• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

All Gens Reforming How We Advertise Spotlight Voting

unira said:
Just to be perfectly clear, I was the one who broke this rule and I was fully aware of it. I did it because a competing tier had taken the lead with discord advertising, and in a moment of selfish foolishness I was pretty sure I could get away with it. That decision by just one person ruined the opportunity for the whole playerbase; getting away with it was just a matter of whether mods were actively policing at the time. Many people have already pointed out problems with the rule despite this being a deliberate rule break, like the responsibility of moderators to police several community spaces, how easily rule breakers can circumvent this, how unfair it is to the rule abiding players, and how easy it is for unknowing players to break it. I agree with these criticisms and I'd support changes to the rule as well. But it wasn't a mistake just to be clear and I take full responsibility for that. Sincerest apologies to the ADV RU playerbase.
Its pokemon, its not that deep
 
Last edited:
perejil said:
We keep getting older, perhaps try this one, instead of a monthly ladder, give a day of the week to each gen 1-5. You can add the others if youd like, but the retro gens are the 2d ones. By holding it every 5 days you also make it so that every gen will have every day of the week in given time.
I feel like changing ladders every 5 days is way too short. For context, most spotlight ladders give players 5 days to vote on the next ladder, so spending 5 (or even 3) days for a 5 day ladder seems like a huge overexertion and a lot of effort for very little reward. I am fine with 2 week ladders because that at least is a solid amount of time to give players experience the ladder, but any shorter seems like players get too little opportunity to play the tier.

I would also like to set a deadline by the 20th of November for any final changes to the new system. As a reminder, this is my current solution:
Tbolt said:
Based on what I have read so far in this thread, I will shift my current preferred solution to:
  • Eliminating the generation vote and having it rotate around similar to the Ubers/UU ladder. I will probably give it a 4 generation offset (so if the Ubers/UU ladder is for BW, then the Community Choice ladder would be for RBY).
  • Keeping the generation cooldown at 6 months. This ensures that large, popular, multi-generation formats get an extended cooldown while smaller, one-generation formats effectively only get a one-generation cooldown.
  • Removing the advertising restrictions as I initially wanted.
 
Last edited:
Tbolt said:
I feel like changing ladders every 5 days is way too short. For context, most spotlight ladders give players 5 days to vote on the next ladder, so spending 5 (or even 3) days for a 5 day ladder seems like a huge overexertion and a lot of effort for very little reward. I am fine with 2 week ladders because that at least is a solid amount of time to give players experience the ladder, but any shorter seems like players get too little opportunity to play the tier.

I would also like to set a deadline by the 20th of November for any final changes to the new system. As a reminder, this is my current solution:
Tbolt, what I meant was,

Mondays you have RBY tiers
Tuesdays you have GSC tiers
Wednesdays you have RSE tiers
Thursdays you have DPP tiers
Fridays you have BW tiers
Saturdays you have RBY tiers,

as such they keep rotating, since theyre less than 7. Im not sure how to handle gen 6 and 7 and 8, I dont much care for them.

But itd be cool if you knew, hey this monday we can play RBY UUBL. Keeps it rotating.
 
I mean this just sounds horrible all around to be honest. Issues of PS staff needing to change the ladders every day aside, only having a format be ladderable for exactly one day gives people no real time to actually engage with the formats while also just being a bit of a middle finger to anyone who simply can't hop on to play the One Day their tier has a ladder active. This also seems like it would just kill spotlight tours unless you separate them from the ladders which just seems counterintuitive at that point.
 
igiveuponaname said:
I mean this just sounds horrible all around to be honest. Issues of PS staff needing to change the ladders every day aside, only having a format be ladderable for exactly one day gives people no real time to actually engage with the formats while also just being a bit of a middle finger to anyone who simply can't hop on to play the One Day their tier has a ladder active. This also seems like it would just kill spotlight tours unless you separate them from the ladders which just seems counterintuitive at that point.
If you miss it just play it the next week. Bit easier than waiting until next year for the next chance to run your RU team.

I dont particularly care about tours currently, theyre a thing of the past.
 
perejil said:
If you miss it just play it the next week. Bit easier than waiting until next year for the next chance to run your RU team.
I feel like the point of spotlight ladders is that they spotlight the metagame in question. I don't really think that forcing these metagames to share a spotlight is going to really help anyone involved. Spotlights are helpful for these metagames because they allow for opportunities for these communities to potentially grow and welcome in new players who are interested in these metagames. Having a ladder that's only available on a certain day (good luck showdown devs) will only reduce the potential audience these metagames can attract, not to mention that the odds these players are retained from week to week are also not super high.

