Sigh...
NU should be a tier with Beedrill, raticate, plusle/minun etc. Not a place for Hypno/Camerupt, who are currently TOP tier UU pokemon. With Pokemon like Blaziken running rampant through the weak UU walls, including steelix and the like, i still dont see how this is an effective method. To make the test shorter they should see that the OBVIOUS BL pokemon stay BL before the UU tier becomes the BL tier, and the BL faux tier becomes nothing. Pokemon like Raikou barely even have checks in the BL tier, now in the UU tier, it will be near impossible to stop.
These pokemon are fresh in my mind because i play advance often still, and these pokemon STILL outclass the pokemon they did in Advance, for the most part (an exception being the odd pokemon with misplaced stats, and no stab in Advance such as Azumarill). They are not near UU Standards.
Assuming we want to keep the UU tier an Underused pokemon tier, with pokemon that cant fit in the OU metagame, I beleive we should see to it that there is no room for pokemon like Raikou, Feraligatr, Slaking etc. in this UU test. Logic: Why is Raikou in the same tier as Manectric? These pokemon can be USED in OU games fairly effectively and clearly outclass some of the fairly often used UU pokemon.
Hearing that there should only be about 5 pokemon in the BL tier makes me shudder. The reason many people still beleive Advance is the best generation is because of the balanced tiers, BL teams CAN exist there needs to be at least 30+ pokemon in the BL tier imo. And to quicken the test up, let us skip the clearly banned pokemon, and get to the debatable Pokemon. The UU/OU tiers in advance, are VERY balanced, and to do that pokemon like Arcanine were banned. Although, i do understand that the metagame has changed, and old advance pokemon are outclassed(e.g. Blaziken is outclassed by Infernape), they are still far to powerful for the UU tier.
To sum it up.....
Testing pokemon that are clearly too powerful is a waste of time, and not needed. And secondly, many, maybe even 40%+ pokemon must remain or get put into the BL faux tier, its the only possible way to balance the UU tier.
Does anyone else agree, or have some sort of view on this?
Eh, and Auto-weather is an OU thing, it does not belong in this tier >_<.