Maximum Carnage Mafia - Avengers Win! (As well as Pidge and tredge)

I would wait just a little longer. Yes I believe DCJ is very suspicious; however, I feel that lynching him because he holds the pumpkin bomb isn't the best idea. It would prove his case, but we may need that item at a later date. For the time being, I will hold off my vote; however, DCJ would be the person I would lynch at this moment.
 
Yes, but now that the pumpkin bomb is public knowledge, the mafia will target DCJ at night in order to obtain it. Basically, if we lynch DCJ, the worst that happens is we lose a pumpkin bomb, which we may lose at night anyways. Right now, even if you believe DCJ is innocent, the best action is still probably to lynch him. Therefore, lynch DCJ.
 
That is true. It does make sense, unless we can target it for ourselves (but I don't know if we have thieves amongst the Carnage-allied villagers) So to delay the lynch, I will hold off changing my vote, but unless another target comes up, I will lynch DCJ
 
I'm actually more convinced we need to lynch DCJ now, just to destroy the pumpkin bomb. The only way to keep it away from the mafia would be for him to give it to a villager at the end of the day, and who would he give it too? Reach's kidnapped, and macle's still suspicious, and there's really no other candidate to hold the item. The possibility of a village thief is there, but A) the thief would need to out himself now to stop voting against DCJ to destroy the bomb, and B) the thief would need higher priority than the mafias' thiefs, and would need a way to avoid getting hooked.

If the mafia gets the bomb, that's REALLY bad news. If the village ends up with it, well, if the village ever gets in a situation where we need to strategically use the bomb, we're screwed anyway.

If DCJ is lying, we lynch him. If he's telling the truth, we need to destroy the bomb now. I actually believe DCJ is (mostly) telling the truth right now, but I'm still voting against him. My logic makes sense to me.

Of course. A better candidate changes everything.
 
bleh

I am still not sure if DCJ is mafia or not, but I think that lynching him to get rid of the pumpkin bomb is better than mafia getting it (which they will), and I think that if DCJ WERE village, he would agree also. This is an aspect we haven't talked about yet.

besides, a lynchproof silencer doesn't sound good for the village right now anyway.
 
You know, I think macle would appreciate it if we respected his wishes and hold off on lynching DCJ...it's not like DCJ is going to run off if we don't lynch him quickly enough.
 
Dusk 1

As the day goes on you slowly find a suitable target to lynch. However, as it goes on it becomes clear that you have decided to make DCJ an enemy. As you get rid to lynch (read: KILL (read: mortally wound so he goes to the hospital so he can no longer play in the game)), a bright flash and smoke appear. It appears that DCJ threw a Pumpkin Bomb. When the smoke had gone, he was no where to be seen.

However, after you go home (read: Break into a random person's home and take it over for the night) and watch the news, disturbing information for those allied with Carnage is on the TV. It appears that Anachronism had been captured with a Vacuum Cleaner!

Dear Anachronism,

Sandman_Large.jpg


You are The Sandman. You are one of Spider-Man's more reluctant villains, usually committing crimes only to help your family. Recently, your daughter has become ill again, and you have been promised enough money to help her if you join the Sinister Twelve.

At night, you may send a PM to RB Golbat and Dubulous titled "Night x - Sending Grains of Sand After <user>". You will have some of your grains of sand follow this user during the night, learning their full role PM by the time day breaks.

You win if The Sinister Twelve eliminate all unfriendly threats.
Click to expand...

To make matters worse, Reachzero was still missing. Nonetheless, as you put down the remote, you prepare to leave the house to preform your villainous deeds for the night.

Night 1. 48 hours or all PMs.
 
DCJ is clean, but crap on Anachronism. We could have used him.

I have a theory on his death. What if the mafia can capture/kill people during the daytime, like normal superheroes? This would explain Anachronism's sudden death
 
One has to keep in mind that an lynch-proofing item is really only good for the mafia/wolf. For all we know, DCJ might have stolen the goblin bomb n0 and decided to fake claim as the Green Goblin. The Green Goblin might also be a false claim for the wolf, so don't go on immediately thinking that DCJ is clean even though he had the bomb. At least we have an item that could be used against us out of the way. I'll be on IRC 'till 11:00 p.m. if you wish to contact me.
 
Wth? How did that happen? :-(

DCJ may not be perfectly clean. But it's hard to imagine anyone other than the green goblin with the pumpkin bomb. And it's hard to imagine the green goblin on any team with spiderman. It's possible, but at this point I think DCJ is at the leased more clean than average.

edit: gf makes good points
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top