Hopefully I'm not being redundant or a broken record as I type this, this discussion brings a lot of thoughts to my mind as the RoA ladders have immense value for me and are very fun to see, although I have also grown to appreciate the retro VGC ones sometimes.
Hope this long post is also noteworthy and decent enough to read, I'm a tad sleep deprived and don't have much longer to write this, I'll edit this later tomorrow if needed.
Long yap-to-rant about my experience as an avid spotlights player
I am unsure when I truly got dedicated to playing the spotlight ladders in Showdown,bBut have memories dating back to at least 2023. I'm primarily a GSC, ADV, DPP and BW lower tiers player; I specify as I am not quite as attached to the OU formats of GSC and DPP in particular. Regardless, I must mirror some thoughts regarding generation voting: how often has GSC ever won a generation vote? I am quite unsure myself and can't remember the last time this happened before this year. Regrettably, it is an unpopular gen through and through, and while I feel hyping just one specific gen's tier may be difficult, hyping up an entire generation is not, to which I feel a ban on advertising at least generations themselves is a bandaid fix that only truly affects the generations that would desperately need a fresh playerbase, while wholly ineffective at preventing gens that are already very popular from hogging ladders as soon as possible - not all generations have a big, popular youtuber ala Jim or Yellow who can hype them up with memes and elaborate educational videos.
May we consider how often RBY or ADV wins a generational vote, in return? It feels like we get at least one RBY ladder, intentionally or not, every other month or so. It got to the point I am confident I played pretty much every lower tier of this generation in ladder at least once, if not twice even for tiers which aren't UU/Ubers (which would be the easiest to get a ladder for, as those are not chosen by popular vote). It's as if the monthly gen voting has turned into an incredibly uneven tug-of-war that potentially puts players of each generation at odds with each other, a David vs. Goliath fight where I have to try and pray that RBY - a generation which is potentially carried not only by a massive, highly dedicated playerbase who will definitely be excited to vote for and play almost any lower tier ladder for it, but also potential new faces led by the newest funny RBY interaction video - doesn't win the trillionth ladder this year (PLEASE do not take this as a jab against RBY's community - as much as said ladders have helped me to decide I absolutely despise playing this generation 90% of the time, I deeply, deeply respect their dedication to even the lowest and least popular tiers).
Asking for tours and even random matches in the RoA room is not exactly the best solution and means a player needs to be particularly persistent; asking for matches with random players is a shot in the dark IMO, and about roomtours, it is not rare for them to have low single-digit player numbers entering, and notably, either case often pits one against a more skilled player with more experience, to which I feel goes against the purpose of Spotlights inviting newer faces who never played a certain tier (or even generation) and only really "feeds" the playerbase who already existed there.
In my honest opinion generation voting
NEEDS to go, no questions asked; it is the minimum needed towards creating spotlight ladder voting equity. To quote directly from my long yap,
while I feel hyping just one specific gen's tier may be difficult, hyping up an entire generation is not - I believe we can see certain generations have expressively larger playerbases by reason or the other, which means that with advertising or not, it is prone to be a steep hill for unpopular gens to win a vote against more popular ones.
The "automatic" Ubers/UU ladders themselves are interesting, but may not truly help retain players; I believe we can all agree Ubers is not the most balanced format in any generation and may not be a good entry point for certain generations to get the player counts they desire, just having an Ubers or UU ladder for a generation alongside said gen's OU may also not paint a great picture of how diverse said gens can get on their other tiers, specially special "side-games" (BDSP and LGPE) contained under their respective gen's RoA spotlight voting, so distinct that they can almost be classified as their own generations in a way. Hell, I didn't
know BDSP lower tiers were an actual thing until recently, not that I have much experience with BDSP as a gen overall, as it only appears occasionally a year at best, at the same time, I am fascinated with how varied LGPE tiers appear to be, and wonder how badly they may be hit by not even their respect game's OU being often seen in ladder.
A third RoA spotlight ladder would be cool and very appreciated but I do not believe to be explicitly necessary and I do not feel we should bang our heads too hard against the wall asking for one, specially with retro VGC ladders being a possibility of oldgens "exposure" to the doubles-VGC playerbase which certainly exists but may feel alienated in seeing mainly only singles ladders be promoted for oldgens (or heck, maybe they could find similar official Nintendo tour ladders for gens 1 to 2 fun too, maybe? VGC isn't decided by the doubles battle format after all - team preview and the bring 6 pick x structure is a defining aspect here too).
I firmly believe once you grow attached to a specific gen, any tier on said gen can turn far more enjoyable as you gain appreciation to said gen's mechanics and nuances, which brings the issue of overcoming the initial bias a player may have with said gens.
tl;dr: Remove gen voting ASAP, preferably make it so the gen chosen
is not the same gen as the UU/Uber rotational pick to aliviate the feeling that some gens may not be given attention. If possible, observation and following of the VGC retro gen ladder for a month can be interesting to help further the feeling of old gen variety in a month; I firmly believe gen variety is the right step, and believe just OU/Ubers/UU ladders for a specific gen may be insufficient to achieve that goal.