oh its not showing for me and alice said it didnt show for her earlier
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Working Title Mafia (Game Thread) [Mafia Wins]
- Thread starter ImaginaryNeon
- Start date
fwiw it shows for me
1) for what I said in my post #690 I can't determine any stance from him. I saw all his messages in the thread and I don't see him giving an opinion on anything that isn't very obvious.
2) Simply from reading how he's playing THIS game, he's not giving much explanation for his actions to see the reaction of others, but then he argues concisely and coherently.
I was also his teammate in the previous Mafia game of the temples and saw/heard that his style is different from the conventional one for the reasons mentioned above.
That's what I observe, at least.
3) Honestly, I’ve never made one of these reads lists, but it would be something like this:
Town: Lechen, Hydreigon
Probably town: Jalmont, Alice, Joey, M2H
Neutral: DBD, Genisu, probably everyone else
Slightly scum: Saber, Redless
No read: Des, Catfries, Flanders (I don’t really understand his aggressive playstyle)
1. pulsar512b null slight scumlean, i dont like her posts, but i never do lol feels like possible scum(i think pulsar on scum tries to sweettalk newbies a bit more, which i havent seen a lot of this game.
2. Catfries bro has not typed, which means its hard to read them null, would support lynching later if we dont have better targets.
3. Alice Kazumi null slight scumlean, her posting hasnt been good and she is normally less active on scum then town,scumslips?
4. Dead by Daylight scumread, i dont know what bro is doing but its not good, then again he normally plays mafia with a stash of crack next to him.
5. genisu towncore
6. saberslasher11 townlean, its saber slasher he hasnt scumslipped yet so. also i liked his entrance a bit but it could be scum saber asw.
7. Lechen towncore
8. Redless null, i dont like their posting much, but it has gotten better.
9. HydrogenHydreigon high townread.
10. JALMONT its the goatmont ##shootalice, meh i never like his d1 lol but he gets better later, i think its cuz he doesnt like voting anyone d1
11. joey scumlean, i dont like what hes been cooking but he also doesnt play mafia
12. ElectricityCat null rn im trying to figure them out tho.
13. des121null maybe slight scumlean, newbienewbienewbie but its like saber 3p sort of newbie like slipping a ton
14. StupidFlandrs48 townlean flandrs starts acting like he is above the age of 5 when he is mafia, which i havent seen this game, maybe he has some sort of antiaging raygun that lowers his age when mafia now instead of just town tho.
15. M2H scumlean i didnt like his entrance, but others arent willing to shoot him early, but i definitely would vote him later down the line if i dont feel more confident about him.
yk im realizing what if neon. just gave the first 4 people scum
2. Catfries bro has not typed, which means its hard to read them null, would support lynching later if we dont have better targets.
3. Alice Kazumi null slight scumlean, her posting hasnt been good and she is normally less active on scum then town,scumslips?
4. Dead by Daylight scumread, i dont know what bro is doing but its not good, then again he normally plays mafia with a stash of crack next to him.
5. genisu towncore
6. saberslasher11 townlean, its saber slasher he hasnt scumslipped yet so. also i liked his entrance a bit but it could be scum saber asw.
7. Lechen towncore
8. Redless null, i dont like their posting much, but it has gotten better.
9. HydrogenHydreigon high townread.
10. JALMONT its the goatmont ##shootalice, meh i never like his d1 lol but he gets better later, i think its cuz he doesnt like voting anyone d1
11. joey scumlean, i dont like what hes been cooking but he also doesnt play mafia
12. ElectricityCat null rn im trying to figure them out tho.
13. des121null maybe slight scumlean, newbienewbienewbie but its like saber 3p sort of newbie like slipping a ton
14. StupidFlandrs48 townlean flandrs starts acting like he is above the age of 5 when he is mafia, which i havent seen this game, maybe he has some sort of antiaging raygun that lowers his age when mafia now instead of just town tho.
15. M2H scumlean i didnt like his entrance, but others arent willing to shoot him early, but i definitely would vote him later down the line if i dont feel more confident about him.
yk im realizing what if neon. just gave the first 4 people scum
can u explain your reads, it helps people read u ty
ok not sure why des sheeped me onto the jalmont vote, that makes me suspicious of this slot
No, I don't have much impact yet, I'm trying to improve that. I define having impact as being very active in the thread, contributing new things, and giving coherent theories. Also, responding to others and giving opinions. Providing information for the future of the game.
Hydreigon has a lot of impact, M2H has impact, you, Alice isn’t talking much but still has impact when she does, Joey those are some examples.
flandrs btw is just that one 10 year old kid on smogon claiming he is 18, yk how it goes and he lives in the mountains and jumps people all day irl
ok yeah this post reads as scum
?? this post makes zero sense
I outlined my reasons for the vote throughout the thread, I'm just curious about why des immediately after I posted my vote followed me onto the wagon
watch genisu try to push this mislynch and then when I flip town try to blame it on me
maybe they agreed for some reason? if you think jalmont is scum and this guy jumps on jalmont then you start scumreading the guy agreeing with you???
then again, you are the guy who last NOC scumread a townie because they said they were going to take an AP exam
i was unaware of their timezone, and lying about activity means you are scum, which is fine for me to push, however after i got evidence to the contrary, hhs reaction was genuine and caused me to high tr him, you on the other hand spent the entire game sheeping the entire scumteam trying to mislynch the dude who clapped their whole team brahh ion wanna hear it
Are you in a PC?
I'm not very good at analyzing yet, but I don't know what else I could say about my read list.
Lechen doesn't need much explanation. Hydreigon for being the player with the most impact that I'm seeing, with very coherent messages.
Jalmont, Alice, Joey, M2H I also like how they post, the ideas that really point towards something concrete. I feel they are trying to contribute to the town.
DBD, well, he's really starting to look suspicious :(((( I usually trust DBD a lot; I've trusted him in my 3 Mafia games. Honestly, I just consider him a friend and want to give him a chance. Please, DBD, if you read this, try to make a post analyzing the game a bit more.
You, I just starting to pay attention to your posting and playstyle so neutral, maybe townlean as we are having a cool interaction here.
My scum reads, not much more to add than what I said before, I don't have too much information at this point in the game either.
No reads are due to a lack of content or because they are new.
Few man, I think you made me talk more tonight than I did in my past three Mafia games. Enough for me today. I’m going to study and sleep now. It was very entertaining, though.
If you need anything else, I will read and comment a bit tomorrow before lunch.
If you need anything else, I will read and comment a bit tomorrow before lunch.
#1 you have no friends in this game everyone is an enemy, for example me and alice are good friends outside but here i try my best to have no positive bias vs her, which has helped me a lot.
#2 Jalmont, Alice, Joey, M2H I also like how they post, the ideas that really point towards something concrete. I feel they are trying to contribute to the town. didnt you just say jalmont was thinking incoherently, and can you explain your thoughts as to what is concrete in the following 3 peoples posts?
you need content for people to read you, and for mafia games you are generally expected to be much more active than you currently are lol, nice talking to you tho