just realized i tagged random user Gale instead of Gale Wing Srock in my above post whoops
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
NOC Fire and Ice Mafia: Fire and Ice tie, the village loses.
- Thread starter The Diabolic Gift
- Start date
- Status
Oh, it's fairly likely. Gale looked like he might have been the hammer today, so I can see a mafia jumping on early and being opportunistic and pushing it.
Nah, Gale was not defeatist at all when I've played with him and he's been allied with me. In the FFA game which we played with each other in he remained strong right to the end even when he knew that I was betraying him (because I told him I was betraying him, I would have felt bad otherwise). The defeatism was very out of character for him and a sudden change in tone (the post wasn't hyper) threw me off guard, so I voted for him. Like I said though, it was more for pressure than anything anyway. I don't know whether I think he's town or scum, but I know he'd pick up his game and play should we actually nearly lynch him.[/quote]
Gotta go to school, no time left. Cya later.
Spiffy I didn't respond to your post because it was just saying you're wrong HD with no real argument. But I pointed out later anyway that Celever is playing cooler.
I've been busy this day, I've also been busy the last mafia game. I mean I've tried my best to contribute but apparently if I don't make tl;drs with in depth analyises I will appear scummy so I won't mind if you guys lynch me cuz I don't meet that standard.
I've been busy this day, I've also been busy the last mafia game. I mean I've tried my best to contribute but apparently if I don't make tl;drs with in depth analyises I will appear scummy so I won't mind if you guys lynch me cuz I don't meet that standard.
Spiffy I didn't respond to your post because it was just saying you're wrong HD with no real argument. But I pointed out later anyway that Celever is playing cooler.
I've been busy this day, I've also been busy the last mafia game. I mean I've tried my best to contribute but apparently if I don't make tl;drs with in depth analyises I will appear scummy so I won't mind if you guys lynch me cuz I don't meet that standard.
I've been busy this day, I've also been busy the last mafia game. I mean I've tried my best to contribute but apparently if I don't make tl;drs with in depth analyises I will appear scummy so I won't mind if you guys lynch me cuz I don't meet that standard.
Celever, he's playing ok now but I can't let go for the reasons I mentioned. Also, US seems to be playing to opportunisticly so he'd be my second vote.
Double post...Anyone still complaining that I don't contribute enough? 
I have Yeti as slight town since he's trying to stir discussion, although as some previously have pointed out, the scums have good reason to try to scumhunt the other scum at this stage.
HD is more of a 'I'm getting the wrong vibe from this guy, but I don't have anything specific' sort of thing.
Also, FoS Celever, using excessive language and causing that L-2, also this quote:
This is, to me, an attempt to get HD's mind onto someone else, to perhaps give him reason to wihtdraw his vote on Celever for real and place it on said person.Celever said:
I can support a Dle, Celever, or Gale lynch right now. By the way, Unvote anyone that TIK might have lynched, forgot to do this last post.
Well, this is Day One of a NOC, but I'd have to say currently my first choice would be Celever. Reasoning on the post above.
The Uncle Sam bandwagon is probably our best shot to nab a poor playing mafia member clinging to a vote for pretty poor reasons OR to catch a town who bought into the idea that Sam is always dangerous in the lead and looked like he was trying to manipulate. Gale looks the worst from it because he actually is calling for a straight lynch, so it's impossible for him to argue that he was voting just to pressure. He is more just trying to lynch Uncle Sam, which would only really make sense if he just wanted him out of the game due to his experience. And beings that only the mafia actually know who is on their side, this makes it appear to me that Gale was probably taking a very early and ill timed shot to remove him and his experience from the other side. But this is all speculative and the play to call for a lynch on Uncle Sam that early is so bad that it almost spits in the face of any preconceived idea of strategy for either side.
HauntedDiamond is pretty much making all the same plays and mistakes that he did day one of fallout mafia, which makes me wonder if this is just how he plays in general or if this is him following a set pattern. I picked on him a lot for his behavior in Fallout, and analyzed him a lot then, but I'm going to say he is probably the one I would vote on. His defenses have been lackluster to me. It's all kind of maddening to read and to figure out and to his credit he was the first one to jump on the bandwagon so he just might be misguided.
I guess based on my thoughts right now, I would probably kill off Gale just because I feel there is more of a connection to mafia based on actions alone. I can see him being a mafia and knowing who is on his team trying to take advantage to knock out a strategic and experienced piece from another mafia or from the village more so than I see him being a villager and taking a stab in the dark. So Gale would be my answer to Yeti's question.
HauntedDiamond is pretty much making all the same plays and mistakes that he did day one of fallout mafia, which makes me wonder if this is just how he plays in general or if this is him following a set pattern. I picked on him a lot for his behavior in Fallout, and analyzed him a lot then, but I'm going to say he is probably the one I would vote on. His defenses have been lackluster to me. It's all kind of maddening to read and to figure out and to his credit he was the first one to jump on the bandwagon so he just might be misguided.
