NOC Working Title Mafia (Game Thread) [Mafia Wins]

why is pulsar trying to throw shade on everyone. Is it just to move the vote away from joey? I see a pulsar/joey scumteam with joey trying to bus yesterday.
 
Lechen said:
I have ISOed your posts, and you defended JALMONT way too much than I see any other town doing, possibly to sheep him. Your vote on dbd felt opportunistic af. You also tunneled dbd and pulsar too hard for my liking, didn't consider any other possibilities (dbd is my only scumread) and scumread pulsar hard for smth that seems like lazy town would do However, if you somehow aren't scum and flip town, we will know that both wagon's starters were composed of people who were clean and pulsar would be a much more tempting vote.
Click to expand...
This is fair. I will say in regards to the dbd vote, I absolutely suck at day 1s and me having a solid scumread at all is a new development for me, but obviously it did not work out. i did give a lot more scumreads day 2 (pulsar and redless, and lean ecat)

JALMONT was sooooo clearly town, I think it's absolutely ridiculous that he was voted yesterday to be honest and if M2H hadn't been confirmed townie who turned out to just be wrong I don't think jalmont gets voted. hardly anyone else was scumreading him and most who were were just sheeping m2h

I still absolutely stand by the pulsar thing. pulsar knows how she is perceived and thought she could get away with that, and was pretty much correct! no one really pressured her the whole day and she gave 0 contributions

in a vacuum i would say my scumread on redless is still stronger than my scumread on pulsar, but with the track on redless + the revelation (for me) that wolf has another ability that could be tracked i don't think it's smart at all to bank on redless being backup and vote them today (same argument applies to catfries)

##vote pulsar

i don't really think there's a way this day goes that will get me to swap this vote (BUT I AM NOT LOCKING IT PULSAR TAKE NOTES)
 
I should also note that des just answered my "why didn't you lock on Jalmont" with "I forgot" which is sketchy as fuck

And saying you get town and wolf vibes from someone at the same time is also like what??? It makes more sense for pulsar than most ppl but still. I've been giving des the newbie pass for a while so these moments have been easy to ignore individually, is that a mistake?
 
I find it strange how the joey wagon is passing through with no opposition. I think it will be a better idea to ##Vote des121 instead. Their posting of saber assuredly being town is weird and I think that's not smth noob town does
 
The amount of posts, the reasoning, the concern, the intention to resolve from Des... all of this has greatly improved in her over the last few days.

I've noticed a significant improvement, she's new, and I don't think she's faking any of this. I believe Des is town strongly.
 
Town core:
Lechen: Lechen :thumbsup:
HydrogenHydreigon: He has been overly committed almost all the time. He is the person who tries the hardest to solve the game, who analyzes the most, and throughout the game, we have all read him as town. Besides this, we know 100% that he is not WW. M2H said he used Jailkeeper on him N1, where the WW killed someone. This indicates that he is not WW because otherwise, his kill would have been blocked. If he were mafia, his behavior and his actively solving attitude wouldn't fit... I firmly believe he is town, and I put him together with Lechen.

90% Chances Town:
Des121 (reasons mentioned in previous post)


We have this people left:
pulsar512b: Could honestly be both Mafia or WW. I never read anything from Pulsar in this game that I liked, and my suspicion only increases as the days go by. They behave randomly, and it seems everyone thinks they are town. They could be mafia, and those defending them might be their partners. Their attitudes don't make sense to me for any faction.

Catfries: Probably not the wolf, he was tracked very early in the game (N0) there are very few chances in which catfries would idle his trackable action. We still have that weird theory of catfries being Mafia backup. I would say he is maybe town, but I would like to see more from him today to make a choice.

saberslasher11: I didn't like his vibes much in the first few days. He improved after that and continue to comment occasionally. However, I think they only have 1 or 2 messages longer than one line of text. I guess it's their play style. I don't know him well, to be honest. 33%/33%/33% chance of being wolf/mafia/town. People I trust read him as town, so I give them the benefit of the doubt. Note: if I'm not bad, saber and pulsar have been defending each other. I can see a world where if any of these two flips mafia they are a team, not sure, just a theory.

Redless: Probably not the wolf since last night Lechen tracked. Since we are already in a somewhat advanced stage, it would be quite logical for the WW not to want to use their other trackable action to avoid raising suspicions. That's why I don't clear them 100%
joey

StupidFlandrs48: Similar to Saber (a lot of people I trust had town reads for him), but way more weird. Did you all see that vote last day into redless? I mean, his posting are a bit funny, but idk. I can see him being Mafia or Wolf very strongly. I would need to reread all of his content but I don't have the time rn.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top