• Smogon Premier League is here and the team collection is now available. Support your team!

NOC Everchanging Mafia - Game over, mafia wins!

Peum said:
just to make this clear, the thing isnt about ECat being mayor or mayor+tracker, its about either ECat being mayor or someone else having 2 roles so it didnt show in the votecount that they were mayor.
Click to expand...
oh true I didn't think of that

Either way though we should probably wait for a tracker claim before voting
 
that's 3 votes on ECat so far... I think the message is clear that this is our safest vote and we should probably not tinfoil it

but for the rest of us that haven't voted yet I'm asking you to hold off until we get the tracker claim

(please haha)
 
The one thing I will note is the possibility of a mafia member having both mayor and tracker (or phoopes withholding the fact that they had mayor as well D1). Assuming ECat is town, it's technically in the mafia's best interest to not reveal where the mayor role was, which would throw ECat super under the bus. I think we'd get some good information from a D1 tracker reveal and a D1/D2 mayor reveal. It's not an open-and-shut case on ECat, but they're looking more scum than town right now.
 
Westcraft said:
The one thing I will note is the possibility of a mafia member having both mayor and tracker (or phoopes withholding the fact that they had mayor as well D1). Assuming ECat is town, it's technically in the mafia's best interest to not reveal where the mayor role was, which would throw ECat super under the bus. I think we'd get some good information from a D1 tracker reveal and a D1/D2 mayor reveal. It's not an open-and-shut case on ECat, but they're looking more scum than town right now.
Click to expand...
I dont think the mafia knew either that the mayor 2 votes were shown in votecount lol
 
Peum said:
I dont think the mafia knew either that the mayor 2 votes were shown in votecount lol
Click to expand...
I'd agree that they most likely didn't know about that, but the fact that there's a chance means that it's not 100% guaranteed. It's enough for a vote unless better evidence is available imo, but there could be more concrete evidence.
 
anyway heres my readslist atm

Townread:
Peum
Celever

Townlean:
genisu

Null:
Everyone else

Scumlean:
a fairy

Scumread:
phoopes

Likely Confscum:
ElectricityCat
 
really not liking phoopes atm but a good portion of that case is based on interactions with ecat so i'll wait to case it so as to not preflip
 
“because I said so” is essentially Peum’s reasoning for saying ECat is mafia mayor. Which like, I still think ECat is mafia mayor and Peum is town, but I am less convinced than all of you haha

@ Evie my interaction with ECat was literally “hey everyone don’t dogpile on ECat for making a post you think is bad,” which is NAI for me. I’m just a nice guy okay? Hahaha
 
AirC said:
Whatever Peum is saying feels like the definition of insisting upon itself
Click to expand...
1769032434879.png
 
phoopes said:
@ Evie my interaction with ECat was literally “hey everyone don’t dogpile on ECat for making a post you think is bad,” which is NAI for me. I’m just a nice guy okay? Hahaha
Click to expand...
its not just that, its that you've been taking a soft defence stance on ECat throughout the game on different issues, including in this exact post
 
I have no role to claim. I dont think it's impossible that ecat happened to be vanilla and one mafia player got two roles to start with, but it doesn't look good.

At this point the possible-probable mafia mayor can just choose to never use it so they dont have to pass it, right?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top