• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

CAP 38 - Part 10 - Moveset Discussion

Zetalz said:
quz mentioned it briefly but we do need to decide what flavor of 50% recovery move 38 has at some point this stage. We could wait a few days until we have Art to make a decision, but feel free to mention your preference now, if you have one. If there's no real interest, we'll just lock-in bog standard Recover.
Is Synthesis on the table? It's by far the most common 50% recovery on Grass types.
If Synthesis is not an option, I say wait for art; I suspect we'd end up going with Recover, but other options could fit depending on the design.
 
Zetalz said:
Other Things:
quz mentioned it briefly but we do need to decide what flavor of 50% recovery move 38 has at some point this stage. We could wait a few days until we have Art to make a decision, but feel free to mention your preference now, if you have one. If there's no real interest, we'll just lock-in bog standard Recover.
i think synthesis is probably our recovery flavor. we're a grass-type, we're guaranteed some sort of flower somewhere in the design, i feel like it's the obvious option. my one worry is that it might alter how we interact with our own and opposing weather, which is a major part of ubers that eternatus has very little interaction with. weather isn't omnipresent over here like it is there, but malaconda at least is good enough that this should be taken into account
 
this is a. really long one. I'm sorry in advance to anyone who decides to read this in its entirety.

:landorus:
regarding earth power
traceyscetchit said:
:Ceruledge:, :Chuggalong:, :Gholdengo:, :Iron Moth:, :Kingambit:, :Kitsunoh:, :Mollux:, :glimmora:,:heatran:,:Pecharunt:, :Ramnarok:, and :Slowking-Galar:
Okay, let's go over them.

the calcs (offensive set)
:ceruledge:
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Ceruledge: 195-231 (67 - 79.3%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Earth Power vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Ceruledge: 250-296 (85.9 - 101.7%) -- 12.5% chance to OHKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Ceruledge: 52-61 (17.8 - 20.9%) -- possible 5HKO

:chuggalong:
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Chuggalong: 179-213 (77.4 - 92.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Earth Power vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Chuggalong: 231-273 (100 - 118.1%) -- guaranteed OHKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Gholdengo: 226-268 (71.7 - 85%) -- guaranteed 2HKO

:gholdengo:
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Gholdengo: 211-250 (66.9 - 79.3%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Earth Power vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Gholdengo: 270-320 (85.7 - 101.5%) -- 12.5% chance to OHKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Gholdengo: 226-268 (71.7 - 85%) -- guaranteed 2HKO

:iron moth:
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Iron Moth: 364-432 (120.9 - 143.5%) -- guaranteed OHKO

:kingambit:
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Kingambit: 224-265 (65.6 - 77.7%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Earth Power vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Kingambit: 289-341 (84.7 - 100%) -- 6.3% chance to OHKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Kingambit: 239-283 (70 - 82.9%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery

:kitsunoh:
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 104 HP / 0 SpD Kitsunoh: 234-278 (71.5 - 85%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Earth Power vs. 104 HP / 0 SpD Kitsunoh: 304-359 (92.9 - 109.7%) -- 56.3% chance to OHKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 104 HP / 0 SpD Kitsunoh: 252-299 (77 - 91.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO

:mollux:
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 248 HP / 212+ SpD Mollux: 286-338 (72.7 - 86%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Earth Power vs. 248 HP / 212+ SpD Mollux: 364-432 (92.6 - 109.9%) -- 56.3% chance to OHKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 248 HP / 212+ SpD Dry Skin Mollux: 47-56 (11.9 - 14.2%) -- possible 8HKO

:glimmora:
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 252 HP / 4 SpD Glimmora: 468-551 (126.4 - 148.9%) -- guaranteed OHKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 252 HP / 4 SpD Glimmora: 62-73 (16.7 - 19.7%) -- guaranteed 6HKO

:heatran:
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Heatran: 374-442 (115.7 - 136.8%) -- guaranteed OHKO

:pecharunt:
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Pecharunt: 218-257 (57.3 - 67.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Earth Power vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Pecharunt: 278-330 (73.1 - 86.8%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Pecharunt: 117-138 (30.7 - 36.3%) -- 52.9% chance to 3HKO

:ramnarok:
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Assault Vest Ramnarok: 203-244 (56.2 - 67.5%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Earth Power vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Assault Vest Ramnarok: 265-312 (73.4 - 86.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Assault Vest Ramnarok: 55-65 (15.2 - 18%) -- possible 6HKO
:ramnarok-radiant:
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Assault Vest Ramnarok-Radiant: 213-252 (59 - 69.8%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Earth Power vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Assault Vest Ramnarok-Radiant: 273-322 (75.6 - 89.1%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Assault Vest Ramnarok-Radiant: 114-135 (31.5 - 37.3%) -- 86.5% chance to 3HKO

:slowking-galar:
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 252 HP / 4 SpD Slowking-Galar: 179-213 (45.4 - 54%) -- 44.5% chance to 2HKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Earth Power vs. 252 HP / 4 SpD Slowking-Galar: 231-273 (58.6 - 69.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 SpA Life Orb Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 252 HP / 4 SpD Slowking-Galar: 96-114 (24.3 - 28.9%) -- 99.5% chance to 4HKO

:gholdengo:, :kitsunoh: (if it traced Flower Veil): Mystical Fire will probably be used over Scorching Sands for slightly more power and/or a SpA decrease.
:kingambit:, :kitsunoh:: Scorching Sands will probably be used over Mystical Fire for burn.
:glimmora:, :iron moth:, :heatran: : OHKO'd by Scorching Sands.
:pecharunt:, :ramnarok: : Stay as a 2HKO through both Scorching Sands and Earth Power.
:ceruledge:, :mollux:, :slowking-galar:, all the Steel-types : Our chances improve from a 2HKO, but are still not guaranteed to OHKO.
:chuggalong: : An interesting case. Our chances improve to a guaranteed OHKO, but this is fragile enough to be broken by something as simple as Chuggalong putting 4 EVs into HP.

the calcs (defensive set)
SunshineFuture said:
EVs: 252 HP / 252 Def / 4 Spe OR 4 HP / 252 Def / 252 Spe
Using these EVs to determine our damage output. I can see a world where we have some amount of SpA investment, but I'm too lazy to factor that in.
:ceruledge:
0 SpA Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Ceruledge: 124-146 (42.6 - 50.1%) -- 0.4% chance to 2HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Earth Power vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Ceruledge: 158-188 (54.2 - 64.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Ceruledge: 33-39 (11.3 - 13.4%) -- possible 8HKO

:chuggalong:
0 SpA Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Chuggalong: 114-136 (49.3 - 58.8%) -- 98.8% chance to 2HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Earth Power vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Chuggalong: 146-174 (63.2 - 75.3%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Chuggalong: 31-36 (13.4 - 15.5%) -- possible 7HKO

:gholdengo:
0 SpA Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Gholdengo: 134-158 (42.5 - 50.1%) -- 0.4% chance to 2HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Earth Power vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Gholdengo: 172-204 (54.6 - 64.7%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Gholdengo: 144-170 (45.7 - 53.9%) -- 42.2% chance to 2HKO

