• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

CAP 38 - Part 9 - Secondary Ability Discussion 2

Spammernoob

is a Forum Moderator
Moderator
CAP 38 So Far


Please pay very close attention to Guingil's posts during this thread and remain on topic. DO NOT begin by posting massive lists of abilities!

Some general rules for this discussion:
  • Custom abilities are banned. No exceptions. Posts suggesting custom abilities will be deleted.
  • There are ability banlists for the different stages of ability discussion. Posts suggesting banned abilities will be deleted.
  • Flavor abilities do not have any place in this thread. Do not bring up flavor reasoning. Posts that rely on flavor reasoning will be deleted.
The following abilities are banned from this discussion:

Fully Banned Abilities group
Arena Trap
As One
Aura Break
Bad Dreams
Battle Bond
Beads Of Ruin
Beast Boost *
Chilling Neigh
Commander
Dark Aura
Dauntless Shield
Delta Stream
Desolate Land
Disguise
Dragon's Maw
Dragonize **
Embody Aspect
Fairy Aura **
Flower Gift
Forecast
Full Metal Body
Grim Neigh
Gulp Missile
Hadron Engine
Hunger Switch
Ice Face
Illusion
Imposter
Intrepid Sword
Mega Sol **
Moody
Multitype
Neuroforce
Orichalcum Pulse
Piercing Drill **
Poison Puppeteer
Power Construct
Primordial Sea
Prism Armor
Protosynthesis *
Quark Drive *
RKS System
Schooling
Shadow Shield
Shadow Tag
Shields Down
Soul Heart
Spicy Spray **
Stance Change
Sword Of Ruin
Tablets Of Ruin
Tera Shell
Tera Shift
Teraform Zero
Teravolt
Toxic Chain
Transistor
Turboblaze
Unseen Fist **
Vessel Of Ruin
Victory Star
Wonder Guard
Zen Mode
Zero To Hero

* These abilities will only be unbanned on a concept which is based around this ability - Such as an Ultra Beast or Paradox Pokemon
** These abilties will be treated as fully banned for the remainder of SV CAP, and will be pending review next gen.
Soft Banned Abilities group
These abilities are banned by default and should not be discussed barring exceptional cases. If you believe one of these abilities should be considered, you can make a post trying to explain why an exception is warranted in this specific case and if both the TL and Ability Leader agree, it will be allowed. If the TLT disagrees with the unbanning proposal, they should be considered fully banned and should not be further discussed.

Bulletproof
Color Change*
Defeatist
Dry Skin
Earth Eater
Flash Fire
Fur Coat
Good As Gold
Gorilla Tactics
Huge Power
Ice Scales
Libero*
Levitate
Lightning Rod
Magic Bounce
Magic Guard
Magnet Pull
Mimicry*
Motor Drive
Parental Bond
Protean*
Pure Power
Purifying Salt
Regenerator
Sap Sipper
Slow Start
Stall
Storm Drain
Truant
Volt Absorb
Water Absorb
Water Bubble
Well Baked Body
Wind Rider

*These abilities can only be considered for an unban if the Ability stage is done before typing.
Secondary Ability ban group
Comatose
Drizzle
Drought
Electric Surge
Fluffy
Grassy Surge
Innards Out
Misty Surge
Prankster
Psychic Surge
Sand Stream
Snow Warning
Speed Boost
Stamina
Steam Engine
Supreme Overlord
Toxic Debris
Triage
Flavor ability only ban group
Ball Fetch
Battery
Costar
Friend Guard
Healer
Honey Gather
Illuminate
Pickup
Power Spot
Power of Alchemy
Propeller Tail
Receiver
Run Away
Stalwart
Symbiosis
Telepathy

-----

Primary Ability banlist
Fully Banned Abilities group + Soft Banned Abilities group + flavor ability-only group

Secondary Ability banlist
Fully Banned Abilities group + Soft Banned Abilities group + secondary ability group + flavor ability-only group

Flavor Ability banlist
Primary ability group + secondary ability group


-----

Ability banlist PRC threads:
 
Hello, one and all. We are back, back again, to what is now the final competitive stage for the 1.0 release of CAP38: Secondary Ability 2 (Electric Boogaloo).

Just as a recap, the main thing we identified CAP38 was lacking during our first go was the existence of a viable defensive set. This was decided as an essential quality that would make us Eternatus-like in Concept Assessment 2. We had paused the Secondary stage because we felt there was inadequate information about how an ability could help with this, without knowing what moves the Pokemon has first. Now we have this information:

Movepool 1.0
Acid Spray
Bullet Seed
Clear Smog
Earth Power
Endure
Energy Ball
Facade
Giga Drain
Gunk Shot
Helping Hand
Knock Off
Leaf Blade
Leaf Storm
Leech Seed
Meteor Beam
Mystical Fire
Poison Jab
Protect
Recover
Recycle
Rest
Scorching Sands
Seed Bomb
Sleep Talk
Sludge Bomb
Stockpile
Substitute
Take Down
Tera Blast
Toxic
Toxic Spikes

In particular, we have received Knock Off as a tool to help said defensive sets, in addition to a few other tools like Clear Smog. Hence, I raise the question again:

Does our current kit, without a Secondary Ability, ensure a viable defensive set that competes decently with our offensive sets for usage?

