Postgame Acid City's Trouble [Day 4/End: City Win! 4/10 Players]

Blazade said:
Looking at the Dulla thing, you have to wonder why she's alive at this point. If she isn't scum she's an excellent NK target. So that leaves a few possibilities:

1) She's scum and woulnmt be NKed

2) She was protected by someone who read her as Power

3) She was left alive by the scum as prime mislynch bait.

In case 3 I think Jalmont looks pretty bad but it's tough to read this situation and Dulla could be a good lynch

Ullar there doesn't have to be a teansporter lol. Also at this point if we'rehaving specific roles claim we may as well go balls deep and get everyone out there. We can still scumhunt a bit and I've got a nice townblock lined up though so none of that should be necessary.
Click to expand...

What? I don't understand why you are confused as to why Dulla is alive lol. Like first off, there's only been one night of killing, and second off why on earth would Dulla be an excellent nK target? That legit makes no sense to me unless I am really missing something (like Dulla is the warden or whatever).

It's still possible for Blazade to be bad right? Given that it would block Blazade's ability? So I don't think we can just write that off as a possibility.
 
jalmomt' said:
What? I don't understand why you are confused as to why Dulla is alive lol. Like first off, there's only been one night of killing, and second off why on earth would Dulla be an excellent nK target? That legit makes no sense to me unless I am really missing something (like Dulla is the warden or whatever).

It's still possible for Blazade to be bad right? Given that it would block Blazade's ability? So I don't think we can just write that off as a possibility.
Click to expand...

It seems like the same posts that made me an obvious Lynch target to you make me a great night kill read to blazade. Also it is true that we can not rule out blazade being bad.

EDITed becausen my phone hates me and turned the qquote into a huge mess of mis formatted and double quoted nastiness
 
Jalmont said:
What? I don't understand why you are confused as to why Dulla is alive lol. Like first off, there's only been one night of killing, and second off why on earth would Dulla be an excellent nK target? That legit makes no sense to me unless I am really missing something (like Dulla is the warden or whatever).

It's still possible for Blazade to be bad right? Given that it would block Blazade's ability? So I don't think we can just write that off as a possibility.
Click to expand...

If Dulla isn't scum she's citizen power (which we now know is warden) or protective, either of which is a good choice for a night kill.

I'm trying to read whether she was left alive for lynching or scum to begin with. I'm not shocked she's alive, just wondering why.

I'm not bad here lol. My ability was blocked but this was at the beginning of the night so the scumteam would have obviously put the kill on the other guy. Me being jailed doesn't better explain the lack of a NK in any way. Again look at D1 where the tone is lazy bandwagoning. I'm trying to play the game by pushing lynches and reading reactions and if you think Ullar reads genuine for his behavior today then I should read just as genuine as well.
 
so I'm going to go on and say Dulla/Blazade (those are the right players?) are both 2good for this town and scum hunted the hell out of eachother, yah? if this were OC Mafia I'd nominate them for town leaders, but as such, nope. if anybody wants to follow up on a few of the previous NLs, my NL is the only one. gg.
 
Blazade said:
If Dulla isn't scum she's citizen power (which we now know is warden) or protective, either of which is a good choice for a night kill.

I'm trying to read whether she was left alive for lynching or scum to begin with. I'm not shocked she's alive, just wondering why.
Click to expand...

what how do we know this again. looks like i completely missed this part because i don't recall a claim of any sort ?_?
 
Yeah I can vote this for now. Enough people are obvtown that it's really hard for acidphoenix to be.

/vote acidphoenix

Time to post. I can also see arguments to lynch Dulla, Jalmont, or B_T but we need more discussion right now.

After realizing what I did about Dulla and pressing her on D1 I'm inclined to believe she breaks on the town side of that line but it is a very risky call so I want to hear what other people think.

Jalmont voting Dulla looks bad if she's a mislynch but more inportantly I don't think he's actively trying to figure things out the way he's been posting recently.

B_T had a lax attitude about yesterday's lynch and has yet to contribute anything of substance.

If you want me to explain my townreads I can but I think a lot of those are clear/something I've said before. Keep in mind a town read is not too far off from a neut read at this point in the game but the neut may not even be harmful lol
 
Of my townreads I'm probably most nervous about DLE because his read is probably the most behavior over evidence based. I'm curious what he thinks of the people I mentioned
 
Votes: (2.3)

Jalmont (2) - Dullagamur, ButteredToast.
Acidphoenix (1) - Jalmont.
Blazade (1) - AcidPhoenix.
No-Lynch (1) - Shubaka17.

Currently, Jalmont is in danger of lynching at the end of the day because of being voted first in majority.
 
Last edited:
Blazade said:
B_T had a lax attitude about yesterday's lynch and has yet to contribute anything of substance.
Click to expand...

There is no topic of discussion for me to contribute on. I've read everything and I have got nothing to say. We have four things that happened so far to talk about and each is pretty cut and dry...

1) King_ got mislynched. Oops. Seemed like a decent lynch target and we needed to lynch someone. Is that lax though? No. Day one lynches are feel lynches and not result driven. I was fine with going for him and I'm not questioning my decision. Sorry it ended up not going our way. Results wise from the lynch, there idn't really seem like there was much of a bandwagon in the least. DLE, Blazade, Ullar, Acidpheonix, Jalmont and myself were all in it in the last moments, though blazeade dropped out. Doesn't really tell me much game wise. I'd assume mafia would be weary of jumping on the lynch together anyways to avoid being on the lynch, but it was also a safe lynch to jump on as it wasn't seriously challenged by anyone. And when the top town reads were on the lynch.

2) The blazade and ullar thing which ended up being put on the backburner pending future results.