:iron moth:
0 SpA Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Iron Moth: 228-272 (75.7 - 90.3%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Earth Power vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Iron Moth: 292-348 (97 - 115.6%) -- 81.3% chance to OHKO
0 SpA Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Iron Moth: 31-36 (10.2 - 11.9%) -- possible 9HKO

:kingambit:
0 SpA Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Kingambit: 142-168 (41.6 - 49.2%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
0 SpA Venusaur Earth Power vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Kingambit: 182-216 (53.3 - 63.3%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
0 SpA Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Kingambit: 152-180 (44.5 - 52.7%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery

:kitsunoh:
0 SpA Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 104 HP / 0 SpD Kitsunoh: 150-178 (45.8 - 54.4%) -- 51.6% chance to 2HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Earth Power vs. 104 HP / 0 SpD Kitsunoh: 192-226 (58.7 - 69.1%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 104 HP / 0 SpD Kitsunoh: 160-190 (48.9 - 58.1%) -- 96.1% chance to 2HKO

:mollux:
0 SpA Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 248 HP / 212+ SpD Mollux: 180-212 (45.8 - 53.9%) -- 34.4% chance to 2HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Earth Power vs. 248 HP / 212+ SpD Mollux: 228-272 (58 - 69.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 248 HP / 212+ SpD Dry Skin Mollux: 30-35 (7.6 - 8.9%) -- possibly the worst move ever

:glimmora:
0 SpA Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 252 HP / 4 SpD Glimmora: 292-348 (78.9 - 94%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Earth Power vs. 252 HP / 4 SpD Glimmora: 380-448 (102.7 - 121%) -- guaranteed OHKO
0 SpA Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 252 HP / 4 SpD Glimmora: 39-46 (10.5 - 12.4%) -- possible 9HKO

:heatran:
0 SpA Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Heatran: 236-280 (73 - 86.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
0 SpA Venusaur Earth Power vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Heatran: 304-360 (94.1 - 111.4%) -- 68.8% chance to OHKO

:pecharunt:
0 SpA Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Pecharunt: 138-164 (36.3 - 43.1%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Earth Power vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Pecharunt: 178-210 (46.8 - 55.2%) -- 69.5% chance to 2HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Pecharunt: 74-88 (19.4 - 23.1%) -- possible 5HKO

:ramnarok:
0 SpA Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Assault Vest Ramnarok: 132-156 (36.5 - 43.2%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Earth Power vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Assault Vest Ramnarok: 164-196 (45.4 - 54.2%) -- 44.1% chance to 2HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Assault Vest Ramnarok: 34-41 (9.4 - 11.3%) -- possible 9HKO
:ramnarok-radiant:
0 SpA Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Assault Vest Ramnarok-Radiant: 136-160 (37.6 - 44.3%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Earth Power vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Assault Vest Ramnarok-Radiant: 174-206 (48.1 - 57%) -- 89.1% chance to 2HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Assault Vest Ramnarok-Radiant: 73-86 (20.2 - 23.8%) -- guaranteed 5HKO

:slowking-galar:
0 SpA Venusaur Scorching Sands vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Slowking-Galar: 84-100 (21.3 - 25.3%) -- 0.2% chance to 4HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Earth Power vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Slowking-Galar: 108-128 (27.4 - 32.4%) -- guaranteed 4HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Slowking-Galar: 45-54 (11.4 - 13.7%) -- possible 8HKO

Earth Power allows us to deny a Clangorous Soul from :chuggalong:, OHKO :iron moth:, :glimmora:, and :heatran:, and chip everything else for more damage than Scorching Sands can.

Fun side note: LO :ceruledge: serves as a good revenge killer to defensive CAP38, as it can heal more HP from Bitter Blade (even with us having 252/252+ physical bulk) than we can dish out.

traceyscetchit said:
Finally, scorching sands has a strong secondary effect. Any analysis reducing scald to simply an 80 bp water type move would find scald a terrible move.
Quick stop to discuss the secondary effect. 3/9 of Pokemon you gave as a primary target of Scorching Sands are simply immune to the 30% burn chance (as well as :kitsunoh: if it Traces our Flower Veil). Meanwhile, all except :ceruledge: are immune to poison from Sludge Bomb.

Rubberducking is a technique usually used in software engineering. A software engineer may explain code to someone, and in doing so, gains a better understanding of it and its flaws.

I originally wrote this section with the intent to explain why Earth Power should be put on, but my thoughts on it have shifted since beginning to write this two days ago. It appears to me that Earth Power allows us to shift offensive CAP38's matchup against multiple defensive targets from a 2HKO to an OHKO. Meanwhile, it does not provide as much use to defensive sets, as it has a worse secondary effect and the power increase is less impactful. At this stage, I'd rather we start low and have lots of checks, and then (if needed) raise our floor so that we're more viable in the current meta. For this reason, I'd say we should not start out with Earth Power on the 1.0 release.


:deoxys-speed:
Regarding utility:
People tossed up a bunch more utility options since I last posted, so here are my thoughts on them.

common utility bits
:weavile:
Spammernoob said:
Knock Off
Personally, I don't really like the feeling of this one. Mainly, Knock Off encourages hit-and-run playstyle with hazards, which doesn't feel a lot like Etern; while Toxic can be hit-and-run, it also enables staying in and grinding out in certain matchups, which is just not an option with Knock. We are sacrificing some of Eternatus' playstyle for viability here. If we did not have Ground coverage guaranteed, I might be a bigger fan of this, as it would open up MUs vs Fire-types (mostly Mollux). As-is, it feels a bit inelegant, but probably gets us to the point of viability.
DaddyBuzzwole said:
knock off: i kinda vibe with item denial being our "permanent progress that few things are immune to" thing. although i think knock is kind of boring and cheap and i'd prefer corrosive gas, i did some statistical analysis and found that knock works better as a toxic analogue:
  • ubers has 33 pokemon above c rank and 8 of those (24.2%) are immune to toxic or otherwise some sort of toxic absorber:
    • :zacian-crowned::necrozma-dusk-mane::eternatus::kingambit::hatterene::glimmora::gliscor::blissey:
  • meanwhile, cap has 74 pokemon above c rank, and 18 of those (24.3%) have at least some sets that can absorb knock off:
    • booster energy users: :great tusk::iron moth::iron crown::iron valiant::raging bolt:
    • status orb users: :gliscor::snaelstrom::naviathan::ursaluna:
    • single-use item users: :stratagem::chuggalong::heatran::glimmora:
    • unremovable items: :ogerpon-wellspring::shox:
    • spikes immunity + no rocks weakness + reliable recovery: :clefable::corviknight::skarmory:
  • if we were to do corrosive gas instead, we'd have to add gholdengo and hatterene to the list, which would mess up the almost perfectly aligning percentages. so even though i like corrosive gas better in terms of flavor and novelty, knock off is objectively the best analogue to toxic in terms of absolute volume of relevant absorbers
I actually kinda agree with Spammernoob here. Knock Off does offer slight chip damage, but it can only be used once per opponent and only on a few opponents. Sure, Toxic does have a similar issue, but it has a lasting effect that eventually pressures the opponent to switch and reset the timer. I don't know if item removal can pressure anyone out, unless your opponent is really dependant on the item.

