• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Proposal Add Champions VGC to WCOP

With the new worlds circuit opportunities being announced for countries that did not have any way to officially compete in VGC, and an overall massive rise in its popularity, I think we should add Champs VGC to WCOP. In my opinion, it is the single best tier to add for a tour like this. A lot of the common isolation issues from the rest of the team become a non-issue where players are very willing to help in each other's tiers and have camaraderie owing to being from the same country and fighting to win for it.

Wanted to post this thread well in advance for countries to prepare if this gets accepted. From what I have seen, almost all countries that participate in WCOP have a competent pool of VGC players they can get, with available and public sources everywhere to find good players in your country very easily. The key point is that VGC will be a vast new player pool to tap into and will not eat away at or overlap with the current slots or pool of players, meaning even countries with smaller player bases should not have any issue.
(If you want to check, some quick sources I know are the tournament websites like limitless, victory road; Vgc world cup, Global challenge records can be filtered by country, ladder, VGC twitter, and of course all the discord groups)

Why Champs VGC > DOU: Accessibility. It is a much more popular and widely played format. Since all countries already have a competent player pool and a constant new influx of players coming in, it will be a much easier experience for everyone (especially countries with smaller player bases) to get competent players. It also helps in incorporating players from that community into the Smogon environment through the best and friendliest tournament we have to offer.

Proposed Formats:

Option 1:
4x SV OU
1x Champs VGC
1x SS OU
1x SM OU
1x ORAS OU
1x SV UU
1x SV Ubers

Option 2:
5x SV OU
2x Champs VGC
1x SS OU
1x SM OU
1x ORAS OU
1x SV UU
1x SV Ubers

When the idea of adding VGC to WCOP was brought up during SPL discussions, it was very well received with almost no pushback, so wanted to put up a thread to gauge community opinion and see if this would cause any issues for smaller countries.

Also before it gets flooded with discussion of adding other tiers, would request this thread only be related to this topic (format, issues, etc.) and not addition of another tier or something else, those can be done in their own thread.
 
Last edited:
I would like to bring up a possible third option in

3x SV OU
2x Champs VGC

1x SS OU
1x SM OU
1x ORAS OU
1x SV UU
1x SV Ubers

In my eyes
- it addresses the SV burnout quite smartly
- if gen 10 really is a legends style game (which it seems to be), it helps us slowly transition from a "simulation tier" website by updating the identity of one of our flagship tournaments.

I propose that captains of all teams (both main event and qualifiers) are surveyed/polled regarding this. I don't want to speak on anyone's behalf, but the accessibility & outreach of pokemon champions really does make me believe that every region (both big and small) has atleast 2 very competent options for vgc.

I also think that it's better to address this in some capacity sooner than later (possibly in the next ~1.5 months?). After all we are only 1-2 regulations away from the metagame that will be played in wcop. Will give people ample time to prepare.
 
Last edited:
Spitfire said:
I would like to bring up a possible third option in

3x SV OU
2x Champs VGC

1x SS OU
1x SM OU
1x ORAS OU
1x SV UU
1x SV Ubers
Vouch, keeping the number to 10 seems ideal because we dont need to add 1 or 2 extra sv for the reasons mentionned above.. also adding that the excuse of "the tournament will need 12 slots in the future" as it was done for spl recently would not make any sense here so...
my comrade breloominati's options looks optimal to me.
 
Last edited:
Rubyblood said:
1 SV OU
1 Champs VGC
1 SS OU
1 SM OU
1 ORAS OU
1 BW OU
1 DPP OU
1 ADV OU
1 GSC OU
1 RBY OU bo3

Bring back the og format by adding the all gens and 1 sv slot not 2 or w/e and also add one vgc slot
I love spl but another tour that does the same thing+vgc is maybe not what wcup should be.

I also think Spitfire idea is much better and the best way to continue in the future. We’ll have to transition gradually toward a tier system based on Champions, using Smogon’s 6v6 formats as a reference, and move away from generation-based solo tiers going forward.
 
