My bad, A+Isn't Beedrill already A?
My bad, A+Isn't Beedrill already A?
The biggest reason is of course Mega Aerodactyl, who beats it pretty handily 80% of the time (really, GameFreak? Fighting gets fucking Close Combat on top of all its other moves and the strongest physical Rock move with perfect accuracy is Smack Down?)(I totally forgot that No Guard applies to Aero's attacks as well, meaning that Stone Edge will always land), as well as being unable to use Mega Aero yourself, which is either the best Pokemon in the tier or in the top three. Meanwhile, 83/80/80 bulk leaves a lot to be desired when you consider Normal/Flying typing because Mega Pidgeot resists exactly zero priority in the tier, and Mamoswine's drop especially means that sweet sweet 121 Base Speed stat isn't as valuable as it really needs to be. Jolly LO Ice Shard has a 31.3% chance to KO stock with JUST Rocks. Adamant bumps that up to 87.5. That's mostly what I've got to say about Pidgeot for the time being. Keep it A+.
, but less effective STABs, significantly worse bulk (seriously, Mamoswine does nearly the same amount with a now neutral Ice Shard), no immunities, and a reliance on Protect which causes some 4MSS. Keep it A.
It's not as effective in checking physical threats as Qwilfish is, which is where they traditionally compete, but its tremendous speed for a wall is massively useful. Funnily enough, its presence in the tier is pretty much the lone reason to run Jolly on Tyrantrum, who otherwise would prefer to run Adamant on its Band set, as well as threatening Honchkrow (all the other 100 Base Speed defensive Pokemon have gone to OU), but it being in the tier and a possible threat is pretty huge. Its special bulk is also tremendous, so while its special resistances aren't anything to sneeze at, it can take a lot of neutral special attacks, while only slightly being hindered by its lack of reliable recovery. There's also the bonus of punishing Trick users with Black Sludge. Since Starmie's departure a few months back it's also now the fastest spinner by a rather significant margin, and it is both threatened by and threatens the new toy, Mamoswine. You get KO'd if Mamoswine so much as looks in your direction funny, but it can't switch in for fear of Scald, and should you run some speed to differentiate yourself from Qwilfish (which I would try if I could stand to use stall/semi-stall, where I feel Tentacruel is best used) YOU could potentially switch in on Mamoswine and then force it out with Scald. Not that they'd be expecting speedy Tentacruel, but that's half the fun of so much natural speed on a defensive Pokemon. Keep it A.
HJK being unreliable (this is what happens when you strive for statistical rigor across several hundred players, some of them get all the misses) on top of REALLY bad bulk (you thought Midgeot was bad? Say hello to 65/60/60) means Mienshao isn't pulling as much weight as he used to. I realize I may sound like a broken record with all the schtuff about Mamoswine, but 1) He's like my third favorite Pokemon, and 2) His presence REALLY shakes up the tier Seriously, STAB Ice Shard off 130 Attack is bonkers in UU. Remember what I said about HJK being unreliable? Well, if you DO miss, that Ice Shard that just flew out first is gonna do a minimum of 47%, so if you switched in on Rocks you just lost your Mienshao. Mienshao still hits super hard, but ONLY with HJK, and his mono-Fighting typing is more a curse than a blessing. He's the ONLY mono-Fighting-type in the tier, every other Fighting-type has that sweet secondary STAB or fantastic additional coverage they can use to help get rid of shit that would normally wall them. Frankly, Mienshao's coverage kinda sucks. Not in that he has necessarily poor type coverage (though he's no Infernape), but none of it really hits that hard. Drop it to A.
One last note about Pidgeot, but also about the tier in general: A lot of users seem to have the idea that a check should operate like a counter. Saturday I got into a bit of an argument with people over PDef Umbreon used as a check to SD Gatr. Simply put, it's a pretty bad check. Most any prior damage and Rocks and you lose your Umbreon without even getting that crucial +2 Foul Play off. Meanwhile, there's a metric fuckton of Pokemon that threaten Feraligatr if his speed isn't boosted and simply don't care about Aqua Jet. The tier is slowly becoming more offensively inclined, and defensive answers are becoming less satisfactory. So yes, Mega Aero takes a big chunk from Hurricane, and yes, confusion hax is a thing. But that's why the definition of a check is a free switch is given. If Aero was a counter then it would readily switch in on Hurricane. Hey, sometimes it still will. But more often than not whatever is least needed in the match will eat the Hurricane and THEN switch into Aero and force Pidgeot out, or KO it. Aero, probably the best Pokemon in the tier, checks Pidgeot 100% of the time and even counters it about 70% of the time. That's enough to keep it out of S.
I lied about that being the last note. Has anyone read Pidgeot's UU dex entry recently? They claim it outspeeds Noivern. Who knew 121 > 123?
