ok here we go
Haunted Diamond - becomes suspicious of jalmont right from the beginning, once jalmont reveals he wanted a no lynch starts being mistrustful of him for much the same reasons as me, but for some reason ignores the fact that i share much of his views because he thinks me and jalmont might be friends or something? i don't understand how he could misread the situation between me and jalmont, and the way he flips quickly from being suspicious of spiffy's lynch on cancerous to voting on cancerous is also very odd. the worst of it is, by voting cancerous after my post he made me look scummy by association. i have no qualms with a vote on haunted diamond since i know i'm village and if everyone thinks either me or him are mafia then it must be him.
Celever - had some heat on him since the beginning and didn't seriously try to defend himself either, and when he said he shared his thoughts on everything relevant it amounted to nothing more than an agreement with my stance on lynching d1 and a vote on sunny. didn't really start posting substantially until he got off his ipad and onto a computer. spiffy calls him out for his active lurking and his none-contribution, celever uses ipad as excuse (tbh i have been following this game half the time on an ipad as well but i guess none of you could tell?), not satisfied with how he defended himself but let's see how he carries himself now that he's on a computer and can post properly. i could see lynching him on d2 and beyond depending on how he posts from here on out.
Jalmont - advocates no lynch from the beginning which i assumed was overcaution and wasn't really concerned about, didn't become suspicious of him until he reversed his position. says he had a plan but because no one tried to lynch him it wasn't carried out, then said he advocated no lynch to gauge people's reactions (as for what he found out god only knows), overall his insistence on moving past this issue i can read as either incompetent mafia backpedalling or incompetent villager trying to cover his failed plan and right now i'm leaning towards the latter. then there was that personal kerfuffle with von even though von was basically defending him. the way he's played so far annoys me and i take everything he says with a grain of salt.
vonFiedler - notably having big debates with both moi and jalmont though the latter was more personal in nature. the way he debated with moi and how he discussed moi overly thinking from the mafia perspective makes me think he is village. annoyed with me and haunted diamond for tunneling on jalmont even after him in his own way has already defended jalmont. even if he wants to lynch me i do enjoy when he posts.
ButteredToast - acting the reasonable guy who doesn't want to step on anyone's toes, what worries me is when he assumes too much stuff, like whether the mafia has day talk and how the game structure is set up, but right now i can put it down to inexperience. also troubling is his insistence on lynching jalmont even if he might be village on the basis that unhelpful villagers should be lynched anyway, this is not a good line of play and i hope he realises this. i appreciate his confidence in me, but i do want to know where this stems from. acts a bit too overly diplomatic for my liking but i cautiously read him as village.
PokeguyNXB - this guy is like butteredtoast in his inexperience except he has taken the opposite approach by making short posts that offer little information and seems to content to follow other people's leads. i feel that he has slipped under the radar a bit and people need to keep an eye on him and force him to say stuff.
LightWolf - i like that he also calls jalmont out on his weird shit, but what i like even more is his calling out of spiffy. posts very little but when he posts it is content-rich. if i weren't so averse to making text walls i would adopt this style next time so i don't get so easily labelled as scum. will be interesting to see how he plays as the game develops. will he post more regularly now that he's been to the dentist?
sunny004 - in much the same boat as PokeguyNXB, people don't expect much from them and in return they get to slip under the radar, is this a line the village should be taking? i'll admit i have been guilty of this what with my preoccupation with jalmont, but i think i will pressure these guys more in the future.
Cancerous - didn't post any significant content until amianki requested a summary, at which point he complied, and then got jumped by jalmont and spiffy. i don't care that he posted a summary after 'inactivity', what i do care about is that his defense after becoming a target was that he was contributing by making amianki discuss moi aka pointless busywork, like what the hell kind of defense is that? he has mixed feelings about me because of my 'connections' to spiffy which i find weird and hilarious at the same time. i don't know if it's the language barrier or what but his attempts at activity are barely better than pokeguy and sunny. i wouldn't have a problem lynching cancerous either but it appears right now we have a better target (NOT ME THOUGH)
Amianki - his activity is decidedly pro-village, i like that he calls butteredtoast on his 'too eager to please' posting style, and he also got an early scumread on haunted diamond as well. like lightwolf he also seems to call out spiffy who may be using the prodding of other players to appear as an active villager. overall i feel good about him.
Serious Bananas - also found jalmont's no lynch gambit suspicious from the start but this was dropped once jalmont backpedalled. has okay reads on butteredtoast and cancerous while his stance on sunny and pokeguy are the opposite to mine. hard to get a read on him as hasn't exactly been actively posting but his habit of defending the inactives aka sunny and pokeguy seems kinda off to me, probably because of my difference of opinion compared to his on these users.
rssp1 - holy fuck this guy posts a lot, gives me the same vibe as butteredtoast except rssp1 seems to move the conversation along a lot more. at this point i'm tired of going through this thread and unfortunately the last two players on the player list have posted the most. i think he's village and let's leave it at that.
Spiffy - spends the majority of his time prodding other players for their opinions, whether this is a mafia trying to appear like a busy villager like others have suggested, right now i'm leaning no. jumped on celever for his active lurking which i don't disagree with, especially given celever's lackluster defense, this has been dropped for now but i will bet good money on spiffy picking this line of thought again later on. seems to be the de facto village leader whether he likes it or not. interesting that lightwolf wants to see spiffy defend himself when his back is against the wall, but right now there isn't really much to go after spiffy for.
oh and just for good luck
I didn't say you were picking the fight. I said you were perpetuating it to make it seem like you're contributing. Notice how despite being caught up in this debacle with you, I have consistently shared my thoughts and very recently had an entire post responding to posts on the last two pages alone. I would not need this "fight" to appear contributional, whereas it would work more to your advantage. That is what I am saying.
I didn't say you were picking the fight. I said you were perpetuating it to make it seem like you're contributing. Notice how despite being caught up in this debacle with you, I have consistently shared my thoughts and very recently had an entire post responding to posts on the last two pages alone. I would not need this "fight" to appear contributional, whereas it would work more to your advantage. That is what I am saying.
I didn't say you were picking the fight. I said you were perpetuating it to make it seem like you're contributing. Notice how despite being caught up in this debacle with you, I have consistently shared my thoughts and very recently had an entire post responding to posts on the last two pages alone. I would not need this "fight" to appear contributional, whereas it would work more to your advantage. That is what I am saying.