tell people that they are or aren't weak to something, and this will make them discount it as a possibility. This will do nothing for the already advanced community and actively hurt newer players who may seek tools like this.

Get rid of it, or find a way to make it usable enough that it isn't actively going against what you envisioned it doing.
 
iforgetwhyimhere said:
I don't think the overuse of AI in external fields is particularly relevant to this discussion.

However, there is a skill to realizing that your product, AI or not, does not perform to a level to be taken seriously, let alone see much use. What you've effectively done here is make a mockery of teambuilding tools by publishing this slop that will only hurt newer users who are unfamiliar with teambuilding and trust it. You're replacing the honest work of fucking around and finding out with an inaccurate tool that will tell people that they are or aren't weak to something, and this will make them discount it as a possibility. This will do nothing for the already advanced community and actively hurt newer players who may seek tools like this.

Get rid of it, or find a way to make it usable enough that it isn't actively going against what you envisioned it doing.
It is a mockery, because it doenst account for amoongus that has... 0.70218% usage in OU?

You cant be serious! It didnt made it into my training data. Same with all other shitmons people keep posting.
 
this is a thread about the tool obviously which doesn't seem that good
but hating on someone incessantly just for wanting to have a tool to help them improve is sooo lame.
chess got much worse after engines, but it also provided many tools for people interested in improving to help themselves. people on this site for a while seem to think there's an obligation for all new players to have it as hard as they did, imagine an old grandmaster hating on a newer player for wanting to utilise an opening database. obviously theyre not complete parallels, and i dont think anyone would want a perfect building/playing tool like there is in chess, but please be kind

people honestly interested in improving will be able to improve more, people interested in cheap wins will be able to have that more easily. the tool nor creator is the evil here
 
DIYUSI said:
Good thing that mankind was already in that position before AI became a popular thing. My point was that saying AI is bad without judging the results of its usage is just giving credit to techno-facists that want to replace everyone with robots. What needs to be said over and over is how the "casual" users of AI lack the ability to determine if what they made is good or not. Most of the time, they are incompetent in that aspect and it's important to clown on them since they are the primary reason of why AI is such a big issue for our society right now.
I do not care that mankind was already in a bad spot before AI, because that doesn't excuse AI from making things worse. I heard someone describe this defense of AI as "saying you might as well yell at your wife since you've already beaten her," and that's the best way I can put it.
 
bbnate said:
this is a thread about the tool obviously which doesn't seem that good
but hating on someone incessantly just for wanting to have a tool to help them improve is sooo lame.
chess got much worse after engines, but it also provided many tools for people interested in improving to help themselves. people on this site for a while seem to think there's an obligation for all new players to have it as hard as they did, imagine an old grandmaster hating on a newer player for wanting to utilise an opening database. obviously theyre not complete parallels, and i dont think anyone would want a perfect building/playing tool like there is in chess, but please be kind

people honestly interested in improving will be able to improve more, people interested in cheap wins will be able to have that more easily. the tool nor creator is the evil here
The tool is complete and utter dogshit, utterly useless to experienced players, and harmful for new players.
 
bbnate said:
but it also provided many tools for people interested in improving to help themselves. people on this site for a while seem to think there's an obligation for all new players to have it as hard as they did, imagine an old grandmaster hating on a newer player for wanting to utilise an opening database
There's a very important difference between "This tool helps new players!" and "This tool tells you it will help you as a new player, but the advice it gives is so genuinely dogshit it is just going to drag you down even further." In this case, it is the latter. This isn't people wanting to keep new players from having tools that make it easier, this is them actively protecting new users from receiving confidently incorrect information.

It paints the scenario as something its not, and gives you advice for the scenario it tells you it is. That advice doesn't help in the scenario it actually is.
 
iforgetwhyimhere said:
There's a very important difference between "This tool helps new players!" and "This tool tells you it will help you as a new player, but the advice it gives is so genuinely dogshit it is just going to drag you down even further." In this case, it is the latter. This isn't people wanting to keep new players from having tools that make it easier, this is them actively protecting new users from receiving confidently incorrect information.

It paints the scenario as something its not, and gives you advice for the scenario it tells you it is. That advice doesn't help in the scenario it actually is.
yeah very fair. criticism of this particular tool seems very warranted from what i can tell
but it seems clear that the creator was acting in good faith (from what i can tell), and that a decent chunk of the criticism is just seeing ai and being angry.
there's very valid concerns to be made about deskilling, finch made them better than i could, but ultimately the points about this should be directed at the individuals (looking to play and improve) rather than the tools, and especially not manifest in hate to the creators
 
My opinion
Why not I’ll throw my few cents?

I know I haven’t been on showdown as long as many people here, but I’m a working intelligent human being so I have enough to make a statement. When I started pokemon showdown, I was making Gen 8 NatDex Ru inspired by Karen’s famous quote of using your favourites. Ai doesn’t have favourites. Let alone better judgement. Ai doesn’t have a place here. Although my better judgement, it has reasons to exist in other fields. But on a battle sim for a game? Why are we using it? The use of Ai here is just saying that you don’t have the patience, skill or brains to create a team yourself. “Oh I had Ai create a team for me” yeh but you don’t know how it works instantly? Does the Ai even know?
Look I like the idea of using algorithms to find usage stats, damage outputs, and matchups, like Ai is supposed to be used. It’s supposed to be used like an assistant, not your boss.
It’s gettin a little long but I’ll end it short saying that Ai has no rightful presence here. It has its uses, but teambuilding isn’t one I agree with, and that’s not even including helping you on the ladder or playing for you aswell?? You must be out of your mind.
 
ANinjaDude said:
I do not care that mankind was already in a bad spot before AI, because that doesn't excuse AI from making things worse. I heard someone describe this defense of AI as "saying you might as well yell at your wife since you've already beaten her," and that's the best way I can put it.
What defense lmao. I'm not defending anyone here, just saying how being anti-AI without linking it with the current results of its product is dumb. I said it twice how, in this case, the product was awful and, as I said again, we can generalize how AI is bad in the sense it's overused by people that are wasting resources to make complete dipshit. If you think I was defending AI, then maybe you need to be less of an idiot and learn how to read. If anything, I was agreeing with everyone here but I was disliking answers like from Finch that felt very emotional when you could just explain that the tool was trash and it was, again, a terrible usage of AI.
 
bbnate said:
a decent chunk of the criticism is just seeing ai and being angry.
DIYUSI said:
being anti-AI without explaining the current results of its product is dumb. I said it twice how, in this case, the product was awful and, as I said again, we can generalize how AI is bad in the sense it's overused by people that are wasting resources to make complete dipshit.
I'm not trying to defend the actions of other users in this thread, in fact I think they could chill a little (though I will not call them out).

There are issues to be found, and that is very apparent, but there is an incredible difference between hating this for using AI, and hating this for being bad. I'm mostly anti-AI myself, especially in coding and Pokemon, but I think some people here have to understand going after this simply for having AI accomplishes nothing. There are problems with the product itself that make it bad, and being "made using AI" is not an inherent issue that deserves as much flaming as is occurring.

TLDR for skimmers: Yes, it sucks, but "it's AI!" is not a valid criticism in isolation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top