ntrnsc mtvtn said:Oh, dear. I kept telling myself to stay away from forums because something like this could happen. Clearly, me on any forum is ultimately bound to cause vexation in others no matter my intentions, and the resulting discourse is never good for my health. I'll try to keep it short.
Me assessing that strategy was all about finding out if it was unbeatable.
I chose yours because it was the one Single Train strategy most unlike everything I had tried previously, and because it is this thread's most proper attempt at an unbeatable team. You may have read my assessment as one big attempt at lowering the credibility of your team, which is very unfortunate. The way I read your answer, you agree on my conclusion that the team can be defeated, even if played right. As such, you could've answered my post with one word instead of going into detail about how far out my scenarios are, since if they can happen, that's enough.
If this is true, then you should indeed have stayed away from forums because it's obvious to anyone who has played a few hundred battles in the Subway that no team is unbeatable, especially compared to Gen 4. No one including myself has ever intimated that my team is unbeatable, so forgive me for assuming you weren't actually attempting to engage in some sort of discussion. If you genuinely expected someone to respond to a post that was 1,700 words with just one, then, again, perhaps you shouldn't be posting on forums. That's not how they operate, and that's especially not how I operate (no one who's familiar with these threads is at all surprised at my thorough response to your post).
I wasn't going to offer a sheepish, almost apologetic "no" to your question about my team's viability, one that would indicate that I've somehow backed into the #1 spot. Forgive me for giving you the benefit of the doubt of wanting your post to be responded to in kind if you genuinely expected a one word answer, but when explanation is expected, I will not disappoint. I can't say I'm surprised that (or if) you differ with this ideal, given that you seem to have expected the rest of us to accept your incredibly minimalist 579-streak post that was also your first on these forums, an oddity wildly exacerbated by your later posts demonstrating that you in fact are one of the most capable posters these threads have ever seen and not one who is unwilling or unable to explain him- or herself.
I would've much rather heard about Prankster Taunt, U-turn (you briefly mention this), and Effect Spore variants. Most of those scenarios assume perfect AI, so in the events where a threat is dealt with by stupid AI, like Rock Blast (and Prankster Taunt??), it's nice to get some information, but with all my Subway battles I just find that the AIs dumb decisions can't be reliably predicted at all. Your question about 'my' Dragonite illustrates the unfortunate interpretation pretty well, because surely I realize the value of Multiscale Dragonite and that it can go far on the Subway, but that's completely irrelevant when discussing 'invincibility', which was my intention, as I've mentioned.
Forgive me for not responding to the Prankster Taunt thing, I had roughly 1,680 other words in your post to give their due. If I haven't mentioned it already, yes Thundurus and Tornadus are too "stupid" to use Taunt on Whimsicott, using Volt Switch and Hurricane respectively. Volt Switch is almost as annoying for obvious reasons but not as bad as Taunt. Trainers who can use these two pokemon are rare, and only in one instance are guaranteed to use the sets in question (even though they're the otherwise popular set4), so I don't see them often, and even less as the lead.
Effect Spore is found on a whopping total of one pokemon in the Subway in Breloom, who needs to not have Poison Heal and also present itself as the second pokemon for me to care. If it leads and it does have Effect Spore, it will be dead to its Toxic Orb in about seven turns after Whimsy Taunts it (Tricking is pointless). Static and Flame Body can be annoying but can be played around if I really care, and as with Effect Spore only present a real issue on the second poke. I usually don't end up even caring about Flame Body because Dragonite can still mow down a shitton of pokes at an effective +2 behind a Sub. Again, forgive me for seeming to have skipped a few of your reservations, but literally nothing has changed on how a trickscarf team deals with generations-old abilities and I and others have indeed posted how to deal with them in this thread and its previous iterations.
What you interpret as 'beating around the bush' is not me being a little wanker feeling better for not using crippling strategies (more on this later), but is me addressing Prankster Taunt and U-turn, along with several other doubts I have about the invincibility of said strategies. And yes, I keep talking about invincibility, which may be considered a joke since 'no team is unbeatable', which in itself is probably the reason you misinterpreted the purpose of my post, but as I've mentioned in several posts in the aftermath of my record streak; if it's not unbeatable, I don't really see the point in me trying it for an increase.
And this is why I mentioned beating around the bush—it has nothing to do with you being a "little wanker" and everything to do with the fact that there could almost not be a more obvious reason to use the team if you or anyone is looking for an increase. It is the #1 team on the list. It is really that simple and I only hate to have to point this out again because I really, really, really don't want to be perceived as tooting my own horn. The record and the explanation behind the team speak for themselves for those looking to increase their own streaks, and it's a little annoying to even have to type this. Of course, you have your *own* reasons for not wanting to use the team, which is fine, but don't profess to speak for everyone else when you "think out loud" on a forum. If you were speaking for just yourself (which I doubt) then, with respect, I would ask you who cares whether or not you personally are going to use someone else's team. I don't think you were speaking just for yourself, which is why I responded the way I did.
Forretress used Explosion on the first turn, and if you switch to Dragonite, could do so before any Dragon Dances leaving you in an undesirable position. 5 PP moves (or the likes) leave, as you acknowledge, Dragonite with less than maximum set up, and while this is often enough, it can lower the bar for aforementioned conditions required to stop Dragonite, with the pkmn it will no longer knock out in one hit. Your Excadrill example also illustrates how such a situation could arise. Don't get how you can call Weavile 4 a piece of cake and then proceed to give an example where it ends up being quite the nuisance. But why am I even writing this; you're not talking about invincibility.
Forry does 29-34% to Whimsy with -2 Attack Explosion, meaning that I essentially trade my Sash for a 3-2 lead. Unless you think Focus Sash is integral to winning up 3-2 you should realize that I like my chances in this situation (which has happened a handful of times). A ton of the "second poke" would-be threats, for example, disappear when Draggy doesn't have to worry about statusing itself killing the second poke it faces cause the battle would be over. With regard to 5pp moves and the like, I will tell you right now that if I were assured +4 and a Sub at 100% HP with Dragonite with two mystery pokemon left to face, I would take it every time. Every single time and I am not kidding. You can come back at me with some pokemon beats pokemon with defensive spread or typing but I will stand by this given how much Subway I've played. And Weavile's a piece of cake because its actions don't alter my strategy—I've thought about it, come up with a viable way of beating it and proven that, like every other pokemon, it needs numerous instances of hax to threaten me, despite its seemingly worrisome on-paper type advantage over my team.
Okay, I'm mainly upset about that last part, which is what I'm referring to in the beginning of this post. I'm not a native speaker of English, nor do I have much experience with online communication between strangers (especially forum-based), and I should've seen it coming that this would land me in trouble. The linguistic problem lies in the fact that my word of choice was 'rude' (which I'm unable to properly apply), and the fact that I even made such an ambiguous comment to a stranger lies in my lack of online/forum experience. The initial comment was made following a slight compliment to your person, and as such was meant to highlight the (not really) humoristic fact that cunningly crippling Subway pkmn is generally not something you expect to be a past time of a nice guy. The usage of the word in the post you're quoting is me writing online Subway diary, and is not directed at you or the credibility of your team. I talk about feeling like a kid with a GameShark, which was a problem I personally faced when I started using Multiscale on the Subway, and how this strategy really doesn't change that at all, just moving further in that direction. Yeah, your comment on Whimsicott, saying it hurts my 'argument' shows your perception of what I said. As if I'm somehow drawing a line to discredit your chosen strategy, while in fact I'm simply talking to myself about how I feel when using it.
You *have* drawn that line though, numerous times. You've nitpicked nearly every single part of my team and discredited the strategy, citing, unprompted I might add, literally dozens of reservations you have with it. Before you think I've actually taken offense to these reservations I will note that I have posted in this thread that I actually *welcome* nitpicking of my teams. The only difference here is that you've voiced opinions to which I could have replied with one word: "scoreboard". I'm above that though and have actually striven to distance myself from the record (stating at least twice that it's the #1 team, not that it's "my" team), and, again, I actually like this kind of back-and-forth as I stated in my previous post.
So if you're really just musing aloud and using this thread as some sort of diary, I would ask you, after insisting that the question genuinely carries no malice: who asked you? Who asked you to use this thread as your diary? Who asked you what your opinion was about another team? Now those questions are going to look unfair no matter what so I will answer for you: "I did." We all did—this thread invites such musings and thoughts and is how these threads thrive. But you very, very literally asked for the responses I've issues thus far. Remember, a real diary can't write you back.
I guess this showcases one of the problems I have with online communication. Anyway, it's a fact that Whimsicott, regardless of its stats, can screw the Subway over big time in a way not possible for the roster AI itself, and that's what matters to my perspective. Again 'fun' for you, no, that's your business, I'm talking about my gaming experience, essentially me being unable to feel excited. Your comment on me using Scizor and Dragonite echoes my sentiments on Multiscale in the Subway. I do indeed find the team, and especially the Dragonite version, less rewarding than many other strategies. If you find your current record team more rewarding, that's very positive and you should be happy, but didn't you say it was boring in some earlier post? The particular line of strategy that led to the team I used for 579 was Scizor and friends, just trying out what does best, so I'm not surprised at all that I landed on often used pkmn - remember, I deliberately traded for a Multiscale Dragonite, since no access. Whimsicott and Mesprit are a lot better for Subway than player versus player, right? So is there really any point in looking at player versus player usage statistics?
I did say it was boring, yes. I'm not the one making unsolicited posts about others' teams being boring, though. And the point of referencing usage statistics was to highlight the fact that utility is incredibly relative and can't be used as a basis for Subway arguments. What difference does it make whatsoever that the AI can't use Whimsicott? They most likely would if it had about 15 more Base Attack and Special Attack—statistics that would in no way alter how I've used it. Why does it matter to you that the AI can't use it? It bothers me a lot more when I see the AI activate pinch berries that aren't available to us.
Hm, washing hands, exploiting AI.. If one can prey on the AIs flawed decision-making to get ahead and make way for a positive experience, then that's dandy. I'm mainly concerned about staring at the (more or less) same battle scenario for hundreds of battles. Like I'm controlling the opponent, cracked the code by constructing an ingenious (better word than rude?) team, and then feel like I've conquered the Subway. Then I guess I'd move on. To me, the Subway is just where I have my main game fun after the game scenario is over, where it actually matters what you use, build pkmn and such, so I don't really desire breaking it or whatever, which is why it is unfortunate that you keep referring to my 'Subway is all about setting records', as that is actually a slight complain on the design of the Subway (compare to what I've just said). I'm well aware that it can't be helped that much though. Your last bit nails much of what I've commented on, fun/excitement being subjective - it's just me talking to myself, not at all trying to offend anyone or dictate how they should play. It's absurd to have to defend such basic principles of human kindness. I've already mentioned how my post was assessing the invincibility of your team, however ridiculous that is, and as such my points/reservations were and are perfectly legitimate. Even if we assume that my post wasn't meant to be an assessment of invincibility, and that it was littered with flawed logic and false perceptions, how do you even begin to get agitated by my comment on lack of experience, going as far as to call me a hypocrite? I was musing (which probably isn't the thing to do on an online forum) over whether I should help people who created strategies which power they overestimated. Stuff like people claiming that some well set up pkmn can take out everything when that's plain wrong, just found many examples of that and figured it's probably none of my business. In this case, lack of experience is a great thing from an enjoyment perspective, I'd say - I had fun finding out about things like that.
I can state that you're waxing hypocritical (which is different from calling you a hypocrite) when you demonstrate a lack of experience using my team, asking so many reservation-laden questions about it that have either already been answered or easily put to rest here, yet you're offering to help people who have demonstrated a similar misestimation of strategies. When you say "I'm not sure if I should correct people when they write stuff that is plain wrong" you're expressing some air of superiority over some unnamed posters, when you yourself have no right to express such sentiment when your 1,700-word unsolicited nitpick of my own team/strategy was objectively and unequivocally full of "stuff that is just plain wrong". I'm going to requote something from your original post on this:
"So, even if one manages to get Dragonite perfectly set up in every single battle, there are still so many things that can go wrong, and as such I'm very surprised that Jumpman16 has reached 630 with that strategy, which has nothing to fall back on. I must be missing something."
Besides the fact that you'd have us believe that this was some diary-entry to which you didn't expect me to respond in kind, I went to great lengths to show you what you were indeed missing. Dragonite is really, really hard to kill (as in "igarvey: dragonite survives stab ch blizzards now" hard). The genies never use Taunt. Gigalith1 and 2 are rare and never use Rock Blast (and, now that I think about it, would need five hits to actually do anything with since it almost certainly takes two hits to break my Sub and a third to affect Multiscale). There simply aren't nearly as many combinations of Focus Sash and Brightpowder and Quick Claw as you may have thought given the distribution of those items through the four respective pokemon sets. I salivate when I see Excadrill4 because Poison Jab makes my job easier. Ice Pokemon hardly even use Ice moves on Mesprit to get locked into. And so on, and so on, and I'm not even including your follow-up reservations from your latest post.
Your last line takes the cake. I didn't come here for schooling, and I don't think any of it is warranted. Basically, you're throwing logical ground principles my way, for something I don't at all see myself being guilty of; such as questioning others' fun or knowledge. It illustrates the way in which my posts are interpreted as coming from some teenage douche, but I guess I can thank myself for that, writing as a non-native speaker under a lackluster low post count user profile. Unless you give a fuck about which aspects of the Subway I find exciting, which you shouldn't, you're taking all kinds of weird offenses from my post.
Let me repaste this then:
"So, even if one manages to get Dragonite perfectly set up in every single battle, there are still so many things that can go wrong, and as such I'm very surprised that Jumpman16 has reached 630 with that strategy"
You may not know me, but why don't you take a step back and consider why someone may find this "offensive" (your word). The #1 and #2 streaks in DPPT were Trick teams, and they both murdered the Tower for well over 2,000-win streaks. This Whimsy one is a slight variant. And since you said "Jumpman16" and not "someone", I think it's fair to state that it's Jumpman16 who has the #1 streak in both games, with the same strategy. I think it's also fair to say that no one who paid any attention to the last thread (Smogon's second-most popular of all time), or this one, or who knows much of anything about me would be "very surprised" that Jumpman16 has the Tower/Subway record again with a Trick team. It's fair to say that I know what I'm doing, so what were you attempting to gain by posting this comment?
I already know that arguing (anonymously) over the Internet is like participating in the Paralympics, and I've mentioned how this does no good for my health, so this will definitely be my last post and read of this thread, outside of checking for roster data. I figure this will suit me better as well, as my Subway fun's been weird ever since I signed up. Guess I made the right decision back in November when I withdrew my submission of that 409 (406) streak. I envy those of you who can maintain your fun while doing this thing. I'll let my posts stay, but by all means, if it's not too much to ask for; remove me from your listings. Going here was never about getting credit or entering some sort of penis measurement contest, which I'm obviously interpreted as participating in, but was simply to share/archive just a little bit of all the time I'd spent on the Subway. Real talk, and this might seem phony as hell if you don't know about my approach to pkmn or intrinsic motivation in general; I don't care about streak length, it's just an annoying but very central aspect of the Subway I have to deal with. It should be obvious if you read this post for what it is, but projection can't be helped. Just posting this draft, should suffice, won't be revisiting anyway. Now, free as a bird.
Streak length is unfortunately the only measure of "greatness" in this thread. If you think you're annoyed, imagine how Peterko feels right now, or how I felt when I was 2,100 battles behind him years ago. This isn't always fun endeavor, and as you noted, teambuilding and strategizing is much, much more fun. People like me "maintain our fun" by defending these things when they are challenged, lest we be relegated to accomplishing mere lucky, "very surprising" streaks by the uninitiated. I don't care one way or another if you post again (you have like seven posts, let's be real), because these threads have seen people like you come and go and the real enthusiasts stick around.