Each setup has 3 random towns and 1 town support, and transporter is not a unique role, so theoretically there could be 4 transporters if the rng was really crazy
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Town of Salem 2 Mafia: Revival - WON BY THE MAFIA AND THE WITCH
- Thread starter Ehmcee
- Start date
If everyone in the game is town yes, but Hydro could have also been lying because he’s scum
But yeah if Hydro is town it was probably a hypnotist, or Joey says roles can be duplicates but someone else would’ve claimed transported by now bc we’ve all been here since Hydro claimed besides DBD (I think)
joey are you sure 2 transporters can spawn because what happens if transporter 1 transports a with b while transporter b transports b with c
If I was host and there were more than 1 transporter I'd redo it.
I think watcher is actually here under "lookout", right?
no but lookout, what he claimed isn't in my results
I think the first question that needs to be answered before we can start to draw any conclusions from this interaction is, Dead by Daylight were you transported?
I would vote Alice out of the two because scrambling together a claim based on the info available that is now invalid bc she was prepping for the wrong scenario just like… happens in games like this
Why would fakeclaim Alice include Lookout in her list of roles for roxie(?) hydro(?) idk anymore when there was a claimed Lookout elsewhere yk
Why would fakeclaim Alice include Lookout in her list of roles for roxie(?) hydro(?) idk anymore when there was a claimed Lookout elsewhere yk
Can you read the results I posted twice
Alice x Hydro scumteam is extremely possible due to mech but also bc of the Whisper Mechanic where I’m p sure they were the 2 players going ham on D1 whispers
Which don’t get me wrong fits both of their personalities but there was also nothing to talk about on D1 the biggest use of whispers is to ingratiate yourselves emotionally with town as scum
Which don’t get me wrong fits both of their personalities but there was also nothing to talk about on D1 the biggest use of whispers is to ingratiate yourselves emotionally with town as scum
I did I’m drunk in bed idr the target but ik Lookout wasn’t there
Ok yeah so the claimed list would’ve been for Hydro which tbf is bold bc Hydro is alive but yk
That’s part of what links Alice and Hydro together as scumbuds tbqh because claiming rolecop (whatever the ToS name is) on an alive other alignment player is extremely bold unless they’re your partner who you know will back up the claim
That’s part of what links Alice and Hydro together as scumbuds tbqh because claiming rolecop (whatever the ToS name is) on an alive other alignment player is extremely bold unless they’re your partner who you know will back up the claim
If I I was mafia I would have included lookout in my results based on the fact that roxie got transported with the supposed nightkill DBD. He claimed first lookout so if I knew they were transported I would have fakeclaimed from the lookout list. What you are saying doesn't make sense.
I think one of des or dbd is lying here. This doesn't make sense.
It’s weird that your result also included Hydro’s role though right? If his role wasn’t included he would’ve countered your claim when you made it, when we all still thought you targeted Hydro
It’s not tiny odds but it’s a nice coincidencen
I don’t think you’re crossed with des, I think you’re about 80% crossed with DBD or there’s a minority 20% chance you’re crossed with Hydro instead
I also thought it was roxie/hydro because he claimed transported and is in my list.
I feel like we've reached a point of chaos where someone actually does have to be flipped to tell us anything, because this is getting a bit nuts:
if every single one of alice, dbd, hyhy, and des are town the following would have all had to happen
- des targeted roxie and dbd to transport
- dbd was targeted for the kill night 1 and also targeted with a janitor
- alice targeted roxie and received dbd's possible role list
- dbd targeted roxie to investigate and ended up investigating himself, learning that roxie/alice visited him. This means roxie would have had to self-target with something, and could not possibly have self-killed. if roxie targeted dbd instead of themselves dbd would not have seen it on their investigative
- there is a godfather in this setup who happened to double target roxie/dbd with the janitor
- there is also a hypnotist in this setup who independently hit hyhy with a fake transporter result on the same night all of this nonsense happened
this is all technically possible but extremely unlikely, I think. Would flipping alice or des answer more questions? I think it would have to be one of them, right?
would a transporter role alert someone that they've been transported? I would assume yes because it's one of the hypnosis options on the document.
if every single one of alice, dbd, hyhy, and des are town the following would have all had to happen
- des targeted roxie and dbd to transport
- dbd was targeted for the kill night 1 and also targeted with a janitor
- alice targeted roxie and received dbd's possible role list
it would be one of the following (investigator? I'm pretty sure that's synonymous with watcher)
- dbd targeted roxie to investigate and ended up investigating himself, learning that roxie/alice visited him. This means roxie would have had to self-target with something, and could not possibly have self-killed. if roxie targeted dbd instead of themselves dbd would not have seen it on their investigative
- there is a godfather in this setup who happened to double target roxie/dbd with the janitor
- there is also a hypnotist in this setup who independently hit hyhy with a fake transporter result on the same night all of this nonsense happened
this is all technically possible but extremely unlikely, I think. Would flipping alice or des answer more questions? I think it would have to be one of them, right?
would a transporter role alert someone that they've been transported? I would assume yes because it's one of the hypnosis options on the document.
Do you think it’s likelier that Hydro didn’t counter your result because he’s one of the roles on it, or because he couldn’t because his actual role is a scum role not in your resultI also thought it was roxie/hydro because he claimed transported and is in my list.
Okay, here's how this could have gone down without anyone lying:
1. Des transports the player in Roxie's spot (Roxie) and the player in DBD's spot (DBD). DBD is now in Roxie's spot and Roxie is in DBD's spot
2. An unidentified transporter transports the player in Hydro's spot (Hydro) with the player in Roxie's spot (DBD). DBD is now in Hydro's spot and Hydro is now in Roxie's spot.
Now DBD's Lookout, Alice's investigator, and Roxie's ??? are targeted at Roxie's spot - which Hydro is in. DBD sees Alice and Roxie visit and Alice gets a result based off of Hydro's role.
This means the kill was launched at DBD's spot, because that's where Roxie ended up.
If anyone else was transported during the night, NOW is the time to say it, because it is very important.
1. Des transports the player in Roxie's spot (Roxie) and the player in DBD's spot (DBD). DBD is now in Roxie's spot and Roxie is in DBD's spot
2. An unidentified transporter transports the player in Hydro's spot (Hydro) with the player in Roxie's spot (DBD). DBD is now in Hydro's spot and Hydro is now in Roxie's spot.
Now DBD's Lookout, Alice's investigator, and Roxie's ??? are targeted at Roxie's spot - which Hydro is in. DBD sees Alice and Roxie visit and Alice gets a result based off of Hydro's role.
This means the kill was launched at DBD's spot, because that's where Roxie ended up.
If anyone else was transported during the night, NOW is the time to say it, because it is very important.
I mean if he was scum with his actual role I don't see why he would counter it. Scum hydro would have accepted it either way. Or Im not sure I follow your thought process
DBD claimed lookout (watcher), not on the list. The transported role alerts. Pretty sure DBD would have claimed he was transported since there was all the talk. That's why I think one of des and dbd lies.