NOC Working Title Mafia (Game Thread) [Mafia Wins]

M2H said:
i genuinely don't know how somebody reads all of my posts and goes "hmm... yeah thats a null slot"
Click to expand...
yeah i have thoughts about this you have posted a lot and some felt scummy. so im scumleaning m2h a litttttle bit (not much)

also jalmont firing off a random vote w no exp why is weird, saber has felt lean town to me if anything....
 
Catfries said:
Zero, at least for forum mafia.
Anyways I need to post something so here are my thoughts
No way Lechen is evil with that no cc tracker claim
Genisu, HyHy, and Flandrs seem town
M2H is certainly aggressive but we do need someone hanged today so I don't necessarily think they're scum.
Pulsar leans evil to me.
Click to expand...
is this ever coached

does someone who doesnt play maf have this many thoughts

also hyhy is NAI, genisu is. i havent read but im assuming hes being a dickhead which is hard to read as town but is nai, and flandrs i almost think is a lil scummy
 
i think my scumreads so far in order of magnitude are catfries and then jalmont and then m2h and then flandrs i think
townreads are saber and lechen is, i mean not a hard town lock we could still see a cc, but a soft lock
 
StupidFlandrs48 said:
I can tell genisu is trying to improve his content here but it just comes off as buzzword salad with all of the usual attitude we know and hate. The meta take on Jalmont and everything he's said about M2H have also been nonsensical Ls across the board. None of this is really a comment on his alignment.
Click to expand...
yep i agree this is prob a correct take
 
joey said:
I didn't like dbd's entrance posting a readlist with no explanations and not elaborating when people asked - I feel like I did the exact same thing last game I played as scum because it was the easy way to be "contributing to the game" while adding no information that will actually have impact
Click to expand...
hmmm this is a good point. but i dont see scum dbd calling out scumteammate jalmont. maybe this is mafia/wolf?
 
HydrogenHydreigon said:
REDLESS READS ACROSS THE GAME
Alice saying first post of redless has bad vibes #159
Lechen agreeing with alice #160
from m2h #175 possibly scumread there idk how to read that list
m2h pinging alice/redless as a pair #180
lechen says alice/redless seems plausible #194
flanders' vote on redless and reasoning #243/#249
first post from genisu quoted in my prev post #280
i think redless is sus #373/#375
redless in my scumpool #399
genisu doesn't like any of their posts #403/#405
lechen fine with redless vote #472
genisu fine with redless vote #493
lechen votes redless #517
genisu doesn't like redless vibes #523
dbd says rdelses scum eq is rising and votes redless #529

the only post that even qualifies as pushback is genisu #280 and that opinion changed down the line so there has been virtually zero pushback to redless as a vote, and i highly doubt mafia is just willing to drop redless here if he is mafia so i find this very strange
its not like only one person has read him either half the pl just went "yeah sure hes sus idm voting him"
Click to expand...
this is a lot of work to go through.

redless is probably not scum i think tbh?
 
Lechen said:
Before I hop on the prospective joey wagon, does anyone have prior game exp with him? We can check if he has comparable levels of inactivity in games where he is town. Anyways, i agree with redless wagon no pushback having red flags but i do think he could possibly be wolf tbh which explains why his first post emphasised hitting werewolf
Click to expand...
hes pretty much this active irregardless of alignment
 
Redless said:
I thought it was suspicious the way that m2h swapped to the Redless train so late. It felt opportunistic to me. Like scum trying to rush the lynch.

Vote m2h

I am willing to be the sacrificial lamb as well. When I flip town please be very suspicious of the people who voted for me, especially those who waited until later to do so (instead of those that started the train).
Click to expand...
this is very dismayed depressive posting
 
HydrogenHydreigon said:
ok i think ive pinpointed why
all of pulsar's reads come off as super intentionally hedgy; the all have the format like oh this is [towniesh phrase here] but [mafiaish phrase here] or vise versa
Click to expand...
i kinda feel like this is nai for me im just not really a fan of working off of low info and being confident
 
JALMONT said:
I'm not really feeling this game honestly - I'll be in class at deadline so won't be around. I don't really like any of the mainstream options. I suppose I'm okay with saber/dbd/flanders (depending on how flanders is from now until I can't check the thread). Didn't really like saber or dbd's responses to my pushes.

I'll try and come back to this in a few minutes
Click to expand...
how tf is jalmont a student

i thought he was like a 30 yo dad of three
 
JALMONT said:
I don't really get the Redless push vs say any of the other null posters.

I have to admit Catfries is pretty suspicious just because their two posts were very stilted compared to say des, who comes across as more naturally clueless (with all due respect haha). Clearly catfries is reading the thread if they can point to a certain post which leaves them to believe flanders is town. that energy not being consistent throughout the thread is strange to me and makes me think they are trying to "contribute" just to avoid attention (eg people randomly scumreading des for their posts).

I can't ever vote for catfries today however


someone needs to remind me how saber was as scum in TOS NOC, I get the feeling this saber and that saber are much more distinct so I'm probably just totally off.
Click to expand...
good post
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top