Last edited:
Honestly, I think we should seriously consider cutting down the number of SV OU slots. We've had enough of this generation at this point. The tier has been frozen for years, and having 5 slots dedicated to it is just exhausting. I don't really see why we should keep giving so much slots to a generation we've been playing for four consecutive years.

If we limited the current generation to just 1 or 2 slots, we'd have plenty of room to bring back other tiers. BW, DPP, ADV, GSC, RBY... There are so many formats we could include, and I don't think there's any good reason to keep prioritizing Gen 9 over all of them. We've had our fair share of SV OU.

In fact, if we're only keeping 1 or 2 SV OU slots, I don't see why we wouldn't just include all the old gens. It would make the tournament much more diverse and give people more reasons to get involved. That's also why I'd rather see us think in terms of old gens rather than low tiers. Gen 9 has had its spotlight for long enough.

And I genuinely don't think this would benefit Belgium in any particular way. I'm trying to be as objective as possible here. I'm just thinking about what kind of format I'd actually enjoy playing in and be motivated to invest time in. Not sure about you guys, but give me ur opinion.

On another note, I actually like the idea of introducing VGC Champion. We were already considering adding a doubles format back then, and I think it's a good opportunity to finally do it. Change is good, and adding a completely different format would bring something fresh to the competition.

If that ends up overlapping too much with Retro WCoP, then we could simply consider dropping Retro WCoP altogether. In my opinion, the main event should always take priority. I'd rather have one strong, diverse main tournament than split the playerbase across two events that end up serving a similar purpose.

One thing I would definitely keep, though, is the 10-slot format. I think it's the best way to maintain some actual competition between countries and make sure the tournament feels substantial.

My ideal format would therefore look something like this:

- SV OU
- SS OU
- SM OU
- ORAS OU
- BW OU
- DPP OU
- ADV OU
- GSC OU
- RBY OU
- VGC Champion OU / a second SV OU slot

That way, we still have room for the current generation, we get to bring back the full range of old gens, and we introduce a new format with VGC. To me, that's a much more interesting and balanced lineup than having half the tournament dedicated to SV OU.
 
Maktyum said:
I love spl but another tour that does the same thing+vgc is maybe not what wcup should be.

I also think Spitfire idea is much better and the best way to continue in the future. We’ll have to transition gradually toward a tier system based on Champions, using Smogon’s 6v6 formats as a reference, and move away from generation-based solo tiers going forward.

I get what you mean, but honestly, if you love SPL, why would we want to move away from a format that people genuinely enjoy and look forward to every year?

To me, the best approach is to build on what already works. SPL is one of the most anticipated tournaments of the year and probably the one that generates the most excitement within the community. The difference with WCoP is that you're fighting alongside your brothers, representing your country. That's where the whole experience becomes different, regardless of whether some of the tiers overlap.

And if those are the tiers we've chosen for Premier League and the format works so well, I don't think that's a coincidence. There's probably a good reason why people enjoy playing them.

That being said, I think adding a VGC Champions slot could be a nice way to bring some diversity compared to SPL and give WCoP its own little twist. I wouldn't go as far as adding two VGC slots, though. I feel like the player pool is still too small to justify dedicating that much room to it.
 
The current main tier was handled in a historically disastrous way.


How we can tolerate to have multiple SV slots when the tier is going so badly, Most of players and even the top ones needs to cheese by playing extreme playstyle like screens HO, sun, webs etc. In addition, we have a suspect who make no sense by having the option to add a pokemon which adds more variance to the tier.
We must also realize that things need to change, and we can start by rejecting mediocrity.

VGC PART

VGC is becoming increasingly prominent, it's a fact since Gamefreak places more importance on this format than on 6vs6. I know we have to maintain our identity as a 6vs6 focused sit , but I don't see a problem with having it with 6vs6 format. Both must coexist to make smogon more appealing and accessible to everyone.
My other point is that most DOU players already play VGC and I know a lot of veterans who have stopped playing a 6vs6 to play VGC, adding them to the WCOP would be a huge for the hype and the prestige.


