• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

CAP 38 - Part 10 - Moveset Discussion

Status
Not open for further replies.
Name: Fast Defensive
Move 1: Recover
Move 2: Whirlwind / Haze / A Screen / Mystical Fire
Move 3: Sludge Bomb / Energy Ball
Move 4: Earth Power / Mystical Fire
Ability: Flower Veil
Item: Leftovers / Heavy-Duty Boots / Rocky Helmet / Some Berry / Air Balloon
EVs: 180 Def / 32 SpA / 48 SpD / 248 Spe or 180 Def / 32 SpA / 88 SpD / 208 Spe or 180 Def / 32 SpA / 132 SpD / 176 Spe
Nature: Timid Nature

EV explanations
  • The three spreads are things I whipped up quickly for three seemingly important Speed benchmarks that CAP 38 may want to hit (Stratagem | Darkrai | Tornadus-Therian)
  • 180 Def survives unboosted Hemogoblin Flare Blitz.
  • 32 SpA OHKOes Booster Speed Iron Moth and forces Chuggalong to tera if it wants to use Clangorous Soul with Earth Power. Kitsunoh is also 2HKOed with Mystical Fire and 3HKOes Substitute + Protect Kyurem with Sludge Bomb.
  • 48 SpD survives Booster Speed Iron Moth's Firey Dance (94% of the time) & +1 252 SpA Chuggalong Clanging Scales. 88 SpD makes 252 SpA Gholdengo's Shadow Ball a 3HKO and survives Make It Rain after Stealth Rock and a single layer of Spikes. 120 SpD makes Equilibra's Earth Power 2HKO after Stealth Rock and survive Slowking Galar's Future Sight (most of the time 1.2% | 6.3% chance). Kind of annoyed after spending a while in the calc the spreads ended up being just swap Speed for Special Defence (i.e. 16 HP / 252 SpD survives +2 0 SpA Make It Rain).

Moves

Whirlwind | Haze Phazing in general is pretty good and has advantages over Clear Smog such as removing Booster Energy Boosts and ignoring Substitute. The minus priority is an issue so that is why I've suggest Haze as well. Clear Smog just feels that it prioritizes flavour over function and can be easily denied through Substitute or :steel:.

Reflect | Light Screen While Screens might be associated with a suicide lead they historically have seen use outside use outside that role. Eternatus itself ran a Reflect + Air Balloon set primarily for Marshadow and maybe CAP 38 could have a similar interaction with Revenankh or do something similar to SS Light Screen Toxapex. It seems unlikely that a screen would ever become super common on a defensive CAP 38 set, but adds some potential depth.
 
Guingil said:
I continue to hold the position that Knock Off isn't doing enough on its own to ensure a defensive set. Maybe it gets slashed on an offensive set, but not more than that. :Serperior: is about the only speedy offensive Pokemon I can find that runs both recovery and Knock Off, without hazard or pivoting tools, but that is not on a bulk-invested set.

For either Mortal Spin or Will-O-Wisp, an interesting comparison could be :Cinderace: with its own hazard removal option and status. The bulky set with Pyro Ball, Court Change, and Will-O-Wisp competes decently versus an offensive set with an arguably lower ceiling than 38's. It's not apples to oranges, as Cinderace has pivoting and we have recovery + Knock Off instead. But as :Ogerpon-Wellspring: has shown through its utility set, often you drop recovery before you drop Knock Off and pivoting, so I'm not sure what it says about our viability.
Ok, so the reason no pokemon performs well with only knock off is mostly due to the fact that extremely few pokemon receive only knock off.
1794863606539.png

1794863628499.png

Very few of these pokemon are even remotely comparable to our situation. Serperior, shiftry, leavanny, victreebel, mewtwo, and a few others have paltry defenses. Slaking has obvious issues. Goodra sneaks onto the list because of life dew. Others actually do have defensive sets utilizing solely knock off, such as venusaur and reuniclus. Many of the pokemon you listed in your previous posts, such as darkrai and walking wake, have far worse defensive typings, abilities, and access to recovery than us.

Probably the best targets for comparison if you're trying to make this argument are chromera and revenankh, but again, defensive chromera and revenankh are hopelessly outclassed by defensive CAP 38. Revenankh gets priority moonlight and will-o-wisp, but its superb offensive typing is horrendous as a wall; bug/poison/rock/fighting/normal as a defensive profile walls nearly nothing in the current metagame. Chromera has the stats and movepool, but is extremely exploitable with color change when it plays the long game.

We are in a fairly unique spot right now. I agree with your conclusion, that knock off is not enough for defensive sets, but this is mostly intuition. Venusaur has a similar movepool and the same typing, and pulls off knock defensive in low tiers, so I don't think this is as easy of an argument to make as you're making it seem.

