u/StreetlightTones
Monocolour refers to Pokemon that share the same official Pokedex colour. The monocolour format in DPP OU has been played before, but without as vast a pool of Pokemon the later gens have, it feels unbalanced without additional rules. This post aims to provide a ruleset that incorporates shiny colours as a means of balancing and formalising a monocolour metagame in DPP OU, while trying to be as consistent with the official colours as possible, but also without appearing too arbitrary. The format can then be used for casual tournaments and the like :)
Colours:
The ten official Pokedex colours as they stand, how powerful the Pokemon in their category are, and what kind of teams you can make with them:
- Red: Contains standalone powerful Pokemon like Scizor and Latias, but does not offer much diversity.
- Blue: The best colour. Contains staples like Metagross and Azelf and a large variety of strong Water-types.
- Yellow: Has Jirachi, but not much else to complete a viable team.
- Green: It's up there with Red, featuring Tyranitar and a vibrant Grass-type variety.
- Black: An extremely limited selection where Weavile is king...
- Brown: Contains good Pokemon like Heatran and Dragonite, but can only barely fill a team viably.
- Purple: Contains your favourite spinners Starmie and Forretress, and other good mons, but not that great.
- Grey: A colour filled with slow Pokemon and bulky steels.
- White: Doesn't even have enough Pokemon to fill a winnable team...
- Pink: Has all your favourite blobs! But still not so viable.
Balancing:
Shiny colours will only add so much to the Pokemon pool of each colour, and some colours like White will hardly receive support (as colours like Pink and Yellow are more common for shinies), so the first obvious move is to form colour coalitions in order to have less but more diverse pools. Combining colours can actually be done while maintaining colour coordination:
- Red, Blue and Green, arguably the three best colours, will remain their own faction.
- Yellow and Brown are "almost there" strong. By combining them into an "Ochre" faction, the options are expanded enough for a viable team.
- Pink and Purple can be combined into a "Fuchsia" faction. This faction will receive immense support thanks to the common pink and purple shiny colours.
- Given the lack of good mons in Black, Grey and White, let alone mons in general, all three will merge to form a "Monochrome" faction.
Shinies:
Without official Pokedex colours for shinies, determining the colour of them can feel like an arbitrary process. Most of the time, the colour of a shiny is obvious (e.g. the red Gyarados is red). In cases where the shiny colour can be perceived in more than one way, a systematic approach can weigh the options and help categorise a shiny into its appropriate colour.
- What is the Pokemon's predominant colour? E.g. Shiny Nidoqueen has some pink parts, but she definitely has more green on her pixels-wise.
- Which part of the Pokemon's body does the official Pokedex use to determine colour? E.g. Blastoise is predominantly brown thanks to its shell, but it is classed as Blue officially, having a blue head, limbs and tail. Hence, it is reasonable to call shiny Blastoise Purple.
- Should the Pokemon's official colour be reconsidered? This seems arbitrary at first but makes sense when you take a Pokemon like Bronzong. It appears blue on the colour spectrum but is officially Green. However, Bronzong's shiny is a lot more objectively green. To prevent an overlap where both Bronzong variants are green, and hence sharing its strength with other factions, it's best to re-class non-shiny Bronzong as Blue for diversity's sake.
- Would a Pokemon benefit X Pokemon pool more than Y Pokemon pool? This line of thought is in the interest of the metagame. If a shiny Pokemon's colour is controversial, then this reasoning can be implemented to justify categorisation of a Pokemon. E.g. shiny Moltres can definitely be considered Red or Pink, but Red has plenty of Fire-types already, whereas Pink is lacking.
The Six Pokemon Factions:
Below is a colourful but tedious visualisation of the best Pokemon to use in each category! Of course, the Pokemon you see are not the only Pokemon you can use; there are decent options for each colour that aren't shown here.
Resources: https://pokemondb.net/pokedex/shiny, https://play.pokemonshowdown.com/sprites/gen4-shiny/
Unbans:
You may have noticed a few OU foreigners above! Some unbans have been made for further balancing.
- Red: Non-shiny Deoxys-Speed gives Red a reliable Spikes setter and another generally powerful Pokemon to add to its still very shallow Pokemon pool. Shiny Deoxys-Speed will not be allowed for yellow.
- Fuchsia: Even with the shiny buffs, Fuchsia teambuilding can still feel somewhat restrictive. Therefore, non-shiny Mew, when stripped from its ability to Baton Pass stats, is an acceptable inclusion (you're welcome mackie!) Shiny Mew will not be allowed for Blue.
- Monochrome: Cursed with a miserable Pokemon pool, Machamp and Snow Cloak (likely to be seen in the form of Froslass) will authoritatively grant the outcast monochrome faction the "hax" gimmick. The Snow Cloak unban also extends to other colours, as Pokemon like Glaceon are now usable if you're into that. Non-shiny Machamp will not be allowed for Green.
- Sleep moves, except for Spore on Breloom: Sleep moves will be unbanned to buff some factions' weaker Pokemon, like Smeargle for Monochrome and Ochre, Roserade for Green and Uxie for Blue and Ochre. However, given Breloom is already a strong candidate in both its factions, Breloom will remain banned from using Spore.
I am all about feedback and I am happy to read any questions, ideas and suggestions for improving the format. Was my approach to balance a monocolour format the right idea to begin with? Are the rules too harsh/lenient? I'm even happy to read why you think a certain Pokemon isn't a certain colour. Why isn't Infernape Red ffs?
If this concept gets enough interest, I will take the time to draft a comprehensive list of the colours of all 400-something or so legal Pokemon and their shinies. Thank you for reading!