EDIT: Fuck, that got wall-of-text-y. Sorry.
The biggest reason is of course Mega Aerodactyl, who beats it pretty handily 80% of the time (really, GameFreak? Fighting gets fucking Close Combat on top of all its other moves and the strongest physical Rock move with perfect accuracy is Smack Down?)(I totally forgot that No Guard applies to Aero's attacks as well, meaning that Stone Edge will always land), as well as being unable to use Mega Aero yourself, which is either the best Pokemon in the tier or in the top three. Meanwhile, 83/80/80 bulk leaves a lot to be desired when you consider Normal/Flying typing because Mega Pidgeot resists exactly zero priority in the tier, and Mamoswine's drop especially means that sweet sweet 121 Base Speed stat isn't as valuable as it really needs to be. Jolly LO Ice Shard has a 31.3% chance to KO stock with JUST Rocks. Adamant bumps that up to 87.5. That's mostly what I've got to say about Pidgeot for the time being. Keep it A+.
but with less effective STABs, significantly worse bulk (seriously, Mamoswine does nearly the same amount with a now neutral Ice Shard), no immunities, and a reliance on Protect which causes some 4MSS. Keep it A.
It's not as effective in checking physical threats as Qwilfish is, which is where they traditionally compete, but its tremendous speed for a wall is massively useful. Funnily enough, its presence in the tier is pretty much the lone reason to run Jolly on Tyrantrum, who otherwise would prefer to run Adamant on its Band set, as well as threatening Honchkrow (all the other 100 Base Speed defensive Pokemon have gone to OU), but it being in the tier and a possible threat is pretty huge. Its special bulk is also tremendous, so while its special resistances aren't anything to sneeze at, it can take a lot of neutral special attacks, while only slightly being hindered by its lack of reliable recovery. There's also the bonus of punishing Trick users with Black Sludge. Since Starmie's departure a few months back it's also now the fastest spinner by a rather significant margin, and it is both threatened by and threatens the new toy, Mamoswine. You get KO'd if Mamoswine so much as looks in your direction funny, but it can't switch in for fear of Scald, and should you run some speed to differentiate yourself from Qwilfish (which I would try if I could stand to use stall/semi-stall, where I feel Tentacruel is best used) YOU could potentially switch in on Mamoswine and then force it out with Scald. Not that they'd be expecting speedy Tentacruel, but that's half the fun of so much natural speed on a defensive Pokemon. Keep it A.
HJK being unreliable (this is what happens when you strive for statistical rigor across several hundred players, some of them get all the misses) on top of REALLY bad bulk (you thought Midgeot was bad? Say hello to 65/60/60) means Mienshao isn't pulling as much weight as he used to. I realize I may sound like a broken record with all the schtuff about Mamoswine, but 1) He's like my third favorite Pokemon, and 2) His presence REALLY shakes up the tier Seriously, STAB Ice Shard off 130 Attack is bonkers in UU. Remember what I said about HJK being unreliable? Well, if you DO miss, that Ice Shard that just flew out first is gonna do a minimum of 47%, so if you switched in on Rocks you just lost your Mienshao. Mienshao still hits super hard, but ONLY with HJK, and his mono-Fighting typing is more a curse than a blessing. He's the ONLY mono-Fighting-type in the tier, every other Fighting-type has that sweet secondary STAB or fantastic additional coverage they can use to help get rid of shit that would normally wall them. Frankly, Mienshao's coverage kinda sucks. Not in that he has necessarily poor type coverage (though he's no Infernape), but none of it really hits that hard. Drop it to A.
One last note about Pidgeot, but also about the tier in general: A lot of users seem to have the idea that a check should operate like a counter. Saturday I got into a bit of an argument with people over PDef Umbreon used as a check to SD Gatr. Simply put, it's a pretty bad check. Most any prior damage and Rocks and you lose your Umbreon without even getting that crucial +2 Foul Play off. Mind you, this was brought up as one of the few checks to SD Gatr. Meanwhile, there's a metric fuckton of Pokemon that threaten Feraligatr if his speed isn't boosted and simply don't care about Aqua Jet. The tier is slowly becoming more offensively inclined, and defensive answers are becoming less satisfactory. So yes, Mega Aero takes a big chunk from Hurricane, and yes, confusion hax is a thing. But that's why the definition of a check is a free switch is given. If Aero was a counter then it would readily switch in on Hurricane. Hey, sometimes it still will. But more often than not whatever is least needed in the match will eat the Hurricane and THEN switch into Aero and force Pidgeot out, or KO it. Aero, probably the best Pokemon in the tier, checks Pidgeot 100% of the time and even counters it about 70% of the time. That's enough to keep it out of S.
I lied about that being the last note. Has anyone read Pidgeot's UU dex entry recently? They claim it outspeeds Noivern. Who knew 121 > 123?
