I wont try and argue too much, but Swoobat has great speed, a usable in-game special attack, and is a godsend against the multitude of fighting and bug types you run into. I never bothered with Pidove, so I'm not exactly sure how it fairs in compairison, but the psychic typing was far more beneficial than it ever was hindering. I'm not saying it was the most super-fabulous pokemon, but it was a lot more helpful playing through than Munna ever was. Maybe I just got lucky, but I swear, it definitely pulled it's weight.
I will say, that I expect the same fate for Pidove/Unfezant as Swoobat against Marshal though; while it seems like a good idea, pretty much every pokemon he has knows stone-edge, and lemme tell you, I never saw it miss. Maybe once if you're lucky.
And you say Whimsicott doesn't kill things fast, but I'll tell you, he kills things extremely effeciantly, even when faced with poor type match-ups. Mine had Giga Drain and Big Root, so even if they did manage to get a hit off after parattract, it was often pretty inconsequential. You say risky at best, but I promise, even if they got to attack through infatuation, and stun-spore missed, I was still in a possition to pull of an easy KO.
It swept a lot of trainers, including gym leaders and those of a distinctly higher level, with little to no difficulty, items, or switching(to the point where I stopped using it for a while to give my other pokes a chance to level); which I think qualify as top-tier.
I will say, that I expect the same fate for Pidove/Unfezant as Swoobat against Marshal though; while it seems like a good idea, pretty much every pokemon he has knows stone-edge, and lemme tell you, I never saw it miss. Maybe once if you're lucky.
And you say Whimsicott doesn't kill things fast, but I'll tell you, he kills things extremely effeciantly, even when faced with poor type match-ups. Mine had Giga Drain and Big Root, so even if they did manage to get a hit off after parattract, it was often pretty inconsequential. You say risky at best, but I promise, even if they got to attack through infatuation, and stun-spore missed, I was still in a possition to pull of an easy KO.
It swept a lot of trainers, including gym leaders and those of a distinctly higher level, with little to no difficulty, items, or switching(to the point where I stopped using it for a while to give my other pokes a chance to level); which I think qualify as top-tier.