• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Smogon Forums

Finchinator
Finchinator
Well you’re proposing we suspect something that is slightly below in public support and way below in council support where it would normally be, so that’s pretty clearly forced.

And I never said suspects = bans, I just said excess bans are bad and bans aren’t the only tools to changes tier. Not sure why you followed up with that.
cat111ca
cat111ca
And now we circle back to why my first points were important. It was bearly, only technically below public support and now we have to wait half a year! The thing about bans not being suspects is related because you said excess bans ard bad. Excess (and it's the first one in 8 months I don't think that's excess) suspects are not excess bans! If the suspect fails than, as I said, it's officially healthy! Excess suspects Are healthy! Also what ways are there to make a tier less stale other than suspects?/Gen
Finchinator
Finchinator
For starters, you’re still ignoring the bit about council support. Tiering isn’t just survey and crowdsourced data. Council consensus is what makes any decision and surveys didn’t even exist for 90%+ of our history. I popularized surveys to assist us and give the public power, but claiming that there are hard-and-fast numbers like 3.5 and they mandate action is a misapplication
Finchinator
Finchinator
But also: a suspect takes up a ton of resources. Thousands of hours of players laddering, forum tools, contributor hours, etc. — we don’t ever do “well, when in doubt” suspects, no. We only do it when support is there and the standards are met. Otherwise, we would end up with more lousy suspects like Walking Wake’s premature one, which was my own error. We always strive to update our process and communicate properly. In this case, that process leads to Dragonite not having enough support.

There’s no 6 month wait either, Dragonite wasn’t close to this place 6 months ago and there’s another survey likely later this month with SPL beginning
cat111ca
cat111ca
Well. 10 people being able to choose not to do something about a Pokemon is very undemocratic and has killed tiers before (dpp council choosing to not have a complex ban on iron head :Jirachi:
Finchinator
Finchinator
That’s the whole point of councils and nobody called smogon a full democracy. The power of tiering decisions is never in the hands of the general public — otherwise, darkrai and iron valiant would’ve been banned way earlier this generation. It’s the job of the council to be up to date and determine when the playerbase can kick in for a survey or a suspect
cat111ca
cat111ca
I didn't know the pace surveys happen. It needs to be said somewhere when's the next survey
Finchinator
Finchinator
Finally, if you genuinely think an iron head ban in DPP is proper tiering practice, then I implore you to actually read through tiering policy. That’s a non-starter and, even if council wanted it, higher staff would reject it immediately. That’s not how tiering works and is really just slop, not reality. You don’t ban a move for the sake of preserving a pokemon, especially not in a one off setting. If it broke numerous things, diff story. But that isn’t the DPP Jirachi case
cat111ca
cat111ca
And why is that good? Why is Smogon not being democratic a thing that needs to be kept and not slowly changed over time?
Finchinator
Finchinator
survey dates depend on how the council sees the tier and what is going on at any given time — you cannot just say oh it’s happening on X day months or weeks before when you don’t know what will happen. Think suggesting this kinda shows you’re misunderstanding the process
cat111ca
cat111ca
Than just a rachi ban or a bab of iron head on rachi. It was an example of council killing tiers fgs
cat111ca
cat111ca
Maybe i do. Maybe the process is, again, really undemocratic and has no reason to be kept?
Finchinator
Finchinator
Smogon is more democratic than ever — we had more suspects these past two generations than ever before and I brought sweeping surveys to give people a voice, but we also need to be practical: someone being 1750 on ladder doesn’t necessary mandate their opinion to override a clear majority within a council. If we have 8 people and 8/7 or even 6 of them don’t want a Dragonite suspect, then it’s pretty obvious that there’s a lot of reason not to. If you break things down further, which I can as I have data, the survey replies on Dragonite show most people who qualify on the fringe of ladder are more likely to give it a 4-5 while most who do from top of ladder or tournaments are more in the 2-3 range.
Finchinator
Finchinator
No, it pretty clearly has a reason to be kept. You just aren’t really reading my reasoning or selecting to ignore it for some reason.
cat111ca
cat111ca
What reason? Genuinely what reason is there for it being kept? It being more democratic doesn't mean it can't be better! (The thing about the data of the more qualified a player is the less they think it's broken is good data but atp we're debating something else)
Finchinator
Finchinator
Again: the power to make decisions over what should be suspected or quickbanned is not something the public is qualified for. They play the tier and are qualified to rate things or vote on suspects, but there is a huge difference in understanding, experience, and tiering knowledge. Playing the tier doesn’t stand-alone qualify someone to make larger tiering opinions, it really just means they understand the metagame. These are very different things. This is why we have rolled out more suspects and surveys, which fits what the represent, but every single tier (not just OU) has councils to make larger scale decisions!