Also to DaddyBuzzwole: 1) we outspeed all Pokemon in both the status orb and single-use item categories, which means that their items don't get a chance to proc before being knocked off, and 2) I'm fairly certain Power Herb offensive CAP38 would also qualify.

:glimmora:
Spammernoob said:
Mortal Spin
This option compromises heavily on CA2, where we decided we wouldn't play into the hazards game. However, I suppose that is an actualization guideline that is lower priority than having multiple viable sets (even though I'd rather not compromise it). In conjunction with Mystical Fire, which can pressure most Steel-types, Mortal Spin probably works solidly as a removal option (maybe secondary on teams that really need it) and I suppose there's a world where CAP38 can be used on the same team as Slowking-Galar for Kyurem support?
My problem with Mortal Spin is the fact that it automatically poisons the opponent, which denies us from both Scorching Sands burn and Toxic. While regular poison is a good status, it's definitely the least impactful of the three. I don't really care about the hazard game, and I would appreciate another remover, but the side effect is too much for me.
I also have the same problem with Rapid Spin. I don't want us to outspeed Scarf Darkrai / Ogerpon without a Scarf of our own.

:smeargle:
The interesting ones!
Spammernoob said:
Other Options
I think it's possible to play into our Speed and tailor our defensive set to beat a certain archetype, like how Cresceidon targets offense and is basically dead weight vs fat. Basically, we're looking to specialize to carve out a niche. Something like Heart Swap / Topsy Turvy to punish setup while leveraging our speed is probably workable, though it is pretty matchup-fishy and I'm 99% sure people will hate on it. People have expressed distaste for Encore / Taunt, and they probably don't feel right here (even though they'd be strong). Acid Spray is probably fine here as well, no one uses this move but maybe there's an application?

Finally, I'll discuss some moves that probably are fine supplemental, but don't really get us to viability. Clear Smog and/or phazing seem reasonable here, as anti-setup options for defensive. Recycle seems funny for niche Meteor Beam applications. Cosmic Power or Stockpile (if we're worried about power level) are interesting, but probably not high priority right now. Partial trapping like Infestation seems niche, but potentially useful.
:manaphy:Heart Swap: It seems really funny and I can see a niche, but I don't want something like Obliteryx again where pitting any special attacking setup against it just results in boosting it.
:malamar:Topsy-Turvy: Less severe. I like this option a lot, though I think making 2 good CAPs in a row (for the same meta!) that punish setup is not that good an idea. Physical setup sweepers seem to be rarer compared to in OU because of Obliteryx, and I don't think we should do the same for the special side.
:victreebel:Acid Spray: It does seem like it could be worth it. Defensive CAP38 take more than 2 turns to KO a lot of bulky threats, and Acid Spray is a great way to either threaten out possible checks or deal a lot more damage if they choose to stay in. Offensive CAP38, on the other hand, KOs most threats in 2 turns or less, rendering Acid Spray less usable.
:mollux:Clear Smog: Despite my thoughts on Heart Swap and Topsy-Turvy, I think Clear Smog could actually be a good add-on. Unlike the other two, it does not punish the user for setting up besides the turn cost. I do see an unlikely world in which Clear Smog is the main utility move (Prankster Haze Tomohawk shows how powerful fast stat removal is.)
:spidops:Phazing: I think this could work. With phazing, the only part to take into account is the bulk. I can see a variation of the offensive set using this to force out opponents, but it's a powerful tool on the defensive set. However, I do think the phazing in question should come in the form of Circle Throw, as I think we would need some way to punish offensive sets for running phazing. We already threaten out most Fairies, so Dragon Tail is out of the question, as are Roar and Whirlwind as they are only blocked by Gholdengo. This also serves to improve Dragapult's matchup against us.
:dedenne:Recycle: Concerns about using a dexited move aside, I don't think Meteor Beam would be used much on defensive sets. Recycle seems to buff offensive sets while offering little to no value to defensive ones (the biggest thing I can see with it is Recycle + Sitrus Berry, and Recover already gives us reliable healing).
:cosmoem:Cosmic Power / Stockpile: This is like the textbook example of boosting mostly the defensive set and providing little utility to the offensive one. I think this is low enough impact that it can be run on 1A sets, but not 2A. Whether or not people would want to run 1A sets is another question.
:pajantom:Partial Trapping: I can see this thriving on defensive sets that run off of chip damage (Toxic, Leech Seed, Salt Cure, etc.), especially since it prevents them removing Leech Seed and Salt Cure, as well as resetting the Toxic timer. I can also see this used on offensive sets to trap opponents into a bad matchup, though I think that interaction is niche enough that it's not really something to worry about.
:Raticate:Super Fang: An interesting way for CAP38 to chip half health from major Pokemon, but is that something we have to worry about? Our STABS + coverage already chunk a lot of HP from opponents, as my Scorching Sands calcs show. It wouldn't give a lot of utility for offensive sets, so I'm not against it, but I don't see a reason to put it on either.

:mew:
My own ideas!
:deoxys-defense:Teleport: It's an interesting utility that allows defensive sets to slow pivot out despite our great Speed. Meanwhile, the offensive set would not want to risk getting hit for a lot of damage when pivoting, so they'd likely choose to manually switch instead. Not really Etern-like, but pretty funny.
:wyrdeer:Psyshield Bash: It provides a small amount of chip while boosting our physical defense. In addition, it fully fails against :Obliteryx: switching in=, allowing us to not give it an unintended stat boost. The downside, of course, is the 90% accuracy, which may cause us to miss the stat boost at a critical moment.
:tsareena:Trop Kick / Chilling Water: It allows us to lower opponents' Atk with greater reliability (though at a much lower severity) than Scorching Sands, while (in the case of Chilling Water) providing extremely weak coverage.
:grimmsnarl:Spirit Break / Snarl: Same as above, except for SpA. I don't see this being used over Mystical Fire, except maybe Snarl on teams that are really fearing :dragapult:. I do want to put these options out here, though.
:swalot:Gastro Acid / Worry Seed: The poor man's :miasmaw:. Apart from that Pokemon, we don't really see any Pokemon that can mess with Abilities. Gastro Acid could provide some new angles to that, as we can disable and then switch into a better check for the now Ability-less Pokemon.

:comfey:
Regarding 50% Recovery
Zetalz said:
Other Things:
quz mentioned it briefly but we do need to decide what flavor of 50% recovery move 38 has at some point this stage. We could wait a few days until we have Art to make a decision, but feel free to mention your preference now, if you have one. If there's no real interest, we'll just lock-in bog standard Recover.
Synthesis / Morning Sun, definitely. It allows us to gain a lot of HP when in or faced against a Sun team, and we already check most of the Pokemon in a Rain team. In addition, they just fit the flower and plant theme better than just Recover.
But could we do both Synthesis and Morning Sun? There is precedent for this: flower-based Pokemon like :cherrim:, :sunflora:, and the :Oddish: line all double up on Synthesis and either Morning Sun or Moonlight. I feel that if nothing else, this allows for added flavor and an extremely funny niche set where you can use a 50% recovery move up to 16 times. (This probably won't be run, it's not worth the 2 move slots. still really fun to think about though)
 
Last edited:
Fuck it, Stockpile

CAP 38 @ Power Herb
Ability: Flower Veil
Tera Type: Grass
EVs: 4 SpA / 252 SpD / 252 Spe
Timid Nature
- Stockpile
- Meteor Beam
- Giga Drain
- Recover

Cosmic Power spooks me a bit, but I have a hard time seeing Stockpile sets get out of hand with subpar offensive coverage and defensive boosts capped at +3. Not sure if these EVs or moves are strictly optimal, just mirrored what Eternatus runs, but this is a tame pro-concept option.
 