OU PLAYERBASE( RBY to SS)

We have to realize how important this playerbase is : I'll explain why is it

Each tier has its share of passionate and highly skilled players, some of whom even contribute very positively to the community. Take, for example, Ruffles and his tremendous work for ORAS, as well as Dice and Posho, who organize highly prestigious tournaments in BW(Mastermind) open to everyone as an introduction to BW. And there are many other examples, such as the ADV community, known for being the largest and most active, with a new, very talented player base and prestigious tournaments organized every year.

All of these theses tiers are very interesting to play and watch because, despite the years most of them continue to evolve.
We’ve seen significant changes in DPP and BW, and the player base continues to evolve. Even the meta is evolving with the arrival of Registeel, which is becoming a very common Pokemon in the tier. So there will never be a problem with quality or hype, since these are the most passionate and prestigious playerbase.
If you’re also tired of seeing RBY and GSC, you shouldn’t be because these formats are also undergoing significant changes, and modernity is very much present ; you just have to watch the matches. We’re a long way from the days when everyone played the same teams like bots, with a generally low skill level. The RBY community is very active for example.
As a GSC mainer, I can say the same about that community, there are a few fewer of us, but we’re just as passionate. I can also say that it’s no longer as easy as it used to be to win consistently with the same teams, since the average skill level in this tier has improved significantly, with many new players who have their own styles with an excellent Knowledge of the tiers. We can also see this in Siatam's work, based on the stats So we’re still seeing interesting strategies and never seeing the same match styles as it did in the past.

~~~~ So, on behalf of all these communities, please include them to make the World Cup much more fun and prestigious by ensuring that all these people feel a sense of pride in playing for their country ~~~~

The conflict of the format between the lowtiers playerbase and oldgens playerbase.

I think my first post was too subjective and self-centered.

I’ll admit that the player base for the lower tiers is very good, because these tiers have the advantage of not having a metagame that’s set in stone over time while a tier is being developed. I’ll admit that they’re fun to play, especially when it comes to the building aspect, which is a part of the game I respect immensely. I really enjoyed playing them for the Grand Slam, and I think they deserve to exist just as much as the oldgens.
We must therefore find a compromise between these communities.

what I'm proposing:

1 SV OU
1 Champ VGC OU
1 SS OU
1 SM OU
1 ORAS OU
1 BO3 Masters/BO3 ST
1 BO5 Classic
1 BO5 Slam
1 SV UU
1 SV UBERS

Conclusion :

I sincerely believe that this format is the best option because it will satisfy the low-tier, old-gen, and VGC player bases while making the tournament more prestigious in a context where SV is about to enter its fifth year.
We need to make the right decisions and really pay attention to them this year; we need to stop settling for mediocre formats and find solutions. It’s obviously hard to be objective when it comes to our personal preferences, which is why it’s important to discuss this.
 
Last edited:
The spl sv discussion made it clear we do not care about what the community wants so why don’t we just make this tour all sv too? Td response was hilarious on that thread. As for wcop this tour is buns until it goes back to old gens being integrated. It is a shame we are forced to keep eating the same shit bad formats we are shoveled every time and are expected to eat it w/o question.
 
I think adding two VGC slots to WCOP is a step in the right direction, but it shouldn't come at the expense of any OU or SV slots.

Almost any team can afford to include a top VGC player, and I genuinely believe many players would be interested in competing in VGC at World Cup, especially since it would serve as valuable preparation for the upcoming Pokémon World Championships.

Cutting down on SV slots would be a mistake because, at least within the World Cup scene, SV serves as an important stepping stone for up and coming players looking to establish themselves. I can think about a lot of names which made their debut in WCOP and eventually we have seen them in other big tours like SPL or SCL.

