Id be willing to bet my bank account M2H rogue'd me last night. I thought about targeting him with my action but I didnt just in case Evie was protecting him.
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC E.G.O Wielders Mafia - A 17P Role Madness (Game Thread) - MAFIA WIN
- Thread starter HydrogenHydreigon
- Start date
hello, i've been briefly glancing at the thread here and there but not a ton - the only posts i somewhat read were hal's. So I can't make any reads with confidence right now, but I reckon we can solve most of the game from his ISO since that man loves to yap. And I'd rather do that than read 75 pages 
it's getting late, so everybody have a good night sleep and let's make this a great game tomorrow
it's getting late, so everybody have a good night sleep and let's make this a great game tomorrow
Hey fren!hello, i've been briefly glancing at the thread here and there but not a ton - the only posts i somewhat read were hal's. So I can't make any reads with confidence right now, but I reckon we can solve most of the game from his ISO since that man loves to yap. And I'd rather do that than read 75 pages
it's getting late, so everybody have a good night sleep and let's make this a great game tomorrow
Glad to see you again.
I am curious what you think about Hal's posts and possible teammate slips.
Day 1:
Fairy says there is probably a 3P in the game
Celever and flandrs have a clash where Celever is somewhat antagonistic to Flandrs ( he said it was to get Flandrs mad so thats not really conjecture on my part)
Wisteria and CK (your slot) end up having similar opinions (Ill have to revisit that). I think CK cast some doubt on her for saying scum might be in lurkers. I know I didnt quite like that part of Wisteria's post myself.
Celever is ran up, with Apricity's vote being a turning point.
Celever claims tracker and self votes.
NightEmerald emerges as a CW although Wisteria/NE have hard townread each other all game.
Evie/Chemdah wagons get modest support.
Cele flips town tracker.
Fairy dies.
Day 2:
Mostly dominated by me/M2H/Apricity all fighting in a big free for all.
Apricity only wagon most of the day.
NightEmerald claims mayor who gets half(?) a vote every time he guesses how many actions failed during the night.
Evie claims doctor who fails if her target is targeted by any nonkilling role.
Some votes go on Evie/Chemdah/Neon, with Neon being one of the bigger CWs at the ennd
Apricity wagon consolidates support at end and he flipped.
ok, so i was asleep when Evie and NE claimed roles, but I do kinda believe them here from what I've read from my action results. Doesn't mean that they're 100% telling the truth, but I believe it's way more likely than them lying about their roles. Anyway, I'll just go ahead and vote who I would've voted D2 if I hadn't slept in
##Vote: Neon
##Vote: Neon
Not completely clear on whether this is true or not, but there probably is a 3P considering the number of potential flavors in PM lore that could qualify as a 3P
Noted. Given that there has only been 1 kill each night it seems unlikely there is an actual SK in the game. Arson or something even more weird more likely if there is one.
d2 i wouldve voted NE fwiw, im not sure about who i would have ended up on. i unfortunately also slept through because im very stupid and my sleep is very bad
n1 targeted hal, n2 targeted m2h so someone else must have done so too
or well more accurately i would have tried to vote for ne but i imagine i would end up on apricity bc i think between him and neon i liked neon a lot more.
Holy shit soldier tf2 mention
I feel like I slept through like half of N2
Personally I'd kill Saxton Hale but that's just me.
I agree with this in principle, but it's worth noting that M2H's strongest scumreads (besides hal) were NE and ch3mdah. Food for thought as we navigate this phase.