To clarify what we mean by a defensive set, the wording in Concept Assessment was "Ability to flex EVs for bulky or offensive sets". I don't imagine an offensive set with Knock Off slashed on some moveslot to count for this, but it doesn't need to be 252 HP / 252 Def either. Some combination of bulk and, I imagine, Speed should suffice to show a viable set; or conversely, show that none of those would function decently enough. As some have said before, even a 3A tanky set like :Venusaur-Mega:'s could be a consideration here, but something like 2A + utility/Knock was what we began with. This is optional, but feel free to theorize a set using the template to make your argument:

CAP38 Set Template
Name:
Move 1:
Move 2:
Move 3:
Move 4:
Ability: Flower Veil
Item:
EVs:
Nature:

For this entire thread, I will say that the arguments need to be almost purely from a viability perspective to be taken into consideration. The existence of the defensive set is the highest priority for Eternatus-like vibes; we do not have room for anything that still argues for vibes at the cost of viability. But it is also important to remember that the defensive set does not need to be exactly as viable as the offensive set, which has been the case for Eternatus across generations as well. Just something that merits, say, a set mention in the analysis is my benchmark. We can compare with existing defensive Pokemon for competition and/or models as well.

I will leave this open for ~24 hours, as we've already had enough time to discuss some of this during our first iteration of the stage. Specific ability suggestions are NOT OPEN and will only be opened if we think the current kit cannot ensure defensive viability. In that case, we will also cut No Competitive Ability as a polling option. For the time being, we only seek to understand our current adequacy or lack thereof.
 
After perusing the move list I feel right now Cap 38 has the tools it needs where a secondary ability does not feel necessary however I can also see arguments of why that could not be the case. I feel wholeheartedly that these moves and flower veil should be enough to do its job and having a few hard counters and checks is better for a meta balance as a whole however I would like to see more takes on abilities before we can truly make sense of its scope as it stands however I feel that a secondary ability may not be the best approach but I can also see how it could help but I will still just mostly post my yap of a thought train here to try to gauge if I really want an ability or not also do take anything I say outside this official thread with a grain of salt. After looking at the moves again it doesn't really have a true defensive set going however with flower veil getting rid of status I see a knock defensive set being relatively helpful here and it can reliabily spread toxic and heal itself with recover so as I see it since there is a decently good chance of a knock defensive set that can mog offensive fairy types like valiant and the like, I feel a secondary doesn't feel as good here compared to other caps within the past. So I would be mostly in favor for not having a secondary at the moment.
 
Last edited:
Since this Pokemon has to match :eternatus:'s role in Ubers, I'd say A SECONDARY ABILITY would be a better choice. Everyone can see that Eternatus only has one ability anyway. Even though it's quite tough with Meteor Beam and Knock Off, as it can hit Psychic, Fire, Bug and Flying types hard, so with these, almost nothing can go against it. Flower Veil isn't really going to be of much use, so another ability helps it emulate Eternatus quite well.
But I might change my mind.
 
Last edited:
I personally find Flower Veil to be pivotal to the 'Mon's identity (especially speaking as somebody who saw firsthand the carnage it wrought on the art submissions), but I still support the idea of a flavorful utility Ability that ideally does not outclass it.

When it comes to competitive viability, not gaining much from the Burn immunity means Flower Veil leaves something to be desired from an offensive standpoint.
 
Now that we know the movepool we are working with for V1.0, I can now safely state without the worry of poll jumping that I believe we really didn't achieve enough from the movepool process to suggest we fixed the immediate problem that defensive sets are not going to be close to being on par to Offensive 3/4A sets. Whilst Knock Off is a nice option for utility for defensive sets, the momentum sink we would give up for the sake of item removal isn't outweighing the option to run offensive sets to brute force past the defensive checks that are looking to come into CAP 38. Therefore I'm now confident we can't keep pushing the issue at hand back any further and that we should go ahead and look at secondary abilities that would boost specifically defensive variations in a similar way how Flower Veil can help offensive ones by granting immune to speed drops from paralysis immunity, we should give defensive sets a niche ability to handle certain checks that offensive 38 sets can't force past on damage alone.

Quick note that I'll provide supporting calcs later but assuming defensive 38 will be running little/no SpAtk investment, our offensive pressure starts to look pretty dire and becomes a liability outside of item removal to rely either on checks having lack of recovery (mostly :Equilibra:) or hazard stack to chip away at checks to force the recovery which isn't a reliable option (:Corviknight: ignores Spikes and has Roost as a prime example.)
 
Last edited:
Does our current kit, without a Secondary Ability, ensure a viable defensive set that competes decently with our offensive sets for usage?
No. If "ensure" is the bar, we probably don't meet it right now. We're in a tricky position where defensive sets seem likely to be both pretty good and outclassed. Knock helps a bit, and it's quite possible that some combination of attacks and utility does make fatter sets work fine, but I don't think we can be assured that we're there yet. My gut says we're not that far off though.

