A preamble on the Sega Genesis (to give some context on the upcoming Sega Genesis reviews I've got cooking up)
The Sega Genesis is a really underrated system, which sucks since it ends up getting easily buried in greater gaming discourse, but it results in the Genesis being IMO the best retro system to collect for when it comes to price vs game quality. All of the "really desirable games that didn't sell millions of copies" are in that somewhat reasonable $45-70 range, any Sega published game outside that group (of which there are a LOT) is like $10-30, and there's maybe 10 games that go for $100+ (all of which you can live without) while the SNES has like 60 of them (which includes Lufia 2, Chrono Trigger, Earthbound, and every Mega Man besides X1).
The Genesis was very much a console in the right place at the right time. With arcades still booming, the Genesis tried to focus more on bringing the Arcade experience home, a philosophy that also reflected in the kinds of games on the system. While the SNES focused more on making more expansive and content-rich games, which obviously aged better consider how gaming tastes have developed since then, the Genesis was the cheaper console that focused on shorter games that were much flashier, intense, and often harder; many of the killer apps on the Genesis don't even have unlimited continues, let alone a save system.
Sure, the SNES was the stronger system in most aspects: Colors, music that used samples, and complex graphical effects possible through Mode 7, but the Genesis had a much faster processor, hence the slogan "Blast Processing". This actually worked well to the Genesis ideologies: They want fast, hard, and flashy games, and a fast processor that minimizes slowdown is extremely helpful to have. A prime example of the Genesis's advantage can be seen in Shmups. The limited scope of these games already makes them a poor fit for the types of games that fit the SNES ideologies, but then you combine it with a much slower processor that resulted in far slower and laggier gameplay. Meanwhile, Shmups absolutely flourished on the Genesis. Similar stuff happened with Run n Guns and arguably even sports games. Hell, even the Genesis sound chip fit into this ideology. It was far less intuitive than the SNES's, but when used properly, it could actually do rock and electronic music a lot better than the SNES; genres that, surprise surprise, go really well with intense action games.
Conversely, while the SNES is considered one of the greatest systems ever made for RPGs, the genre just did not fit the style of game and audience the Genesis was looking for. This meant that the Genesis actually floundered in Japan while the SNES got new games as late as 2000, years after anyone in the West cared. Combine these factors together, and pretty much every RPG on the Genesis and Sega CD got localized for the US; while the SNES has a laundry list of JP-only RPGs (most of which came out in 1995 or later), the only really noteworthy ones we missed on Genesis were Langrisser 2, Rent a Hero, and Monster World IV (which actually got an official localization by Sega in 2012 lol). Hell, many of the RPGs on the Genesis were published or developed by Sega themselves, and even the SRPGs like the Shining Force games and Warsong (Langrisser 1) got localized, a genre that was pretty much absent from any console in the West until Final Fantasy Tactics.
But the question is...were these games any good? The Genesis doesn't have the wide colors or graphical effects that allow for the stunning look of most SNES RPGs. Their sound chip doesn't really work well for the orchestral sounds found in most SNES RPGs. And Sega's gameplay philosophy don't really align with games that are long, expansive, and story-heavy. How can Sega even make an RPG that competes with the SNES,
especially one without action elements?
It's simple, you don't. Sega made an RPG that played to their strengths.
"And the world continued for thousands of years..."
Phantasy Star IV (1993 / 1995)
Developer / Publisher: Sega
System: Genesis. Lotsa ports but most of modern system ports got delisted (it's on NSO Expansion tho). I'm playing on an original Genesis cart
Completion Notes: P sure I did every sidequest. Didn't play the other Phantasy Star games (you don't need to but there are some references to past games throughout)
Immediately upon booting up Phantasy Star IV, before even the Sega logo finishes fadeing in, it becomes clear that this game is gonna be...different from your typical 16-bit RPG.
Almost every 16-bit RPG begins with an orchestral piece, either a calm and beautiful orchestral piece to set the mood right, something more sweeping and epic to impress upon you the epic scale of the journey you are about to embark upon, or even sometimes both. Sure, plenty of Genesis games try to compete and do very admirable jobs but...come on, stay in your lane, you're not outdoing the
Chrono Trigger or
Final Fantasy VI openings lol.
So instead, when you boot up Phantasy Star IV, the game hits you with
THIS.
Phantasy Star IV has a bit of an odd reputation. It seems to be hailed as one of the greatest games ever made, and a game that could apparently "compete alongside the best the SNES had to offer." And yet, it's not a game that really gets discussed much in RPG discourse, even Shining Force 2 gets a lot more attention. I think, more importantly, I've never really gotten a good explanation as to
why Phantasy Star IV is good. The general impression I've gotten is that it was a cleanly executed JRPG with a strong scope that happened to be on Genesis (a system not known for RPGs),
therefore, it is one of the all-time greats ("It's Final Fantasy for the Genesis!!!!"). God knows, the SNES has plenty of those kinds of games, but you don't see Lufia II or even Super Mario RPG on Wikipedia's greatest games ever list.
