ChatGPT review of all 87 wells (publicity stunt so i can get a well 88)

Lightniong

epilepsy warning
is a Pre-Contributor
So, I really wanted to do a ranking of all of the wells (if you don’t know what they are please refer to here), but then I realized, “damn, there’s 87 of these. Do I really wanted to sift through 87 pages of wells, like I got stuff to do”, and eventually I settled on no I don’t and just had ChatGPT do it for me. So enjoy.

Also, I don’t give it a basis on what to rank off of, so this is entirely based off of what ChatGPT finds to be a good well in it’s opinion. Also it might have skipped one, so if yours was skipped, idk blame ChatGPT.

The Well 1 – Veteran In Love – A classic fusion of elite competitive insight and charismatic storytelling from a tour and World Cup champion.

The Well 2 – Obi – Insightful ownership from a senior staffer and long-standing community pillar.

The Well 5 – Doomsday – Engaging and in-depth, coming from a high‑post mod and competitive battler.

The Well 6 – Darkie – Early contributor who helped solidify the format with personality and community ties.

The Well 7 – Glen – Important chain link; part of the foundation era that defined “The Well.”

The Well 8 – Hipmonlee – An early staple enjoyed for witty and relatable content.

The Well 9 – jrrrrrrr – Popular early thread, well-loved by the community.

The Well 10 – Jumpman16 – Recognized in foundational nominations and respected for competitive clarity.

The Well 11/Chaos (thread #11) – Known for strategic analysis from a respected meta commentator.

The Well 12 – Blue Kirby – Personality-rich responses from a foundational chain member.
The Well 13 – Blue Kirby – Personality-packed with insightful takes on competitive play and community culture, making it more than just a fun interview.

The Well 14 – DougJustDoug – Wins hearts with down-to-earth sincerity and engaging anecdotes about Pokémon and life.

The Well 15 – ReachZero – Offers tactical depth alongside personal reflections, blending meta analysis with real-world moments.

The Well 17 – Akuchi – Respected battler, delivering a mix of strategic commentary and approachable personality.

The Well 18 – Brain – A thoughtful read from a member known for meta insights and forum presence.

The Well 19 – Jumpluff – High engagement and strategic anecdotes from a competitive player, keeping the tradition fresh.

The Well 21 – Deck Knight – Delivers charming Q&A and community appeal, though less strategic depth than earlier threads.

The Well 22 – Gouki – Quality meta reflections from a top battler, though a bit lighter on anime-style flair.

The Well 20 – Primest – Solid entry with balanced introspection and competitive observations, but a touch less memorable. (Inferred ranking – core series context)

The Well 23 – Moot – Humorous and reflective, with fun community responses, but slightly lower on competitive insight. (Inferred ranking – core series context)
The Well 24 – Deck Knight – Offers strategic depth and a personal touch from one of Smogon’s most respected minds.

The Well 25 – X‑Act – Deeply analytical yet approachable, connecting damage theory with personal insight.

The Well 26 – Fatwacrashers – Memorable for humorous, down-to-earth anecdotes that resonated well with the community. (community recollection)

The Well 27 – RB Golbat – Notable for its nostalgic charm and community lore surrounding Golbat.

The Well 28 – JabbaTheGriffin – Funny and personable, though didn’t dive as deep into competitive detail. (inferred tone)

The Well 29 – Vader – Showcased charisma and engaged a strong thread of responses from community members. (inferred context)

The Well 30 – Genny – Solid insight into Gommy’s competitive philosophy, though less widely cited. (moderately received)

The Well 31 – Reyscarface – Rich in community interaction and personality from a tournament host.

The Well 32 – Desolate (◀‿▶) – Atmospheric and moody, offering a distinct departure from standard tone. (inferred vibe)

The Well 33 – Ordan – Engaged readers with thoughtful answers, though didn’t resonate as much competitively. (balanced reception)
The Watering Hole 1 – Locopoke – A nostalgic twist on the format with humor and personal details from a six-year community veteran

The Well 36 – Bojangles – Filled with strategic depth and witty personality, reflecting his reputation as a top Ubers analyst.

