• Smogon Premier League is here and the team collection is now available. Support your team!

NOC Everchanging Mafia - Game thread - Day 6!

genisu said:
like who? literally havent seen anyone besides celever townread vishy
Click to expand...
Bliz and Phoopes
phoopes said:
^not that I agree completely with that, but I think it’s pretty obvious that vishy is noobtown as well. I was suspicious on day one as well but I said before, if vishy was scum their scumchat would’ve told them to stop acting so cryptic and saying “I’m suspicious and bad” etc so that’s why I’m pretty certain vishy is town
Click to expand...
Blizihguh said:
-- Town core --
Vishy Fishy: Obvtown, anyone who seriously suspected this at any point is either smoking something or they're scum lol
Click to expand...
 
Peum said:
ElectricityCat Evie vishy fishy Dead by Daylight genisu would appreciate if everyone made one
Click to expand...

Town
me
Westcraft - I know he would have the easiest time bussing afa, but I don't think a scum tracker would ever out their own partner with that threadstate and how poorly we had solved at that point.
ECat - There's just no way scum posts like ECat has, I refuse to believe that scum would just let poor ECat flounder on his own
pulsar - I legitimately don't see any reason for the scumcase on her? Someone point me to it, otherwise her activity is NAI and stuff like #1615 in her defense are organic in my eyes


Townlean
Peum
genisu

Re-read tier
phoopes
des
Vishy

Scumlean
AirC - I haven't seen much good content from him yet, and stuff like #2076/#1746 just looks like mafia trying to lay low and skate by on thread consensus. The way he was able to deflect attention from his horrendous track on West also makes me ponder whether or not some of his accusers were scum in that scenario. This is my biggest scumread of the game thus far.
Evie - Her scumread on Pulsar feels faked. Sure, you can point at her D1 posting where she ended on a vanity wagon, but it's quite clear that on days where it really mattered, Evie was looking for every chance to jump off the wagon. See #1731 - sure, she does try and get Bliz onto the Pulsar wagon. However, once she realizes that it would be a terrible look if Pulsar flipped town and she was the one pushing her so far (which I think would have happened), she instantly sticks her neck out to try and get off the wagon by offering to vote Bliz. Additionally, past Day 1, the content I've seen has mainly been "being happy" with a Pulsar vote; that is in no way real commitment.
 
Dead by Daylight said:
Town
me
Westcraft - I know he would have the easiest time bussing afa, but I don't think a scum tracker would ever out their own partner with that threadstate and how poorly we had solved at that point.
ECat - There's just no way scum posts like ECat has, I refuse to believe that scum would just let poor ECat flounder on his own
pulsar - I legitimately don't see any reason for the scumcase on her? Someone point me to it, otherwise her activity is NAI and stuff like #1615 in her defense are organic in my eyes


Townlean
Peum
genisu

Re-read tier
phoopes
des
Vishy

Scumlean
AirC - I haven't seen much good content from him yet, and stuff like #2076/#1746 just looks like mafia trying to lay low and skate by on thread consensus. The way he was able to deflect attention from his horrendous track on West also makes me ponder whether or not some of his accusers were scum in that scenario. This is my biggest scumread of the game thus far.
Evie - Her scumread on Pulsar feels faked. Sure, you can point at her D1 posting where she ended on a vanity wagon, but it's quite clear that on days where it really mattered, Evie was looking for every chance to jump off the wagon. See #1731 - sure, she does try and get Bliz onto the Pulsar wagon. However, once she realizes that it would be a terrible look if Pulsar flipped town and she was the one pushing her so far (which I think would have happened), she instantly sticks her neck out to try and get off the wagon by offering to vote Bliz. Additionally, past Day 1, the content I've seen has mainly been "being happy" with a Pulsar vote; that is in no way real commitment.
Click to expand...
you also forgot Pulsar

I would also like to quote something that was said in last games graveyard

" This gameplay sure is something

This is the epitome of Smogon town I guess

Overthinking everything to convince themselves that other townies are actually big brain scum"
 
Dead by Daylight said:
Evie - Her scumread on Pulsar feels faked. Sure, you can point at her D1 posting where she ended on a vanity wagon, but it's quite clear that on days where it really mattered, Evie was looking for every chance to jump off the wagon. See #1731 - sure, she does try and get Bliz onto the Pulsar wagon. However, once she realizes that it would be a terrible look if Pulsar flipped town and she was the one pushing her so far (which I think would have happened), she instantly sticks her neck out to try and get off the wagon by offering to vote Bliz. Additionally, past Day 1, the content I've seen has mainly been "being happy" with a Pulsar vote; that is in no way real commitment.
Click to expand...
Reading the arguments I've gotta chainsaw defense Evie, I cannot defend her d2 vote, but considering that the wagon was " Dead by Daylight, a fairy, pulsar512b, Evie" I dont see how you see it as AI, and the argument about Evie wanting to switch to Bliz is really more worries about the Tie vote, in which in the last game it just meant that there would be no one voted out, and as the main Pulsar wagoner, I feel like Evie didnt want to hop in the wagon until late d3 iirc
 
Peum said:
Reading the arguments I've gotta chainsaw defense Evie, I cannot defend her d2 vote, but considering that the wagon was " Dead by Daylight, a fairy, pulsar512b, Evie" I dont see how you see it as AI, and the argument about Evie wanting to switch to Bliz is really more worries about the Tie vote, in which in the last game it just meant that there would be no one voted out, and as the main Pulsar wagoner, I feel like Evie didnt want to hop in the wagon until late d3 iirc
Click to expand...
d2 wasn't AI, although considering the fact that both wagons were townies and Evie had a fairly consensus scumslot in Pulsar, it would've made sense for her to just push for a pulsar vote there no? the d3 vote is fair, i just find it very odd how evie offered to jump off her #1 scumread's wagon rather than asking, idk, the people on the wagon who were available and itt at that time
 
wait wheres the chainsaw defense?
Peum said:
Reading the arguments I've gotta chainsaw defense Evie, I cannot defend her d2 vote, but considering that the wagon was " Dead by Daylight, a fairy, pulsar512b, Evie" I dont see how you see it as AI, and the argument about Evie wanting to switch to Bliz is really more worries about the Tie vote, in which in the last game it just meant that there would be no one voted out, and as the main Pulsar wagoner, I feel like Evie didnt want to hop in the wagon until late d3 iirc
Click to expand...
 
Dead by Daylight said:
d2 wasn't AI, although considering the fact that both wagons were townies and Evie had a fairly consensus scumslot in Pulsar, it would've made sense for her to just push for a pulsar vote there no?
Click to expand...
This is like a fair argument but i had 5 minutes to read back and place a vote, and of course someone in that situation is gonna place their vote on one of the two wagons they think is scummiest rather than try and lay out a case for a counterwagon
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top