I need to do a VCA at some point.
still a chance of a 3P not existing, but there is, in fact, an abnormality that almost perfectly fits the role of an arson
NOO I MISSED DAYSTART
i had a bunch of thoughts after the hal flip written up let me pull them
okay these were my thoughts unfiltered:
off the hal flip:
joey is probably just locktown off of that shift. the only way scum!joey makes sense there is if that was town!hal, which it wasn't so like :sob:
neon is more likely than not town. there is a line of reasoning where it is possible that hal was bussing neon, but considering that he named ch3mdah/neon/DBD as possible countervotes i'd think the bus angle makes the most sense if all three of these were scum (because he very well could've pushed the vote onto ch3mdah/DBD in a world where those two were town and neon was scum)
flandrs is probably town. notably one of the last things hal does is push back on flandrs voting evie in a way that doesn't particularly seem distance-y. this + his previous posting as well
AP/M2H contains one scum in it AT MOST. this is because after the celever vote scum!AP/scum!M2H/hal could've simply just run the game if they wanted; scum!M2H does not need to push on hal and hal does not need to push on scum!AP like that. on that note, i think both slots are unpaired with hal in their own right, with the AP/hal unpairing stronger considering that hal seemed to be committing to discrediting + possibly even wrangling a vote on him. still hate that AP hasn't answered some of my questions but running on spite after a mafia vote is a poor idea and i don't think he should be the vote d3.
apricity (5): ImaginaryNeon, StupidFlandrs48, skippergamez, M2H, joey
ImaginaryNeon (3): apricity, Evie, NightEmerald
Evie (2): des121, AngryPidgeon
considering how that eod shook up, i wonder how viable it is to greenshelf the entirety of the hal wagon? i feel like hal had a pretty decent grasp on the threadstate (despite M2H and AP pushing back on him) so i'm getting the vibe that the scumteam bussing hal of all people seems like a meh idea at best. skip is the only one i don't have a solid tr on off of hal's flip alone so maybe i look there if i find myself hitting a wall but right now my thoughts are the hal wagon was pure.
noticing that the hal/evie and hal/NE voting blocks have cropped up once again
off the hal flip:
joey is probably just locktown off of that shift. the only way scum!joey makes sense there is if that was town!hal, which it wasn't so like :sob:
neon is more likely than not town. there is a line of reasoning where it is possible that hal was bussing neon, but considering that he named ch3mdah/neon/DBD as possible countervotes i'd think the bus angle makes the most sense if all three of these were scum (because he very well could've pushed the vote onto ch3mdah/DBD in a world where those two were town and neon was scum)
flandrs is probably town. notably one of the last things hal does is push back on flandrs voting evie in a way that doesn't particularly seem distance-y. this + his previous posting as well
AP/M2H contains one scum in it AT MOST. this is because after the celever vote scum!AP/scum!M2H/hal could've simply just run the game if they wanted; scum!M2H does not need to push on hal and hal does not need to push on scum!AP like that. on that note, i think both slots are unpaired with hal in their own right, with the AP/hal unpairing stronger considering that hal seemed to be committing to discrediting + possibly even wrangling a vote on him. still hate that AP hasn't answered some of my questions but running on spite after a mafia vote is a poor idea and i don't think he should be the vote d3.
apricity (5): ImaginaryNeon, StupidFlandrs48, skippergamez, M2H, joey
ImaginaryNeon (3): apricity, Evie, NightEmerald
Evie (2): des121, AngryPidgeon
considering how that eod shook up, i wonder how viable it is to greenshelf the entirety of the hal wagon? i feel like hal had a pretty decent grasp on the threadstate (despite M2H and AP pushing back on him) so i'm getting the vibe that the scumteam bussing hal of all people seems like a meh idea at best. skip is the only one i don't have a solid tr on off of hal's flip alone so maybe i look there if i find myself hitting a wall but right now my thoughts are the hal wagon was pure.
noticing that the hal/evie and hal/NE voting blocks have cropped up once again
with the hal flip we know it was the former
the ardor blossom moth i presume?
i cant tell if i should be reading into the fact that the claimed doc didnt die
like on one hand M2H dying here makes sense but on the other hand evie does have partner equity with hal as M2H outlined earlier
like on one hand M2H dying here makes sense but on the other hand evie does have partner equity with hal as M2H outlined earlier
hal's progression on NE pinged me weird as i was reading thru his ISO as well so im probably gonna be going back to ISOing NE
I'm talking abt doomsday calendar, the one that kills everyone if you take too long
*everyone except for doomsday calendar
oh that makes sense
talk to me about this vote