In principle I agree with Glory2Snowstar that Flower Veil is a defining ability on this mon (from a competitive angle). Shutting down several forms of counterplay wholesale isn't something to be trifled with, and it does genuinely have a lot of nice uses even on a fatter set which might care a bit less about paralysis, because it increases the pool of mons you can switch in on freely and sit on, which is the primary function of a defensive mon. I'm quite worried about pairing this sort of ability with another powerful one, and we need to be pretty careful with that. I'll acknowledge that adding something feels warranted given our goals here.

One last thing I'll say is, we've created a mon with a bit of an achilles heel, which is that non-grass tera negates our ability fully. A secondary ability eliminates that weakness entirely and we're free to use non-grass teras freely (which, as an aside, rubs me the wrong way a bit. In principle I'd rather maintain the minor pitfall). I can see a world where offensive sets get a lot of value out of something like tera ground to achieve certain damage thresholds– Life Orb Earth Power vs. Glowking might be one such example– which could make a secondary ability worth considering even if its primary value tilts toward defensive sets. Obviously Flower Veil is a massive boon for offensive sets and this may be nothing, but I'm mentioning it as another reason we should be careful with our secondary.
 
Last edited:
Don’t have too much to say here beyond my agreement with vile that we haven’t yet ensured a defensive set and with Rysachi that a secondary ability is warranted as a result. The opportunity cost of not running offensive sets on this thing seems too high right now and we should focus on carving out a distinct niche or simply bringing more value to a team with a bulky set, which I don’t believe we’ve accomplished with only our moves so far. Think we need to tread pretty carefully, my instinct is that vile’s right about not being too far off, but it definitely feels like we’re missing one last piece of the puzzle for bulky sets to be plausibly justifiable over offensive ones.
 
Guingil said:
Does our current kit, without a Secondary Ability, ensure a viable defensive set that competes decently with our offensive sets for usage?
I agree with the above posters that the current kit, without a secondary ability, does not currently do enough to facilitate a defensive set that competes with offensive ones. CAP 38 currently has an amalgation of solid traits that fail to coalesce into an appealing package. While these traits are individually nice in a vacuum, they don't seem to do enough to justify running a defensive set. The defensive set doesn't need to directly compete with the offensive set for a spot on most structures, but it does need to justify itself and it is hard to do that when it seems to struggle with a large swatch of the metagame - something that is further amplified when looking at meta relevant teams.

This stems from the poor offensive synergy of its STABs that will leave defensive CAP 38 walled by a lot regardless of what moves it runs. This isn't an issue so long as those holes are reasonably covered by teammates and it seems that there are too many at the moment to achieve that. When I look at the Pokémon that serve as roadblocks to CAP 38 I see two distinct categories:

a) Pokémon that shut down CAP 38 via typing
b) Pokémon that shut down CAP 38 via ability

The secondary ability should address one of those pain points. Even if CAP 38 gets a strong secondary defensive sets will still have ample counterplay, but it would recduce that to a more managable level.
 
Here’s my take on the matter: Secondary ability is fine, as long as it retains our major pitfalls. Some notable pitfalls: Loss of effective type-change Tera, lack of hard-to-predict immunities and no offensive benefit from ability. As long as these hold true, I could see a secondary benefitting us without breaking the Mon.
 
Okay, 24 hours have passed, and I believe we have managed to get enough discussion to move forward.

The defensive set suffers from competition with our offensive set, thus incurring a huge opportunity cost for use, while also facing competition with other defensive Pokemon in the tier. There's no two ways about it: a Secondary Ability is needed to boost it up to a level of viability. We have to be careful here that our Secondary Ability does not inadvertently end up benefiting the offensive set or result in guessing games with Flower Veil, so I will ask that these considerations be taken into account for submission.

So, without further ado, Secondary Ability submissions are open!

But given that we are pulled in a few directions here, I will ask that you post your ability submissions in the following format:



Secondary Ability Submission:

Q1: How does this ability help the defensive set reach viability?
Talk about the set, how it functions in the meta, how defensive 38 carves out a niche--all that good stuff. Does our Secondary Ability provide general usefulness? Or does it target a few dangerous Pokemon in the tier that teams or 38 itself would otherwise struggle against? What are our advantages over competing Pokemon for that role? Feel free to use the template to illustrate your arguments:
CAP38 Secondary Set Template
Name:
Move 1:
Move 2:
Move 3:
Move 4:
Ability:
Item:
EVs:
Nature:

Q2: What are the concerns regarding the ability also being useful for the offensive set and/or leading to guessing games?
Please go over possible benefits that might be useful for the offensive set as well (for example, a defense-boosting ability letting the offensive set come in easier). Does it also lead to unhealthy guessing games? Does it interact with our Achilles' heel of being unable to Terastallize?



Another reminder that arguments need to be almost purely from a viability perspective to be taken into consideration. The existence of the defensive set is the highest priority for Eternatus-like vibes; we do not have room for anything that still argues for vibes at the cost of viability. And No Competitive Ability (NCA) is no longer an option.

