
If you are not an experienced member of the CAP community, it is strongly recommended that you do not post in this thread.
This thread is intended to contain intelligent discussion and commentary by experienced members of the CAP project regarding CAP policy, process, and rules. As such, the content of this thread will be moderated more strictly than other threads on the forum. This is not a Policy Review thread, but requires intelligent posting and serious thought put into every post made.
Introduction
Movepools have been a long and standing issue with CAPs. Finally, in a recent Policy Review thread located here, new requirements and restrictions were placed on CAP movepools in order to bring them back in-line with what a normal OU Pokemon would have. This process guide page describes in greater detail the restrictions and requirements placed on CAP movepools.
This is all immediately relevant because we will, as a community, be reviewing every CAP movepool to date in order to come into compliance with these restrictions and requirements. There are several important considerations for what will be going down with this, however, before we begin with the revisions themselves.
Philosophy
The philosophy of this set of revisions is not so much to revise CAPs to be better or more fair in the CAP metagame, but rather to revert each movepool to the stage where it might have been had the above restrictions been in place during its creation. Because of this, the way the leaders of individual CAP movepool reversions are chosen, as well as how they must conduct their movepool reversion, must adhere to the following guidelines.
- Original authors of movepools have the highest priority in running their respectively won movepool reversions.
- After the original author of the movepool, respected members of the community who were present for that era of the CAP project are prioritized for working on a movepool. These movepools must be revised based on the conditions and metagame features of the time period within which they are created.
- All CAPs that have been previously revised will be reverted to their absolute original forms (including abilities and stats) before the movepool requirements and restrictions will be applied to them.
- The focus of this reversion project is to objectively apply, as closely as possible, the new movepool requirements and restrictions to all previous CAPs. The keyword here is "objectively," wherein we cannot add arbitrary moves because we know/think they will be fair. We must adhere to the concepts and the original movepools as closely as possible.
- This project is not for the faint of heart. If you are chosen to revise one or more of the CAP movepools, I will be breathing down your neck to make sure that it's done right. Furthermore, it will require a lot of research on your part in order to verify that your movepool is meeting the theme of that CAP process, the concept for that CAP, the metagame at that point (including any currently banned Pokemon that may have been allowed then), etc. You may be required to cite your research for review before the movepool is considered complete.
- Before any movepool is considered finished, it will be reviewed by myself, tennisace, and any other interested CAP moderators for objectivity. This is when you may be required to present your research. A lot of information from the older CAPs can be found in this thread.
- All signature moves (Sacred Fire, Heart Swap, Volt Tackle, etc.) are considered VGMs.
- All competitively viable moves for a specific CAP that are not VGMs are considered VGMs. (Such as AncientPower on Technician Pokemon or Wood Hammer on Pyroak)
- All tutor moves are available to all CAPs. Despite CAPs being updated to their stage when they were made, we are allowing all tutor moves for the sake of being up-to-date with the fourth generation, even if that CAP was created before HGSS or Platinum.
- No movepool will be uploaded to the CAP server until all of the movepools are completed.
- The deadline for the completion of this project in its entirety is whenever CAP11's playtesting period ends. That means that we're on a timeline and people working on movepools cannot slack off until the very end.
- Syclant
- Status: Completed
- Original Movepool Author: N/A
- Revision Leader: eric the espeon
- Thread: http://www.smogon.com/forums/showthread.php?t=75874
- Revenankh
- Status: Completed
- Original Movepool Author: N/A
- Revision Leader: eric the espeon
- Thread: http://www.smogon.com/forums/showthread.php?t=75585
- Pyroak
- Status: Completed
- Original Movepool Author: N/A
- Revision Leader: Deck Knight
- Thread: http://www.smogon.com/forums/showthread.php?t=74828
- Status: Completed
- Fidgit
- Status: Completed
- Original Movepool Author: X-Act
- Revision Leader: Deck Knight
- Thread: http://www.smogon.com/forums/showthread.php?t=75442
- Stratagem
- Status: Completed
- Original Movepool Author: X-Act
- Revision Leader: Vader
- Thread: http://www.smogon.com/forums/showthread.php?t=74922
- Arghonaut
- Status:Completed
- Original Movepool Author: X-Act
- Revision Leader: Umbreon Dan
- Thread: http://www.smogon.com/forums/showthread.php?t=75304
- Kitsunoh
- Status: Completed
- Original Movepool Author: darkie
- Revision Leader: Umbreon Dan
- Thread: http://www.smogon.com/forums/showthread.php?t=75770
- Cyclohm
- Status: Completed
- Original Movepool Author: Deck Knight
- Revision Leader: Zystral
- Thread: http://www.smogon.com/forums/showthread.php?t=74951
- Colossoil
- Status: Completed
- Original Movepool Author: Fuzznip
- Revision Leader: Fuzznip
- Thread: http://www.smogon.com/forums/showthread.php?t=75654
- Krilowatt
- Status: Completed
- Original Movepool Author: Jibaku
- Revision Leader: Rising_Dusk
- Thread: http://www.smogon.com/forums/showthread.php?t=74825
In addition to the CAPs requiring their revisions, they will not all be done at once. We are running this revision process in tandem with CAP11, and we do not want to distract all of our best users from the process involved in CAP11. Because of this, only two CAP revisions may be taking place at a given time. When one "finishes" and is approved, that thread will be locked to further discussion and the next one may be posted by the leader for that specific CAP revision. The revision leader for a given CAP is on par with the topic leader for a CAP in terms of having the last say in a movepool, despite suggestions by other members. Either tennisace or myself may step in and try to help push it in an objective and proper direction if we feel that it's straying from the goal of the revision process at large, but will otherwise leave the revision leaders mostly to their own devices. Expect me to harass you if you don't work quickly, as the efficiency of this process is critical. It is OK to sign up for multiple revisions, but be forewarned that we really will try to avoid selecting the same RL for 3 or 4 CAPs. We will also reorder the order of operations based on this so that one RL is not running two CAP revisions simultaneously unless it is absolutely necessary. (ie. the last two) The order of the revisions is given below.Name: Your name, easy.
CAP that you want to review: The CAP's name, easy.
What qualifications you have for reviewing this CAP: Include qualifications such as if you were around for that CAP, if you participated in its creation and subsequent playtesting, if you happened to be a top contender in the movepool submission stage for that CAP, if you're a great member of the CAP community, etc. This is where you basically tell me that you've got what it takes to run a movepool revision and are not going to ditch out or slack off until the last minute.
The Order of Operations
Krilowatt(Rising_Dusk)Pyroak(Deck Knight)Stratagem(Vader)Cyclohm(Zystral)Arghonaut(Umbreon Dan)Fidgit(Deck Knight)Revenankh(eric the espeon)Colossoil(Fuzznip)Kitsunoh(Umbreon Dan)Syclant(eric the espeon)
Anyway, let's get to it!