The reasons why these metagames and communities are considered much more "niche" are not associated with them coming off as uninteresting; heck, I've seen many players in my time have genuine interest of the BDSP metagame, and most players with whom I have interacted with that have played BDSP OU, whether through tours, roomtours, or the spotlight ladder itself, would say they've had a positive experience with it. So why would this metagame, which most people who have played recently would probably agree with the statement that it is at least a "decent" metagame, be much more niche than much more controversial tiers that manage to stay mainstream? It is because those tiers have a consistent ladder, so those tiers will be able to retain players, which in turn helps those metagames develop. Niche communities love it when new players come because of this. I know, from experience being in one, that some of our more notable developments have come from players who don't necessarily main the tier. Not to mention that playing the same players can also be repetitive no matter how much you enjoy playing one given player. Most players on Showdown don't even know that these non-ladder tiers are even playable on showdown.

That's my reasoning for why I think having the spotlight ladder still lasting for a month is still the most viable option. Does it tend to overstay its welcome? Sure. But I think for these types of tiers, especially if they are going to be available once a year, you would much rather have a tier overstay its welcome than have them feel as though their stay was cut short. The community will play their games regardless of whether or not there is a ladder; the ladder is for the new players that the community wishes to attract.
 
Last edited:
I won't even begin to point out the absurdity of one day ladders as igiveuponaname has done this well enough.

I'm pretty happy with Tb0lt's current suggestion but I also want to add:

Skitty (Skittyrox) said:
That's my reasoning for why I think having the spotlight ladder still lasting for a month is still the most viable option. Does it tend to overstay its welcome? Sure. But I think for these types of tiers, especially if they are going to be available once a year, you would much rather have a tier overstay its welcome than have them feel as though their stay was cut short. The community will play their games regardless of whether or not there is a ladder; the ladder is for the new players that the community wishes to attract.
I agree with all of this. Better to have a format stick around for an entire month and give it the maximum amount of possible eyes on it, than to rush spotlight ladders to exist every 2 weeks.

The goal of having an actual featured metagame every month is to try and give it the maximum amount of opportunity. Having a spotlight win out means we normally run one(or two) roomtours for it a day, there's an on demand ladder(which I admit can vary in terms of activity based on time of day + overall player interest), and you have a spotlight round robin tour which basically means you're getting 4 bo3 sets for fun(assuming someone doesn't drop out or no show).

If we switch to super accelerated ladders just for the sake of "fairness," we aren't actually accomplishing anything beyond dangling a format in front of a playerbase's face before taking it away. And frankly, as skitty said, the mains will continue to think about their format whether or not a tier is ladderable. The goal is really to try and appeal to more casual-minded players who might just get hooked and become a fresh new talent for said community. We stand to gain more from having 4 week ladders on that end.

The only "fairness" that should be considered is how long of a cooldown a format has such that other communities have their chance to win out on a ladder, and that's covered in the current proposal. So I personally don't have any complaints, but if I do think of something I'll either edit this or create a separate post.

The last thing I will add: you can always ask RoA staff for tours in the room for the formats you're interested in, even if they aren't spotlight formats! Asking for friendlies or a roomtour is always encouraged, even if staff may not always be available or interested in doing the latter. It's what the room is here for.
 
Perhaps the tier cooldown could be variable based off number of games played.
If one ladder gets 400 games played and another gets 1400, there might be certain checkpoints that add month(s) to cooldown. That way the bigger ones are still kept at bay while the smaller active ones can get a fighting chance more often. I feel as though figuring it with a month delay would be easy, but perhaps keeping track would be tedious (I could volunteer to upkeep if that's the concern).
Could alternatively be adjusted based on number of votes. If one tier gets half the total vote that month, it would have a longer cooldown than one that won with only 30 percent.
Or a combo of the two. If a tier gets tons of the vote but nobody plays, the cooldown could be adjusted there, or vice versa, to prevent like... "Fictional interest?" Or an underground tier that people actually really enjoyed playing getting another round in
 
Erfder said:
Perhaps the tier cooldown could be variable based off number of games played.
If one ladder gets 400 games played and another gets 1400, there might be certain checkpoints that add month(s) to cooldown. That way the bigger ones are still kept at bay while the smaller active ones can get a fighting chance more often. I feel as though figuring it with a month delay would be easy, but perhaps keeping track would be tedious (I could volunteer to upkeep if that's the concern).
Could alternatively be adjusted based on number of votes. If one tier gets half the total vote that month, it would have a longer cooldown than one that won with only 30 percent.
Or a combo of the two. If a tier gets tons of the vote but nobody plays, the cooldown could be adjusted there, or vice versa, to prevent like... "Fictional interest?" Or an underground tier that people actually really enjoyed playing getting another round in