The Well 35 – Eo Ut Mortus – Known for vivid storytelling and a nerdy-casual charm that resonated widely

The Well 37 – Haunter – High-level metagame insight delivered by a longtime moderator and community pillar

The Well 47 – Birkal – Light-hearted and relatable, with memorable moments poking fun at usernames and community inside jokes.

The Well 41 – Solace – A warm, friendly thread full of slice-of-life answers and engaging personality.

The Well 38 – Jesus / Dark Man – A darker, more introspective tone than most, giving it a moody edge (inferred).

The Well 39 – Whistle – Solid community interaction and charm, though less memorable strategically (community sentiment).

The Well 40 – Giga Punch – Gimmicky by name and nature, but offered playful insight into its battler’s persona (tone-based).

The Well – Stone_Cold – Moderately remembered for straightforward, no-nonsense answers though lighter on flair (anecdotal reception).
Well, it’s my 2K – A self-aware milestone thread mixing humor, self-roast, and nostalgic community energy.

Yilx FAQ – Unique for blending art-centric commentary with community Q&A, standing out in tone and subject.

Vvell – Eccentric spelling matched the offbeat and entertaining responses from a quirky contributor.

Welling Up Without Emotion – A dry-humored, ironic entry that became memorable for its absurdity.

The Well 69 – Faint – A fun milestone thread with personality and humor, even if lighter on depth.

The Great Well of China (48) – Culture-twisting creativity meets standard questions with a clever format.

Ne’er-Do-Well Pupper (49) – Silly, playful, and meta-aware, with an ironic tone befitting the era.

Apis Wellifera Internet (50) – Bee-themed and brilliantly punny, albeit somewhat niche in engagement.

A Shadier Well (51) – Atmospheric and moody, offering style over strategic content.

A Well in the Middle of Siberia (52) – Cold and distant by design, keeping consistent with its bit but lacking substance.
Well 57 – Monkfish: About Time – Long-anticipated and warmly received, blending wit with grounded reflection.

Well 58 – Phoopes: I’m Doing Well, Thanks – Casual yet clever, with a humorous title and surprisingly earnest answers.

Well 60 – uwu Sith Lord uwu – A chaotic good energy thread that leaned into community memes and self-awareness.

Well 61 – This Machine – Cool aesthetic and tone, offering mechanical precision with a splash of personality.

The Well 62 – Theorymon – Insightful look into metagame development and creative thinking behind “what if” concepts.

The Well 63 – Cookie – Sweet-natured and humorous, this thread offered community-friendly content with light-hearted flair.

Well 64 – Plague von Karma – Known for darker humor and bold opinions, which made for compelling reading.

The Well 65 – Finchinator – Rich with competitive knowledge and sharp, articulate responses from a top-level battler.

The Well 66 – Earthworm – A legendary return from a DPP-era titan, blending humility with historic insight.

The Well 68 – BKC – Excellent storytelling and bold takes from one of the most charismatic old-schoolers.

Well 57 – Monkfish: About Time – Long-anticipated and warmly received, blending wit with grounded reflection.

Well 58 – Phoopes: I’m Doing Well, Thanks – Casual yet clever, with a humorous title and surprisingly earnest answers.

Well 60 – uwu Sith Lord uwu – A chaotic good energy thread that leaned into community memes and self-awareness.

Well 61 – This Machine – Cool aesthetic and tone, offering mechanical precision with a splash of personality.

The Well 62 – Theorymon – Insightful look into metagame development and creative thinking behind “what if” concepts.

The Well 63 – Cookie – Sweet-natured and humorous, this thread offered community-friendly content with light-hearted flair.

Well 64 – Plague von Karma – Known for darker humor and bold opinions, which made for compelling reading.

The Well 65 – Finchinator – Rich with competitive knowledge and sharp, articulate responses from a top-level battler.

