Samtendo09 said:But I beg you one question: Are some of the top tiers in recent generations immensively unfun to fight against?
For me, they really are. Making offense more viable is fine and all, but to go as far as making battle ending in far fewer turns than before can make the matches going way too fast with too few countermeasures.
50/50 is awful to fight against, as shown with Kingambit and Raging Bolt. Spammable 120 BP spread is awful to fight against, as shown with Terapagos and Calyrex’s Rider forms. A Pokémon that hit hard, fast and can survive one side with an easily spammable STAB can get on one’s nerve, as shown with Flutter Mane. Rain is also lot more painful to deal with with Archaludon entering the scene.
If spectacle and match speed are vastly prioritized over enjoyment, that is a problem that will eventually come to haunt VGC. Meta Knight almost singlehandedly killed Brawl competitive scene, Bayonetta did in Smash 4, and other hated top tier does it in other less popular competitve scenes. So it’s not a stretch to think that one day, the excessive power creep has gone so bad that VGC matches aren’t interesting to watch anymore.
See this is criticism I can get behind.
I'll point, I don't think VGC is *balanced* in the true sense of the term.
GF is 100% "balancing" around spectacle and fast paced games, because they know that's what people want to watch. Obviously, there is also a limit to how much *players* are willing to play it.
The thing is, I don't think the "120 BP spread moves" or "excessively easy to set up gigabulky mons" are the problem they have, far from it.
Something that you'd notice is that there's no actual overwhelming presence, there's no CHALK this gen, while there's definitely some top dogs amongst the restricted (which is to be expected in a singles restricted meta tbh), there is a decent spread amongst 4-5 of them with usually 4 or 5 taking about ~80% of the picks, leading to a centralizing meta that still isn't just "the same 6 pokemon in all top teams" and at least gives you a somewhat narrow amount of stuff to cover for.
The non-restricted surprisingly have a pretty solid balance in distribution, even otherwise-bullshit mons like Sneaseler, Incineroar or Urshifu don't usually break a 35% presence since each fit on different archetype and the top 5 restricteds (usually so far, Terapagos, Miraidon, Calyrex(both of them) and Zamazenta) all fit in different archetypes.
There is one thing I however think that if it keeps up *will* bite this design phylosophy in the back, and it's RNG.
Pokemon games have always had RNG in them, almost every attack has infamous 10-30% effects, crits exist, damage ranges exist, and abilities that have % to trigger exist.
RNG isnt inherently bad when it's limited. Bo3 generally makes sure the better player still wins (albeith honestly they should move to Bo5 at this point), but with how fast paced the meta has become, all it takes is a single "unlucky roll" to flip a match.
Sure comebacks are fun to watch and scenic but... how does it feel to lose to a 10%, or to bank all your winning chances on a 25% chance to triple protect? Or miss 3 90% in a row, cause we know Will o Wisp is actually 10% accurate.
I mentioned earlier "VGC streams chat". When "crits happen" or similar things, a lot of people do complain about "skilled game". While a lot of times this is just people being dumb... is it really? I've watched almost every single streamed VGC event this year, and honestly, there were far FAR too many matches, including top 8 or even finals, where it just boiled down to who got lucky.
The random effects, as well as crits ignoring de/buffs, mainly exist as a way to prevent stall and defensive strategies from being overwhelming, but when the game becomes this fast and this explosive, they turn too many games into lotteries. And yes, Sneaseler isn't helping it. *Most* of the time, Dire Claw hasn't really won a match off a status roll, usually the target still dies before even getting a turn, or the status isn't relevant at all. But the simple fact it exists on a pokemon that is on its own very common contributes turning a lot of matches into "just get lucky four head".
THAT is really gigabad for the game. THAT is the criticism to the balance approach GF has I can agree with.
It's not the powerhouses, it's not the fast paced meta, it's the fact that those are mutually exclusive with RNG.
Powercreep is fine. Playing lottery in a competitive environment where there's prizes and actual money behind is terrible and I agree WILL damage the game long term if they don't calm down with it.