Mortal Spin > Knock Off

I’m not convinced Knock Off will single-handedly guarantee the existence of a defensive set. It might not be the intention to make Knock Off do this, as it can be combined with other tools for a more complete defensive/utility package. But these tools are also typically something like pivoting, setting entry hazards, or removing them. Some speedy mons that run Knock Off are :Tornadus-Therian:, :Walking Wake:, :Kitsunoh:, :Ogerpon-Wellspring:, and all of these possess one or more of the additional tools I mentioned. :Darkrai: is a notable exception, running Knock pretty decently, so there might yet be the option to emulate that. But even then, I would classify those sets as primarily offensive utility rather than the kind of defensive I was imagining for us to emulate.

This is a more difficult question for CAP38 because the defensive set has to justify its existence not only versus competing defensive Pokemon, but also against its own offensive sets. CAP has offensive setup Pokemon like :Caribolt:, :Cawmodore:, and, to a lesser extent, :Revenankh: that mostly skip on Knock Off in service of a more reliable offensive kit. While Meteor Beam is a different kind of setup, it is still a setup, and I fear our offensive lean with stats might land us somewhere in that vicinity.

It might be worth revisiting the question: what exactly is an Eternatus-style defensive set? We have had some discussion about its interpretation. Originally, it was meant as 2 Attacks + utility + recovery, i.e., exactly like Eternatus. Since then, people have entertained the possibility of 3A sets as well as 1A + 2 utility sets. Even there, some options like Clear Smog skirt the line between being utility and being an attack (for example, is Mollux 2A + utility, or 1A + 2 utility?). My two cents here are that a defensive set should be something that has investment in bulk, as is the case for Eternatus. This naturally extends to a function of tanking attacks, rather than 38 threatening switches and using that turn to execute its utility option. The specifics of the distribution of attacks are a secondary concern. The winning stat spread had tanking and not being 2HKOed by :Great Tusk:'s Headlong Rush as a key calculation, and this range has other neat calculations like versus :Dragonite:'s Ice Spinner, 5 allies fainted :Kingambit:'s Sucker Punch, and versus :Revenankh:'s Ghost STAB. So there is definitely value purely defensively. It's only a question of making the niche good enough on top of this tanking value.

As I said, I think Knock Off is not the best thing to enable defensive sets. There is also competition from Knockers that have additional tools. In fact, among them, I am looking at specifically :Great Tusk: and :Iron Treads: as models. These two drop Knock on some of their sets, but never Rapid Spin. As spoo has brought up, removal is an essential niche to find a spot on a team, and almost everything that gets it runs it (and the number of things that get it is few, anyway). So, I think Mortal Spin can be a surer bet to ensure a defensive set.

I will justify this suggestion from the viability angle first, before getting into the weeds of concept adherence. Thudding into Steel-types like :Equilibra: and :Corviknight: is a healthy limiter; Mystical Fire is rewarded but is also not overwhelming them immediately. As spoo puts it, Mortal Spin would likely result in the Pokemon being part of a removal pair rather than standing alone as the sole spinner on a team. For example, alongside Equilibra, a physically defensive 38 could come in on a :Kitsunoh:, unafraid of Shadow Strike and Will-O-Wisp while threatening it out with Mystical Fire. Mollux is competition for a spinner slot, but typically that Pokemon has to duck away from any opposing Knock Off, especially against targets it otherwise has a good matchup against such as Ogerpon-W. Not facing this issue is a pretty big differentiator. In fact, with Rocky Helmet and the poison inflict, we sort of replicate a playstyle similar to Eternatus' chipping down of things long-term with its stronger Toxic in its tier--we can also emulate the fast walling model of Rough Skin Rocky Helmet :Cresceidon:. Clear Smog also goes a long way in ensuring our physical matchups stay manageable as they are chipped down, and it can be afforded due to Mortal Spin's own poisoning capability. Even against some of our other switch-ins such as :Gliscor: and :Snaelstrom:, Mortal Spin is not a dead slot unlike Knock Off. Finally, only Cinderace comes to mind as a fast hazard control Pokemon in OU/CAP, so occupying that niche could be a good way to explore the implications of the Speedy aspect of Eternatus.

For sure, it is a departure from :Eternatus:, which cannot remove hazards. But a growing sentiment, which I agree with, is that we should concern ourselves with the existence of the set rather than the specifics of implementation at this point. Something has to be sacrificed for defensive viability. Literal translations can only take us so far. Eternatus sets Toxic Spikes, but that move hardly sees use in OU/CAP. Eternatus is also not immune to all forms of status, but this was something we reinterpreted as its niche in the OU/CAP tier. It has Dragon-type spammable STAB, while both our typings are limited offensively. Eternatus does not Knock either, unlike Walter White. Eternatus does, however, engage in "don't attack me" strats with Pressure + low PP moves in Ubers, as well as chips foes down with passive damage, and I think Rocky Helmet + poison is a decent translation. Someone said that "Eternatus spreads poison with Toxic, so Mortal Spin spreading poison" was the stupidest thing they had ever heard... which is legit, no cap. But if we look at it more as facilitating a stay-in-and-deny-progress playstyle rather than the hit-and-run playstyle (with us lacking typical "run" tools in the first place), it becomes a less arbitrary choice than something like U-turn or the aforementioned Knock Off. These arguments are not made to be particularly persuasive, but rather illustrative of the fact that a lot of moves can be argued to be pro- or anti-concept based on the specific parameters we value. But I think, viability-wise, Mortal Spin is the most attractive option remaining.

On Other Moves
  • Heart Swap and Topsy Turvy are interesting but involve more fluff and complication than the already approved Clear Smog while basically serving the same purpose of denying offensive boosting as a mode of getting past 38.
  • Similarly, let's go with the more straightforward Recover for 50% recovery. Eternatus gets it, and Chilly Reception hampering Synthesis just adds unnecessary variability to an otherwise honest and reliable Pokemon for flavor reasons.
  • Phazing honestly seems like a full movepool issue. On that note, stuff like Dragon Dance as well.
  • Screens could be a consideration. Although Eternatus gets them, I imagine they'll be used very differently on 38, so I'm not sure.
  • Adding to that, Chloroblast could be interesting for HO sets (MBeam/Screens), but gut feeling is we'd rather not.
EDIT:

CAP 38 @ Heavy-Duty Boots / Rocky Helmet / Leftovers
Ability: Flower Veil
Tera Type: Grass
EVs: 252 Def/ 4 SpA / 252 Spe
Timid / Modest Nature
- Mortal Spin
- Sludge Bomb / Clear Smog
- Mystical Fire
- Recover

Can probably run more optimized EVs.
 