I also have a few changes to propose for Bumboclaat's set:
Name: Fast Defensive
Move 1: Recover
Move 2: Mystical Fire / Roar / Clear Smog / Cotton Guard / Haze / Whirlwind / A Screen
Move 3: Sludge Bomb / Energy Ball
Move 4: Earth Power / Mystical Fire
Ability: Flower Veil
Item: Leftovers / Heavy-Duty Boots / Rocky Helmet / Some Berry / Air Balloon
EVs: 180 Def / 32 SpA / 48 44 SpD / 248 252 Spe OR 180 Def / 32 SpA / 88 SpD / 208 Spe OR 180 Def / 32 SpA / 132 SpD / 176 Spe
Nature: Timid Nature
I would like cotton guard to be added to bumboclaat's set over the screen. Single screens are fairly hard to run in slower formats like cap, and the unlimited duration along with extra defense boost make it far better of a move imo. Its also just a really fun button to click. Similarly, clear smog is a stab option that has already been accepted that fulfills the role of haze. I took the liberties of moving 4 ev's from SpD to Speed on the fast set for the mirror, cutting less viable items, and switching whirlwind to roar for flavor.
 
Last edited:
as the literal only person who has ever suggested or supported teleport it getting rejected is hitting me hard :'(

lol anyway

Will-o-Wisp is fun, but we also have to take into account the fact we're a Poison-type. Our main STAB spreads a completely separate status. Other Poison-type Pokemon that use Will-o-Wisp, such as :Gengar: or :weezing-galar:, have other STABs that don't spread a status condition but still have a beneficial side effect. This allows them to focus on either spreading poison with Sludge Bomb, or attack with a different STAB that still hinders the opponent. The question is, do our Grass-type STABs have a powerful enough side effect it's worth using over Sludge Bomb against a neutral opponent? Does it even have good enough coverage it's worth running alongside or over Sludge Bomb on a 2 attacks set?

Mortal Spin, on the other hand, gives us a guaranteed way to spread the status we're known for, as well as providing some of the most appreciated utility in the game. It spreads significantly more chip damage and removes hazards at the cost of not boosting our tankiness at all. However, there are a few questions that comes with the inclusion of this as well: is it worth it to spread a status that takes several turns to show results, especially compared to Burn or Paralysis? Is it worth it to spend a slot on something that deals weak damage and is completely ineffectual against one of the most common types in the meta- one that our STABs are already walled by?

I think trying to kick making a defensive set to the second Secondary Ability stage is not going to achieve anything meaningful, especially considering they already considered how to make a defensive set viable and pushed that to this stage. That plus the fact that moves are more versatile than Abilities suggests to me that we should aim to get that discussion over with here, assuming we only have Flower Veil.

Just some things to consider.
 
Alright gang, not quite been 72 hours but due to IRL factors I'll be wrapping us up a tad early. Before the meat of my post, here's our final approval update list;

Approved:
Kicked to 2.0 movepool:
Reflect/Light Screen, Haze, Whirlwind/Roar
Rejected: Cotton Guard, Mortal Spin, Will-O-Wisp
Previous approvals being cut: Super Fang, Infestation, Spiky Shield

This might look a bit strange, so an explanation is in order. After my last approval post I started tallying up our full 1.0 movepool, and it quickly became evident that 38's movepool had ballooned into the second-largest 1.0 movepool of all gen 9 caps at 34, only just behind Hemogoblin's 35. We generally prefer to keep 1.0 movepools as tight as possible, and after consulting with TLT it was evident there was some chaff we could cut.

Super Fang, Infestation and Spiky Shield were cut post approval due to the trapping set being niche to begin with. I also kind of forgot to reassess my post after Art wrapped and missed Super Fang getting in which just does not jive with the winning design. We're always competitive before flavor for this stage, but that was a bridge too far. The entirety of the screens set subbed by bumboclaat was similarly kicked to flavor movepool for movebloat reasons. Cotton Guard was fully rejected due it's dubious concept adherence.

Mortal Spin & Will-O-Wisp will not be in our debut movepool. There was support for Mortal Spin post Knock approval, but there was equally as much support for cutting both. I was already of the stance that adding either at this point would push our power level a bit too far for 1.0, and as such I think we'll be better off leaving them on cutting room floor. I am confident Defensive 38 can find its niche without either of these options.


With all that said, here's your final 1.0 movepool for CAP 38!
1.0 Movepool
Includes Grass, Poison & Universal Assumed Moves
Total Move Count: 31

Acid Spray
Bullet Seed
Clear Smog
Earth Power
Endure
Energy Ball
Facade
Giga Drain
Gunk Shot
Helping Hand
Knock Off
Leaf Blade
Leaf Storm
Leech Seed
Meteor Beam
Mystical Fire
Poison Jab
Protect
Recover
Recycle
Rest
Scorching Sands
Seed Bomb
Sleep Talk
Sludge Bomb
Stockpile
Substitute
Take Down
Tera Blast
Toxic
Toxic Spikes

We've had a fairly rough go of it for the moves stage(s) this process, but I think we've managed to come out the other side in good shape. Life really threw a whole bunch of slobberknockers at me in rapid succession, so I deeply appreciate everyone's patience when it came to this stage. All that's left to do now is send this movepool off to TL Spammernoob for approval, see you on the other side everyone!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top