I'll leave this open for ~72 hours, with a 24-hour warning before the end, along with a preliminary slate. Please check if the ability is legal for submission from the list in the OP before submitting!

With all that, happy ability-ing, CAPpers!
 
hi i havent posted about cap 38 competitively in the past like 2 months okay hear me out (or don't because of the ability i'm about to suggest)

Soundproof

Q1: How does this ability help the defensive set reach viability?
Soundproof I feel is more in-tune with the kind of impact Pressure had on Eternatus. It's not a particularly high-impact ability but it does provide extra defensive value to the move Substitute as Substitute's main weakness is Sound-based moves. In the most relevant example, it blocks Psychic Noise which is a total counter to CAP38 in terms of its capability to heal with Recover and dealing Super Effective damage, which can help tremendously several key match-ups. Other important moves that it blocks is Roar to phaze and get rid of CAP38, as well as Parting Shot which is used to gain momentum with Pokemon such as Pecharunt (It is important to note that Flower Veil provides this utility as well). In some more specific scenarios, it blocks Clanging Scales from Chuggalong and Boomburst from Chromera. Relatively low-impact but does help in a number of situations that CAP38 would appreciate.

A set that I would envision with Soundproof:
Name: CAP38
Move 1: Sludge Bomb/Giga Drain
Move 2: Mystical Fire/Earth Power
Move 3: Leech Seed/Toxic
Move 4: Substitute/Recover
Ability: Soundproof
Item: Leftovers
EVs: 48 HP / 252 SpD / 208 SPE
Nature: Timid

(i didn't think too hard on the evs lmao don't worry about it this does outspeed Timid Darkrai which is the important part)

Q2: What are the concerns regarding the ability also being useful for the offensive set and/or leading to guessing games?
The only possible offensive benefit is as a counter measure against Roar in consideration of a Power Herb Meteor Beam Set. I guess there are more possible entries for 38 to come in with Soundproof but for the most part Flower Veil is strictly 1000% better for offensive sets because of Paralysis immunity.
 
Last edited:
I dont wanna submit a specific one just yet, just talk about them.
I think that on-hit abilities are pretty fitting for a defensive set without overlapping an offensive set too much. The meteor beam set isnt looking to trade too many hits and will benefit from 3 atks meteor beam probably more than recover, and also doesnt wanna get paralyzed. Though some of these would probably work well with 3 atks recover offensive, I think pretty much any defensive ability is going to potentially see use on that set, which is a midground between offense and defense.
Anyways, with that in mind I think that Rough Skin, Cotton Down, and Lingering Aroma have a strong case.

Rough Skin works very nicely with Leech Seed- mons like Equilibra that might easily beat us with rapid spin and regular atks with a SludgeBomb/EP/Leech/Recover set now have to take a million percent by touching us with Rocky Helmet, and that allows us to be much more annoying with this combination. Teams always benefit from having a Rocky Helmet guy too, and it kinda feels aligned with filling that "slot". I mean rough skin is just an amazing ability in general, this probably isnt a hot take

Cotton Down says hey- that booster guy you're saving for a last mon sweep? They just wont anymore, and theres nothing you can do about it (which is decently strong) and lets you go fully invested in defenses trading hits with offensive mons because you'll outspeed in the future. Anything hoping to 2hko you on the switch has to be willing to take a big hit, which weakens the threat of things like Great Tusk with Headlong Rush fairly well, and you won't be as bothered by things (aside from Dragapult) hitting you and then going for a uturn after, like Ogerpon. Mons like Zama and Valiant become a ton easier to handle when they're slower than you, either by your own doing or by the team's. You can pair with eject button also to become a high value pivot that can suicide-neutralize 2 mons each battle consistently.

Lingering Aroma is a strong(?) ability that punishes things like Gliscor, Snael, Alomomola and even Libra when they hit you with a contact move. I think these are some key problematic mons and allows you to be a bit of a stallbreaker that can even force the contact moves with Libra/Snael paired with Leech Seed, encouraging a spin. Im liking the idea of making Leech Seed a more oppressive move against its usual answers.

edit: Intimidate is also pretty obviously great, and I don't think its as fitting for the meteor beam set as you might think. since it doesnt grant any benefit from switchins coming in to neutralize you after meteor beam, all it does is offer more bulk on setup, but flower veil also offers a ton of free matchups to boost on and also removes a bunch of counterplay switchins, so it probably would not be on that set. however, it would be very powerful on an offensive 3 atks LO recover type thing. definitely worth considering though because this would easily allow this mon to wall ground types and set back mons like dragonite that dont appreciate that extra turn getting sludge bombed and potentially poisoned, can convert a very shaky check into a more solid one.
 
Last edited:
Mold Breaker

Q1: Main draw of this ability is enabling a set of knock/sludge bomb/scorching sands, allowing us to drop fire coverage and run a much more potent 3-move combo. Mold breaker also does some neat stuff like removing shox’s item and being able to status garg with our attacks. However, the ability to fully leverage our typing’s defensive profile by running a bulky set and still be a formidable progress maker gives defensive sets a more plausible use case. Simply put the goal with this ability is to raise the value floor of bulky sets.

