That_Dwayneee said:To be frank I don't get this, older gens have less spikers and more ways to deal with said spikers:
Gen 3 has skarm setting spikes as one of the best mons in the tier, but there are two viable spinners rather than just one, magneton to limit skarm's spikes outright, and the only ghost in the tier is very threatened by the two spinners
Gen 4 has a spikes problem between the introduction of the rotom forms and the mons in gen 3 that used to run spin falling off, yes, but even then starmie still exists to remove hazards, and the tier has multiple magnet pull mons to limit the spikes output from the most viable spikes setter, which is skarmory
Gens 5 and 6 have excadrill, and in the latter it is the literal best mon in the tier
Gen 7 has much wider defog distribution, including the genies, the tapus, rotom-wash, and gliscor as well as excadrill still being in the tier
And we all know that this wasn't an issue in gen 8
Spikes is a much more constricting presence now in gen 9 has been in any gen before it, except for the times when the deoxys forms were allowed in the tier, or when excadrill was banned entirely and magic guard teams took over the meta
Edit forgot to mention what it's being compared to:
Gen 9 has one viable spinner - that is extremely threatened by ghost types - no viable magnet pull pokemon - which doesn't matter anyway since skarmory is no longer the best spikes setter by a wide margin - 0 viable defoggers, and 3 very relevant spikes setters which all have wildly different counterplay, unlike the previous gens where the spikes mons could generally be dealt with in a similar way. Looking at all of this why do you think balance teams have largely just decided to run 6 spikes immunities
Removing spikes in ADV is not as easy as you might thing. Something occasionally said about Skarm is that it’s a spinblocker in its own way. Dol and Mie are the best spinners in the tier. Toxic + Drill Peck can 1v1 Claydol and win the Spikes war. Starmie has a better shot thanks to 32 Recover pp and Natural Cure, but Toxic still puts it on a timer and forced it to switch put eventually, meaning Skarm can still get up a Spike. Plus defensive Mie doesn’t have enough horsepower to threaten Skarm much since they run SpD investment.
DPP has very few good spinners. Starmie is good, but gets threatened by Scarf Tar and Scarf Rotom. Donphan (yes its viable in DPP) can Foresight to click Spin on Ghosts, but Hydro Pump from Rotom threatens it, and Tusk doesn’t have the longevity Starmie does, and Forretress…is Forretress. It is often why defensive teams gear towards running multiple spike immune mons like Latias, Clef, Flygon, and Bronzong.
Things get a bit better in BW. Excadrill is a great spinner that can actually threaten Jellicent, the main spinblocker, and Skarm with SD boosts. Tentacruel only fits on Rain but puts Jelli on a timer with Toxic and can 1v1 Ferro after a burn. Starmie is also still decent, but loses to the best Spiker in the tier Ferrothron, even with Scald burns into the mix.
Despite only having four hazard control options, we should be thankful for the ones we actually have, albeit small.
A contender for Top 5 in the meta and the Spinner on 70% of teams. Unlike with ADV Skarm, none of our Spike setters can safely come in on Tusk to set Spikes back up except Skarm, but the Skarm is hella exploitable. A free switch in for Raging Bolt, Ghold, Pult, Volc, Mola, Prim, Clef, Gking, whatever the Tusk player wants. BU Tera Poison Tusk also 1v1s Gliscor and even Skarm after its been Knock’d which isn’t hard to do btw. Pult takes massive damage from Spinner or HLR (one shot by Knock) and Balloon Ghold is likely to succumb to Spinner + HLR. So none of our best spinblockers actually wanna switch into it, especially when they’re needed for other roles.
This singlehandedly shuts down Skarm/Ting/Gliscor builds while threatening with a CM sweep. It also shuts down Deo-S since most of them don’t run Skill Swap. So unless your name is Samu H. Rott, Spikes ain’t coming up.
Treads is more of an offensive spinner, but its amazing at anti-leading many hazard leads like Glimm, and Deo-S. Good if you wanna keep hazards off early. Also shits on Pult/Ghold.
Run Tera Ice Blast Cinder. Trust me on this. Not only does it give you an option to snipe Lando and Dnite, but Fire + Ice hits the three most common Spike setters while U-Turn smacks Samu hard. Cinder will find a way in, Court Change, and then nuke Gliscor for trying to even the score. So what if Gliscor Teras back? Now its eating 3 layers of Spikes every time its switches in.
Close to a month ago I made a Spikes guide if you haven’t checked it out.
https://www.smogon.com/forums/posts/10008679/
There are also others ways of dealing with Spikes, even when you’re not running 6 boots mons. Simply making your teams offensive enough to deter opportunities is enough. Heck, Balance teams don’t even need to run boots on everything either. We’ve seen Tusk/Gking/Gambit Balances find success on ladder and SPL.
If you’re letting them get off three Spikes that easily, either you played overly passive or played recklessly with your Tusk. Again, SV OU is very punishing to passive or reckless plays, and I respect that. Whether the tier is balanced or not, that’s up for debate. Personally, I think we are very close to a staple metagame and the issues brought up by the playerbase are a bit overreactive. Some players wanna run passive, do-nothing teams and having a counter to everything rather than accepting that this generation is more offensive than the previous.
Even then, every archetype is viable. Stall is still consistent into the mid and high ladder. HO is HO. Balance is slowly reshaping itself to fit with the rest of the meta, and BO made a comeback with options like Lando and Dnite circumventing alot of their former issues.
Anyways, I have a spicy write-up coming up later, but first, I wanna ask.
Spring is coming and everyone’s lawns are wet and invaded with weeds.
Anyone wanna borrow my lawn mower?