Why kneecap ladders people want to play to prop up ones nobody is actually interested in playing? Just because a less popular tier has a ladder doesn't translate into people actually playing it, as seen by the absolutely abysmal turnout for GSC UUBL (of which I lowk enjoyed playing, but finding a game was nigh impossible). Tangential, but I think the staff pick's ladder needs to come back. Having a third option was so nice for months where neither ladder interested you, especially considering how, by its very nature, the rotational ladder may as well not exist for large swathes of the year for players of certain persuasions (old/new gen players; ubers mains; uu mains)
 
Erfder said:
Perhaps the tier cooldown could be variable based off number of games played.
If one ladder gets 400 games played and another gets 1400, there might be certain checkpoints that add month(s) to cooldown. That way the bigger ones are still kept at bay while the smaller active ones can get a fighting chance more often. I feel as though figuring it with a month delay would be easy, but perhaps keeping track would be tedious (I could volunteer to upkeep if that's the concern).
Could alternatively be adjusted based on number of votes. If one tier gets half the total vote that month, it would have a longer cooldown than one that won with only 30 percent.
Or a combo of the two. If a tier gets tons of the vote but nobody plays, the cooldown could be adjusted there, or vice versa, to prevent like... "Fictional interest?" Or an underground tier that people actually really enjoyed playing getting another round in
We are actually considering a form of what you wrote internally but we would have to scope out what it looks like to encourage fairness. No guarantees on how it plays out but I felt you should know your post did inspire some discussion among RoA staff.
jimmy the card said:
Why kneecap ladders people want to play to prop up ones nobody is actually interested in playing? Just because a less popular tier has a ladder doesn't translate into people actually playing it, as seen by the absolutely abysmal turnout for GSC UUBL (of which I lowk enjoyed playing, but finding a game was nigh impossible). Tangential, but I think the staff pick's ladder needs to come back. Having a third option was so nice for months where neither ladder interested you, especially considering how, by its very nature, the rotational ladder may as well not exist for large swathes of the year for players of certain persuasions (old/new gen players; ubers mains; uu mains)
It's worth peeling back the curtain a little bit to say we don't have control over the third ladder. Believe me, I wish we did, but I also understand why PS! staff wants to give a highlighted ladder to VGC every month given that it is the more popular "irl" form of mons.

If anything I would argue that the UU and Ubers communities are fairly privileged to have the rotationals that they do because there is almost always a ladder that suits to their sensibilities, and the only thing holding them back from having an oldgen they enjoy every month is simply due to the generation. (As someone who mostly sticks to gens 1-5 and 8 these days, 6-7 mean fairly little to me and I do get what you mean by this... Pun intended). They exist because their communities are just that much more overwhelmingly popular and they would end up winning most votes by default.

If we had control over the third ladder again or magically had a fourth, I'd push very hard for staff pick and try to make whatever format is picked that month offer some variety to the other two. Unfortunately we can only work with what we're given though. Just wanted to write this for transparency sake to say that if it were just me speaking as a community member, I agree a staff pick ladder would help complement the other two. It's just our hands are tied on that end.
 
Hopefully I'm not being redundant or a broken record as I type this, this discussion brings a lot of thoughts to my mind as the RoA ladders have immense value for me and are very fun to see, although I have also grown to appreciate the retro VGC ones sometimes.
Hope this long post is also noteworthy and decent enough to read, I'm a tad sleep deprived and don't have much longer to write this, I'll edit this later tomorrow if needed.

Long yap-to-rant about my experience as an avid spotlights player
I am unsure when I truly got dedicated to playing the spotlight ladders in Showdown,bBut have memories dating back to at least 2023. I'm primarily a GSC, ADV, DPP and BW lower tiers player; I specify as I am not quite as attached to the OU formats of GSC and DPP in particular. Regardless, I must mirror some thoughts regarding generation voting: how often has GSC ever won a generation vote? I am quite unsure myself and can't remember the last time this happened before this year. Regrettably, it is an unpopular gen through and through, and while I feel hyping just one specific gen's tier may be difficult, hyping up an entire generation is not, to which I feel a ban on advertising at least generations themselves is a bandaid fix that only truly affects the generations that would desperately need a fresh playerbase, while wholly ineffective at preventing gens that are already very popular from hogging ladders as soon as possible - not all generations have a big, popular youtuber ala Jim or Yellow who can hype them up with memes and elaborate educational videos.