3) Jalmont being weird and refusing to explain himself after the day started in the middle of the blazade/ullar thing, which is dumb from numerous perspectives.

4) Shubaka subbing in for jumpluff, which was weird that it happened so quickly after jumpluff said he'd be on later and said nothing. Might be that more was being said in a mafia chat about his activity, but from ground level where I'm standing it looks weird.

The acid lynch on activity is as silly as any day one lynch on activity. If you want something, we're better off letting Walrein sub in for him and going off of that. You guys who are voting for inactive makes me think you're going for the easiest "anyone but me" lynch which screams scum.

That's all we got right now to really talk about. With Jalmont seemingly giving up caring, we're on an island with half the game being inactive and the other half seeming town and swimming in circles.
 
oh oops i need to not totally forget to post here

I annoyingly am being forced to get a bed, may start a post on mobile, but if I don't will do so tomorrow morning

at the very least i will read the thread on mobile before going to bed

i literally haven't read anything d2 so no i can't give you particular rando reads right now
 
If I may weigh in on Jumpluff/Shubaka subbing, there was stuff goin on in PMs which I don't think I can disclose? Like even disclosing there bein stuff in PMs might get me GodKilled? idk man. Anyways, Jalmont is rubbin me the wrong way in all kinds of ways only half of them from other games and I sincerely hope I don't get my forum games mixed up
 
shubaka17 said:
If I may weigh in on Jumpluff/Shubaka subbing, there was stuff goin on in PMs which I don't think I can disclose? Like even disclosing there bein stuff in PMs might get me GodKilled? idk man.
Click to expand...

Me speculating on the weirdness and abruptness of the sub from my point of view isn't asking me for you to reveal convos between the host, jumpluff, etc. It's just me pointing out that the whole substitution was weird considering there were a lot of players whose inactivity was far worse than jumpluffs who haven't been subbed, and jumpluff said he'd only be inactive for a few hours.

Again, nothing that you need to do to address it per ce. But it's just thoughts I have that I'd want to air.

If you're mafia though, you should DEFINITELY need to post your scum buddies and all your night actions or we'll lynch you. :p
 
Nah I mean I get that not much has happened but people still have opinions on each other and that's worth talking about BT. Like you haven't even mentioned Dullagamur or DLE.

Good to see acid posting again.

/unvote for now.

Not really sure why I'm getting voted by him. Guess people are DJSaltyNuts about the King_ lynch? You don't get to high horse me about being wrong when most of you don't even have concrete opinions on people? Like I almost got Vigged yesterday and the warden put me under review for potentially being mafia (ironically saving me in the process) and at this point I'm one of the only people trying to solve the game and start discussion.

Activity's going to be pretty limited this weekend cause Otakon. I'll try to keep up and regardless I'll still make an informed vote.
 
I guess I'm wrong about Dulla for now. I didn't really think about the 5 VT thing mainly because I thought there were 5 VTs too. I hate setups like this where there's just a bunch of random crap and stuff is hard to figure out. I guess I had overly high expectations for her given that I thought she played NOCs before but whatever I suppose. Don't understand Blazade being jailed "in the beginning of the night" but I'll just chalk that one down to weird setup stuff and believe him for now.

I also don't understand how if we only have one of the Citizen Power roles and Blazade knows who the warden is but acts like Dulla could still be mafia. So that part doesn't really make sense to me. I guess he's just trying to cover for her? But then it doesn't really make sense to me where the whole "well if jalmont is right about her being mafia" thing comes from then. that part also doesn't make sense but i guess i'm going to ignore that for now.

From my POV atm scum is BT / DLE / acid taking Blazade/dulla/Ullar at face value here and saying their mafia. I dunno I always want to say DLE is village but then he's disappeared again so impossible to say. pluff was my auto town based on d1 stuff but then the sub was no good and shubaka being suspicious of me now makes me feel like pluff's stuff on d1 was just a possible way to get the heat off of them early. beats me. cancerous is weird too because he's also inactive, but i don't think he's bad for now but idk.

A lynch on BT is probably not bad at this point, especially if you buy his "don't lynch afk acidphoenix." (who btw put an interesting vote on blazade) His justification for voting him is p. bad because he doesn't even think I'm mafia, just that I'm not helpful. That's not v. good reasoning since it doesn't really make it seem like you're interested in lynching mafia! I agree w/ Blazade about the fluff, a lot of his posts are very fluffy (just take a look at that last post lol that summarizes things that have happened in the game). His vote on me is v. hypocritical and not at all town-motivated - feels more like revenge for how I'm playing and even when I gave him a chance to be srs, he went all-in on mocking me even though he seems to hint at me being town which is weird? Yikes.

Me being weird isn't dumb by the way. I expect these sort of things (well duh, since I choose to play a certain way because I expect ppl to react in a predictable way at the start) but if you can't figure things out after the first time when playing with me then maybe you need to take a look at yourself lmao.
 
ButteredToast said:
/Vote Jalmont because he asked for it. If you're not going to play the game or you're not going to answer questions, then respond in such a lackluster way where you say "I do what I want, if you don't like it vote for me"... Well, I'm going to vote for you.

Jalmont
Click to expand...

This is an example of a not very good vote.

It's fine up to the point where I give him a chance to do a real vote, which BT doesn't take. At that point is when I think BT looks scum because the justification is poor, he's not lynching because he thinks I'm mafia (misreading my post to boot), and it goes against the in-game meta/persona/whatever you want to call that he's built up to this point.

Or I guess BT could just be dumb. That's certainly plausible. I'm also unsure given the inactives we have that I read as mafia but can't necessarily put as mafia due to inactivity. Welp
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top