Mortal Spin > Knock Off
I’m not convinced Knock Off will single-handedly guarantee the existence of a defensive set. It might not be the intention to make Knock Off do this, as it can be combined with other tools for a more complete defensive/utility package. But these tools are also typically something like pivoting, setting entry hazards, or removing them. Some speedy mons that run Knock Off are
:Tornadus-Therian:,
:Walking Wake:,
:Kitsunoh:,
:Ogerpon-Wellspring:, and all of these possess one or more of the additional tools I mentioned.
:Darkrai: is a notable exception, running Knock pretty decently, so there might yet be the option to emulate that. But even then, I would classify those sets as primarily offensive utility rather than the kind of
defensive I was imagining for us to emulate.
This is a more difficult question for CAP38 because the defensive set has to justify its existence not only versus competing defensive Pokemon, but also against its own offensive sets. CAP has offensive setup Pokemon like
:Caribolt:,
:Cawmodore:, and, to a lesser extent,
:Revenankh: that mostly skip on Knock Off in service of a more reliable offensive kit. While Meteor Beam is a different kind of setup, it is still a setup, and I fear our offensive lean with stats might land us somewhere in that vicinity.
It might be worth revisiting the question: what exactly is an Eternatus-style defensive set? We have had some discussion about its interpretation. Originally, it was meant as 2 Attacks + utility + recovery, i.e., exactly like Eternatus. Since then, people have entertained the possibility of 3A sets as well as 1A + 2 utility sets. Even there, some options like Clear Smog skirt the line between being utility and being an attack (for example, is Mollux 2A + utility, or 1A + 2 utility?). My two cents here are that
a defensive set should be something that has investment in bulk, as is the case for Eternatus. This naturally extends to a function of tanking attacks, rather than 38 threatening switches and using that turn to execute its utility option. The specifics of the distribution of attacks are a secondary concern. The winning stat spread had tanking and not being 2HKOed by
:Great Tusk:'s Headlong Rush as a key calculation, and this range has other neat calculations like versus
:Dragonite:'s Ice Spinner, 5 allies fainted
:Kingambit:'s Sucker Punch, and versus
:Revenankh:'s Ghost STAB. So there is definitely value purely defensively. It's only a question of making the niche good enough on top of this tanking value.
As I said, I think Knock Off is not the best thing to enable defensive sets. There is also competition from Knockers that have additional tools. In fact, among them, I am looking at specifically
:Great Tusk: and
:Iron Treads: as models. These two drop Knock on some of their sets, but never Rapid Spin. As spoo has brought up, removal is an essential niche to find a spot on a team, and almost everything that gets it runs it (and the number of things that get it is few, anyway). So, I think
Mortal Spin can be a surer bet to ensure a defensive set.
I will justify this suggestion from the viability angle first, before getting into the weeds of concept adherence. Thudding into Steel-types like
:Equilibra: and
:Corviknight: is a healthy limiter; Mystical Fire is rewarded but is also not overwhelming them immediately. As spoo puts it, Mortal Spin would likely result in the Pokemon being part of a removal pair rather than standing alone as the sole spinner on a team. For example, alongside Equilibra, a physically defensive 38 could come in on a
:Kitsunoh:, unafraid of Shadow Strike and Will-O-Wisp while threatening it out with Mystical Fire. Mollux is competition for a spinner slot, but typically that Pokemon has to duck away from any opposing Knock Off, especially against targets it otherwise has a good matchup against such as Ogerpon-W. Not facing this issue is a pretty big differentiator. In fact, with Rocky Helmet and the poison inflict, we sort of replicate a playstyle similar to Eternatus' chipping down of things long-term with its stronger Toxic in its tier--we can also emulate the fast walling model of Rough Skin Rocky Helmet
:Cresceidon:. Clear Smog also goes a long way in ensuring our physical matchups stay manageable as they are chipped down, and it can be afforded due to Mortal Spin's own poisoning capability. Even against some of our other switch-ins such as
:Gliscor: and
:Snaelstrom:, Mortal Spin is not a dead slot unlike Knock Off. Finally, only Cinderace comes to mind as a fast hazard control Pokemon in OU/CAP, so occupying that niche could be a good way to explore the implications of the Speedy aspect of Eternatus.
For sure, it is a departure from
:Eternatus:, which cannot remove hazards. But a growing sentiment, which I agree with, is that we should concern ourselves with the existence of the set rather than the specifics of implementation at this point. Something has to be sacrificed for defensive viability. Literal translations can only take us so far. Eternatus sets Toxic Spikes, but that move hardly sees use in OU/CAP. Eternatus is also not immune to all forms of status, but this was something we reinterpreted as its niche in the OU/CAP tier. It has Dragon-type spammable STAB, while both our typings are limited offensively. Eternatus does not Knock either,
unlike Walter White. Eternatus does, however, engage in "don't attack me" strats with Pressure + low PP moves in Ubers, as well as chips foes down with passive damage, and I think Rocky Helmet + poison is a decent translation. Someone said that "Eternatus spreads poison with Toxic, so Mortal Spin spreading poison" was the stupidest thing they had ever heard... which is legit, no cap. But if we look at it more as facilitating a stay-in-and-deny-progress playstyle rather than the hit-and-run playstyle (with us lacking typical "run" tools in the first place), it becomes a less arbitrary choice than something like U-turn or the aforementioned Knock Off. These arguments are not made to be particularly persuasive, but rather illustrative of the fact that a lot of moves can be argued to be pro- or anti-concept based on the specific parameters we value. But I think, viability-wise, Mortal Spin is the most attractive option remaining.
On Other Moves
- Heart Swap and Topsy Turvy are interesting but involve more fluff and complication than the already approved Clear Smog while basically serving the same purpose of denying offensive boosting as a mode of getting past 38.
- Similarly, let's go with the more straightforward Recover for 50% recovery. Eternatus gets it, and Chilly Reception hampering Synthesis just adds unnecessary variability to an otherwise honest and reliable Pokemon for flavor reasons.
- Phazing honestly seems like a full movepool issue. On that note, stuff like Dragon Dance as well.
- Screens could be a consideration. Although Eternatus gets them, I imagine they'll be used very differently on 38, so I'm not sure.
- Adding to that, Chloroblast could be interesting for HO sets (MBeam/Screens), but gut feeling is we'd rather not.
EDIT:
CAP 38 @ Heavy-Duty Boots / Rocky Helmet / Leftovers
Ability: Flower Veil
Tera Type: Grass
EVs: 252 Def/ 4 SpA / 252 Spe
Timid / Modest Nature
- Mortal Spin
- Sludge Bomb / Clear Smog
- Mystical Fire
- Recover
Can probably run more optimized EVs.