Q2: I won’t deny that mold breaker has some situational applications for offensive sets too; bypassing unaware, multiscale, and levitate isn’t insignificant, and it would open up avenues for non-grass teras (most likely ground). However, there is still a significant opportunity cost to dropping flower veil, and something very important to note is that this ability announces itself immediately. We know what we’re dealing with as soon as 38 hits the field. While MB does improve certain matchups like libra, it doesn’t really hard-flip any key checks or counters in the same way that, say, an immunity ability would, and makes us vulnerable to new forms of counterplay like paralysis as a tradeoff.

Overall this ability does some small but useful stuff and avoids guessing-game headaches that other comparable secondaries introduce. I think it’s certainly a step in the right direction, although whether it’s far enough of a step is hard to say.

Shield Dust

Q1: This is for garg. Most balance / fat teams need salt cure counterplay. Being able to compress woger check + garg check + soft speed control + bulky poison is a real reason to get thrown on a team.

Q2: Of course the question is whether we’d just run offensive investment with shield dust and still check the important boxes. I’m leaning towards no, because ogerpon is strong as hell, and bulk is also nice for dealing with other pokemon that your bulky poison usually wants to beat like zama, but this is just my personal intuition. I don’t think offensive sets are super keen on ever giving up flower veil anyways.

This ability is very low-impact, and to contrast it with mold breaker, does not intend to raise our value floor but instead locks in a key matchup that gives us a unique defensive niche compared to other bulky poisons in the tier.
 
I'm not submitting anything since I'm still quite new to the CAP meta, but I do want to float some ideas out there for the sake of it. Admittedly I do come from a place where thematics hold a strong skew in what I select, but I'll try my best to ensure they strike that ever-so important balance between being viable defensively and not COMPLETELY outclassing Flower Veil.

Dry Skin interests me due to the polarity it introduces- you transform your fearlessness of Water-Types into a downright craving for their generous heals, and it also grants you a Grass-Type that prefers the Rain to the Sun (and I've heard Rain could use some more love in CAP). Of course, on the other end you've resigned yourself into becoming Ramnarok's favorite vegetarian special with Mollux eating the scraps. It pivots far from the blanket "positives" of Flower Veil and deeply ingrains you (hehe) into a more concrete role.

Wandering Spirit is a guilty pleasure of mine that I'm going to throw out here as the evil Bizarro version of Lingering Aroma. What you sacrifice from the safety of a blanket Ability nullification, you gain in stealing some downright diabolical Abilities that can open up multiple avenues for longevity and might. Bam, Unaware from a switch-in on Arghonaut to set yourself up for either a quick Giga Drain kill and preemptively sabotage setup sweeps from the chumps in the back. If you're insane, you can miraculously intercept a First Impression from Lokix for TINTED LENS. Mold Breaker from Cucibelle, Galvanize from Caribolt, Heatproof from Naviathan. The amount of chaos this Ability provides feels apt as a parallel to Flower Veil's stability, the highs shoot FAR higher but boy do you have to work for them.

Magician is here for simple reasons- I think Knock Off is lame and way too safe of a Move, and Magician fresh after a Power Herb-charged Meteor Beam accomplishes the progress of snagging your foe's precious Item in a way that feels more dynamic.

Seed Sower is probably my favorite choice for a secondary, and it's for most of the reasons that were stated prior in the initial discussions. Grass STAB boosts are cool, sure, but the Earthquake nerfs and universal healing are what stand out the most to me here. You WANT to be tanky to fully capitalize on this one, and you even become willing to throw yourself into a dangerous field just for that juicy Terrain activation. Even after getting KO'd your valiant sacrifice can still bear fruit, and that feels pretty Legendary-coded to me. It's a team player's Ability, as opposed to the self-centered luxuries offered by Flower Veil. Mollux and Crucibelle would especially like this one, I think!
 
Last edited:
Coming in to back up Mold Breaker. While it does free our Tera from its grass-type prison, it announces itself THE MOMENT it hits the field, which knocks anti-guesswork out of the park. Losing complete status immunity, I think, is a bigger nerf than the offensive applications can make up for on offensive sets, as all of a sudden :cresceidon: is not completely walled by 38 and can pull some actual shenanigans to slow it down as it so likes to do (+ Tera Ground opens up some actual super effective attacks for it). Overall, I think it’s the most inoffensive ability submitted that still actually does something defensively (see: Spoo’s post on the matter).
 
Seconding Shield Dust, it seems to have a clear use case specifically for defensive sets, and some very niche applications beyond Garg. It doesn’t do a whole lot but competing with flower veil on a defensive set without overshadowing it is extremely difficult, and Shield Dust keeps some of your benefits from Flower Veil, the Garg interaction could be significant enough to give it the edge.

Mold Breaker feels strange and unconvincing to me. The whole idea behind it is enabling one set, whose advantage is just compression to enable knock off. I guess that’s the right idea, but it just doesn’t seem to me to have such a big advantage and such a broad application over more obvious sets like grass ground knock or poison fire knock or even grass poison knock.
And if a secondary ability really is needed for CAP38 to reach viability (which I disagree with but this discussion is happening under that assumption), then we are saying that this one specific set is what we are making viable.

