As a player, personally I heavily disagree with the notion that tournament players averaging their opinion is better. When we as tournament players rank these Pokemon, we are trying to project a view of the meta that, to the best of our ability, is an accurate representation. Personal opinions do matter, but mainly in terms of innovations and counter meta trends, but that is mainly important in metagame discussions, team-building, and tournament preparation, not in the VR. A Pokemon's viability is a reflection of how important and how winning it is in the metagame, and we consciously or unconsciously use data sets such as usage and win rate as a metrics when forming our subjective opinion. The problem is that biases veer us off too much, and even in the same 30 minute session that takes to rank all these Pokemon we cannot keep a straight single view of the metagame. Having a purely objective data-only driven view goes further than just achieving more accurate or meaningful rankings, but even opens up the very same tournament players to blind spots and our own biases. I know it did for me.
Let me start with the biggest example.
The Mega Alakazam Hit Piece
I'm going to look at a case-by-case view of the most recent SPL and do some data-analysis to eliminate confounding factors:
1. Mega Alakazam vs. base Alakazam
2. New players not knowing how to use Alakazam
3. Same teambuilders passing teams around
4. Head to head winrate
5. Focus Blast misses
All of these are either outright eliminated by looking at SPL data or can be calculated and included in our assessment.
So, let's start with its usage and winrate.
Mega Alakazam was brought 13 times and Alakazam was brought 1 time, with a combined win rate of 14.29%. To be clear, that is exactly 2/14 games won, WITH ZERO HEAD TO HEAD GAMES.
Let's go in order.
W1:
Santu vs. PJ
:diancie-mega::hippowdon::talonflame::volcanion::excadrill::tangrowth: (W)
:alakazam-mega::bisharp::excadrill::rotom-wash::garchomp::tornadus-therian: (L)
Alakazam win? No
Focus Blast used? No
Structure? Offense
Lost against? Balanced
W1:
Piyu vs. xray
:gyarados-mega::serperior::mew::weavile::volcarona::cloyster: (W)
:alakazam-mega::bisharp::excadrill::rotom-wash::garchomp::tornadus-therian: (L)
Alakazam win? No
Focus Blast used? Yes, twice
Focus Blast hit? Yes, twice
Structure? Offense
Lost against? HO
W2:
NoName6293 vs. Ox the Fox
:venusaur-mega::magnezone::clefable::chansey::quagsire::skarmory: (W)
:alakazam-mega::clefable::excadrill::rotom-wash::hippowdon::tornadus-therian: (L)
Alakazam win? No
Focus Blast used? Yes, four times
Focus Blast hit? Yes, four times
Structure? BO
Lost against? Stall
W2:
Poek vs. Piyu
:latias-mega::ferrothorn::clefable::slowbro::hippowdon::tornadus-therian: (L)
:alakazam-mega::tyranitar::serperior::rotom-wash::heatran::landorus-therian: (W)
Alakazam win? Yes
Focus Blast used? No
Structure? BO
Won against? Balanced / Semistall
W3:
Santu vs. Persephone
:pinsir-mega::serperior::bisharp::kyurem-black::garchomp::mew: (W)
:alakazam-mega::magnezone::clefable::dragonite::gliscor::skarmory: (L)
Alakazam win? No
Focus Blast used? Yes, once
Focus Blast hit? Yes, once
Structure? Semistall
Lost against? Offense
W4:
Santu vs. c0mp
:venusaur-mega::gliscor::manaphy::zapdos::chansey::mew: (W)
:alakazam-mega::bisharp::latios::excadrill::garchomp::thundurus: (L)
Alakazam win? No
Focus Blast used? Yes, twice
Focus Blast hit? No, twice
(Missed twice)
Was the miss majorly impactful to the game? No (chansey was full hp into +1 Mzam both times with Twave ready, you just spam Soft-Boiled after you tank it until it misses)
Structure? Offense
Lost against? Semistall
W4:
Piyu vs. Ox the Fox
:venusaur-mega::gliscor::manaphy::zapdos::chansey::mew: (L)
:venusaur-mega::rotom-wash::clefable::alakazam::garchomp::skarmory: (W)
Alakazam win? Yes
Focus Blast used? Yes, once
Focus Blast hit? Yes, once
Structure? Balanced / Semistall
Won against? Semistall
W5:
Santu vs. Ox the Fox
:scizor-mega::garchomp::weavile::zapdos::suicune::mew: (W)
:alakazam-mega::rotom-wash::clefable::chansey::gliscor::skarmory: (L)
Alakazam win? No
Focus Blast used? Yes, once
Focus Blast hit? No
(Missed once)
Was the miss majorly impactful to the game? No (it was against a SpD Zapdos)
Structure? Semistall
Lost against? Offense/BO
W5:
Metallica126 vs. London Beats
:scizor-mega::garchomp::gengar::zapdos::serperior::keldeo: (W)
:alakazam-mega::weavile::clefable::volcanion::excadrill::zapdos: (L)
Alakazam win? No
Focus Blast used? No
Structure? BO
Lost against? Offense/BO
W6:
KingofKing vs. NoName6293
:venusaur-mega::tyranitar::mew::thundurus::excadrill::talonflame: (W)
:alakazam-mega::volcarona::rotom-wash::landorus-therian::excadrill::tornadus-therian: (L)
Alakazam win? No
Focus Blast used? Yes, thrice
Focus Blast hit? Yes, twice
(Missed once)
Was the miss majorly impactful to the game? Yes
Structure? Offense
Lost against? Offense/BO
W6:
Ruffles vs. London Beats
:latias-mega::gengar::clefable::ferrothorn::hippowdon::rotom-wash: (W)
:alakazam-mega::serperior::manaphy::thundurus::bisharp::landorus-therian: (L)
Alakazam win? No
Focus Blast used? Yes, once
Focus Blast hit? Yes, once
Structure? HO
Lost against? Balanced / Semistall
W8:
Ruffles vs. BluBirD
:lopunny-mega::heatran::clefable::amoonguss::seismitoad::skarmory: (W)
:alakazam-mega::excadrill::rotom-wash::clefable::dragonite::landorus-therian: (L)
Alakazam win? No
Focus Blast used? Yes, twice
Focus Blast hit? Yes, once
(Missed once)
Was the miss majorly impactful to the game? Yes
Structure? BO
Lost against? Semistall
Semifinals:
NoName6293 vs. Mgdos16
:gyarados-mega::weavile::serperior::volcanion::excadrill::zapdos: (W)
:alakazam-mega::bisharp::excadrill::manaphy::garchomp::tornadus-therian: (L)
Alakazam win? No
Focus Blast used? Yes, once
Focus Blast hit? Yes, once
Structure? Offense
Lost against? Offense
Semifinals:
Santu vs. Ruffles
:lopunny-mega::sableye::thundurus-therian::shuckle::bisharp::manaphy: (W)
:alakazam-mega::serperior::heatran::clefable::garchomp::skarmory: (L)
Alakazam win? No
Focus Blast used? No
Focus Blast hit? No
Structure? Balanced
Lost against? HO
Yeah. Let's put all of this together!