I guess based on my thoughts right now, I would probably kill off Gale just because I feel there is more of a connection to mafia based on actions alone. I can see him being a mafia and knowing who is on his team trying to take advantage to knock out a strategic and experienced piece from another mafia or from the village more so than I see him being a villager and taking a stab in the dark. So Gale would be my answer to Yeti's question.
UGH now I think I would prefer a PokeguyNXB lynch over anything else. His play is just way too different from and much less helpful than when he was town in Fallout, as I've outlined before. I feel like if he continues acting this way (and there is no indication that he won't) he'll be lynched on future days anyway so why not get it over with now? I am still willing to lynch Haunted Diamond but I think Pokeguy is the superior option.
Unvote
Vote PokeguyNXB
Unvote
Vote PokeguyNXB
ButteredToast what you're calling mistakes is me being busy. Even then I've still been more relevant than you in this game so please stop evaluating my skill and let me have some fun.
The reason I'd prefer Haunted Diamond over Pokeguy or Gale is that I feel a Haunted Diamond flip will tell us more about a lot of people, most particularly Yeti. As in, I think that if he flips mafia then she is an excellent person to take a long, hard look at in future days.
Pokeguy meanwhile...no one's been on his side. He hasn't been on anyone else's side. And he's ignored too many people to point out any sort of passive buddying either. I agree that I think he will be useless in coming days and may well be mafia, but I'd rather lynch him later on if he continues to be unhelpful after people's opinions on him become a little less uniform.
My vote on Haunted stays. I would be willing to lynch, in order, Pokeguy>Gale>Acidphoenix>Celever as well. I think lynching anyone else would be a poor choice, though DLE I'm admittedly only giving a free pass because I expect him to play well.
Da Letter El I'm tagging you one last time in the hopes that you will respond. Houston, do you copy?
Pokeguy meanwhile...no one's been on his side. He hasn't been on anyone else's side. And he's ignored too many people to point out any sort of passive buddying either. I agree that I think he will be useless in coming days and may well be mafia, but I'd rather lynch him later on if he continues to be unhelpful after people's opinions on him become a little less uniform.
My vote on Haunted stays. I would be willing to lynch, in order, Pokeguy>Gale>Acidphoenix>Celever as well. I think lynching anyone else would be a poor choice, though DLE I'm admittedly only giving a free pass because I expect him to play well.
Da Letter El I'm tagging you one last time in the hopes that you will respond. Houston, do you copy?
Wayan Vistar
formerly Flyhn
Okay real talk. Why am i acting so different? Because i'm a fucking blue. I HATE not having a night action, and i joined this game hoping on 5/13 odds i'd be Doc/Maf so at night, the only part of the game i'm actually GOOD at, i could actually DO SOMETHING. As anything other than blue, be it scum or a pr, i'm pissy about not getting lynched, but when i'm blue, i'm not unless it's mylo/lylo, cause i'm useless anyway and wouldn't mind being mislynched. Remind me not to join setups with mostly blues ever again please
PokeguyNXB if you're going to sulk about being vanilla the whole game instead of do what has been overwhelmingly asked and expected of you then you are more then welcome to sub out. If you are being truthful and your outrage at being vanilla is preventing you from doing ABSOLUTELY ANYTHING to help then we would be much better off with someone who is willing to try.
I still don't buy it. A village power role has the same exact purpose as a vanilla during the day, so that is no excuse for his play style being so drastically different. Once again instead of trying to contribute Pokeguy resorts to excuses and defending himself. I'm keeping my vote.
I still don't buy it. A village power role has the same exact purpose as a vanilla during the day, so that is no excuse for his play style being so drastically different. Once again instead of trying to contribute Pokeguy resorts to excuses and defending himself. I'm keeping my vote.
And what if I flip town? You know, it sounds a little weird to just vote me that in case i turned out mafia you could take a look at someone.
Oh great and stealthed by Haunted Diamond:
The point is we learn more from lynching you then we do from lynching Pokeguy. However, you've been more helpful/active at the same time. So it's really a toss up. Prove that you'll be useful and active (what are your thoughts on Pokeguy's recent behavior? Spiffy's?) and it only helps your case.
The point is we learn more from lynching you then we do from lynching Pokeguy. However, you've been more helpful/active at the same time. So it's really a toss up. Prove that you'll be useful and active (what are your thoughts on Pokeguy's recent behavior? Spiffy's?) and it only helps your case.
I was gonna talk about Pokeguy. He is sounding realllllyyy weird. He wasn't so insecure the last game.
IDK though...should i remove my lynch from celever? Here's my order of lynching preference: Celever, Pokeguy, and possibily US
IDK though...should i remove my lynch from celever? Here's my order of lynching preference: Celever, Pokeguy, and possibily US
Oh now Haunted Diamond "SUDDENLY" has Pokeguy in his top two lynched despite not having mentioned him AT ALL the entire day. That makes perfect sense.
UncleSam lol that's probably because Haunted Diamond is in survival mode instead of trying to actively help the town. I've already said that they are interchangeable to me and honestly I think one is Fire and one is Ice.
UncleSam lol that's probably because Haunted Diamond is in survival mode instead of trying to actively help the town. I've already said that they are interchangeable to me and honestly I think one is Fire and one is Ice.
- Status