NOC Working Title Mafia (Game Thread) [Mafia Wins]

jfc redless has said like nothing this game except to proclaim hes town in a way that ive not seen from his previous town games. giving big scum
 
ElectricityCat said:
Please don't vote for M2H on day 1. This would be the third mafia game in a row where he leaves on day one as town (assuming he is town here too).

Honestly, I don't see any irrational comments from him. I think all his posts are quite coherent.
Click to expand...
this sort? of feels like scum!ecat scum!m2h but i think its just as likely to be town.

ive honestly liked ecats posting i think this is good solid posting even if its a lot less than ideal but okay kettle calling the pot black
 
also yea after no cc on lechen (i hadnt considered this when i thought lechen was maybe not town) i think lechen is fairly confirmed as town tracker which is. cool? i guess?
 
in trying to write out my defense to what I said I have come to the conclusion that I was wrong

here was my original thought process that I was trying to write out
"we have backups" isn't really good argument imo. Even if we would still have a tracker should the first tracker die, it's still a significant hit at town to lose one layer of defense on their ability to track

if someone CCs tracker, what do we gain today that we couldn't gain equally tomorrow? If someone CCs tracker right now, do we vote out Lechen immediately? I don't think so, that would mean we potentially waste our D1 vote and lose a PR (and this is where I realize that then whoever CC'd them gets voted out day 2 regardless and trading the 1 tracker for a mafia member is probably worth it so yes we do vote lechen out in this scenario)

conclusion i need to think more about my takes before I post them
 
It depends on the nature of the CC but tracker absolutely should always CC here if Lechen is capping. It's pretty awful to tie up jk and fake clear Lechen off of the claim when CCing always creates a 1v1 with a maf in it.
 
pulsar512b said:
this is a pretty reasonable post but feels like it could be scummy?
Click to expand...

I only identified with the new one because in my previous NOC, I also perceived you that way. I remember you got angry when I posted a theory that didn't follow the OP statement and I didn't know that.

pulsar512b said:
this sort? of feels like scum!ecat scum!m2h but i think its just as likely to be town.

ive honestly liked ecats posting i think this is good solid posting even if its a lot less than ideal but okay kettle calling the pot black
Click to expand...

Regarding M2H, it's not because we are mafias. I have appreciated him since my first Mafia game, and in the next two games, he was voted out on day 1 and was innocent. But anyway, what I'm saying is very off-topic, it wasn't a game read, it was a random comment.
 
I saw that some people said I play differently compared to my last game, and yes, well, I tried to improve and I’m still trying.

I think M2H and Alice talk about my change as if it were something negative, but I see it as positive. In my last game, at this point, I had around 30 pages unread and no opinions about anyone. Now at least I have read all the messages ( I didn't understand everything, but at least I think I got most of it). Maybe I don't post as much, but at least I participated a couple of times without anyone needing to tag me (just like 2 or 3 post, but that's progress for me) :totodiLUL:
 
ElectricityCat said:
I saw that some people said I play differently compared to my last game, and yes, well, I tried to improve and I’m still trying.

I think M2H and Alice talk about my change as if it were something negative, but I see it as positive. In my last game, at this point, I had around 30 pages unread and no opinions about anyone. Now at least I have read all the messages ( I didn't understand everything, but at least I think I got most of it). Maybe I don't post as much, but at least I participated a couple of times without anyone needing to tag me (just like 2 or 3 post, but that's progress for me) :totodiLUL:
Click to expand...
just an idea, try posting more it helps people read you
 
ElectricityCat said:
but at least I participated a couple of times without anyone needing to tag me (just like 2 or 3 post, but that's progress for me) :totodiLUL:
Click to expand...
This reminds me that we have some people that apparently need to have a couple of votes or scumreads to participate:wo:


JALMONT said:
I don’t really want to vote honestly do we have to
Click to expand...
Well there are 2 night kills and there are some people with low content, will it get better in d2? We'd have to get a scum on d2 or it gets really hard if we don't vote today. I feel like if we vote today one of the player we find scummier it gets easier to progress in the following days even if we hit town.
 
genisu said:
just an idea, try posting more it helps people read you
Click to expand...

Yeah, today, when I woke up, I tried to read to catch up, but I couldn't make any posts because I had pending things to do. I’ll try to come and comment more regularly.
------

However, today I didn't see many things. Many people were marking Redless and DBD as suspicious, but it was because they didn't have much participation. Both were pressured to speak up already.

From around page 18 to 21, I didn't understand much, haha. I think Genisu, Hydreigon, and others were just sharing thoughts on who might be scum. But I didn't really identify with anything they said.

I haven't seen much more relevant than that. I still haven't managed to clear up much of what's going on. I think more conclusions will come out tomorrow when we’re all forced to vote for someone. Then we can see everyone's votes and the reasons they have.

I’ll try to read and comment again around 1 AM GMT-3. I'll try to comment something in the morning, afternoon, and evening every day.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top