LBN said:So, first off its worth noting three things.
- Entei scored 7 suspect, 1 do nothing internally. So any ideas of "loud minority" can shut that shit up expeditiously.
- Most on council are not convinced Entei is broken. Swagger being uncompetitive aside, I would say a good chunk of council sits in DNB, including myself (probably). Us supporting a suspect and us intending to vote do not ban are not mutually exclusive.
- The reason we did this suspect now was this was the last week we could get this suspect up before we got it bleeding into circuit playoffs, which isn't ideal for obvious reasons.
The first part does not even support that "loud minority is bullshit" statement, council is still in the minority compared to the actual player base. If you look at the actual scores, it's 5.11 on the survey. That is still in the minority, simple as that.
If majority of the council isn't even in the ban side, then why was this even a suspect???? It should be supported by both council and the community for wanting to get rid of it (especially the latter, which again, entei does not reach). If there isn't any mon that reaches this, then i'm sorry, but just don't suspect anything. This reasoning makes it even worse man.
The final point is just like, it's already going to be bleeding into circuit playoffs. Week one is going to most likely be going up next week, so the first two weeks of playoffs are going to be affected. If you wanted to avoid affecting playoffs as much as possible, then this suspect should have been done 2 weeks ago.
LBN said:I'm gonna rip this to shreds, if I'm honest. I have nothin against you obviously, but I'm sorry this tone can fuck right off.
No this tone is fair. If I believe the council has made a poor decision, I will call it out as such. The last few posts have been saying how out of left field this suspect is. The council should be held to a high standard and should be willing to hear out the community, if it is not following the community, it is not doing its job.
LBN said:Yes, our physical fire resists are fucking poor at the job at checking Entei. Maybe I should've been more clear, but I still stand by the innate statement that the physical fire resists are shit at the job of checking our physical fires.. of which we have like two. The only other physical fire type we have is infernape and well, literally nothing I can do will get this playerbase to give this mon even a proper chance so I'm not even gonn bother mentioning it. Frankly if this tier had OUs playerbase Infernape would be B- rank at minimum but unfortunately their skill level is comically out of reach for ours so lmfao what can you do.
- Noivern explodes
- Bike Explodes
- Hersculegion is a mon with no recovery, is grounded, is SLOWER, and takes like 27 from sacred fire and 40 from Trailblaze. This is not a reliable check unless your scarf after literally 1 single interaction get this shit off the list.
- Lum Rhyperior.. considering you take like 35 from Trailblaze and one burn means you risk your mon becoming worthless I can't say listing that is good faith. Works as a Tertiary measure I suppose.
- Suicune is good but I still argue a mon that is forced to rest without sleep talk and takes hazards will always be shaky when its slower. Especially with how much Entei loves spikes.
- Quag and Gastrodon take like 50 from Trailblaze with max max phys def, and considering Entei spreads burns like its middle school valentines candy this isn't reliable at all. Even worse when the Entei decides to go Adamant.
- Vaporeon and Slowbro are comfortable, yes. I'm still not a major fan of Vaporeon but like its not bad. Not anymore.
Now onto this. I think again, saying our fire resists suck ass is bullshit.
Now for the actual mons listed.
LBN said:- Noivern explodes
- Bike Explodes
Noivern is pretty shit yes, but nowhere did I list it. Bike is an okay softcheck, it can pivot into sacred fire in a pinch (especially if it's facade which gains a good boost) and knock/dtail it out in a pinch. Shouldn't be anywhere close to your main answer, but can be a tertiary check.
LBN said:- Hersculegion is a mon with no recovery, is grounded, is SLOWER, and takes like 27 from sacred fire and 40 from Trailblaze. This is not a reliable check unless your scarf after literally 1 single interaction get this shit off the list.
Not all enteis are trailblaze. And frankly put, for the bo teams that herscu finds itself on, that is more then fine. You do not need to permawall it, so having herscu as a check is fine.
LBN said:- Lum Rhyperior.. considering you take like 35 from Trailblaze and one burn means you risk your mon becoming worthless I can't say listing that is good faith. Works as a Tertiary measure I suppose.
I listed both Lum and cloak, and both are more then fine.
252 Atk Entei Trailblaze vs. 252 HP / 0 Def Solid Rock Rhyperior: 120-144 (27.6 - 33.1%) -- 82.5% chance to 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
I'm sorry, 33% max to it IF it gets the right switch is still going to be fine. And Lum rhyperior is completely able to ignore the confuse and ko tera normal entei. Cloak completely dominates it. This is a fine answer, you do not need to permawall entei to beat it, especially since entei does not have reliable recovery.
LBN said:- Suicune is good but I still argue a mon that is forced to rest without sleep talk and takes hazards will always be shaky when its slower. Especially with how much Entei loves spikes.
Suicune is fine being forced to rest, it works so well in spite of that. And besides, even if it doesn't somehow win against it, you take away all of sacred fires burn pp, which is the main threatening part, making entei a non issue. This is similar reasoning why deo-d is a good check.
And just as much entei loves spikes, suicune loves removal, so I would say that entei being paired with spikestack is fair, but ultimately it goes both ways.
LBN said:Quag and Gastrodon take like 50 from Trailblaze with max max phys def, and considering Entei spreads burns like its middle school valentines candy this isn't reliable at all. Even worse when the Entei decides to go Adamant.
They do yes! And they can switch into sacred fine, quag can still spread toxic fine enough and gastros go special attacks anyways. A lot of these also go the tera route, of which then they 100% check it. But besides, the biggest issue with entei is switching into sacred fire, which they do fine. Ada entei is memes, that set is not used nor will be used because entei being slower then scarf krook after a trailblaze is nonsense.
LBN said:- Vaporeon and Slowbro are comfortable, yes. I'm still not a major fan of Vaporeon but like its not bad. Not anymore.
Vaporeon was never listed in the OP btw, so like, can you see where I'm saying it feels biased? It's giving an opinion that even if it's not intentional, is painting a picture that is not correct.
LBN said:After that you just get a buncha burn victims. Terrakion is a burn victim, Tera Registeel is a burn victim, Swampert isn't that much of a burn victim anymore since I find special surf pert is the best set rn but still takes 38% from TB with no recovery so glhf.
Swampert is the only one that I would remotely call an entei check, and for the offenses pert finds itself on, that trailblaze damage is fine.
LBN said:Swagger Entei is just undefendable cheese, and let it be known if Swagger was actionable it would've been targeted by council unanimously. Set is pure stupid cheese and is by leaps and bounds the main reason council sought a suspect test. I don't think any defending this set is really valid just because of how effective a +2 Entei is backed behind a shield of RNG. I'm not spending time writin this segment out I got shit to do.
Alright, let me defend it. Swagger entei is a set that is tied to an archetype that has been heavily struggling and even the set itself is completely fine and struggles a lot more then I think people give it credit for. Not only does it have to dedicate an item slot and moveslot to a 1 time boost (which means stuff such as haze or phasing ruin it) but also one that necessitates rocks to be kept off and one that will also most likely not be at full hp due to the importance entei has on ho (checking gardevoir and sun mainly). It also has to rely on an 85% accurate move to get said boost (this has nearly screwed me over in an scl game btw, so it is something that will come into play). Once it has gotten said boost, sure it's strong, but Pokemon such as slowbro, vaporeon, suicune, rhyperior, quagsire (unaware ignores the boost so it can take a hit, toxic, then switch around to check it, or just tera and beat it). It also is very tera hungry to not just get phased by stuff such as bike or take massive damage from Vern.
LBN said:Entei to me is a mon that will only get a worse public reception over time. You can say we rushed it in this case, maybe. But this feels like a case of people seeing Jolly Boots Mamoswine do no damage, and then saying DNB when anytime you venture outside the literal weakest mamoswine you got a demon. Go venture with Adamant Entei, Double Edge Entei, Tera Dark Crunch Entei and you'll very quickly see how easily Entei will be getting 2 taps with even the slightest chip. I'm still not 100% sure I'm going to vote ban, but I am heavy leaning that way.
Okay, here's the difference.
We actually saw the broken Mamo sets. We have not seen those for entei. We have seen the freeze dry nmi and tera dark ada knock Manos. You can say those entei sets but have we actually seen them used in a serious amount? Like people have ran double edge entei, and it's simply an okay tech options. We haven't seen the other two and no, test games do not count. Unless they see serious tour usage, they should not be used as reasoning. This is poor reasoning and can be used to justify banning lots of things. "Ban gardevoir because cm garde is broken" "Ban Mew because np bolt beam is broken" you get the idea. We should ban shit because it's broken due to the sets that see usage.
Frankly put, this reasoning is making this suspect even worse. A suspect that most of the council do not find is broken, is something not supported by the community, and reasoning given is from sets that do not see usage.
Going to be the last post on this topic to not stink up this thread, but we can also not suspect Pokemon? Like we don't need to have suspect tests on shit. And if we are, let's do things that the community and council believe will have a solid chance of getting banned, otherwise we are just wasting time.