It’s supposed to improve your knock by hitting shox, but a far more common knock absorber in Gliscor is now a completely free switch ins compared to a set wielding a grass move. Its supposed to help you hit garg more significantly, but the reason you’re clicking sludge bomb into it in the first place is because you didn’t slot a grass move.

I also agree the offensive applications are small, maybe it can enable compression for meteor beam sets as well? There is not a ton to worry about with regard to question 2, at least that’s my current view.
 
Hi all, dropping in to say hi, how are you, and how has your day been, stay safe out there, but also, perhaps less importantly, to announce the 24-hour warning for Secondary Ability submissions!

Some of the discussed abilities have neat ways to try to ensure a defensive set while not impacting offensive sets too much. Reminder: for an ability to be considered for the slate, it needs to be in the format I've put for answering the two questions. Without further ado,

Initial Slate:
Mold Breaker
Shield Dust


Both of these have received support and lead to a specific niche for the defensive set to fill, and were thus obvious choices.

Not Submitted Yet:
Contact-punishing abilities


Soundproof has some applications, but I can't envision the set proposed for it really taking off. Dry Skin is illegal and Magician perhaps works best with the Meteor Beam set. Among the other unsubmitted ones, I'd like to hear a little more about Seed Sower, as, in my opinion, it benefits LO sets quite significantly by reducing recoil and powering up our Grass STAB.
 
Going to submit Static as my main choice for the secondary ability although I'm in full support for Mold Breaker for the reasons that have already been talked about prior.
Guingil said:
Q1: How does this ability help the defensive set reach viability?
The main key factors we want to achieve from this secondary ability is that we want something that can differentiate defensive sets from offensive ones and the fact that we want both abilities to remain low impact. I believe Static has low impact in the fact that we still have very prominent counters in :Slowking-Galar: and :Blissey: , which we previously stated during both primary ability and movepool that it is healthy to have these clear checks to CAP 38 without attempting to move the needle to find ways around beating or making it awkward for them to beat 38. What it does for us is push some matchups for us to become more favourable the more time they spend around 38 without attempting to outright remove it. Some meta relevant examples of this being :Zamazenta: , :Corviknight: , :Alomomola:, :Samurott-Hisui: and :Ogerpon-Wellspring: where we can punish resisted hits or pivot from all of these examples with a chance in especially :Zamazenta: and :Ogerpon-Wellspring: to be a far less effective end game sweeper/cleaner if it can be easier to outspeed.
Guingil said:
Q2: What are the concerns regarding the ability also being useful for the offensive set and/or leading to guessing games?
As mentionted in the first statement, there is a trade-off compared to our primary ability Flower Veil which as mentioned by both Spoo and IGotEaten, is the way 38 retains the immunity to status which is extremely relevant as a prime way to be an absolute counter to :Cresceidon: with Thunder Wave specifically and also a way to offensively keep :Stratagem: in check by being able to outspeed and threaten a kill without any risk of 38's speed being lowered to become slower.

As for predicting which set 38 would be running between Offensive Flower Veil and Defensive, it would be slightly harder to differentiate compared to the likes of Mold Breaker due to lack of immediate recognition of an ability trigger. I'd argue the fact we aren't trying to change our MUs against reliable counters and the notaciable damage difference between Max SpAtk and 0SpAtk sets being immediately recognisable once we see the damage on said counters should make it less concerning for us.

Quick example of damage calcs, whilst there is marginal overlap between min/max damage rolls between them both, in the majority of cases it will be a noticeable differentiating point:
252 SpA Venusaur-Mega Sludge Bomb vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Slowking-Galar: 49-58 (12.4 - 14.7%) -- possible 7HKO
0 SpA Venusaur-Mega Sludge Bomb vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Slowking-Galar: 40-48 (10.1 - 12.1%) -- possible 9HKO

The final point regarding Terastallization for CAP 38 and the idea around the locking of Tera Grass to keep Flower Veil intact compared to tera flexibility the secondary ability can provide 38 with previously mentionted Tera Ground in mind, whilst it'll be hard to argue against this point with, I don't necessarily think having tera flexibility on defensive variations will prove to be too problematic as we would still lack the damage output and limited setup boost with Meteor Beam which offensive 38 sets can abuse. There is also an argument to be made that offensive 38 variations can also use Tera to boost coverage and forgo Flower Veil especially for the likes of Tera Ground to keep paralysis immunity which both cases of Tera Ground would still allow us to be vulnerable to the likes of :Cresceidon: which we originally wanted 38 to be a direct counter to ontop of having a negative MU against other 38's that haven't used Tera by gaining weakness to Grass which would potentially see usage especially Giga Drain on more defensive spreads or 3A Meteor Beam sets, making Tera timing on 38 quite vital.

Quick Edit: I've changed my submission from Effect Spore to Static. It reached a consensus that people would rather have it be a more consistent chance of a specific status rather than the element of randomness you get from Effect Spore ontop of not being able to punish grass types that are immune such as :Ogerpon-Wellspring: . I'm fully in the opinion that Poison Point is far too weak of an option if we are trying to catch hit and run style Pokémon whereas Flame Body could be considered the opposite where it could make the defensive profile of 38 too strong and therefore I decided to go with the middle ground and arguably the most desirable status from Effect Spore.
 