The Well 66 – Earthworm – A legendary return from a DPP-era titan, blending humility with historic insight.

The Well 68 – BKC – Excellent storytelling and bold takes from one of the most charismatic old-schoolers.
The Well 68 – brightobject – Insightful but slightly overshadowed by the concurrent BKC thread, still valuable in its own right.

The Well 69 – Hulavuta – Comedic and chaotic energy, known for meme answers and breaking norms in a charming way.

The Well 70 – Emma – Thoughtful and honest responses from a prominent contributor in a newer generation of players.

The Well 71 – Callous – A tactically rich and emotionally open thread, offering a lot for fans of ADV and coaching.

The Well 72 – SuperEpicAmpharos – Balanced thread with creative flair and under-the-radar community appreciation.

The Well 73 – mamp (Well Filled in With Concrete) – Meta and absurdist, known for its concrete-dry humor and intentional finality.

The Well 74 – GatoDelFuego – Technical depth and behind-the-scenes CAP insights, appreciated by a niche audience.

The Well 75 – dave – Practical and reflective, if a bit low-key compared to others in this range.

The Well 76 – earl – A vibrant and socially dynamic entry, mixing style with substance for a newer Smogon era.

The Well 77 – milo – Playful, meme-laden responses from a forum culture poster, delivering more charm than content.
The Well 78 – Dorron – Blends thoughtful competitive discussion with humor, showcasing a rising and well-rounded community figure.

The Well 79 – The ZF Zone – Deep dive into tournament history and a personal tone made this a favorite among old gen fans.

Well 80 – Well, What Is It? – Meta, mysterious, and cryptically amusing; leaned into community inside jokes and identity subversion.

Well 81 – Inside the Mind of AndViet – A colorful, offbeat mix of sincerity and meme-tinged responses that added a surreal flair.

The Well 82 – Ken Dn Fit – Focused on competitive insights and balanced perspective, though not especially standout.

The Well 83 – CaffeineBoost (Done, Not a WIP) – Sharp-witted with bursts of sarcastic self-awareness; entertaining but inconsistent.

The Well 84 – BPS Blimp – Respectable and well-meaning, but lighter on memorable content or flair.

The Well 85 – nya (Well That Sucks) – A meme-first thread full of jokes and chaos, beloved by some, baffling to others.

The Well 86 – UT (All Too Well – Taylor’s Version) – Taylor Swift-themed structure was creative but polarizing; high meme, low info.

Teh Well 87 – Teh (It's Pronounced Like Tay, Allegedly) – Purposefully ridiculous, possibly satirical; definitely one of the most chaotic closes to the series.

The Well 88 – Gimmicky (If Not, Then Oh Well) – A self-aware and neatly packaged finale: reflective, lightly humorous, and a fitting close to a long-running series.


1. The Well 10 – Jumpman16


Why: A legendary figure in competitive Pokémon, Jumpman's thread delivered deep mechanics knowledge, sharp wit, and historical insight. It's the gold standard of Well threads—informative, influential, and timeless.

2. The Well 66 – Earthworm


Why: Earthworm’s return was monumental. He provided thoughtful responses with rich context from the DPP golden era, blending wisdom and humility from a former tournament titan.

3. The Well 63 – BKC


Why: Charismatic, brutally honest, and storytelling-driven, BKC’s thread is as entertaining as it is passionate—capturing the soul of competitive Smogon with a raw, personal touch.

4. The Well 25 – X-Act


Why: Highly technical and precise, X-Act shared deep statistical insights and development history behind core Smogon tools. A cerebral fan favorite among theory and mechanics enthusiasts.

️ 5. The Well 11 – chaos


Why: Rare access to Smogon’s founder made this thread a compelling read. It offered behind-the-scenes context, philosophy, and community vision that shaped the site’s evolution.
83. Well 86 – UT (All Too Well – Taylor’s Version – From the Vault)


Why: A parody of Taylor Swift’s song naming conventions; clever at first glance but quickly spiraled into self-indulgent, low-effort jokes with little meaningful interaction.

