I never said "OMG IM SO VILLAGE I DIDN'T VOTE FOR SUNNY AND YOU GUYS ARE SCUM". I even fucking said I would have voted for sunny too based on the seemingly valid evidence against him. And I ALSO said that the bandwagon could just be due to the lack of posts in the day which just made it SEEM like a bandwagon when the votes fell one after the other.
There's this little thing called an implication. You should know, you like to use them. Why even bother calling the Sunny lynch a bandwagon if the evidence against him was so solid? You even admit that you'd have voted for him (so why didn't you?), so what do any of us gain by you bringing attention the fact that you didn't vote for someone who ended up as town?
Assuming the doctor is notified that they have successfully blocked a kill (I think they would be?) then there is absolutely NO reason for them NOT to come out right now and out me for the "liar" you think I am if they blocked a kill on Night 2. As you said, we have a decent lead having lynched two anti towns, so the trade of a power role for scum is advantageous to the town. You're saying "Everyone consider the slight possibility that the hooker/doctor blocked the kill, but the power roles still shouldn't confirm this if they actually did" just to leave things more up in the air. It's stupid for power roles that have caught scum to stay hidden at this point in the game, yet you encourage this so the game is as ambiguous as possible. This is anti-town behavior.
ASSUMING THEY GOT A RESULT THAT CONFIRMED THEIR PROTECT WORKED, IF THE DOCTOR SUCCESSFULLY PROTECTED SOMEONE ON NIGHT 2 PLEASE SAY SO. IF THIS HAPPENS, IT CONFIRMS THAT I AM LYING ABOUT MY BPV AND EVERYONE IS WELCOME TO LYNCH ME.
Assuming
Why would they be? When has it ever worked like that? If a role just works, the person who used it is not notified on smogon mafia. There are multiple circumstances that could have led to that kill failing, and no one would really know or even have reason to suspect you unless the person protected was Serious Bananas.
Why would someone pretend to be BPV? A rare village role? Gee, I dunno guys, maybe so we wouldn't lynch them? What I'm saying is its dangerous to assume anyone is clean short of an inspector saying so, and that's not really how NOC works. It's everything else that makes me, and has always made keep an eye on you. You want everyone to assume you're village, but exactly what have you done for the village but bicker, tunnel Fate (the other assumed villager), and lie to get your points across? If someone wants me to think they are village, it had better be for sound reasoning and a track record of lynching scum.
I am fine with the mass claim issue being left up to discussion but seeing as we don't have great leads at the moment I thought it would be something that could help, and I still think it would. The mafia already know what me and Fatecrashers are (assuming Fate isn't mafia) and Haunted Diamond might have inspected someone (is he a role NAME cop or just a regular cop? Still unclear on this) to limit possible pr rands, so I think it's a net benefit to mass claim.
Oh I think I've got a great lead or two. So who is we then?
I'd respond to Jalmont post #1239 but without quotes or references to what he's talking about in each line, it kinda seems like he's just having a seizure. As for interpreting the post where he says "hey I Jalmont am scum" well... if I'm interpreting wrong, why did he even ask? I made my two top mafia partners pretty clear.