May we consider how often RBY or ADV wins a generational vote, in return? It feels like we get at least one RBY ladder, intentionally or not, every other month or so. It got to the point I am confident I played pretty much every lower tier of this generation in ladder at least once, if not twice even for tiers which aren't UU/Ubers (which would be the easiest to get a ladder for, as those are not chosen by popular vote). It's as if the monthly gen voting has turned into an incredibly uneven tug-of-war that potentially puts players of each generation at odds with each other, a David vs. Goliath fight where I have to try and pray that RBY - a generation which is potentially carried not only by a massive, highly dedicated playerbase who will definitely be excited to vote for and play almost any lower tier ladder for it, but also potential new faces led by the newest funny RBY interaction video - doesn't win the trillionth ladder this year (PLEASE do not take this as a jab against RBY's community - as much as said ladders have helped me to decide I absolutely despise playing this generation 90% of the time, I deeply, deeply respect their dedication to even the lowest and least popular tiers).

Asking for tours and even random matches in the RoA room is not exactly the best solution and means a player needs to be particularly persistent; asking for matches with random players is a shot in the dark IMO, and about roomtours, it is not rare for them to have low single-digit player numbers entering, and notably, either case often pits one against a more skilled player with more experience, to which I feel goes against the purpose of Spotlights inviting newer faces who never played a certain tier (or even generation) and only really "feeds" the playerbase who already existed there.

In my honest opinion generation voting NEEDS to go, no questions asked; it is the minimum needed towards creating spotlight ladder voting equity. To quote directly from my long yap, while I feel hyping just one specific gen's tier may be difficult, hyping up an entire generation is not - I believe we can see certain generations have expressively larger playerbases by reason or the other, which means that with advertising or not, it is prone to be a steep hill for unpopular gens to win a vote against more popular ones.

The "automatic" Ubers/UU ladders themselves are interesting, but may not truly help retain players; I believe we can all agree Ubers is not the most balanced format in any generation and may not be a good entry point for certain generations to get the player counts they desire, just having an Ubers or UU ladder for a generation alongside said gen's OU may also not paint a great picture of how diverse said gens can get on their other tiers, specially special "side-games" (BDSP and LGPE) contained under their respective gen's RoA spotlight voting, so distinct that they can almost be classified as their own generations in a way. Hell, I didn't know BDSP lower tiers were an actual thing until recently, not that I have much experience with BDSP as a gen overall, as it only appears occasionally a year at best, at the same time, I am fascinated with how varied LGPE tiers appear to be, and wonder how badly they may be hit by not even their respect game's OU being often seen in ladder.

A third RoA spotlight ladder would be cool and very appreciated but I do not believe to be explicitly necessary and I do not feel we should bang our heads too hard against the wall asking for one, specially with retro VGC ladders being a possibility of oldgens "exposure" to the doubles-VGC playerbase which certainly exists but may feel alienated in seeing mainly only singles ladders be promoted for oldgens (or heck, maybe they could find similar official Nintendo tour ladders for gens 1 to 2 fun too, maybe? VGC isn't decided by the doubles battle format after all - team preview and the bring 6 pick x structure is a defining aspect here too).

I firmly believe once you grow attached to a specific gen, any tier on said gen can turn far more enjoyable as you gain appreciation to said gen's mechanics and nuances, which brings the issue of overcoming the initial bias a player may have with said gens.

tl;dr: Remove gen voting ASAP, preferably make it so the gen chosen is not the same gen as the UU/Uber rotational pick to aliviate the feeling that some gens may not be given attention. If possible, observation and following of the VGC retro gen ladder for a month can be interesting to help further the feeling of old gen variety in a month; I firmly believe gen variety is the right step, and believe just OU/Ubers/UU ladders for a specific gen may be insufficient to achieve that goal.
 
Given that I have not seen any suggestions that are improvements over my prior checkpoint, we will go ahead with the following changes for RoA Spotlights from here on out:
  • Eliminating the generation vote and having it rotate around similar to the Ubers/UU ladder. I will probably give it a 4 generation offset (so if the Ubers/UU ladder is for BW, then the Community Choice ladder would be for RBY).
  • Keeping the generation cooldown at 6 months. This ensures that large, popular, multi-generation formats get an extended cooldown while smaller, one-generation formats effectively only get a one-generation cooldown.
  • Removing the advertising restrictions as I initially wanted.
December 2026's Ubers/UU ladder will be BW, so the Community Choice ladder will be an RBY tier. The formats will continue to rotate out from there.
 
Back
Top