Decided by me and Sae :]
Swadloon (Grass) D -> Unranked
There is so reason to use this since Levanny outclasses in almost way and Swadloon doesn't get any notable moves to use. Unlike Levanny, Swadloon isn't Taunt bait. Horrible typing as well.
Jumpluff (Grass) D -> Unranked
If you want a Swords Dancer then go with Sceptile. It has a "better" physical movepool anyways. Whimsicott is way better as an annoyer since it gets Prankster.
Hawlucha (Flying) -> D -> C Rank
It isn't D Rank bad tbh. It makes an excellent late game sweeper with Acrobatics and HJK. Has access to Taunt + Swords Dance / Bulk Up as well.
Carbink (Fairy) C -> Unranked
There is no reason to use this over Diance.
Qwilfish (Water) C -> D
Tentacruel fills the role much better as a Spike / Toxic Spike setter. Intimidate may be cool, but it's not that bulky in the first place. It does have some niches that keep it in D such as Taunt, Destiny Bond, T-wave, and Explosion.
Qwilfish (Poison) C -> D
Scolipede arguably fills the role better as a Spike stacker because of Speed Boost + STAB that hits Psychic types Super Effectively. It has its niches that keep it in D.
Carbink (Rock) C -> Unranked.
You have Diance lol
Sawk (Fighting) -> Unranked
Fighting has sucky Hazard control so there's rocks 90% of the time ruining Sturdy. It's outclassed power wise / speed wise by things such as Terrakion.
Poliwrath (Fighting) -> Unranked.
Keldeo / Conkeldurr outclasses it and there's no significant Water weakness outside of Terrakion and Infernape. It's slow as well.
Stunkfisk (Electric) B -> D Rank
It fits D rank's description perfectly.
D Rank: Reserved for Pokemon that are outclassed in almost every single way. These Pokemon are only used for one of their moves, or for their typing / ability. Even so, they are generally second rate Pokemon meaning that they can be only brought in once or twice to perform their role. These Pokemon rarely adapt to the metagame.
It's offenses are outclassed by almost every single offensive mon. Defensives are pretty decent but it's still weak to notable types such as Ground, Ice, and Water. Stunfisk is only used for Stealth Rocks.
Shaymin B Rank -> Unranked
You have Skymin and Shaymin has a sucky typing. Used for Natural Cure but faces competition with Roserade who has a better typing.
Xatu (Flying) B -> D Rank.
So much Defog and they're on great mons too. It sadly isn't B rank material :[
Furfrou B -> C Rank
I guess AFD's right :[
Hitmontop B -> D Rank
Fighting isn't meant to be "defensive" and it gets worn down easily since it has no recovery. It's pretty meh and you end up wasting a slot.
Toxicroak (Fighting) B -> D Rank
It can beat up Fairies but Klefiki and Mawile wall it so hard. Dry Skin lets it wall Crocune but is it worth giving up a slot on your team?
Durant (Steel) A Rank -> B Rank
/me cires in a corner. It's not A rank material ;-;
Forretress (Bug) A Rank -> B Rank
Same role as Armaldo and they both preform their roles fairly well. Forretress is weak to Fire while Armaldo is weak to Rocks. It's Taunt bait.
Lucario (Fighting) A Rank -> C Rank
It's obviously not as good as it was before. Physical is outclassed, and Special's just meh. So slow as well. Mostly used for priority Bullet Punch for dem Fairies, and as a mixed attacker to get through Skarmory / other walls.
Ambipom A Rank -> C Rank
It's not that good, but it's not that bad. It uses up a slot when you could be running something like Diggersby. It's extremely frail as well so it's hard to pass Wishes to it.
Cinnico A Rank -> B Rank
Truedrew agreed with the drop as did a majority of people
Rotom-W (Electric) S Rank -> A Rank
Used for Water STAB vs Ground teams, but Gastro still walls it pretty hard.
Deoxys-S S Rank -> A Rank
It's not S Rank material, but it is your best suicide lead.
Umbreon A Rank -> B Rank
I love it and all but I don't feel like it's A quality. I personally think that S / A Rank should stick with the standard T-tar, Gren, Mandi, Bisharp, Hydregon, Sableye and some others. #Generic
~~~~~~~
Things that I feel like could be changed.
Heracross (Bug) A Rank -> S Rank
Scarf Heracross decimates Fire / Flying etc Monotypes with ease after all of the threats are gone. Genesect and Heracross make a terrifying offensive core since they shred each others weaknesses. Moxie is an awesome ability, it has web support so it outspeeds other scarfs, no Talonflame, takes neutral damage from Rocks etc.
Mamoswine (Ice) A Rank -> S Rank
It's so Anti Meta. Earthquake + Stone Edge can easily 1-2HKO a majority of Ice's weaknesses. It's unpredictable as well since it can run stuff like Freeez Dry / Scarves etc. Thick Fat is cool for an Ice mon. Takes Neutral damage from Ice. Ice / Ground STAB lets it force out a majority of Stealth Rockers if played right.
Azumarill (Fairy) A Rank -> S Rank
This is the thing that's keeping Fairy from being 6-0ed by Fire every time. Since Monotype's so restricted, a single Belly Drum can sweep through weakened / unprepared teams. It has screen support (from Klefiki) so it's pretty easy to set up.
Tagging people who had stuff changed:
XatuAppraisal @N64
Dirpz Hutyro truedrew saquibalmamun1997 I might've missed some people. So let the discussion begin!
What else needs to be changed / what shouldn't be changed? Do you agree with these decisions?