Townlean+:
a fairy - soft claimed, townish role confirmed (through my night results). that said she was very hands off d1 iirc and I remember not particularly liking her posts. she also pushes hard on lhf like des and pulsar (though in the case of pulsar EoD2 all the scrutiny was deserved). I value my mech knowledge a little higher than my social reads though hence townlean.
Hyhy - still reads like he's genuinely trying, though obviously I feel like his reads on me are off. If he doesn't have a satisfying answer to my responses to him I might bump him down but I still wouldn't vote him off next day.
CK - the same mech knowledge still holds: there's no way we don't have a vig in role madness, there was no counterclaim. but the longer mafia leaves him alive the more sus he becomes. I disagree with some of his evaluations but I don't get particularly bad vibes.
Vizh - I'm biased because he's argued in my favor a couple of times already but I find their logic solid - like klook at 2917, that just makes sense.
Light townlean:
skipper, charlie, sunny: I've been trying to read up on/ISO these people several times but a lot of their posts are NAI, refer back to much earlier discussions (making it even more tedious to read further back when low on time). I am a little surprised to see so many people rank sunny so high given that his posts don't stand out to me so much (positively or negatively) but like I said earlier I do think his vibes earlygame were fine. Maybe I'll be able to reach a better conclusion once I make my lil chart of reads.
Null:
Wisp - I might've put pulsar here as slightly scummy but I liked Wisp's entrance so far and don't envy the amount of work they have to do to catch up. des's voting of that slot makes me think this slot might actually be town, but there's like 5 scum in this game and they gotta be somewhere.
Scummish:
NightEmerald - this hasn't changed much from my previous look and I'll need to look again cause I saw a couple people re-evaluate their opinions on him in a more positive way, and the last couple posts strike me as no worse than the people I have in light townlean
Scummy:
des - absolutely the GOAT for liking posts though
DBD - obviously do not like his push on me, and I think the logic is inherently flawed and I've pointed out before so I won't repeat myself. there were some posts today that I thought were more productive but that's something I can say for almost the entire game at this point
a fairy - soft claimed, townish role confirmed (through my night results). that said she was very hands off d1 iirc and I remember not particularly liking her posts. she also pushes hard on lhf like des and pulsar (though in the case of pulsar EoD2 all the scrutiny was deserved). I value my mech knowledge a little higher than my social reads though hence townlean.
Hyhy - still reads like he's genuinely trying, though obviously I feel like his reads on me are off. If he doesn't have a satisfying answer to my responses to him I might bump him down but I still wouldn't vote him off next day.
CK - the same mech knowledge still holds: there's no way we don't have a vig in role madness, there was no counterclaim. but the longer mafia leaves him alive the more sus he becomes. I disagree with some of his evaluations but I don't get particularly bad vibes.
Vizh - I'm biased because he's argued in my favor a couple of times already but I find their logic solid - like klook at 2917, that just makes sense.
Light townlean:
skipper, charlie, sunny: I've been trying to read up on/ISO these people several times but a lot of their posts are NAI, refer back to much earlier discussions (making it even more tedious to read further back when low on time). I am a little surprised to see so many people rank sunny so high given that his posts don't stand out to me so much (positively or negatively) but like I said earlier I do think his vibes earlygame were fine. Maybe I'll be able to reach a better conclusion once I make my lil chart of reads.
Null:
Wisp - I might've put pulsar here as slightly scummy but I liked Wisp's entrance so far and don't envy the amount of work they have to do to catch up. des's voting of that slot makes me think this slot might actually be town, but there's like 5 scum in this game and they gotta be somewhere.
Scummish:
NightEmerald - this hasn't changed much from my previous look and I'll need to look again cause I saw a couple people re-evaluate their opinions on him in a more positive way, and the last couple posts strike me as no worse than the people I have in light townlean
Scummy:
des - absolutely the GOAT for liking posts though
DBD - obviously do not like his push on me, and I think the logic is inherently flawed and I've pointed out before so I won't repeat myself. there were some posts today that I thought were more productive but that's something I can say for almost the entire game at this point
