Done Add displayable pronouns to settings

Status
Not open for further replies.

April

She's out back counting stars
is a Site Content Manageris a Top Social Media Contributoris a Community Leaderis a Top Community Contributoris a Top Smogon Discord Contributoris a Top Metagame Resource Contributoris a member of the Battle Simulator Staffis a Senior Staff Member Alumnusis a Contributor Alumnusis a Top Smogon Media Contributor Alumnus
Community Leader
A common issue faced on the site, especially in public chatrooms, is the (usually unconscious) assumption that whoever you're currently talking to is male, and as such, a lot of people unconsciously refer to others with he/him pronouns without really thinking about it. Many people will default to they/them no matter who they're speaking to, which isn't the biggest issue in the world, admittedly, but can also be uncomfortable for users who don't use neutral pronouns. Alternatively, in the event a user comes out as trans, other users may not know and will continue to (accidentally) misgender them, which can be upsetting.

The issue of accidental misgendering, while minor, could be easily fixed by allowing users to display their pronouns next to/below their avatars. These pronouns would not reset with a logout, similar to a user's avatar, but they would be editable at any time.

Currently, the closest we have to a feature like this is statuses, but these are imperfect. Many users don't know that they're available as an option, while many users may require that space for other messages. Adding a toggleable pronouns button where users could write in their pronouns to display them when their username is clicked on would both free up a users status for whatever message they need there while also preventing the feature from essentially requiring users to be "in the know" to properly take advantage of it.

Does this open the door to some inherent sillyness or misbehavior? Potentially, but no more than statuses themselves already do. In the event a user is seen abusing this feature to an unacceptable degree, they can be given the proper punishment, but I do not feel like this mild drawback should prevent PS! from implementing an otherwise incredibly positive accessibility feature.

Mockup of what this might look like

pronouns.png

Screenshot 2024-07-31 151657.png
 
pretty much yeah. running this idea back given it's been a few years since it was suggested and i think with how the community has evolved recently, it would be a good addition

How has the community evolved recently?

Last time someone asked about implementing pronoun display, we decided that statuses worked well enough. You say users would have to be "in the know" to put their pronouns in a status, but wouldn't that also apply to any new pronoun display setting? In general, we prefer to keep things simple rather than adding extra features if it's not necessary. But maybe pronoun display solves a problem that can't be solved any other way?

(Moderation load is also a concern that's been raised before, but I think there are probably ways to mitigate that or at least make it no worse than statuses already are. Open to feedback from staff who do moderation, though!)
 
How has the community evolved recently?

In the past few years, more and more queer people have either joined the site or risen up the ranks to become more prominent members; while obviously queer smogon/showdown users always have existed and been prominent users, that number has trended and is only trending upwards

.You say users would have to be "in the know" to put their pronouns in a status, but wouldn't that also apply to any new pronoun display setting?
That's part of why I'm specifically requesting it to be an obvious, unmissable button where it is. Statuses aren't advertised much on the site or in its settings, making them a bit of a hidden feature, especially for people who don't regularly use the site.

I think the issue i brought up could also be solved by having a general "status" button similar to the one in my suggestion; this wouldn't require any new features to be added, it would simply make an existing one slightly more accessible, being right there on the settings menu instead of being something that takes a bit of digging to find. this would fulfill a primary goal of the pronouns button request while also making statuses in general more widely used
 
In the past few years, more and more queer people have either joined the site or risen up the ranks to become more prominent members; while obviously queer smogon/showdown users always have existed and been prominent users, that number has trended and is only trending upwards


That's part of why I'm specifically requesting it to be an obvious, unmissable button where it is. Statuses aren't advertised much on the site or in its settings, making them a bit of a hidden feature, especially for people who don't regularly use the site.

I think the issue i brought up could also be solved by having a general "status" button similar to the one in my suggestion; this wouldn't require any new features to be added, it would simply make an existing one slightly more accessible, being right there on the settings menu instead of being something that takes a bit of digging to find. this would fulfill a primary goal of the pronouns button request while also making statuses in general more widely used
Would adding a button to set statuses in the Settings menu address your concerns fully? I think I'm totally fine with that. Or do you think there are still benefits to a pronouns display field?
 
Would adding a button to set statuses in the Settings menu address your concerns fully? I think I'm totally fine with that. Or do you think there are still benefits to a pronouns display field?
I'd be perfectly fine with this, fulfills a similar purpose while also highlighting a feature i really like on the site. Thanks for your consideration :heart:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top