I agree that SV is currently in a weird state, but reducing the number of slots would essentially be an admission that we have poorly managed our flagship format and that we are unable to address their underlying issues. Instead, we should focus on fixing our flagship formats and tackling the problems at their core, rather than turning Smogon into Nugget Bridge 2.0 by giving VGC so much room at the expense of OU. Our goal as a historic competitive platform is to offer a valid alternative, not serving the official nintendo format and I say that as someone who plays both on Smogon and VGC.
Also data suggest that engagement in Pokemon Champions is slowing decreasing, VGC is not less boring than OU unless the new regulations bring in some significative metagame shift.

Said that, I totally support this format:
5x SV OU
2x Champs VGC
1x SS OU
1x SM OU
1x ORAS OU
1x SV UU
1x SV Ubers
(and eventually adding one more substitute slot I guess)

I do not think the high number of slots should be a major concern since VGC is a totally a different thing to manage than the og smogon formats. I prefer two VGC slots because for a VGC player having more people to test with can be more motivating.
 
Last edited:
Eoward said:
Honestly, I think we should seriously consider cutting down the number of SV OU slots. We've had enough of this generation at this point. The tier has been frozen for years, and having 5 slots dedicated to it is just exhausting. I don't really see why we should keep giving so much slots to a generation we've been playing for four consecutive years.

If we limited the current generation to just 1 or 2 slots, we'd have plenty of room to bring back other tiers. BW, DPP, ADV, GSC, RBY... There are so many formats we could include, and I don't think there's any good reason to keep prioritizing Gen 9 over all of them. We've had our fair share of SV OU.

In fact, if we're only keeping 1 or 2 SV OU slots, I don't see why we wouldn't just include all the old gens. It would make the tournament much more diverse and give people more reasons to get involved. That's also why I'd rather see us think in terms of old gens rather than low tiers. Gen 9 has had its spotlight for long enough.

And I genuinely don't think this would benefit Belgium in any particular way. I'm trying to be as objective as possible here. I'm just thinking about what kind of format I'd actually enjoy playing in and be motivated to invest time in. Not sure about you guys, but give me ur opinion.

On another note, I actually like the idea of introducing VGC Champion. We were already considering adding a doubles format back then, and I think it's a good opportunity to finally do it. Change is good, and adding a completely different format would bring something fresh to the competition.

If that ends up overlapping too much with Retro WCoP, then we could simply consider dropping Retro WCoP altogether. In my opinion, the main event should always take priority. I'd rather have one strong, diverse main tournament than split the playerbase across two events that end up serving a similar purpose.

One thing I would definitely keep, though, is the 10-slot format. I think it's the best way to maintain some actual competition between countries and make sure the tournament feels substantial.

My ideal format would therefore look something like this:

- SV OU
- SS OU
- SM OU
- ORAS OU
- BW OU
- DPP OU
- ADV OU
- GSC OU
- RBY OU
- VGC Champion OU / a second SV OU slot

That way, we still have room for the current generation, we get to bring back the full range of old gens, and we introduce a new format with VGC. To me, that's a much more interesting and balanced lineup than having half the tournament dedicated to SV OU.
Don't understand how you just randomly removed UU and Ubers without even mentioning it that's crazy.

I'm one of the biggest SV fans on this site for context before I write this out. I also thought before this thread that VGC doesn't really belong in tours like SPL and SCL, but WCOP seems to be a perfect tour for this. It's a perfect way to integrate VGC into the community by providing them an opportunity in one of the biggest tours on the site

Rubyblood said:
1 SV OU
1 Champ VGC OU
1 SS OU
1 SM OU
1 ORAS OU
1 BO3 Masters/BO3 ST
1 BO5 Classic
1 BO5 Slam
1 SV UU
1 SV UBERS
Spitfire said:
I would like to bring up a possible third option in

3x SV OU
2x Champs VGC

1x SS OU
1x SM OU
1x ORAS OU
1x SV UU
1x SV Ubers
The big issue is that there's no middle ground. With just 10 slots you have to pick between the four ideas.

Include UU and Ubers