1. Mega Alakazam vs. base Alakazam: Not relevant (Base Alakazam WR: 100% (1/1). Mega Alakazam WR:
7.69% (1/13)
YIKES!!!)
2. New players not knowing how to use Alakazam: Not relevant
3. Same teambuilders passing teams around: Not relevant (used by multiple people with different, unique, and varied builds)
4. Head to head winrate: Not relevant
5. Focus Blast misses: Mostly irrelevant
- Focus Blast was clicked by Mega Alakazam 17 times, of which 12 of them hit (at 70.6% funnily enough)
- 13 games of Mega Alakazam were played, of those only 4 games included a focus blast miss, of which only 2 mattered
- With 100% Focus Blast accuracy, Mega Alakazam's winrate jumps from 7.69% (1/13) to 23.08% (3/13)
- If it had Aura Sphere instead, only 1 of these games would be saved imo (Noname vs. King), making its winrate 15.38% (2/13)
We saw that no matter what structure it was used on or went up against, it lost (except once on BO). While this is only one tournament, 1) the results are absolutely terrible, and 2) it is part of a larger trend.
THIS IS WHY I LOVE THE OBJECTIVE VR. It has rid me of the subjective
feel that Mega Alakazam is a top 5 Mega. Just to be clear, if my method was used on these stats of Mega Alakazam, it would be straight D rank, even with the 100% Focus Blast winrate. Keep in mind, its overall usage is 14.58%, the second most used mega in the tournament after Mega Scizor. So if anything, it is actually getting an insane boost in VR due to its very high usage compared to other megas.
So, why is Mega Alakazam's winrate so low? A post mortem analysis
So if you look at all the games, pretty much all were winnable. Sure, there might have been 1-2 bad mu's, but generally not a consistent theme. This is actually good, because it tells us Mega Alakazam and Mega Alakazam teams do not have a habit of netting bad mu's.
I want to look at some data I plucked from the replays I analyzed.
- The average turn Alakazam first used a move was Turn 23
- That means that on average, it came out a little less than half way through the game (47% into the game to be specific)
- The average number of moves Mega Alakazam clicked per game was 4.4
- That means that on average, it exerted direct pressure 10% of the game
- Caveat: Alakazam was used to in some games to exert pressure and double without using a move
From analyzing games, I came to a few conclusions why I think Mega Alakazam is not that great:
- Scarce opportunity to come in: the combination of its fragility, typing, and pre-mega speed results in difficulty coming in.
- For example, it is incredibly dangerous to lead into a Weavile team.
- You can't even come in on status such as Wisp or Toxic because you will be susceptible once you mega.
- Compared to something like Weavile with similar bulk, Weavile can come in on psychic moves and some moves it resists.
- No midplays / midgrounds: Mega Alakazam has to either hit Psychic or Focus Blast or Shadow Ball like 90% of the time
- Weavile has to choose between only 2 moves most of the time
- Weavile can often get away with just clicking Knock Off
- Even if you click Shadow Ball on a steel type, you still have to hit Focus Blast after
- Psychic offensively is not great, resisted easily and has an immunity
- It has this feature of being all-or-nothing. Often if you miss or get the prediction wrong, Zam is just dead, unlike Weavile.
- 4MSS: Despite having near perfect coverage with 3 moves, you actually really want Protect to mitigate the 1st weakness.
- However, without Taunt or Encore, you lose on its major strength: stallbreaking and anti-setup abilities
- Metagame trends: for example Mega Scizor, Talonflame, SpD Clefable, SpD Garchomp, Mega Metagross, Mega Gyarados, etc.
- Mega Scizor was the highest used Mega this tournament, which is actually incredibly annoying to Mega Alakazam, since it has to hit two Focus Blast (on top of predicting the correct switch) and even then it doesn't even KO as many people (including myself and the smog dex) EV to live two Focus Blasts w/o rocks up.
There are also alternative explanations though:
- Mega Alakazam’s best structures may not be found yet
- It is notoriously hard to build around, and some of the SPL builds shared the same core (Excadrill, Torn), despite being from different builders
- Like Mega Scizor, whose win rate rose once its structures were found, or Mew, whose usage jumped, Mega Alakazam’s viability could rise if new structures emerge.
- Even high-level tournament players may not yet have found a consistently winning way to use it
Finally, I leave you with this: