I've collected so many thoughts while reading everybody's responses, that I need to make another post addressing some of the points being made to facilitate productive discussion where we don't talk past each other.
Shurtugal said:I agree that SM is unbalanced and has a team builder issue, but the issue is not Kartana. I do not think banning Kartana will fix the larger issue at hand.
I'll just be blunt: Z-Moves are the issue. Not that I want to totally ban them, but it pushes so many Pokemon over the edge. Oftentimes you need to run more than one Pokemon to safely check something (looking at you Magearna, but applies to literally every single offensive Pokemon) in the event it has the Right Z-Move, creating a rather horrible experience if I am honest. Ask yourself: would Kartana be broken without Z-Move? Heck would Pheromosa have been broken without a Z-Move to give it an accurate Focus Blast and a Z-Hyper Beam to blast through Toxapex? Would Zygarde have been an issue without the option to run Z-Outrage/TA to blast through otherwise perfectly safe checks like Tangrowth?
My point with bringing all that up is that the issue with SM in most of it's recent suspects/the tier as a whole is Z-Moves, which create an horrible imbalance in the team builder. Without the strain of Z move, it would be much more possible to build more consistent teams because you would have more team space. Right now you literally have to accept you lose to x or y because there isn't enough space to have 2 checks for everything.
While I get where you're coming from I dont think that one necessarily excludes the other. Regarding z-moves, I believe that as a whole they add a very good element to the game, opening up a myriad of creative solutions to a variety of problems. For example defensive uses of z-moves where Toxapex can deal massive damage to SD Gliscor / Magma Heatran or Tornadus-Therian can guarantee the OHKO on SD SpD Tapu Bulu seem very healthy and desirable to me. Some other examples would include z-Heal Bell, z-Toxic to get past Taunt etc. There are, however, certain Pokemon, or even certain moves where z-moves feel unfair, or quite frankly 'bullshit'.
From my point of view, we need to be more open to
complex bans, especially when it comes to z-moves. There are currently two specific instances involving them that make me scratch my head:
- Using Z to get past certain drawbacks of moves whilst making them even stronger: Hyper Beam / Giga Impact, Outrage-esque moves, Draco Meteor-esque moves, Freeze Shock / Solar Beam-esque moves.
- One-Two punch usage of boost into z-move vs the defensive counter, oftentimes using one of the moves mentioned in point one. Tail Glow Manaphy, Swords Dance Kartana etc.
Therefore I could see benefit in these getting looked at:
- Tail Glow (SD? Nasty Plot?) + z-move
- Hyper Beam / Giga Impact + z-move
- Draco Meteor-esque + z-move
- Outrage-esque + z-move
- Freeze Shock-esque + z-move
I am not sure if anything ought to be done at all, and I'm probably in the camp of z-moves being fine as they are, but complex bans should definitely be on the table for issues like these.
ABR said:Choice band has few totally reliable counters, which are probably limited to Scizor, Tangrowth, and Skarmory, but general pivots can be made with Lando-T, Torn-T, Toxapex, and so on.
I believe CB to be the main offender so I'm going to address this point in particular since I dont think the countermeasures you listed are particularly reliable.
- Mega-Scizor:
Mixed defensive takes around 40 from Sacred Sword, meaning that just one double on Stealth Rock can put it in 2HKO range the next time around (MegaZor also cant hold Leftovers so the chip is particularly bad). Forced to Roost. Can get trapped by Magnezone, and not just by Scarf Magnezone like Kartana, it also gets trapped by Choice Specs and Z.
- Skarmory: Also gets trapped by Magnezone, also by every set, just even worse. In case it is holding Shed Shell, Kartana can remove it via Knock Off. Overall a relatively niche Pokemon.
- Tangrowth: I'm assuming we are talking about physically defensive here, since AV gets clean 2HKOd by Smart Strike and would only be in the pivot category you mentioned afterwards (it also really doesnt appreciate Knock Off). Granted, pdef Tang is a pretty good countermeasure to CB Kartana, however, not only is it a very niche set, it also gets its Helmet removed & Smart Strike is still able to pressure it with the assistance of Stealth Rock as most of them dont run Synthesis and some may not even have HP Fire.
calcs regarding the pivots you mentioned:
252 Atk Choice Band Kartana Smart Strike vs. 252 HP / 4 Def Tornadus-Therian: 264-312 (72.9 - 86.1%) -- 81.3% chance to OHKO after Stealth Rock
-1 252 Atk Choice Band Kartana Leaf Blade vs. 248 HP / 80 Def Landorus-Therian: 189-223 (49.6 - 58.5%) -- 99.6% chance to 2HKO
-1 252 Atk Choice Band Kartana Leaf Blade vs. 248 HP / 80 Def Landorus-Therian on a critical hit: 424-501 (111.2 - 131.4%) -- guaranteed OHKO
252 Atk Choice Band Kartana Leaf Blade vs. 252 HP / 4 Def Toxapex: 196-232 (64.4 - 76.3%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Stealth Rock and Black Sludge recovery
252 Atk Choice Band Kartana Leaf Blade vs. 252 HP / 4 Def Toxapex on a critical hit: 295-348 (97 - 114.4%) -- 81.3% chance to OHKO after Black Sludge recovery
All three of these are at risk of immediately dying vs Rocks + Smart Strike / Leaf Blade crit (the high crit rate absolutely needs to be taken into consideration when talking about Kartana's viability imo) and they do not appreciate the damage otherwise, either. Even Knock Off does massive damage to them while removing their Item, which can be very important.