Last edited:
Iron Barbs/Rough Skin
Guingil said:
Q1: How does this ability help the defensive set reach viability?
This is a very similar ability to effect spore that imo does a lot of things better. The biggest thing to keep in mind is that we are an incredible switch-in for physical grass types, such as :caribolt:, :ogerpon-wellspring:, and :rillaboom:, which are immune to effect spore. Additionally, it can activate against foes poisoned by sludge bomb or burned by scorching sands. The 100% activation chance makes the ability more reliable, and the inability to put foes to sleep is significantly healthier for the metagame.
Guingil said:
Q2: What are the concerns regarding the ability also being useful for the offensive set and/or leading to guessing games?
Activating 100% of the time makes the ability reveal more quickly than effect spore. The ability gets value as a function of survivability, and flower veil is a very powerful ability, so its unlikely that this sees value on offensive unless the CAP is on a team where it plans to tera T1 often. This should be of fairly low concern.

Sticky Hold
Guingil said:
Q1: How does this ability help the defensive set reach viability?
It worked for :shox:, it'll work for us too. :Ogerpon-Wellspring: is one of our best switch-ins, and sticky hold helps distinguish ourselves from :mollux: and other wellspring checks by being a knock-off absorber. The current knock absorbers in the cap metagame are :clefable:, :gliscor:, :snaelstrom:, and :shox:, none of which have defensive profiles very similar to ours. This should give us a unique defensive position in the cap metagame.
Guingil said:
Q2: What are the concerns regarding the ability also being useful for the offensive set and/or leading to guessing games?
This ability is complete buns on meteor beam, which wants to be pivoted in and consumes its item anyways. Similarly, life orb isn't getting more value from sticky hold than full para immunity. The biggest concern I can see is offensive boots potentially becoming viable. Still, I think knock off would be near undroppable on such a set so its hard to say if offensive investment would be worth it.
 
Last edited:
I think I agree that iron barbs is better than effect spore as an on-hit.

sticky hold is pretty interesting for teams with hdb spam because we've never really had something so fast that can be part of hdb spam (i think?). i dont fully love it cus i think that knock offers will find their way through this mon faster than some of its peers though.

seed sower is also interesting because if you can appreciate shield dust for beating garg, seed sower + leftovers also completely nullifies salt cure and makes garg feel useless.. It definitely aligns very well with a Life Orb set, but I dont think thats necessarily a bad thing- Life Orb is considerably more of a luxury set right now than Meteor Beam, and its one of the sets we asked to have earlier. And I do think I might use Seed Sower on a defensive set since it makes it safe into EQs and becomes a "proper grass type", as well as of course the healing that you can take advantage of with this mon and also your whole team. So it could be an all-round win, but I am a bit put off by Life Orb Seed Sower Leaf Storms- its extremely powerful, and maybe we could look into removing this option since there's precedent for fully evolved grass types to not have it (Whimsicott?). I would understand though if someone said that with our current chassis, Seed Sower is too much and is encroaching on the primary ability.

Mold breaker is cool n all but yeah I think it focuses mostly on being able to get through Unaware/Multiscale a bit easier with offensive sets, the Knock EP set is respectable but its definitely a much weaker level of defensive set. Is it way worse for defensive than Shield Dust or Sticky Hold? Not in power level perhaps, but it doesn't really attempt to create a new "purpose" like those abilities.
 
Last edited:
I really want to submit Neutralizing Gas again but it might be too good for offensive, sadly.

Here's the Corrosion sub. I'm not super invested in it, but I saw some people mention it on Discord so I figured it was worth submitting.

Name: Corrosion
Move 1: Toxic
Move 2: Recover
Move 3: Giga Drain / Energy Ball
Move 4: Earth Power
Ability: Corrosion
Item: Leftovers / Heavy-duty Boots
EVs: 252 Def / 136 SpA / 32 SpD / 88 Spe
Nature: Timid

Guingil said:
Q1: How does this ability help the defensive set reach viability?
Toxic incentivizing defensive builds is something that probably doesn't need explaining. Corrosion boosts Toxic's consistency in the metagame, allowing it to hit Pokemon like Slowking-G and Equilibra, as well as potential Tera Steel / Poison Pokemon, instantly creating a niche. The big MUs this swings are Equilibra and Tera Poison / Steel Cresselia, which is now forced to run Lunar Blessing to not die to Toxic. Toxic on this set also shores up matchups the 2A do not cover well (Flying and Grass-types); Corrosion notably adds Corviknight and Venomicon to the list of Toxic targets.

Guingil said:
Q2: What are the concerns regarding the ability also being useful for the offensive set and/or leading to guessing games?
An interesting dynamic is that most Knock Off absorbers are also Toxic absorbers. Thus, if you know CAP38 is defensive, the counterplay is not too different for various sets, so I don't think this part is a concern (at least for balance teams; HO might be owned). The main guesswork is discerning between offensive and defensive, though team composition should give clues, and I don't think this is fundamentally unhealthy. Defensive probably reveals itself by switching in to an attack anyways.

