I agree with all of this, "but" this should be the reason that Nintendo either allows legal hacks or actually enforces the No-Tolerance Policy they were so willing to bend in the case of Alakapimp. And "but" is in quotes there because it should really be "and", but this is obviously not the case. I don't know how you can have it both ways in a national tournaments that many, many families (mingot's daughter didn't drive herself to STL) have to devote an incredible amount of time (Omega had to drive 3100 miles roundtrip for Nashville) and money (airfare, fuel, and an unspeakable amount of "etcs" like $200 for a new tire in OD's case).
We're great fans, and we are willing to go to extremes just to play. So yes, I agree with you. People do crazy things to get to places like this.
It is therefore an absolute crock of shit that a person can be disqualified for having 999 pokéballs in their bag (this happened at JAA) but that another person can talk their way out of an instance of hacking in 512 EVs that actually has competitive implications. If Alakapimp were a girl I would actually suspect some kind of sexual favors had to have been offered in exchange for leniency, and the only reason I'd hesitate to say something like that is I wouldn't want anyone to think that I am even remotely joking or saying it for shock value on the internet. Shoddy or Netbattle tournaments or ladder ratings may not be a big deal at the end of the day, and "it's just a game" can apply to any suspicions that a tourament may not have been run fairly. This does not apply to national tournaments where you have to spend hundreds of dollars and give up countless hours of your time to just advance to the next round. This isn't "just a game" when you're talking about that kind of money, that kind of time, and thousands of dollars in prizes and free trips as rewards. And that is why I am beyond disappointed in Nintendo's handling of the only Official tournaments they've held in the past three years, and why many of you should be too.
I always hated the way Official Pokemon tournaments were actually held. I liked the competitors and the prizes, but I agree with you on Nintendo/TPCi's handling of "Official Tournaments". Everything should be strict or lenient, not some and some. If a person is DQ'ed for 999 pokeballs, someone with 512 EVs (that's divisible by 4, thus giving illegal stats) should also get DQ'ed. If they allowed Alakapimp to move one, they should let everyone who used legal hacks to move on.
For the sake of this "rant", I'm willing to overlook Nintendo's insistence upon having their tournaments as doubles only with virtually no exception. I'm willing to ignore the fact that hundreds of families had to drive for hours for Regionals, only to be turned away at the door because of a random entry process they could do nothing about. Willing maybe to excuse the stringent Lv. 50 requirement set in place even though the cartridges have the ability to autolevel pokemon in local battles. I'm even willing to forget the fact that, after all, players weren't sent away before getting a "Shiny Nintendo Milotic" that most certainly does not almost completely defeat the entire purpose of having a shiny that is supposed to be "rare". Because this surely doesn't also ironically underscore my main point about hacking and legitimacy and how much that actually matters to competitive pokémon.
This sounds like sarcasm, but you just pointed out all the bad points. I can't think of much to say here.
But if people really wanted some different colored UU pokemon they could have just hacked it themselves, exactly like Nintendo did. And it is beyond ridiculous to think that a shiny you hacked means enough to offset countless hours driven and countless miles traveled and countless dollars spent towards your competition, but that 999 pokéballs is enough for you to disqualify someone from your competition when it doesn't have any bearing on the actual competition. Especially because this says nothing of the countless hours of effort and thought we need to create a legitimate and great team in the first place that will pass your hack-check test so that we *might* get into your tourney.
Nintendo thinks Shinies are everyone's most desired type of pokemon, especially looking at how people hack just to get them. 999 pokeballs don't have any bearing on the competition, and they actually can be obtained. People spends long amounts of time to prepare for this tournament, so they deserve to see the fruits of their labor.
Seriously, think about it:
Hey, would-be entrants in this Official tourney! You didn't get in because of our computer's RNG, and there's no way we could have orchestrated this part before you drove all the way up here, but here's some intangible pixels we hacked up to comfort you on your five-hour drive back!
Better luck next year—hope we don't hold this event two hours farther from you than we did this time! Oh, but if you're lucky enough to get in next year, if we find out that you have 300 Antidotes or 500 Shell Bells in your bag, you're disqualified! Only we're allowed to hack things that don't even remotely matter with regard to our competition.
This is possibly one of the closest portrayals of Nintendo in pokemon.
The worst thing is that I even have to post about it because it takes away from the amazing efforts of people like OmegaDonut, ipl, and the rest of our fantastic competitors, Smogoners or not. But this needs to be said. The kind of hypocrisy that would allow Alakapimp and his 512 EV pokemon to continue on for the shot a hundreds and hundreds of dollars' worth of prizes and incalculable fame but disqualify someone for having too much of an item that can't even be mass-sold to allow you to buy other items that might help you competitively is mind-boggling, beyond unfair, and should annoy everyone who actually cares about these tournaments.
It annoys me that hypocrisy occurs even in a sturctured environment like this. I really do care for these tournaments, mainly because of the the prizes, the fame, and most importantly, the ability to be with pokemon fans and battlers in real life. I've been wanting to enter an Official tournament ever since JAA, when I didn't preregister for it.
I implore any of you to tell me if I have missed something (yes, even you FiveKRunner). Correct me if I didn't state something factual or was unduly harsh. But please tell me why Smogon or anyone should continue to look up to Nintendo's tournaments as respectable or fair or at the very least even remotely worth the time they want us to put in by not making legal hacks that will pass hack tests. I am *this* close to actually encouraging legal hacks to be created and freely traded through Smogon Wifi, because I will be damned if our Smogoners should have to waste any time making their pokemon legitimately if they don't want to when it very literally does not matter even if you admit to it. I honestly cannot think of a bigger reason than Nintendo itself looking the other way on an actual illegal hack, when they evidently run the only tournaments that matter, to have us as a community finally stop thinking legitimacy and painstaking breeding and training even matter at all as far as competitive battling is concerned.
I think it's worth the time for not using legal hacks if you feel good about yourself by doing something that few others can do without hacks, If you're in for the tournament, however, legal hacks should be allowed. Of course, people will abuse the ability to use legal hacks.