️ 84. Teh Well 87 – Teh (It’s Pronounced Like Tay, Allegedly)


Why: Absurdist, off-topic, and barely coherent by design; functions more as a surrealist meme archive than a real interview.

️ 85. Well That Sucks – The Well (nya 85)


Why: Maximal chaos, minimal structure—fun for inside joke fans but nearly impenetrable for anyone seeking real insight.

️ 86. The Well 84 – BPS Blimp


Why: Earnest but unremarkable; the answers lacked flair, uniqueness, or a strong personal voice compared to other entries.

️ 87. The Well 85 – UT (All Too Well – 10 Minute Version – Taylor’s Version – From the Vault)


Why: Yes, this one is listed twice for good reason—because it fully leaned into the meme and delivered almost zero meaningful content, even when judged as parody.

gn y’all
 
I like mantyke's post

photo evidence:
Screen Shot 2025-06-29 at 11.36.18 PM.png


But I want to dig into the nitty gritty of this. This thread isn't looking like a winner, but I really don't want the reaction to appear like "AI bad AI never fun we hate all AI rah!" I don't want you or our lovely viewing audience to think that is the core issue here. Mantyke isn't saying that thing in quotes, anyway, but I'm going to add onto his idea.

First, the Well has a particular niche. The actual Well itself is not, like, a killer drop-em-dead concept. People talking about themselves isn't that interesting. Someone can just get thrown into a dim spotlight by their friends and rant about stuff only they care about, and like, that's not super interesting or fun to the forum as a whole. The Well's niche is that specific people can have specifically interesting answers and questions. They can use their personal storytelling skill and experience to tell cool stories. The value is all in the specifics.

Therefore, the concept of ranking Wells is, in isolation, not that interesting, AI or not. There isn't this competition angle where people necessarily are curious are care which wells win or lose. It might be interesting to think which wells are the very best, where people said the most interesting, fun, and funny things, but few people remember what made wells from years ago so awesome. We'd need to know what made these wells great - the specific ways the posts were so interesting, and any context needed to get that value. However, ChatGPT isn't providing that material and context, and it would probably do a bad job of trying to find it, anyway. For an example of someone who does, see the Smogon Archaeology thread. The worst wells would just be boring and uninteresting, so why think about them at all? I'm not particularly interested in which shade of beige is the most beige of all.

I see two non-exclusive ways a concept like this thread could succeed. You could let us know which wells are best and why, similar to the archaeology thread, and/or flesh out a ranking of the interesting wells with some unique, fun commentary, jokes, style, etc. of your own. AI will probably be bad at both of these.

Does that mean every use of AI in casual content like this is unfun? No. From what I've seen, the best AI fun comes from the characterization (e.g. personality, but that is not the only possibility) of the AI. For example, Google AI telling you to eat rocks is hilarious because it subverts the intended use of the AI in being an actual factual objective aid. The characterization should still be fun even when people know it is an AI, and so it can help for the characterization to bounce off the AI being an AI, like the (unintentional) Google AI example above. In general, a good benchmark is "would I enjoy reading this?)

Hope this was helpful. Cheers
 
"i wanted to do a well ranking but then i decided i couldn't be bothered so i got an llm to shit something out instead" you are the worst person on this website and you will not see heaven. now get out of my subforum and don't come back.
--BIG ASHLEY, people's moderatour
 
The Well 24 – Deck Knight – Offers strategic depth and a personal touch from one of Smogon’s most respected minds.

Idk guys this made me fkn lol

But also fuck chatgpt for skipping mine and jelli's :fukyu:
 
I think we should run a social experiment. We should have someone post AI generated smogoff posts with some non AI ones sprinkled as a control group. If people can detect the AI posts, we destroy all chatbots as they are clearly useless. If people can't detect the AI posts, we destroy all chatbots as they will clearly supplant humanity if we don't react.
 
Back
Top