Last edited:
Hey gang, just dropping a very quick reminder to everyone that submitting moves for approval via the method in the OP, and as done in spoo and sunshine's posts, would be highly preferred for your posts. I wasn't hard on this earlier on in the stage due to the threads pace and not a lot of moves being talked about, but going forward I'd really appreciate if y'all submitted a bit more properly. Makes my job of collating the thread a lot easier, and helps moves to not get lost in the word salad.

For reference on where we are right now for moves we have;

Rejected moves: Salt Cure
Currently approved moves: Acid Spray, Clear Smog, Toxic Spikes
Submitted moves awaiting approval: Stockpile, Knock Off
Moves mentioned but not submitted: everything else, lol

With the lack of proper submissions and my own limited availability I won't be approving anything for a little bit, but again I would REALLY appreciate it if y'all helped me out in this regard. Still waiting for Art to wrap for a few decisions to be made, and I'm also currently recovering from a hospital trip, so I'm spending most of my time resting. Hoping I'll be back in working order soon, and we can get the pace picked back up with this stage.
 
It sounds like the consensus is that we should go with a different recovery move over Synthesis, which is fair. Could we potentially have both? There is precedent, both for having multiple recovery moves and for Synthesis effectively being a flavor move for the mons that have both (to my knowledge, Gogoat never runs Synthesis over Milk Drink, and neither of the Decidueye forms ever runs Synthesis over Roost).
 
My problem with Mortal Spin is that it's in direct competition with Scorching Sands for many defensive sets, as burn and poisoning cannot coexist. A lot of the arguments I've seen for Scorching Sands talked about the burn chance being useful for utility, and Mortal Spin completely denies that.

On the other hand, there are ways around this: Only try to Spin into special attackers, or Poison-type physical attackers. I do like the fact that on sets running both, it forces you to think about when to click Mortal Spin to avoid poisoning a Pokemon that would much rather be burned. (Mortal Spin will probably just be run over Scorching Sands 99% of the time, but I don't wanna think about that. I like Scorching Sands as a utility move.)

Guingil said:
I’m not convinced Knock Off will single-handedly guarantee the existence of a defensive set. It might not be the intention to make Knock Off do this, as it can be combined with other tools for a more complete defensive/utility package. But these tools are also typically something like pivoting, setting entry hazards, or removing them. Some speedy mons that run Knock Off are :Tornadus-Therian:, :Walking Wake:, :Kitsunoh:, :Ogerpon-Wellspring:, and all of these possess one or more of the additional tools I mentioned. :Darkrai: is a notable exception, running Knock pretty decently, so there might yet be the option to emulate that. But even then, I would classify those sets as primarily offensive utility rather than the kind of defensive I was imagining for us to emulate.
:deoxys-defense:Giving it Teleport solves most of these issues. Its -6 priority makes it unlikely to be used on offensive sets, and it is a very good pivoting move on bulky Pokemon (look at Blissey or Deoxys-Defense!)

Anyway, check out this Teleport set.

Venusaur @ Heavy-Duty Boots
Ability: Flower Veil
EVs: 4 HP / 252 Def / 252 Spe
Bold Nature
Tera Type: Fire
- Recover
- Teleport
- Knock Off
- Mystical Fire

Heavy-Duty Boots so we don't take Stealth Rock chip upon repeated Teleport use.
Teleport + Knock Off to remove items and switch into something that would appreciate it.
Recover to gain back HP (since we'll almost definitely take damage while Teleporting away.)
Mystical Fire to mess with special attackers, as well as to deal decent damage.
Tera Fire to flip our matchup into Fire and Ice attackers (looking at you, :Ramnarok-Radiant:) and to boost the power of Mystical Fire.
 
Last edited:
Moveset Submission

Name: Sun Abuse Offense
Move 1: Mystical Fire
Move 2: Synthesis
Move 3: Solar Beam
Move 4: Scorching Sands/Earth Power (depending on decision regarding Earth Power)
Ability: Flower Veil
Item: Life Orb
Nature: Modest
  • Mystical Fire takes the boost from the sun to dish out some solid damage, while also allowing SpA drops outside of the sun. Just a solid attack overall.
  • Synthesis, while :slowking-galar: does punish with Chilly Reception, provides incredible in-sun recovery, and we can punish it coming in anyway with Ground coverage.
  • Solar Beam is just an amazing move in Sun, and uses 38’s attacking power to great effect. A good click on any non-resisting mons.
  • Ground coverage is here to threaten Glowking and hopefully keep it off the field. This allows us to keep the sun shining and keep blasting away with Solar Beam.
 
Last edited:
Moveset Submission

Name: Offensive Cap 38
Move 1: Sludge Bomb
Move 2: Energy Ball
Move 3: Earth Power
Move 4: Recover
Ability: Flower Veil
Item: Life Orb
Nature: Timid

Personally submitting Earth Power and not scorching sands, Picking a weaker move when we specfically voted for ground coverage doesn't seem right to me, Energy ball is just there as our grass move, and sludge bomb is there for our poison move
 
Moveset Submission
Name: Bulky Knock
CAP 38 @ Heavy-Duty Boots
Ability: Flower Veil
EVs: 252 HP/ 252 Def/ 4 Spd
Bold Nature
-Knock Off
-Sludge Bomb
-Recover
-Mystical Fire

Knock and the poison chance from Sludge Bomb allows it to make progress, Recover gives it longevity. It's suprisingly physically bulky while still being able to deal good damage. Mystical Fire lets it match up into :equilibra: and Knock Off while tanking some hits. Flower Veil lets it switch into things like Will-O-Wisp from :kitsunoh: or Thunder Wave from :slowking-galar:

0 SpA Equilibra Earth Power vs. 252 HP / 4 SpD Venusaur: 178-210 (38.1 - 45%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Equilibra: 86-102 (21 - 25%) -- possible 5HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Sludge Bomb vs. 40 HP / 0 SpD Hemogoblin: 264-312 (79.7 - 94.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252+ Atk Hemogoblin Flare Blitz vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Venusaur: 288-342 (61.8 - 73.3%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
152 Atk Kitsunoh Shadow Strike vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Venusaur: 84-100 (18 - 21.4%) -- possible 5HKO
0 SpA Venusaur Mystical Fire vs. 104 HP / 0 SpD Kitsunoh: 160-190 (48.9 - 58.1%) -- 96.1% chance to 2HKO
 
Moveset Submission

Name: Fast Burn Spread
Move 1: Sludge Bomb
Move 2: Mystical Fire
Move 3: Will-O-Wisp
Move 4: Recover
Ability: Flower Veil
Item: Black Sludge
Nature: Timid

Think as we have already gathered from previous discussion that the offensive sets for CAP 38 has more or less been nailed and doesn't need looking at too much further if we keep with Mystical Fire and Earth Power. For utility sets I've kept it fairly simple and gone for Will-O-Wisp to neuter and wear down some annoying defensive checks for us such as :Corviknight: and :Obliteryx: ontop of being able to slow down :Zamazenta: from making progress with setup. I wanted to try and put forward the idea of Matcha Gotcha however, I feel like we are trying to heavily avoid buffing offensive sets whilst focussing solely on buffing utility and Matcha Gotcha might move the needle too much in favour of offensive sets albeit has the risk of the chance to miss which feels far more impactful on offensive sets compared to defensive ones which would use it to burn phish.
 