I have no idea what a good EV spread would looks like, so I just put enough SpD to not be 2HKO'd by Libra, Spe for Ogerpon, 252 Def, and rest in SpA.

EDIT: I forgot to mention, but I don't really think offensive will want Corrosion + Toxic? It doesn't really open up any untouchable MUs for offensive (Corv and Libra take a decent amount from MFire, Venomicon from Meteor Beam, Slowking-G from EP, etc.) but feels a lot better to click on sets without offensive investment. Additionally, Toxic gains a lot of value from CAP38 being able to Recover-stall afterwards, which encourages bulk investment.
 
Last edited:
:poison: Corrosion :poison:​
Name: Corrosion
Move 1: Recover
Move 2: Toxic
Move 3: STAB Move
Move 4: Steel Coverage / Knock Off / STAB Move 2
Ability: Flower Veil
Item: half a dozen
EVs: 180 Def / 32 SpA / 48 SpD / 248 Spe or 180 Def / 32 SpA / 88 SpD / 208 Spe or 180 Def / 32 SpA / 132 SpD / 176 Spe
Nature: Timid

Guingil said:
Q1: How does this ability help the defensive set reach viability?
There are a fair few Pokémon that will sit on defensive CAP 38 sets in perpetuity with even more depending on what movesets it runs. Although powerful, Corrosion narrows that list considerably in a manner that is far more honest than it would initially appear. There are still a lot of Pokémon that don't care, functionally immune, or can manage being Toxiced reasonably well. For example, Slowking-Galar obviously doesn't love being Toxiced, but it is still able to function and execute its game plan, just not indefinitely.

There still are a lot of defensive Pokémon that just don't really care about Corrosion Toxic and it will be impossible for CAP 38 to handle them all in the same set even if CAP 38 has the means to threaten them naturally. For example, defensive CAP 38 cannot beat all of Clefable, Garganacl, and Gholdengo in the same set and that is ignoring Pokémon such as SD Gliscor that can use it as setup fodder. 4MSS limits Corrosion in an impactful way that (hopefully) makes it reasonable to guess the coverage based on teammates. While Corrosion CAP 38 sets cumulatively will threaten a lot, it will miss out on a lot of important targets no matter what it does.

Corrosion substantially raises the floor while coming with the hefty cause of paralysis vulnerability. Regardless of what the secondary ability is, if defensive CAP 38 sets are good, part of that value will stem from being a defensive Pokémon that outspeeds midrange and even some speedy breakers and having to scout or risk getting crippled changes how it is played.

Guingil said:
Q2: What are the concerns regarding the ability also being useful for the offensive set and/or leading to guessing games?
This is interesting with Corrosion because it doesn't really have an impact on the sets that have received the most attention (LO / Beam). Sure LO would benefit somewhat, but the opportunity cost is massive. Corrosion does have a potential positive impact on offensive sets, but that it letting Choice sets potentially be real. STABs + Earth Power + Toxic could potentially make a potent Choice Specs or Choice Scarf set as CAP 38 would now have a somewhat safe click. I don't see that as an issue as I don't think those are likely to compete with defensive sets anyways. Admittedly, I can see a world where guessing games are a minor issue, but don't think they would end up being a problematic one - especially once things settle. I was actually going to submit Neutralizing Gas as they're two sides of the same coin, but it announces itself.

I don't have the time to submit that, but tl;dr impacts most of the Pokémon Corrosion while having an interesting relationship into the Regenerator Pokémon. Corrosion spotlights Toxic and gives room for Knock Off while Neutralizing Gas spotlights Knock Off while giving room for Toxic.
 
Mold Breaker: Bit unclear to me how weighted toward fat sets it is and if it's doing enough for such sets, but the moveset compression is real and it self reveals so it's fine here.
Shield Dust: Not convinced this sees any use. Its main use case is for switching in more consistently on a mon that we already force out easily. It is quite nice tanking salt cures all day but is it better than full status and stat drop immunity?
Sticky Hold: Borderline for me. We all know the value of this ability and it's definitely weighted toward defensive sets. Some knock users are bad matchups for us and some are good. Arguably does enough?
Iron Barbs: It's fine. Contact punishing wouldn't have been foremost on my list for this but it does stuff. I prefer this over things like Static/Flame Body since those are unlikely to reveal until the moment they activate, and the activation can be really dire for the opponent. The Leech synergy is interesting, but I'm not personally sure if it makes Leech real. I hope so!
Corrosion: It gets used and it's hella pro-concept. Given that several of the other options feel kind of paltry I'm coming around on this a little bit. That said, it's very high-powered and I do think offensive sets might consider it sometimes for moveset compression reasons, to ease prediction, etc. Also the idea of making a grass/poison and then giving it all of ground coverage, fire coverage, and Corrosion for us to mix and match as we please (on top of things like full status immunity), feels very much in the vein of "eliminate all potential weaknesses" which we have arguably gone too far with at times in the past. Just stuff to think about. It's alright.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top