EDIT: Fuck, that got wall-of-text-y. Sorry.
Because Aero is a way more threatening Pokemon in general than Suicune is. If Suicune could, in addition to what it normally does, act as an offensive check as well as defensive, lay down Rocks, Defog hazards, have recovery outside of Rest, use Taunt, and outspeed the entire unboosted tier, than yeah, boot Aero right the fuck out of S. But it doesn't. And no, Aero is not "just as vulnerable to priority". Aerodactyl has better bulk in general as well as carrying that crucial ESpeed resist.
I like your double standard of supporting Pidgeot with team members but not supporting Aero. Your opinion that Pidgeot has as little risk and as high of reward as Aero is wrong. Even on Aero's most one dimensional set, Hone Claws, it can pull multiple roles. Pidgeot does its job of "Fuck the opposition with No Guard Hurricane" VERY well, but that's all it does. It has neither the bulk nor the typing to act as even a decent switch-in except on immunities, and its support movepool consists of Tailwind. Aerodactyl is the better Pokemon and unless you want to implement an S+ rank then Pidgeot should stay in A+. And what the fuck is wrong with rehashing what IB said, he's RIGHT and treading over this ground again is relatively pointless. For the record, Aero is a safe switch-in because it resists Pidgeot's two best moves and if we're going to assume Rocks on Aero's side of the field then I'm sure as shit assuming Rocks on Pidgeot's side, and Pidgeot is put in a way worse position if it switches in on Rocks multiple times. Aero can Roost on Entei's Extreme Speed, Pidgeot cannot.
One last thing about Aero vs. Pidgeot that I'd like to bring up: Why does Aero have so fucking many checks and counters as you say and it finds itself in S yet Pidgeot has significantly fewer and has been A+ for so long? I want you to consider the implications of that before YOU rehash the same arguments again.
It's not as effective in checking physical threats as Qwilfish is, which is where they traditionally compete, but its tremendous speed for a wall is massively useful. Funnily enough, its presence in the tier is pretty much the lone reason to run Jolly on Tyrantrum, who otherwise would prefer to run Adamant on its Band set, as well as threatening Honchkrow (all the other 100 Base Speed defensive Pokemon have gone to OU), but it being in the tier and a possible threat is pretty huge. Its special bulk is also tremendous, so while its special resistances aren't anything to sneeze at, it can take a lot of neutral special attacks, while only slightly being hindered by its lack of reliable recovery. There's also the bonus of punishing Trick users with Black Sludge. Since Starmie's departure a few months back it's also now the fastest spinner by a rather significant margin, and it is both threatened by and threatens the new toy, Mamoswine. You get KO'd if Mamoswine so much as looks in your direction funny, but it can't switch in for fear of Scald, and should you run some speed to differentiate yourself from Qwilfish (which I would try if I could stand to use stall/semi-stall, where I feel Tentacruel is best used) YOU could potentially switch in on Mamoswine and then force it out with Scald. Not that they'd be expecting speedy Tentacruel, but that's half the fun of so much natural speed on a defensive Pokemon. Keep it A.
Alright no reason to get this heated over simple viability rankings, which are after all completely subjective. Any further posts that don't actually discuss viability are gonna be deleted.
Here are a couple nominations that have come up in the council discussion that we'd like to see some more thoughts on: Mega Pidgeot to S, Mega Beedrill to A, Tentacruel to A-, Mienshao to A. Anything relevant about Sceptile has probably already been stated at this point so we should move on from that and the VR council will have a decision on that next time we make changes. Of course you're still welcome to nominate and discuss other things, such as Snorlax to A+.
The only thing Stoutland Had for it was sandrush, and with Hippodown Leaving, its absolutly terrible in UuNew Meta
Some things to think about:
Espeon: With Alakazam gone, the urge for a fast offensive psychic type allows room for espeon to get more use. Of coarse Alakazam had some really good niches over espeon such as FB and encore, but Espeon does tend to fill some of its roles along with providing a team with Magic bounce support.
Stoutland: Pretty much medicore. Moving down is inevitable.
Mega Abomasnow: This one is tricky. On one hand people might be using slowcloak Mamo where Aboma might see some more usage. On the other hand, Mamo is a go to for ice shard as it doesnt require a mega slot and has a powerful stab EQ. Both have great niches in the meta. I just dont know if Mamo will bring it up or allow to see no usage.
[/URL][/IMG]
[/URL][/IMG]![]()
![]()
Clawitzer from Unranked to at least C
I have used Clawitzer and I can firmly say that it is a Pokemon that never lets me down. It gets great coverage with all of its pulse moves which are boosted by Mega Launcher to get powered up to a respectable amount. Clawitzer has never let me down in terms of power. The only problem I can see is it not being to bulky and its saddening speed. This is why I think Clawitzer should at leastbe C-rank though I think it could be B-.