NOC Working Title Mafia (Game Thread) [Mafia Wins]

Please don't vote for M2H on day 1. This would be the third mafia game in a row where he leaves on day one as town (assuming he is town here too).

Honestly, I don't see any irrational comments from him. I think all his posts are quite coherent.
 
M2H said:
I'm gonna need you to explain this in other words O_O I cannot understand what you're saying at all
Click to expand...
I mean that when I was mafia in TOS in the same team that pulsar I defended her by saying that she wasn't the best town. I told that to Lechen in private conversation. You are using the same tactic there so I could see you being in the same team. Not a particularly strong read but a possibility.

ElectricityCat said:
Well, that's the argument she used. but I think she defends her mainly because des is new. Maybe I'm wrong, but that's the feeling I get.

I agree as well, it's a very bad reason to vote for Des, but at least it's cool to add a bit of spice to Day 1.
Click to expand...
Both things are right. Do not vote Des today.
Lechen said:
potentially yeah, i went back to look at ToS and among Alice's first posts was on that called out on her scumbuddy for lurking
Click to expand...
:mehowth:
 
What's up with the power rankings arc? Not a cool thing.

Anyways this is the second time in a row that someone argues TMI for me scum when I'm town I don't even know what I'm doing wrong.

genisu said:
im just wondering since my signature is glitched on my screen, but can you guys see the lcpl team logo?
Click to expand...
I can't see it.
Catfries said:
Zero, at least for forum mafia.
Anyways I need to post something so here are my thoughts
No way Lechen is evil with that no cc tracker claim
Genisu, HyHy, and Flandrs seem town
M2H is certainly aggressive but we do need someone hanged today so I don't necessarily think they're scum.
Pulsar leans evil to me.
Click to expand...
Welcome! Can you explain flandrs and pulsar read?
 
Townread: Lechen, Genisu
Tonwlean: HH
Mixed: M2H, Jalmont
Scumlean: Redless
Not enough info: Literally everyone else, not much has changed between my original reads and this.

I think we'd get more info on some veteran players once time passes. I'd like the newcomers to talk more if possible! We get more information on everyone that way. I'm curious about des reads because she made some really good reads in the previous game.
 
JALMONT said:
Didn’t like their posts, very surface level and the des “scumslip” is bad logic as I said previously
Click to expand...
I can't make a read for him right now because his posts don't have much content but I agree with the bad logic. Feels like jumping into conclusion too quick when it's not the first time that happens.
 
I forgot DBD was in this game we can vote him out too, I didn’t like how he went from a neutral read on m2h to townlean in the space of an hour after being pushed by m2h on that opinion without really mentioning that change
 
Catfries said:
my flandrs reasoning is mostly based on #249 which might be weak but eh.

my pulsar reasoning comes from her susing lechen who had no cc as tracker. i understand that WW could claim tracker but if they did wouldn't the real tracker just cc and a 1f1 would happen?
Click to expand...
This is pretty much why I townread lechen. It doesn't make sense for neither mafia nor ww to claim that. I don't scumread her for that post but she is not the worst vote for d1.

That flandrs post is pretty good I agree. I don't townread him off that because flandrs in general makes well explained and good points. I might need to reread Town of salem game to see his meta properly. We were both scum so I didn't read him at all nor pretended to.

JALMONT said:
I forgot DBD was in this game we can vote him out too, I didn’t like how he went from a neutral read on m2h to townlean in the space of an hour after being pushed by m2h on that opinion without really mentioning that change
Click to expand...
I'd like to read more from both saber and dbd honestly but solid point.
 
HydrogenHydreigon said:
I get it might just be a coincidence redless’ main points were piggybacks but I do feel like their response to being voted is kinda bad??
Click to expand...
The fact that it got glossed over almost makes me think redless could be partnered with one of the accussees and that discussion was just distancing?? But also feel like in no mafia team does redless that flimsy of a rebuttal.. like surely someone would tell him to do better
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top