Mario With Lasers
Self-proclaimed NERFED king
We also have to bear in mind it will have a lot less players, simply because it won't be Standard (and having two Standard OUs would have consequences as severe as having two Smogon forums).There is no point in seeing this as a "suspect" ladder, because the very reason for doing it is to appease two groups. There's no intention of using this second ladder to decide "which metagame should go." We have no intention of eventually getting rid of one. Therefore, it's not a suspect ladder, but a completely different metagame.
This is what interests me the most. What would be the initial banlist? B/W's November one + the weather abilities? The current one with the weather abilities and without Manaphy and Blaziken?It'll need Smogon sanction-- and more importantly, it'll need its own suspect test, suspect process, and ultimately, will result in a completely different ban list. This will put a lot of strain for manpower on a staff that's already kind of spread thin, not to mention divide the community in a more sever way...
Just like Sand dominated in ADV and Stealth Rock in DPPt, and yet nothing happened just because people "got sick of it" ?__? While there are people interested in a non-weather metagame, we don't know how many of them there are and setting up the ladder won't help us in finding the real percentage, simply because there is an unknown number people who want non-weather as the Standard (see: people voting to ban weather). It could be that the number of people interested in non-weather as more than a side metagame is as big as the number of those who wanted SR banned in DPPt, or at least in a separate ladder.Considering the severity of this action (considering the above), I'd say there's no point in doing this if we don't go all the way-- if we do it, it should be a metagame truly free of permanent weather abilities. This means hail has to go too, or the whole point of doing it will be largely lost. We'd have a "hail ladder," which would just be dumb (if you don't think so, you haven't had enough chance to fight hail-- hail would be popular and dominant in a meta with no other permanent weather).
This is not about manpower only, but also about its playerbase being worth the effort; I don't think it's going to be pretty if it ends up like PO's official server's Clear Skies ladder.
EDIT-- Well FlareBlitz said what I did but in less words. And how about a poll in DST once we end discussion here?
What's important is that people acknowledge the only "testing" that will be held is whether there is interest in such a ladder or not, not that we find "weather" a suspect in Standard.I absolutely think that we should start off treating this like a suspect test of sorts and, if successful, we may then implement it as a full new metagame.