Having played it myself, while I wouldn't call Phantasy Star IV a masterpiece...I do think it is very, very good, and definitely a game that is worth checking out as a nice, A-tier 16-bit RPG (if S-tier is considered to include the likes of Final Fantasy VI).
If I can pinpoint the main thing that makes Phantasy Star IV standout, it's the INCREDIBLE pacing. Sega Genesis games were excellent at this stuff and holy SHIT does Phantasy Star IV do a great job of maintaining momentum. The game starts right away, you're right in the first town, introduced to the main leads Alys and Chaz, who both have some fun personality, you're told about a mysterious monster outbreak, you recruit a new party member, and then within the first 5-10 min you're off into the first dungeon. Within my first 45-60 minute playsession, I had recruited another party member, gone through two more dungeons (including a couple boss fights), visited four more towns, and a few story-only locations. Compare this to Final Fantasy VI; as incredible as the start of the game is, that equivalent amount of time is spent entirely in Narshe. It's not really a matter one game being better than the other, it's moreso that Phantasy Star IV is a refreshing change of pace.
This pacing keeps going throughout the whole game. Dungeons are mazes and endurance tests (more on that later), but they're still pretty short. There's a good number of optional dungeons that are sprinkled throughout the entire playthrough on top of sidequests that get unlocked as you explore the world. So if you
do need a quick distraction from the story, they're there for you, which is honestly a nice change of pace from Chrono Trigger and Final Fantasy VI that have great sidequests (especially FFVI), but they're mostly relegated to endgame material that impact the ending. In PSIV, you just waltz into a bird cave you found for shits and giggles, find a cool piece of equipment that you'll use for the next hour or two, and then be on your way.
Battles also move incredibly fast thanks to quick but effective animations, and the Macro system which lets you automatically run through your character's actions from a preset you made outside of battle, drastically cutting down time needed for decision making. Menu movement and text is instantaneous too, maybe even a little too fast since I often skip over things lol, and there's very little pausing during battles from text boxes, animations, waiting for the run action to resolve, etc etc. I've timed some of my battles, I think the average random encounter in this game takes like 20 seconds from loading on the overworld to returning to the overworld.
Oh yeah, you can actually
run from battles fairly easily, which is a big accomplishment considering the run button never fucking worked in Earthbound and takes 9 million years to finish in Final Fantasy VI. Phantasy Star IV gets rather tough as it goes on, not to the point where you need to grind (as long as you're like me and don't consider "backing out of a dungeon when you nab a bunch of items or if you need to heal before returning to fight the boss" grinding), but those dungeons and boss fights can get very stressful, being filled with late-game bosses or enemies capable of 2 or 3 shotting your entire party.
Now, in most JRPGs, bosses with strong attacks aren't really a big deal on their own. But in a move that seems annoying on paper but is actually really smart in practice, PSIV has pretty much no way to recover magic (outside of inns) and your inventory space is pretty tight, only holding about 48 items including Key Items. In fact, revive items and full healing items in general are hard to come by. You get them dotted through the dungeons, but you can only buy them in the final third of the game, and even then, a single one costs about as much as a piece of mid/late-game equipment (I didn't even know there was a store lol, I was just working off of the items I found on the field). As a result, you can't mindlessly mash your way through dungeons or bosses, you have to be mindful of the resources you're working with if you want to survive. This actually makes the run button a strategic decision: Do I trust my ability to cleanly finish this fight? Or should I run away because even if I survive, I will exhaust too many resources? You need to fight some amount of battles after all, you need that EXP for bosses!
I will note that at the end of the day, PSIV is actually a very
simple JRPG. There's pretty much no unique mechanics, it's just your usual attacks and spell slinging. There are special attacks, but they basically operate as limited use "magic-like" attacks (similar to the PP system in Pokemon). There's also an equivalent to Chrono Trigger's Dual and Triple Techs, but they're very finicky to trigger and honestly not all that necessary to beating the game. But this also means that, again, there's really not much you can do to trivialize the game. Yeah, being overpowered is fun and all, but I sometimes wonder if Chrono Trigger would be better if the solution to the entire second half of the game wasn't to spam Gold Stud Luminaire and whatever AoE magic I had on my characters. The final boss has 23,000 HP, and you best believe you are not hitting close to the 999 damage cap; there's no X-Fight or Ultima shenanigans like in FFVI, you are dealing 1,000 damage per turn (assuming you don't need to heal, which you will do a lot!), you are stomaching the occasional attack that will 2HKO your whole party, and you WILL have to battle your way through (it's actually not
that bad considering I won first try, but damn I used up all of my items and barely survived)
Phantasy Star IV's story is actually pretty simple, "kill the evil darkness threatening the entire world" stuff, although it takes place in a setting that mixes fantasy and space sci-fi. The characters don't have a
ton of depth and most of them don't develop a lot. But what makes the story work is how it's presented to the player. Since the Genesis can't do fancy Mode 7 stuff with a million bajillion colors like the SNES, Phantasy Star IV's overworld is pretty bland and archaic looking by late 1993 and
especially early 1995 standards. However, Sega decided to tell the game's story primarily through cutscenes structured like manga, and they work really nicely! Not just at visualizing the story, but also injecting a lot more personality into the cast.