I think we should leave this stage with either Mortal Spin or Knock Off. The former is probably more of a one-and-done fix; Guingil's post lays out a really nice argument for it, and I agree that Mortal Spin is a safer bet if all we are worried about is the viability of a defensive set. Double removal builds are excellent right now, the tier is always in search of more removal options, and fast secondary removal with this unique of a matchup spread is a real niche (albeit probably not one with a super high ceiling). I've flip-flopped a lot on this myself, and I was definitely a Mortal Spin believer at one point. However, what makes me uncomfortable giving it out now is that it represents real concessions on takeaways from our Concept Assessment:

Spammernoob said:
Vital to implement
  • Premium speed tier; outsped by select offensive Pokemon, but outspeeds most of the tier.
  • Ability to flex EVs for bulky or offensive sets
  • Access to powerful permanent progress tool (Toxic)
  • Powerful STABs + Coverage combo (Poison / Fire / Dragon)
  • Access to reliable recovery (via moves)
  • Limited setup options
Good Direction
  • Above-average all-around stats
  • Lack of key utility (non-Tspike hazards, hazard removal, pivoting)
  • Typing provides immunity to Toxic
  • Balanced Offensive / Defensive typing
Unnecessary
  • Typing provides Tspike absorbing utility

Looking at this list, we've done well overall — our last unchecked box is "ability to flex EVs for offensive or bulky sets" (and arguably "access to powerful permanent progress tool" — Toxic in CAP isn't great, as has been discussed). The argument is that Mortal Spin addresses "ability to flex EVs for offense/bulk" (vital to implement), which takes precedence over "lack of key utility" (good direction). But still, I don't believe there are two ways about this: it's a difficult and ugly compromise to hand out hazard tools at this stage. This compromise is only worth making if we are absolutely certain that other options don't suffice.

Personally, I'm not sure that's the case. I won't pretend to be certain that Knock Off or any combination of other moves will absolutely enable the existence of viable bulky sets, but I think we have favorable odds, and the alternative is something that actively makes backwards progress on (lesser) concept goals. Additionally, Knock Off helps address our current lack of permanent progress-making tools. I have some degree of sympathy for the argument that Knock Off encourages a hit-and-run playstyle that pulls us further away, not closer, to Eternatus, but the cost-benefit breakdown of permanent progress tools vs having a hit-and-run playstyle feels pretty nebulous in terms of concept adherence. Due to this subjectivity, I won't take a stand as to whether Knock Off makes us more or less pro-concept on balance, beyond my point that permanent progress tools were something we specifically noted to be important during Concept Assessment. What I will say, though, is that hazard removal forces an equally dissimilar playstyle, so we can probably just ignore the question of playstyle congruence altogether if it's going to be warped either way.

It's also worth a reminder that Mortal Spin is a signature move, which naturally comes with a bit more scrutiny. I guess Rapid Spin or Defog also exist if we really want to go down this route without throwing on a sig. How much this specific point matters will probably vary person to person, but it should matter at least a little.

Again, I think hazard game tools would check the most important box for us at this stage, but should really be a last-resort option that represents total lack of confidence in anything else. I am not fully confident in Knock Off but I am cautiously optimistic about it.

Lastly: just give out Scorching Sands and not Earth Power right now. If this generation's CAPs are anything to go off of, we've had more success when we err on the side of being underpowered rather than overpowered for a 1.0 release, especially when it comes to moves. Admittedly, the only Pokemon that learn Scorching Sands and not Earth Power are Fire-type, but it is what it is.
 
Moveset Submission

Name: Dual Utility
Move 1: Sludge Bomb
Move 2: Knock Off
Move 3: Will-O-Wisp
Move 4: Recover
Ability: Flower Veil
Item: Heavy-Duty-Boots
Nature: Timid

Perhaps I'm jumping the gun, but I just don't think what we're shooting at is cutting it. I know for a fact that if this was any other concept we would cram this guy full of utility in a heartbeat with the spD stat as justification. Additionally, getting utility moves to see usage isn't the goal here, the goal is to get sets with utility moves to run defensive investment. Is realoos' spread actually getting more value from that bulk that it would get from a 126 base spA sludge bomb and enough speed to pass up stratagem? I'm genuinely not sure, and that uncertainty makes me nervous.

For individual explanations of moves, see the two sets above, the moves themselves are nothing new.

edit: Oh also I forgot to mention but cotton guard is really funny if will-o seems like overkill. Thank you for coming to my ted talk.
 
Last edited:
EDIT: I realized there is something I wanted to respond to. I'll put this at the top of my post for visibility.
spoo said:
I think we should leave this stage with either Mortal Spin or Knock Off.

I strongly disagree with this sentiment. As noted in spoo's post, both Knock Off and Mortal Spin trade playstyle adherence for flexible EV allocation. Specifically, Knock Off encourages a hit-and-run playstyle, contrary to how defensive Eternatus plays, and Mortal Spin dips into hazard removal, something we did not want to do in CA2. I agree with spoo that making EV flexibility viable is the most important concept fulfillment goal, and that it supersedes playstyle concerns; however, these options are not the only paths to viability for defensive sets that are still open to us.

Specifically, we left Secondary stage open for this reason. At the time, arguments were made that addressing defensive sets in moves would be easier, but if our best options in movesets are fundamentally flawed, I don't see why we can't pick options that fit the playstyle we want (but don't fully justify defensive sets) and kick the can back to Secondary. One might say that a similar dilemma may occur in Secondary, where we only have imperfect options; unfortunately, due to the structure of CAP process, we can't discuss those options, so that's just a risk we have to live with if we take that route.

This is not poll-jumping; it is merely pointing out a third option on the table. Of course, if you like Knock Off or Mortal Spin, there is no problem supporting them here. I just do not want people to feel pressured to pick between them as if these are the only options to make defensive sets work.

Anyways, rest of post is some moveset submissions.


Moveset Submission

Name: Recycle Beam
Move 1: Meteor Beam
Move 2: Recycle
Move 3: Recover / Mystical Fire
Move 4: Giga Drain / Energy Ball
Ability: Flower Veil
Item: Power Herb
  • A Meteor Beam set with more longevity; Recycle gives CAP38 the option to reuse Meteor Beam at a later time, at the cost of a moveslot.
  • As Meteor Beam is vital to beating certain would-be checks like Tornadus-T and Kyurem, CAP38 greatly appreciates having the option available.
  • Recycle can be used on off-turns if an opponent tries to bait Meteor Beam into a Pokemon like Zamazenta or Ting-Lu, which cannot do much to threaten CAP38, easing prediction (and reducing risk of clicking Meteor Beam early).
  • CAP38's natural speed allows it to outspeed attempts to Knock from almost every Pokemon, which is very beneficial to this set's gameplan.
  • Recover can be replaced for Mystical Fire for strong 3A coverage, at the cost of relying on Giga Drain for recovery

Name: Infestation Fang
Move 1: Super Fang
Move 2: Infestation
Move 3: Recover
Move 4: Psychic Noise
Ability: Flower Veil
Item: Leftovers / Rocky Helmet / Heavy-duty Boots
  • Whirlpool Tapu Fini-style set with partial trapping + 50% move.
  • Set aims to take advantage of passive Pokemon like Blissey that otherwise wall CAP38.
  • Psychic Noise takes the place of Taunt, allowing chip to stick against Pokemon with recovery.
  • Set can almost entirely invest in bulk; only need marginal Speed to deny recovery against most targets (except in mirror).
  • Ruination would be much preferred over Super Fang, but it's also a Legendary signature...