Include Old Gens
Include Multiple SV OU slots
Include VGC


These four things can't all work together in the 10 Slots atm. You would need at least 14 slots total to make everyone happy and even then some SV players would still feel cheaped out with only having 2 slots. I think the current format is completely fine in my personal opinion and was a total blast to watch last year.

I also see the value of adding VGC tho, so I would probably go with option 1 that Maverick suggested.

Another issue with adding the proposal that people like Blunder and Rubyblood suggested is that we will have to rework it completely next year. The focus will be on WW OU and Ubers/UU so adding back old gens just to replace them with more ww slots the next year seems kind of unnecessary
 
Last edited:
lowkey just remove ubers and uu, the idea of having extra lowtier rep in officials is good at heart but it kinda shoots itself in the foot by only including some of them. agree that this is a good way to test run integration of vgc into more competitive smogon spaces and that this could even help some regions field better rosters.
 
One major goal of world cup is for new tour players to break out, so some SV OU should stay, but not too much due to the SV fatigue. The additional goal of WCoP 2027 is to experiment so we can a bit more prepared for gen 10 and champs, so at least 2 slots of champs vgc should be in imo. So I agree with spitfire:

3x SV OU
2x Champs VGC
1x SS OU
1x SM OU
1x ORAS OU
1x SV UU
1x SV Ubers

As much as I love old gens, I don't think adding more makes sense for either above goal. Another option is removing ubers (and maybe uu) for more SV OU. Personally I'm not a huge fan of lower tiers in 5th year of current gen world cup.

Lowkey just add 1 SV OU and 1 Champs over UU & Ubers. Or even add some old gens. UU & Ubers feel so random and unnecessary in this tour
 
Last edited:
Ruffles said:
One major goal of world cup is for new tour players to break out, so some SV OU should stay, but not too much due to the SV fatigue. The additional goal of WCoP 2027 is to experiment so we can a bit more prepared for gen 10 and champs, so at least 2 slots of champs vgc should be in imo. So I agree with spitfire:

3x SV OU
2x Champs VGC
1x SS OU
1x SM OU
1x ORAS OU
1x SV UU
1x SV Ubers

As much as I love old gens, I don't think adding any makes sense for either above goal. Another option is removing ubers (and maybe uu) for more SV OU. Personally I'm not a huge fan of lower tiers in 5th year of current gen world cup.
As much as I love oras, I don't think keeping it makes sense for either above goal.


Jokes aside, I think adding VGC in World Cup is a good thing, I also think re-adding Oldgens is good. To me a tournament that aims at crowning the best country/region of the year should be played in all standard (OU) formats. VGC can be added to that, but it needs to be decided how to handle the change of regulation that can happen mid-tournament. I suggest if a change of regulation happens we just follow it as it happens but maybe some people have different opinions.
 
I think having a lot of cg ou slots is good for helping newer players break out, since wcop tends to be the place for that especially in smaller regions. That said, by next wcop we’ll have played sv for half a decade. Most people agree we’ve had it too long, and either way it’s just a lot of sv especially for a mixed format with old gens and lower tiers at this point in its lifespan. I would say keep the same format otherwise, but instead of 5 sv ou do 3 sv ou 2 vgc, or 4 sv ou 1 vgc. I’m a big fan of reading vgc into officials since it’s gotten so popular, and this seems like the place to do it. If we go down to 3 sv ou I think we should reevaluate when gen 10 comes out if we want all cg ou, to go back to 5, etc. but until then I would add some vgc to change it up and integrate it back into officials.
 
WCoP should absolutely stay at 10 slots for balance sake. Going from 8 to 10 already hurt smaller regions, so going from 10 to 12 would be a step in the wrong direction.

I think adding 1 VGC slot over 1 of the SV OU slots is fine. 2 VGC seems odd to start.

With all of this said, in the future when Gen 10 comes out, WCoP should go back to 8 CG OU, barring any weird circumstances with Champions and Gen 10. We changed the format because SV got stale, and we’re changing it again because it is still stale. That is fine, but unless there is massive community opposition, we should go back to the original team tournament proposal Hogg made all those years back - WCoP for CG OU, SPL for old generations, and SCL for lower tiers.
 