On that note, Phantasy Star IV, has really damn good writing and localization, which makes sense considering Sega likely had a strong localization department given their foothold in NA. Dare I say, it's one of the very best localizations of the 16-bit era (Super Mario RPG, Earthbound, and Snatcher are really the only games that come to mind that best it). Characters talk in a way that feels incredibly natural, there's no odd stiltedness that sometimes exists in FFVI (as much as I adore that game's story and characters). There's a sense of fun to it all, seeing Alys instantly try to get Hahn to pay her for escorting him through the first dungeon, Rune constantly trolling the shit out of Chaz (though gradually become more of a cheeky big brother as the game goes on), Kyra being go-getter cool girl. Since this is Sega, they're a bit more relaxed on censorship. For example, while there's no explicit mention of alcohol, there are bars and they certainly suggest that some characters are drunk. There's even a few mildly risqué moments (mild enough and delivered in such a way that it's admittedly pretty fun/funny rather than weird) such as learning certain things about the main heroine Alys. It was actually kinda surprising to find out that some of the lines in this game were mistranslated, because the writing is so tight that it just
works regardless (i.e. see below)
I'll note that while you're not getting a story filled with iconic moments that deeply explores some rather introspective themes (ala FFVI and grief-based depression), there are some noteworthy highlights through the game.
There's a particular boss fight about a third of the way through the game that is easily one of the best "forced-loss" fights I've ever seen, the way he doesn't attack you at all for two turns straight while all of your attacks miss, the way his first attack just summons a dark figure ala Kefka's Goner attack in FFVI, and when he finally decides to attack a character, the attack animation flashes the screen like CRAZY. It's almost like he's so strong, that the game itself is breaking when he uses it.
The ending, as well as an endgame sidequest, I think hammer in what the game's main theme was: the balance between connections / friendships with others, and the acceptance that we all move on with our lives as time passes so we must have an independent strength too
Vague Endgame Spoilers
Phantasy Star IV has about 10 or so playable characters, and the vast majority will leave the party after joining for at least some amount of time. It feels great to be able to see them again during the endgame, but I will concede that the ending did sting a bit when everyone had to go their own separate ways. This theme is reflected in Chaz's arc as he sees these characters he came to know come and go, many being characters he will likely never see again. Over the course of the game, he goes from being a weak apprentice to the strongest member of your party in a natural ludonarrative. So when everyone has to leave, he now, like everyone else has the strength to keep living on his own terms. Again, it's nothing deep and his character is still pretty basic, but like everything else in this game, the execution is simple but very clean
One last thing I can touch on is the game's soundtrack. The Genesis is pretty infamous for its soundchip producing a lot of bad music, but truthfully there is plenty of great Genesis music, and Phantasy Star IV is one such case. The Genesis soundchip is particularly good at harder rock and metal music as well as electronic, and much like the game's intro, the best in Phantasy Star IV reflect this.
You've got the electronic vibes of
Behind the Circuit, one of the primary dungeon themes. There's the sinisterness of
Laughter, which is basically the equivalent of the Magus battle theme (beware spoilers!!). The more general RPG stuff is great too,
here's another more traditional dungeon theme that is catchy and energetic as hell. And of course, there is the INCREDIBLE
Ooze, a straight-up metal song for the final battle that is equal parts sinister/intense and motivating/exciting (yes, it's absolutely better than Porky Means Business), it's probably my favorite song in the game. And yes, GaMetal has a great
cover of it (and
Laughter too).
If you're looking for a 16-bit JRPG not named Chrono Trigger or Super Mario RPG that's simple, fast-paced / not very long (maybe 20 hours tops if you do every sidequest?), has a straightforward plot that would have fit right at home on late 90s/early 00s Toonami, and is, above all, a lot of fun (unlike FF Mystic Quest), I'd highly recommend Phantasy Star IV. Just maybe don't go in expecting complex gameplay or a particularly deep story-driven masterpiece.