- Magnezone: I know that you havent mentioned him any further than as one of the Pokemon that can outspeed Kartana, however, youve been more vocal about Zone beating Kartana on Discord so I wanted to highlight the importance of the fact that Scarf Magnezone exclusively beats Kartana. Not Z, not Specs. This is important because Scarf Magnezone is a very poor choice in multiple regards, for example if fails to reliably beat any of Ferrothorn (Protect + Leech Seed), Celesteela, Mega-Scizor (it can put it in Kartana Sacred Sword range, but Scizor can U-turn out and potentially counter-trap Zone via HP Ground Ditto so you wont get another shot) and even Mega-Mawile, especially Sucker-Punch variants. Moreover, Scarf Magnezone doesnt take on the role of a fully functional Choice Scarf user so you'll need another one, in addition to already running a very weak Pokemon with little defensive utility.
I would be more sympathetic towards arguments such as 'Mons dont have to necessarily be broken if they have no counters', if Kartana didnt also outspeed Pokemon like Garchomp, Landorus-Therian, the Kyurems and the entirety of base 100 like Mew, Medi and the Charizards (who get 2HKOd by Knock Off without Stealth Rock). Its
fantastic speed (coupled with the Atk it has as well as its movepool in Knock Off, SD + Giga) is one of the two
primary perks (the other one being its ability to hold an Item like CB or Z and the possibility of Kartana being Choice Scarf whilst holding one of the other two items) it has over Mawile, who gets outsped by the likes of Gliscor and Heatran for crying out loud, and you failed to address that in any capacity.
talah said:sure there’s a few things that can pivot in like pex & scarf lando, but if u pivot in on an sd with anything slower or that cant ohko, get ready to lose 1; main point being that these unreliable pivots don’t solve the issue of covering kartana in the builder.
the problem with kart is that there’s literally only 2 things faster than it that can semi reliably switch-in, in fat torn & latias.
how fast kartana is, is what separates it from similar breakers such as mawile
maw is undoubtedly similar to kartana as a disgustingly strong breaker with sd, however, the latter gets much more set up opportunity bc of how fast it is & how many things it forces out, as well as being, albeit only by a little, more consistently able to hold some kind of defensive presence; mawile generally relies on intimidate before evolving for that.
i'd argue that mawiles presence in the tier is healthier than kartanas
Retweeting the best arguments. I agree with your post in general, especially your point of Mawile having great offensive counterplay when not using Sucker Punch + SD due to how slow it is.
talah said:latias is fucked if it switches in on an sd when kart is at 100 or a scarf knock which 2hkos w rocks, while banded can 2hko with smart or knock & again latias cant ohko it back from full.
Latias can run HP Fire or
HP Fighting to OHKO Kart from full without SpA investment. Both moves have a lot of other utility & I believe that you should run one of them on most MLatias sets in todays meta.
talah said:one of which is pretty easily trappable
Latias has a bunch of shenanigans it can do to make trapping it a hard task. The most straight-forward one would be HP Fighting but even Twave + Roost or Reflect Type are a pain so I wouldnt use 'easily' at all here
talah said:with so many extreme playstyles & threats to account for its completely impossible to make a team & not come out weak to some of them when needing to dedicate so much attention to something as overbearing as kartana.
Its not impossible, it just limits the amount of ways to achieve that to a satisfactory degree. Mega-Latias and Tornadus-Therian for example would be great Pokemon regardless of whether Kartana is a thing or not, but having to use them on every team is, in my opinion, not desirable.
talah said:Kartana doesn’t really add anything healthy to the tier apart from being good counterplay to rain. basically, ash & heatran, being the only other mons in ou that compare to kartana with the amount of stress they put on building, add more to the tier than they take away, while the same cant be said for kartana in my opinion.
I mostly agree with this when comparing it to Toxapex or Magearna, but it is worth mentioning that a
supportive set has emerged recently. This set can Defog on Ferrothorn, z-Garchomp (lacking Fire Fang) and z-Landorus-Therian while having access to Knock Off and countering a good amount of dangerous physical Pokemon such as Gliscor and Mega-Gyarados. The reason Heatran & Ash Greninja shouldnt be suspected is because they simply do not put the same amount of stress on building due to either being a bit on the slower side (Heatran), or just having enough satisfactory counterplay (Ash Greninja).
All in all, I still believe that Kartana is the greatest headache across all fronts, but I'm not opposed to Mega-Mawile being tested instead. There is certainly an argument to be made for its non-SD+Sucker sets being over the top to handle defensively, and there is also an argument to be made that the SD+Sucker sets are pretty much Kartana 2.0