Last edited:
I could not possibly agree more with the sentiments above regarding the return of old Gens to WCoP. As many know, I've been a vocal proponent of this for years now, and I think given the fairly widespread sentiments about SV OU overstaying its welcome (not by choice), this is a key opportunity to improve WCoP.

The current format that's been assembled is completely arbitrary. A regions-based competition should feature a variety of different Gens of OU, our flagship tier, not just CG and also not just Fairy Gens. There are robust groups of players across all Gens of OU; it's time to showcase them again for a true international tournament.
 
Last edited:
I would support adding VGC to WCOP albeit in the format of tier pick, with VGC along with the current SPL and SCL tiers being eligible options for teams to pick. I know it was rejected a few years ago but I think it should be revisited especially given the concerns tournaments have gotten stale with how long SV has gone on.

Most of the lower tiers have adopted the tier pick format for one of their yearly team tours and I think it's a much more interesting format than just regular PL and adds a lot of extra strategy, the pools format would have to be modified slightly but I see no reason it can't work and for the playoffs I think it's objectively better.

I disagree with previous concerns that it makes things more unbalanced, a lot of smaller teams have a couple standout players in random tiers and this would allow those teams to pick them (obviously the big teams do too but relative to strength in the current format), and you'd see players in their best tiers instead of reusing teams to play a tier they don't really play. This also seems the best way to balance tiers between the 3 trophy tours, instead of some arbitrarily being in 2/3 compared to others in 1/3.
 
I support the idea of adding VGC over 1 or 2 of the SV slots depending on interest, not in favour of increasing the slots as it's already hard for smaller regions to form a team. I don't hate the idea of having older gens but we already have rcop for that also I like Ubers and UU better then adding more OUs
3x or 4x SV
1 or 2 vgc
Ss
Sm
Oras
Ubers
Uu
 
Speaking as a TD;

The idea of introducing more oldgens into WCoP will not be implemented, as it has 0 support from the entire TD team. This thread's main purpose is for discussing the merit of VGC's addition. Please stay on topic; post related to oldgens will be deleted going forward.

===================

Speaking as myself;

There is no reason imo to not add VGC this year; additionally I would like to see that if it is added this year, in whatever quantity we add it, that it remains in the tournament next year, even if the remainder of the slots are a monolith of WW OU (or whatever that looks like).

Also flex slots in a pools format should never happen.
 
Last edited:
VGC makes a lot of sense in a tournament like WCoP. It is by far the most popular way of playing competitive pokemon and we should be tapping into that. I suggest:

5x SV OU
2x Champs VGC
1x SS OU
1x SM OU
1x ORAS OU
1x SV UU
1x SV Ubers

5 SV OU is a lot of SV OU, especially this far after the gen’s release, but no other number feels quite right to me. 2 VGC slots is a must imo and any less is a failure to meet the moment. To make things even the only options are 3 SV OU or 5 SV OU to me, and 3 SV OU feels like just too little for a tour that historically emphasizes the current gen OU format. 12 starting slots is still a lot, but I dont expect this to be a huge issue as the WCOP format already has 5 SV slots and VGC taps into a playerbase thats largely not involved in the tour already.
 
The best compromise here is just taking one SV OU slot and replacing it with VGC.

People want a different format this deep into the generation. Adding multiple VGC slots is an huge step when we have been hesitant to include it to begin with and we haven’t thoroughly considered including DOU. Adding many old generations puts much of the field at a disadvantage when it will revert to CG for gen10 anyway — I am glad Mason took this off the table. Removing numerous SV OU hurts teams who built up strong depth in recent years. Going up to 12 slots punishes teams who recently became competitive in a 10 slot tournament.

There is no perfect solution. There is no way for everyone to be happy. This is the best combination of meeting community needs, upholding the competitiveness of the tournament, and being openminded to change.
 
Back
Top