I've missed so many conversations!
Celebi
Of course Celebi can't compete as a scald sponge. That's like asking Starmie to be Slowbro. The thing is it has an entire spectrum of sets from leech seed aaaall the way to nasty plot. No wonder it's a tournament special. Celebi is at its best when it's played like a Mew with a stab grass. I don't think anything with healing wish + stealth Rock should be D in any tier bar Uber. It's not that it
should carry those moves, it's that it
could. It's really really hard to rate. I mean, just like Mew, it can get set up on or it can sweep their team. How you gonna rank that?
Tangrowth
You need to weaken this thing before bird spam. Nuff said.
Yes it can't sponge scald, and your opponent is most likely happy to land a burn on it. But as a trade-in we have genuine offense + genuine physical bulk. Compromising on the that two jobs (sleep) for a grass type isn't great, and thus I do think it's supposed to be worse than Amoongus. C+ to B- seems pretty fair.
Jirachi
My boy :[
The unfortunate side effect of having the OUBL pokemon mega Metagross is that everyone comes prepared. I wanted to defend it for being able to run like doom desire + healing wish, or body slam, etc., until I had to admit they are all memes.
Empoleon
People seem to like running offense on this thing more and more. I think its stab combination is still way too niche because it immediately runs into the 4-slot syndrome. It wants scald for consistency, wants grass knot for water, flash cannon for a valuable special steel stab, agility, defog, rock, HP-something for something, and then the end of the day, somehow, still gets strapped to a Shuca berry.
I love this mon as I went back to breed a
5iv with defog, in freaking gen 4, and then RM it till gen 6; my favorite starter. But this thing is still really limited.
Altaria
When it first came out I thought I found the poster boy of bulky offense. Imagine Sylveon with like 12 resistances, roost, and can set up. Over the years people have pivoted to playing it like a fairy mega mence, which is not wrong, it's just competition on the mega slot I reckon. I don't think it belongs with Latios. Either Latios higher or Altaria lower.
Dragalge
100% agreed on the "under explored" assessment by someone before me. Picking the item for it is already mental gymnastics. I think it MUST lean on the "fairy-killer" dragon + toxic spikes 100%, but how we are supposed to achieve that, is still debated. In some way it feels like Goodra where no one move you can nonchalantly click, and I admit I don't know how to make it work consistently. I just find it really cool :]
The Dragon trio
Kyurem I'm really just fearing a sub. Dragonite I'd have to decipher the band/lum/weakness policy thing but all sets eventually just try to outrage something really hard. Chard-X I feel should be on another tier entirely because of
two extremely clickable stabs that aren't one on ATK and the other on SPA, some bulky sets, and there's 8% of your brain screaming "WHAT IF IT'S CHARD-Y ??!" the entire time.