Name: Infestation Seed
Move 1: Leech Seed
Move 2: Infestation
Move 3: Mystical Fire / Sludge Bomb
Move 4: Protect / Spiky Shield
Ability: Flower Veil
Item: Leftovers / Rocky Helmet / Heavy-duty Boots
  • Set aims to stack passive damage effects to pressure opposing Pokemon; trapping + Leech Seed can rack up large amounts of chip.
  • Mystical Fire is attack of choice for Gholdengo / Equilibra; Sludge Bomb is option against Clefable / Hatterene.
  • Both Fire and Poison punish Grass-types, which are immune to Leech Seed.
  • Spiky Shield can deter Rapid Spin attempts, though Protect works fine enough.
  • Fundamentally completely bricked into Slowking-G.

Mainly a Recycle / Infestation post, but also Super Fang saw some discussion and I think it's not terrible here. It obviously sees no usage on Shox, but that's also because Shox has a lot better things to click (though that might also be the case here?). More discussion on this could be warranted. I wonder if Taunt is just better than Psychic Noise here. Well, maybe worth thinking about too.

Anyways, I'm not sure what the EVs would look like exactly with these, but the Meteor Beam set does feel a bit less all-in than other options, so maybe it can bulk invest. Infestation sets obviously push for heavy bulk invest as well.

These sets are obviously not splashable, but Whirlpool Tapu Fini did see real play, so I think that set has the highest chance of being real? The others have their merits, and I think they have potential, but I can't say with confidence they'll be good.
 
Last edited:
Considering my last moveset was just me shilling for Teleport, I think I should probably give some serious ones.

Name: Sweet Potato Chips
Spoob @ Leftovers
Ability: Flower Veil
EVs: 12 HP / 244 Def / 252 Spe
Timid Nature
Tera Type: Fire
- Leech Seed
- Mortal Spin
- Recover
- Mystical Fire
reternatus
Tera Fire to flip our matchup into Ice- and Fire-types and boost the power of Mystical Fire.
Leech Seed and poison from Mortal Spin combined deal 25% damage/turn, as well as destroying all hazards we may encounter. Unless we're in a mirror match or up against a Magic Guard Pokemon, we also won't encounter a 'Mon that's immune to both.
Recover for recovery. Not much to say here.
Mystical Fire to boost our special tankiness, as well as to deal chip damage to anything not carrying Flash Fire.

Chip damage? In MY [Gen 9] CAP?
yeah I think this is the best way to emulate Toxic Eternatus in this meta, as almost nothing is immune to both Leech Seed and poisoning.

Name: Standardest Set
Spoob @ Power Herb
Ability: Flower Veil
EVs: 4 Def / 252 SpA / 252 Spe
Timid Nature
- Meteor Beam
- Sludge Bomb
- Energy Ball
- Earth Power
standardester
Tera Grass to boost the power of Energy Ball while still keeping Flower Veil up.
Meteor Beam and Power Herb to boost our SpA.
Sludge Bomb and Energy Ball for STABs, and Earth Power for coverage against Poison- or Steel-types. (Scorching Sands is lower BP and its secondary effect conflicts with Sludge Bomb.)

yeah this is the set I assume would be the most popular. It's literally what we built the CAP for.

Name: No One Is Safe
Spoob @ Rocky Helmet
Ability: Flower Veil
EVs: 4 HP / 252 Def / 252 Spe
Timid Nature
Tera Type: Fire
- Mystical Fire
- Will-O-Wisp
- Recover
- Knock Off
not even me
Tera Fire to flip our matchup into Fire- and Ice-types. This is especially important as we can't use Will-o-Wisp on Fire-types.
Rocky Helmet + Will-O-Wisp ensures physical attackers will have a bad time.
Mystical Fire ensures that special attackers aren't safe either.
Knock Off gives lasting damage to any opposing Pokemon.
Recover means we're extremely hard to kill.

I created this set with nothing but malice against every Pokemon that dares to run an attacking move. If anything has the gall to switch in against us, they'll be swiftly crippled.
 
Last edited:
Deckus Carde said:
My problem with Mortal Spin is that it's in direct competition with Scorching Sands for many defensive sets, as burn and poisoning cannot coexist. A lot of the arguments I've seen for Scorching Sands talked about the burn chance being useful for utility, and Mortal Spin completely denies that.

On the other hand, there are ways around this: Only try to Spin into special attackers, or Poison-type physical attackers. I do like the fact that on sets running both, it forces you to think about when to click Mortal Spin to avoid poisoning a Pokemon that would much rather be burned. (Mortal Spin will probably just be run over Scorching Sands 99% of the time, but I don't wanna think about that. I like Scorching Sands as a utility move.)

...
Scorching Sands is mainly going to be clicked against Poison and Steel types, which are immune to poison. Like Glowking, Kistunoh, Mollux, and so on. Accidentally poisoning a target that you would rather burn seems like a non-issue. I don't think we should be focused on spreading burns to neutralize physical attackers anyway, a lot of the time it'll just be for chip damage on stuff we can't poison

FWIW, Mud Bomb exists if we want a weaker ground coverage move that doesn't inflict burn (though the 85% accuracy is a little nasty), but part of the case for not giving out Earth Power is to strengthen defensive sets relative to offensive ones, and the burn chance on Scorching Sands helps with that I think



Anyway, giving out one of Knock Off or Mortal Spin both seem like sufficient fixes for our defensive viability, and which is less of a compromise to the original concept seems like a matter of taste. We should definitely get one or the other (unless a secondary ability i.e. Corrosion is going to be re-considered). Stockpile is neat. A lot of these other suggestions seem unnecessary, especially considering Eternatus' shallow-ish movepool
 
Howdy-doo capperino, your local Moves SL here to drop a big update.

Before getting into the meat of my post I will drop a final polite reminder that you need not submit a moveset consisting of moves either already subbed by another user, or moves already in the defining moves and approved moves lists. If you want to support an already submitted move(s), do so without subbing an entirely new set, otherwise you're just clogging the thread. I've left several generous reminders in my prior posts but this is my last warning, so any further posts that break this will be subject to moderation. Read the room (thread) before committing to your posts, please and thank you.


Alright with that said, we've got a gaggle of new approvals to go through. Here's the list of submitted moves since my last approval post;

Approved: Recover, Stockpile, Knock Off, Recycle, Infestation, Super Fang, Spiky Shield, (Earth Power & Scorching Sands)
Rejected: Teleport, Psychic Noise
Kicked to flavor movepools: Synthesis, Solar Beam
Limbo: Mortal Spin, Will-O-Wisp


Utility Belt & Flavor Moves
The handful of niche utility options require little explanation. Recycle & Stockpile are niche options that do not raise the ceiling on offensive sets and allow for a different psuedo-defensive playstyle that I think is a fine fit here. Super Fang was a popular option as far back as Defining Moves, and is the exact kind of less impactful utility (in a vacuum) 38 ought to have in its kit, and pairs well with the newly subbed trapping set. Said trapping set I think is a fine addition, but does not warrant approval of every move submitted by spammernoob to accomplish that goal. The Psychic Noise trapping set, while definitely stronger than the other subbed set, just barely tips past the point I'm comfortable allowing for a niche low-prio set like this, and the Spiky Shield/Leech Seed variant I think fits better with 38's existing tools.

