NOC Working Title Mafia (Game Thread) [Mafia Wins]

Feel free to vote her, I'm just telling you that I won't participate in that :mehowth:

I don't even think she is the scummiest one. Redless, DBD and Joey are probably the best targets from what I listed
 
Alice Kazumi said:
Feel free to vote her, I'm just telling you that I won't participate in that :mehowth:

I don't even think she is the scummiest one. Redless, DBD and Joey are probably the best targets from what I listed
Click to expand...
why is des not scummy though. des's only posts are bad. redless is an alright vote and dbd is fine but joey's posts so far are p decent
 
Lechen said:
why is des not scummy though. des's only posts are bad. redless is an alright vote and dbd is fine but joey's posts so far are p decent
Click to expand...
I said not the scummiest one, not that she is not scummy.

Redless=DBD=Joey > Des = Catfries > Pulsar

I'm not convinced by joey defense honestly.
 
regardless though, i feel like if redless is scum he is wolf and we can afford to deal with wolf later as they can crossfire mafia as well. killing wolf does lessen a nightkill though, but im not convinced redless is more scummy than des
 
Lechen said:
regardless though, i feel like if redless is scum he is wolf and we can afford to deal with wolf later as they can crossfire mafia as well. killing wolf does lessen a nightkill though, but im not convinced redless is more scummy than des
Click to expand...
There are way more chances that wolf kills town than mafia so I'm not sure about that one. Yeah I already pointed out like a day ago that redless is probably the wolf so I agree with your view on him.
 
i ISOed des and im very convinced they are scum , but we can try redless if nobody wants to vote des despite feeling her feeling scummier.
 
Lechen said:
joey's defense is reasonable and puts them as mixed, plus others mentioned that joey is like this regardless of alignment
Click to expand...

Joey has contributed almost nothing and I could argue has some partner equity with DbD. His defense was word salad and he effectively recanted his position.
 
M2H said:
Joey has contributed almost nothing and I could argue has some partner equity with DbD. His defense was word salad and he effectively recanted his position.
Click to expand...
Fwiw dbd has been pretty much my only scumread during this game so far lol
 
Alice Kazumi said:
https://www.smogon.com/forums/threa...afia-explorers-game-thread-game-over.3736749/
This is NOC, I die relatively early.

https://www.smogon.com/forums/threa...salem-won-by-the-mafia-and-the-witch.3742975/
This one is semi-OC but I started it as if it was a NOC.
Click to expand...

If you rolled scum this game, how motivated do you think you would be? What kinda of things would you do differently than in the PMD game, for instance?

What do you feel like you learned in previous recent games that would change the way you play as mafia?
 
The only position I "recanted" was the take about tracker cc which was just me having a bad mechanical take - that was just me not thinking mechanics all the way through, I don't think there's any reason I would've done that on purpose were I scum
 
M2H said:
If you rolled scum this game, how motivated do you think you would be? What kinda of things would you do differently than in the PMD game, for instance?

What do you feel like you learned in previous recent games that would change the way you play as mafia?
Click to expand...
I'd be more aggressive in my approach trying to impact the thread more. It was my first scum game and I tried to appear towny but 3 players correctly called that I was scum. I feel like we as scum team left celever kind of alone in thread so definitely I would try to have more impact.
 
Anyway, the biggest thing I noticed catching up was that it's weird to put sus on jalmont for casting votes without much baseline and not explaining them. That seems very much like classic jalmont town meta trying to subtly put on pressure without fully saying reads
 
And we see that joey is seemingly just playing to JALMONT's gaze by town reading him, hard defending him, and sheeping his DbD read while giving nothing original of his own.
 
M2H said:
Why is des scum?
Click to expand...
posts feel off, early game she mentioned she won't claim what she is, which i think refers to alignment, which is a scummy thing to do. fsr she is saying "thank you" to everyone which reads sort of like a lousy attempt at sheeping when it didn't happen last game, could 100% be wrong, she isn't trying to gamesolve or do anything at all etc. she hasn't defended herself against an accusation from hyhy except for "hey why me" and her vote on jalmont feels off . another reason i like this vote is unlike every other player with the possible exclusion of catfries she hasnt contributed much to the gamestate
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top