hex said:You do make the tournament less inclusive by reducing the amount of teams, like by definition you are limiting the amount of people that get into a tournament. Less managers (not as important) get to shine and less people get drafted to show off their skills for future tours (important). We did this for a Monotype tournament tour a few years back and nobody cared about it. The tour was boring because weeks were settled quickly, and the fake elitist take about game quality didn't end up mattering because the people crying for it called the tour shit anyway. No one will ever be satisfied, I promise you. In PUBD II when I managed to finals and a custom was offered in a 6-team tournament, it was way too easy and it felt like a joke. Those outlier teams can end up winning against teams who need to win really bad and it shakes up the playoff race in an interesting way. It makes those teams fighting for survival lock-in regardless of opponent and make a better story for their journey. It's Pokemon and games are probably going to be shit anyway if it's influenced by luck, and players being "good" or "bad" is mostly subjective when it comes to side PLs. Tour players are expected to win and will get drafted the next year anyway even if they flop, and mainers can go either way and many mainers get snubbed in their own tours. So neither are really impacting pool quality. Manager quality is a good shout, there are a lot of pairs that pretty much prevent signups for side tours. You would be shocked at how many DMs I get as a manager-main of people saying they don't want to be on xyz team (I've gotten asked to manage SSPL by a decent amnt of people for this reason. Not trying to shit on that tour, but my point is that this is the only relevant part of your post). Personally, I just sign up to play, and I don't care otherwise, but the concern itself is valid. Forum mods and TLs should just have a harsher vetting process for managers, and stop letting the same lolcow duos run around to every side tour and waste 7 weeks of people's lives. Duration of a tour is nothing burger. If you can't make time for a tournament, then don't sign up. No one is forcing you to play, and to center an entire tournament around your own schedule because you can't make time is selfish. Unless there is a lot of data to reinforce that people want a shorter ZUPL, then sure go for it.
Addendum for some anecdotal stuff, I very much agree with Lettuce. When kDCA Sealoo and I won NDPL, we had a massive roster shift in W5. That roster shift ended up paying off big time and we ended up winning the tour because we were able to find our groove even as late as that. You nullify that chance when the tour is so short and force teams to basically pray everyone does well within the first 2-3 weeks with not much room for error. In PUCL, my team lost Weeks 1 & 2 miserably. A lot of luck was involved. After that we didn't drop a single week and went on to win the tournament. If that was another 5 week tour, everyones motivation would've died because we would've had such a low margin for error. You do not win a Pokemon tournament without getting lucky, team or individual. No need to exacerbate that.
Sorry for the long post, but I really love playing ZU whenever I'm given the chance and have been playing it for a decent amount of time atp in various tours, so figured I'd say something even if I'm somewhat of a tourist. This just seems like a fixing what isn't broken proposal for the sake of fake quality. We're not playing for money or gaining any attention on social media for winning such a tournament. Never understood elitism outside of SCL/SPL
Very nice post. I agree with some stuff and would probably agree with everything if we weren't talking about ZU/ZUPL, which in my perception you might be misunderstanding the intentions of this change and lacking some information about how our tournaments usually go.
To preface, you mention a lot of your experiences with Monotype and PU, which are valid to bring across the board but mostly as addendums imo. I get that you speak in a tone more of separating officials (SCL/SPL) to non officials / subforum stuff, but I don't think that's a very precise way of elaborating on this. There is a very large gap in interest numbers between UUPL and PUPL for example, and so there is one between PUPL and ZUPL or MPL and ZUPL.
Now I'll be answering your arguments individually.
hex said:You do make the tournament less inclusive by reducing the amount of teams, like by definition you are limiting the amount of people that get into a tournament. Less managers (not as important) get to shine and less people get drafted to show off their skills for future tours (important).
Yeah thinking only on the number of people playing per week, that would be correct. The second part though? ZUPL is supposed to be the most prestigious and of highest level ZU team tournament, and unlike other metagame PLs, it does not work simultaneously as a stair for officials. I can relate: I was the tournament's overall MVP last year and that isn't really something you can use to get into officials like you possibly could in some other metagame PL. Yes, I was playing an oldgen, but let's not larp like a good ZUPL SV record would put someone in SCL. Therefore, this seems like a non issue for me.
hex said:Tour players are expected to win and will get drafted the next year anyway even if they flop, and mainers can go either way and many mainers get snubbed in their own tours.
I really don't think this is true.
When I asked people to name names on snubs for last ZUCL, in which they were complaining 8 slots created some:
Spoiler: he did not name names
Meth Master, a regular, then answered me talking about himself (fair) and Praise the Salt (I don't really know much or see this guy in tournaments a lot but he's a regular). I actually had Meth Master as a sub in my plans but in VC during the auction people were asking for other people and yeah you know how it goes. I thought someone else would for sure pick them up, though. Note that ZUCL was a 8 teams tour but with 8 slots. IMO it was very superior to ZUPL hard in game quality terms, so I do not think the quality talk is entirely fake, and the few snubs people could even name were more results of bad managers drafting rather than anything else.
tl;dr: snubs are produced by people drafting badly, not by not having enough spots, and I can really only affirm on methmaster of these two.
As for tour players getting drafted again even if they flop: Not sure either, I guess it all depends on how much they cared and their results site wide from an year to another. I'd be happy to draft again some who played for me and didn't have a great record because they were getting themselves decently involved and trying to win for the team, but I also wouldn't touch again others who seemed they couldn't care less.
hex said:Forum mods and TLs should just have a harsher vetting process for managers, and stop letting the same lolcow duos run around to every side tour and waste 7 weeks of people's lives.
This is impossible when you barely get eight teams and still want to do eight teams. There is no way to filter whatsoever. ZUPL usually gets like 9-10 but like of these usually 3-4 feel either very very novice, or tour players who have quite literally never interacted within the tier and don't have notable success as managers elsewhere. You need to reduce the numbers of spots for a pickier filtering to happen.
hex said:Duration of a tour is nothing burger. If you can't make time for a tournament, then don't sign up. No one is forcing you to play, and to center an entire tournament around your own schedule because you can't make time is selfish. Unless there is a lot of data to reinforce that people want a shorter ZUPL, then sure go for it.
I'm far from being the only one here. I get that you're speaking in general and not about me at all but if you search for "6x10" "5 weeks" or "6 teams",in the ZU discord, or if you just ask them, you'll see a lot of people in favor, a lot of which are some of the best managers or pool mainstays. In fact, I made it clear that I'm playing regardless of this
As a disclaimer so people don't think I'm nitpicking: I have no answer to the lineup adjustments thing you can do with 8 teams, I think those are still very possible with 6 (not sure if you would remember about Olympiad 3, in which Michael Jordan started as a sub for our team but started playing in week 3 to the playoffs iirc.) But yeah like you can obviously be more patient if it's 8 teams. For the playoffs race, yes eight teams has the potential to be more fun, but for ZUPL I don't really see a difference when, as I already stated, you often have two teams out by the end of week 5 or week 6. So week 7 is in practice with the same stakes of a week 5 of a 6-team tour.
Ultimately, I appreciate you coming here to post your opinion and perspectives. Seems more about you thinking the cons of six teams outweight the pros and I see it as the opposite, which is fair and we can agree to disagree.