I feel you demonstrate this here ironically enough — you are a member of the general public and you’re claiming the DPP council was foolish to not “Complex ban iron head” when that’s a non-starter. To begin, it’s not a complex ban if it’s just a move. Complex bans imply multiple prongs (like swift swim + drizzle’s 2010-2011 deliberation leading to aldaron’s proposal, which brought complex ban into infamy to begin with). But also, anyone with tiering experience knows you don’t use a move ban to sidestep a pokemon ban ever, even if it’s “convenient”, if it’s only broken on a single Pokemon. We tier Pokemon first and foremost with every other target being more in case of emergency or outlier. You may understand DPP well enough to have the stance that Jirachi is an issue, but there’s a huge difference in tiering opinion if you believe the stance to take from that is to ban iron head — this embodies the difference pretty much.
Finchinator
Finchinator
SV OU has been the fastest moving generation both in terms of tiering action (in fact, nearly 2x every other generation besides 8) and natural metagame shifts (ladder is fast moving, teams evolve, trends come and go, etc.)

You can argue there is an issue with threat saturation maybe, but it’s misleading to say it’s stale or stagnant. And it’s absolutely incorrect to force a suspect when there isn’t council support while public support is below the normal bar — this is a waste of time and can actually stifle things when everyone focuses on the suspect rather than the natural progression. Just really think the useful life is over here since you keep talking over me rather than acknowledging why I’m saying what I’m saying or even what I’m saying. It feel like you’re repeating things that have been answered and ignoring a lot of the holes or misconceptions you’re showing.

Have a nice day
cat111ca
cat111ca
1. Im saying to complex ban it on jirachi only
2. Anyone would also know Jirachi in dpp is a unique case where a Pokemon is simultaneously keeping the meta from being unhealthy and also really unhealthy. 3. The thing with first and foremost banning Pokemon doesn't really have any logic or reason behind it. 4. About sv not being stale. Maybe it's because I've joined this gen (don't you dare saying that invalidates my opinion) but I'm mostly used to that pace and the last 3 months were really boring compared to months before. This is an opinion but you can't say that if that's why i think dnite should be suspected than that invalidates my opinion.
5. MY WHOLE POINT IS THAT IT WAS BEARLY BELOW THE PUBLIC MARGIN AND THAT YOU BEING IN THE COUNCIL DOESN'T MAKE YOUR OPINION MORE CORRECT THAN THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE!!!!!!!! I'M THE ONE BEING IGNORED WHILE YOU TRY TO JUSTIFY 8 PEOPLE DISAGREEING WITH 70% OF THOUSANDS GET TO PICK WHAT TO DO! SMOGON SHOULD BE FULLY DEMOCRATIC FOR THIS EXACT REASON . YOU KNOW WHAT? I'M STARTING A REVOLUTION. IF YOU CAN'T REALIZE THAT YPUR OPINION ISN'T MORE VALUABLE THAN THOUSANDS THAN YOU DON'T DESERVE TO HAVE YOUR OPINION BE THE ONLY THING THAT MATTERSSSSSSSSSSS
ILoveGarchom
ILoveGarchom
"the top sv ou players opinion isn't more correct than the average ladder player"
cat111ca
cat111ca
The top sv ou plater isn't more correct than the entire ladder
Back
Top