NOC E.G.O Wielders Mafia - A 17P Role Madness (Game Thread) - MAFIA WIN

[StupidFlandrs48]

This is 'Murica, of course you can

Alice Kazumi sup

 

[Dead by Daylight]

nooooo

 

[Dead by Daylight]

ok my scum teammates are telling me to post reads. hm let's see here

 

[a fairy]

You can ping them but if they reply to your post the replies will be deleted lol

 

[Celever]

Hey I think we said the same thing p much

 

[a fairy]

i said no you said yes what do you mean

 

[Celever]

i said no you said yes what do you mean

You said “I don’t recommend it and this is why” and I said “you could but this is why you shouldn’t”

These are like, the same thing to me

 

[a fairy]

i'm going to fight celever

 

[Dead by Daylight]

I may have accidentally derailed the thread, let's get it back on track with a discussion about Celever

Posts like the following make me think he's just inactive or not paying attention at the minute but trying to filler:

With 17 players it’s realistically (if just town vs mafia) 4 or 5 though. Probably a tad likelier to be 5

Ch3mdah hey friend since you know the flavour

Any role speculation on scum you could do using the base material? For example is there someone who’s a natural fit for “third party”, I.e. against both the town and mafia factions? If so, what uh weapons / items does each of those characters have?

and the filler is conversations like the one we had above.

Stuff like this on Flandrs

Flandrs is probscum but I don’t like the posts of any of the people accusing him either so maybe he isn’t

also feels like an ingenuine attempt at solving, although I will say I do appreciate the later questioning

 

[Dead by Daylight]

weird al, why would you do this

 

[Celever]

I may have accidentally derailed the thread, let's get it back on track with a discussion about Celever

Posts like the following make me think he's just inactive or not paying attention at the minute but trying to filler:


and the filler is conversations like the one we had above.

Stuff like this on Flandrs

also feels like an ingenuine attempt at solving, although I will say I do appreciate the later questioning

All of these posts were done while I was at work so I wasn’t paying that much attention I write them between calls and those gaps are of random length

But the first one is a direct quote response to a question someone asked so the conclusion definitely doesn’t track there, and the third one is part of a post chain it’s one minute after the prior thought so I’d argue more conservatively that it also doesn’t track

The direct response to a question which is quoted in that post is the offender here though. Would you have preferred no one answer the question

 

[Dead by Daylight]

1) i feel the same way as AP did - a circus mod who is (presumably) a good mafia player would likely know what the setup was likeliest to be
2) yes, i would like to see any question posed go unanswered

 

[Celever]

1) i feel the same way as AP did - a circus mod who is (presumably) a good mafia player would likely know what the setup was likeliest to be
2) yes, i would like to see any question posed go unanswered

 

[a fairy]

im a circus mod who is not a good mafia player

 

[StupidFlandrs48]

im a circus mod who is not a good mafia player

Top 10 most convincing af lies:
1. i am town
2. i am bad
3. i hate celever

 

[a fairy]

two truths and a lie

 

[StupidFlandrs48]

a fairy In fairness I've been pretty uncritical of your slot so far so I'm gonna put you on the spot to share some terrible D1 reads

 

[StupidFlandrs48]

Specifically I'm curious about your thoughts on the NE/Wis/CK cabal since you weren't around for a lot of their active time iirc

 

[a fairy]

Specifically I'm curious about your thoughts on the NE/Wis/CK cabal since you weren't around for a lot of their active time iirc

i dont have thoughts about them really, idk if ive played with wp before, i feel like ck improves as more information exists in the game and we're at low information rn, NE i feel like i havent seen at all

 

[StupidFlandrs48]

i dont have thoughts about them really, idk if ive played with wp before, i feel like ck improves as more information exists in the game and we're at low information rn, NE i feel like i havent seen at all

I'd agree about CK generally, I just find it difficult to read interactions between the psmaf people. Need to rely on a translator for them lmao

Can you do an iso skim or something for NE? He has genuinely been one of the most active people

 

[a fairy]

apparently NE is voting for me is what ive learnt

uh idk their posting feels fine but NAI i think, they didnt get too into the weeds on the flandrs stuff, focused on skip and cel thoughts which like hey fair me too to some extent. ive skimmed their iso and my takeawya is that theyve said things but i dont have a take

 

[skippergamez]

can we at least poke at the readable content where 2 people posted nearly identical reads and then one of them went "and the other one's lost their mind their reads are so bad" or whatever, or do we have to focus on the molehill mountain

i dont have thoughts about them really, idk if ive played with wp before, i feel like ck improves as more information exists in the game and we're at low information rn, NE i feel like i havent seen at all

Hmmm

“let’s talk about these two people guys!” —> idk I don’t have an opinion on them

 

[a fairy]

"i would like people to talk about those 2 people so i can begin to form an opinion"

 

[skippergamez]

I may have accidentally derailed the thread, let's get it back on track with a discussion about Celever

Posts like the following make me think he's just inactive or not paying attention at the minute but trying to filler:


and the filler is conversations like the one we had above.

Stuff like this on Flandrs

also feels like an ingenuine attempt at solving, although I will say I do appreciate the later questioning

I’m a little confused by this post cause it seems to blatantly ignore the past like 4 pages…

 

[pulsar512b]

This is a ludicrously high effort gimmick

Congrats on accomplishing this and please don’t do it here LMAO

wouldnt it be fun if we tortured a whole game by making them all do it