Recover was chosen as our 50% recovery move due to Synthesis's drawbacks being more severe than it's upsides; consistency is king here. However I won't preclude it's inclusion in full flavor movepools. Solar Beam is similarly something I don't think requires approval here, and can safely be kicked to the 2.0 release. Teleport has been rejected as pivoting is not something we ever wanted to entertain on 38, and making it "bad" for our build is not selling anything here.


The Big One & Limbo Moves
Knock Off is being approved, and has not been done so lightly. There has been extensive back and forth regarding the moves validity and even viability for our purposes here, both in this thread, in CAPcord, and internal TLT discussion. Counter-arguments against it citing it's poor emulation of Etern, or not 'solving' the defensive set by itself, and even just not wanting another Knock CAP are quite valid. But we stand at a bit of an impasse when it comes to how we address 38's Defensive set, and the leaving-open of Secondary complicates the discussion further. As I am not one to consider arguments for future stages as particularly valid (especially since in a normal process we wouldn't even have the secondary option available), I value trying to accomplish our stated goal of uplifting Defensive 38 as best we can within the confines of this stage.

To this end, Knock Off presents the best case for trying to give 38 at least a somewhat viable tool for Defensive sets. It does not solve the problem by itself however, which is where the limbo moves come into the equation. Wisp has been mentioned multiple times as something to pair with Knock, but is undoubtedly a very powerful combo that I'm not willing to approve all at once, and Wisp itself was not a particularly popular option earlier on in the stage. Mortal Spin is a similar but different can of worms, as it's both quite controversial and is an equally high impact move to include in tandem with Knock. Certainly both of these moves cannot be given to Knock 38, so I ask where we land on the inclusion of Mortal & Wisp in the state we are now. Should one or both of Mortal Spin & Will-O-Wisp be kicked from 38, in the state it is now? My inclination as SL is to ere on the side of caution and deny both, but I'm not going to make any decision until I hear more from the community.


Ground Floor
The debate on what form our Ground coverage should take is a very small one, and not one I've put a lot of stock into here. Frankly I think the primary factor for the debate has been vibes-based, 'weaker is safer' type mentality and choosing to single out EP as an option we can pre-emptively nerf, so why not do it. Or in some arbitrary way to make Defensive more appealing by weakening Offensive. This is not particularly convincing to me, I think moves should be verifiably proven as problematic before swinging a banhammer at 'em, which isn't really in our purview here. This is also a very low-priority argument to begin with, so I'm not going to make it any deeper than it needs to be. To this end, both EP & Scorching Sands will remain in our movepool, any nerfing that may or may not occur should take place in the stage where it's appropriate; in Post-Play Lookback.



Will once again mention the reminder I started this post off with, please keep your posts sensible people. There is also a possibility that any further submissions get denied purely on the grounds of reducing movebloat for 1.0 as we're already looking at a fairly long list, so don't be surprised if that happens. With that, I'm officially announcing our final deadline will be Wednesday, November 18th, so here's your loose 72-hour warning for the stage's wrap-up. I'll drop my final approval post then, and we'll see the stage off. Light's at the end of the tunnel people, let's get her finished up!
 
Last edited:
I would be against including both Mortal Spin and Will-o-Wisp- not just because of the status conflict people have mentioned, but because of one crucial factor: Feature Creep.

We knew, going into CAP 38, we'd have a Jack-of-all-Trades on our hands. Offensive sets, defensive sets- covering every base has been our goal, and we've done our best. But I think the combination of Mortal Spin, Will-o-Wisp and our inherent traits will create something that, while not nessecarily OP, will be incredibly obnoxious to play against. Do we want to release a CAP that can spin off your hazards, tank special hits AND cripple your physical attackers all at once?

I opened this stage with a post about leaving no options on the table, and I'll conclude it with a final counterpoint. We cannot match Eternatus everywhere. We were going to take tradeoffs- and if playing the status or hazard game means we get a defensive set, that's the lesser of two evils.

My personal preference is Mortal Spin, and lock out Will-o-Wisp. It's the better of two worlds, in my eyes: we preserve a valuable defensive role (spinner) without a secondary effect we couldn't already achieve (poison). Leaving out Will-o-Wisp keeps our Def as a kind of Achilles Heel.
 
I agree with feldirion on locking out Will-o-Wisp,as a mini eternatus i personally think we should be a poison merchant not a burn merchant. I just believe this is the best way,while making some compromises along the way of course, how we can do it.
 
i don't think we should have wisp or mortal spin. i feel like interacting with the hazard game takes us down a road that strays too far from concept, and spreading burn isn't necessary when we have the tools we need already. the approved moves give us a good analogue to a lot of etern's tools. we have our recovery, the coverage to address our blind spots, knock off for our permanent progress, super fang for our dmax-cannon-esque broad-spectrum damage click, stockpile for our cosmic power, and a smattering of various little bells and whistles. i think we're good
 
I continue to hold the position that Knock Off isn't doing enough on its own to ensure a defensive set. Maybe it gets slashed on an offensive set, but not more than that. :Serperior: is about the only speedy offensive Pokemon I can find that runs both recovery and Knock Off, without hazard or pivoting tools, but that is not on a bulk-invested set.

For either Mortal Spin or Will-O-Wisp, an interesting comparison could be :Cinderace: with its own hazard removal option and status. The bulky set with Pyro Ball, Court Change, and Will-O-Wisp competes decently versus an offensive set with an arguably lower ceiling than 38's. It's not apples to oranges, as Cinderace has pivoting and we have recovery + Knock Off instead. But as :Ogerpon-Wellspring: has shown through its utility set, often you drop recovery before you drop Knock Off and pivoting, so I'm not sure what it says about our viability.

So, include Mortal Spin for a safer bet for a defensive set. I'd be happy to eat my words about Knock Off, though, if it does end up making the defensive viable on its own. But I just don't see it, with our matchup versus the absorbers + as traceyscetchit said on Discord, Meteor Beam sets targeting the same Fire/Flying Pokemon that Knock Off targets + competition versus other Knock Off Pokemon with their extra tools.
 
Chop both because there are a ton of valid routes to success in ability stage, even though we have rearranged stages we have one of the most defining stages left to do and 99% of defensive mons in the tier have an insane ability. It makes sense why people are hitting the panic button (mortal spin) expecting to wrap things up in this stage but it seems pretty overreactive to me. Im just repeating what I said before but accepting that wisp can probably just go as well atp. Right now even without knock off we have a solid 5-10 abils that make for an immediately good defensive set that I cant mention without polljumping lul so Im fine with proceeding as is
The best execution of this mon clearly doesnt have hazard removal imo and that is still clearly in reach so Im against hitting that panic button- PLUS once you add mortal spin you will have hell trying to get rid of it in ppl because its "not broken", but if the mon truly underperforms it'll be a lot easier to add anti-concept things to save viability in that stage.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top