ShieldPhoenix said:So we all know about the hazard meta in OU. Should anything be done about the meta? If so, what should be done?
A: Do not do anything
B: Ban stealth rocks
C: Ban spikes
D: Ban Gholdengo
E: Ban all hazards
In my opinion, I would choose C or D. I think E is too extreme and can lead to boring pivotspam teams, and we have to acknowledge that hazards are keeping stuff in check. Maybe B could work but I like C and D more.
For C, spikes are one of the reasons why bootspam exists. It’s so easy to maintain them and can easily add up, so even mons like tusk commonly run boots because of how good spikes are. If there is only rocks (and tspikes) we aren’t forced to put boots on almost every defensive mon in our teams.
I also like D. In S/S, spikes were not that crazy since you can easily defog, with no reliable way of preventing it, and there is still rapid spin. While we cannot say for certain that the only reason hazards are oppressive this generation is due to Gholdengo, because there are things such as increased hazard distribution, Gholdengo is one of the major factors. If it gets banned, maybe we can see what happens.
Let me know your thoughts!
F: Ban Heavy Duty Boots. Kids have it too easy these days, we need to get back to early gens when you had two or three viable Rapid Spinners and no Defog. Suffering builds character.
:insert grumpy old man from Up:
Heavy Duty Boots are doing some heavy duty lifting, but we've seen a lot of variety in ways to deal with hazards; everything from bringing Defog anyway, to HO maintaining pressure and never allowing hazards to go up, to Hatterene and Cinderace making them a risk to set, to the old Superman archetypes coming back, to a couple excellent Rapid Spinners, to alternatives like Mortal Spin and Tidy Up. I would not be surprised if some madlad started using Torkoal as a rapid spinner on a semi-sun team and made it work.
Yes, hazard stack has not been this strong and this common in, literally, well over a decade, but that doesn't mean hazards need to be nerfed. Counterplay options exist, and "I don't like it" is not a valid reason to ban things.
MegaScizor32 said:I can agree that dealing with Gholdengo as pokemon is no problem. It’s easy to kill and manageable on the defensive side. The issue lies with its contribution to the hazard control problem. Without Golden Joe, Defog would actually be viable in OU thus giving us more tools to fight against hazards. Who knows we could even see some niche picks outside of OU see some usage for their ability to Defog.
Please show me this mass of defoggers that isn't "Corviknight now gets 25% usage," because I'm just not seeing it. Mandibuzz is a fine mon in OU already, though really limited only to more defensive teams, but other options are flawed: Scizor hasn't kept up with power creep and defog alone wouldn't justify it, Talonflame has a niche on stall but Gholdengo already doesn't want to switch in, and Weezing-Galar can already run Neutralizing Gas to defog on Gholdengo, so it'd just be the Levitate sets that gain.